I've heard Garland sing this song "live" numerous times, and this version is the most gut-wrenching thing I've ever heard. JG was one of the best singers to have ever graced a stage. Garland knew how to internalize a lyric, enabling her to find and convey every subtle nuance of emotion. She new when to reel in the lyric and the melody, which made ths song seem personal, and at the same time, she could take that melody and make it soar. All the while her eyes spoke volumes. Simply amazing.
my goodness!! Everything about this performance is epic. even the camera being so focused on her face makes this timeless. She somehow makes you experience every emotion right with her.
anyone knew what year this was? Did she have Liza yet? She looks like a very young Lady here! Oh and one more think she RIPS my heart out as she ends this song and walks away.She knew what she was doing for as many times they said she was nuts she was in perfect mind in her mind.And it was wondereful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@pusspleaser134 September 24, 1955 on her first tv special "Ford Starr Jubilee" and by then she was married to her third husband Sid Luft and had Liza May Minnelli (3/12/1946), Lorna Luft (11/21/1952), and Joey Wiley Luft (3/29/1955)
I can't stop crying I am listening to Live at Carnegie Hall.WHAT A FUCKING ALBUM.There I said it..No other way to say it she just rips me up what would we all do to see her. RIP Judy the best...
This is the most memorable song performance I have ever seen. Nobody invested their raw emotion into a song like Judy Garland. It's like watching Van Gogh creating a painting.
I just can't watch this without crying....
jacksonbrownepuppy 5 months ago
I started crying when I watched this. Rest in Peace Judy Garland!
UnitedSnipingTacs 9 months ago
I've heard Garland sing this song "live" numerous times, and this version is the most gut-wrenching thing I've ever heard. JG was one of the best singers to have ever graced a stage. Garland knew how to internalize a lyric, enabling her to find and convey every subtle nuance of emotion. She new when to reel in the lyric and the melody, which made ths song seem personal, and at the same time, she could take that melody and make it soar. All the while her eyes spoke volumes. Simply amazing.
twowaystreet101 10 months ago
my goodness!! Everything about this performance is epic. even the camera being so focused on her face makes this timeless. She somehow makes you experience every emotion right with her.
jesparza562 10 months ago
anyone knew what year this was? Did she have Liza yet? She looks like a very young Lady here! Oh and one more think she RIPS my heart out as she ends this song and walks away.She knew what she was doing for as many times they said she was nuts she was in perfect mind in her mind.And it was wondereful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pusspleaser134 10 months ago
@pusspleaser134 September 24, 1955 on her first tv special "Ford Starr Jubilee" and by then she was married to her third husband Sid Luft and had Liza May Minnelli (3/12/1946), Lorna Luft (11/21/1952), and Joey Wiley Luft (3/29/1955)
AdamMichaelMercer 5 months ago
I can't stop crying I am listening to Live at Carnegie Hall.WHAT A FUCKING ALBUM.There I said it..No other way to say it she just rips me up what would we all do to see her. RIP Judy the best...
pusspleaser134 11 months ago
Judy Garland LIVE at Carnegie Hall She lives on !!!! It is a fantastic show she is just a power house....RIP Love Barbara
pusspleaser134 11 months ago
great actress great singer great entertainer great artist.
FunnyHaHaFunnyHaHa 1 year ago
this is the reason why judy garland is the most amazing singer of all time! i cry every time i watch this.
ilovesondheim 1 year ago
i get chills every time. she just wanted to be one of the blue birds, free to fly.
broadwaybaby0303 1 year ago 2
Wonderful! Rest in Peace, Judy Garland!
lovehexum1 2 years ago 2
This is the most memorable song performance I have ever seen. Nobody invested their raw emotion into a song like Judy Garland. It's like watching Van Gogh creating a painting.
swrdfsh53 2 years ago 8