If I were a Greek-Catholic I would certainly quit. This's an abuse in Orient Tradition and should be reported to the local Ordinary (of the Orient Churches Ordinariate) in order to punish the Priest -who allows this terrible "profanation"- and not to let it happen again.
Thanks to God in other parts of the world -not far away from Brazil, though- we can attend a well-celebrated Byzantine Mass.
well I think this roman catholics destroy there on liturgy on the 70 and now they want to destroy the Orthodox Liturgy, someone has to stop them this is a mixture of roman Catholic protestan vatican II mix is horrible.
Rito bizantino??? Desde quando rito bizantino se celebra com música instrumental?
É por essas e outras que batismo ortodoxo, pra mim, só na Rússia mesmo! Aqui ficam querendo inventar o que patriarca nenhum defende.
Digitem "divina liturgia, letanía" ou "ectenia mica" para ver o que é um rito bizantino. Condenável a atidude desse padre, será que ele sabe o conceito de "ortodoxia"?
This is terrible. This is a disgrace to the Greek Catholic tradition. This priest should be REPORTED for celebrating a Divine Liturgy with such music. NO INSTRUMENTS OR POP SINGING IN GREEK CATHOLIC tradition!!
You should remove this immediately from youtube this is a scandal!
This is not local tradition - THIS IS LOCAL HERESY
This is consumer music industry garbage which destroys traditional folk music and any remote heritage of byzantine or gregorian chant. Pray to God that Melkites and other Eastern Catholics retain their true tradition, not to mention the Latins.
sorry, i know i'm being arrogant, but some things just don't mix, like orange juice and toothpaste. "local tradition" has too often been used as an excuse for abuse.
the church itself is made of traditions from the greeks and or romans, whom ever u choose. now if there is an Orthodox or Catholic church in the middle of the native population of central america, u are telling me to not incorporate local traditions within the actual worship? i am not saying radical changes like using juice instead of wine, no i am saying certain hymns, dresses customs....is that so wrong?
O que é isso??? É um total disastre!!
If I were a Greek-Catholic I would certainly quit. This's an abuse in Orient Tradition and should be reported to the local Ordinary (of the Orient Churches Ordinariate) in order to punish the Priest -who allows this terrible "profanation"- and not to let it happen again.
Thanks to God in other parts of the world -not far away from Brazil, though- we can attend a well-celebrated Byzantine Mass.
jumven 5 months ago
NO INSTRUMENTS OR POP SINGING IN GREEK CATHOLIC tradition!!
SaoMateusApostolo 10 months ago
Sickening...
MinisterPrimus 1 year ago
NO INSTRUMENTS OR POP SINGING IN GREEK CATHOLIC tradition!! (2)
WHERE IS THE BIZANTINE HYMN!!!
Loiginer 1 year ago
Profanazione del rito greco, dopo aver profanato per decenni quello latino. Vergogna! Se volete cantare le canzonette andate al festival di San Remo!
TrebleLover 1 year ago
well I think this roman catholics destroy there on liturgy on the 70 and now they want to destroy the Orthodox Liturgy, someone has to stop them this is a mixture of roman Catholic protestan vatican II mix is horrible.
alfabeta3003 1 year ago
E' un abuso liturgico. Una malversazione!
gimalgi73 2 years ago
Rito bizantino??? Desde quando rito bizantino se celebra com música instrumental?
É por essas e outras que batismo ortodoxo, pra mim, só na Rússia mesmo! Aqui ficam querendo inventar o que patriarca nenhum defende.
Digitem "divina liturgia, letanía" ou "ectenia mica" para ver o que é um rito bizantino. Condenável a atidude desse padre, será que ele sabe o conceito de "ortodoxia"?
Swordman85 2 years ago
This disgusts me.... It's bad enough some Catholic novus ordo masses are like this...
We don't need this spreading to Holy traditional masses
choirboy526 2 years ago
BLAAAAAGHH attack of the horrible music! and at a byzantine liturgy no less! I thought the prohibition of instruments would stop this stuff.
hurricaneomega 2 years ago
Io sono di rito romano e chiedo: ma è uno scherzo?
I belong to the Roman Rite and I ask: it is a joke?
boy8321 2 years ago
This is terrible. This is a disgrace to the Greek Catholic tradition. This priest should be REPORTED for celebrating a Divine Liturgy with such music. NO INSTRUMENTS OR POP SINGING IN GREEK CATHOLIC tradition!!
You should remove this immediately from youtube this is a scandal!
ByzantineSpirit 2 years ago 10
@ByzantineSpirit
I am surprised too to hear of musical instruments in such a tradition. It sounds so...different and somewhat inappropriate.
Chichiri520 1 year ago
Idiotic liturgy, idiotic music. nothing to be Orthodox. uniates...
iromaromka 2 years ago
those are not Orthodox
those are a mixture of RomanCatholics pretending been Orthodox...
Uniates
spyrosdch 3 years ago 3
This is no good liturgy.
Kyrie elieson.
forestking19 3 years ago
This is not local tradition - THIS IS LOCAL HERESY
This is consumer music industry garbage which destroys traditional folk music and any remote heritage of byzantine or gregorian chant. Pray to God that Melkites and other Eastern Catholics retain their true tradition, not to mention the Latins.
carolking 3 years ago
leave it to catholics to ruin idiot-proof liturgy with idiotic music.
liangtu 3 years ago
first off it isnt wrong to incorporate local tradition into the church. so u be quiet.
phati129 3 years ago
sorry, i know i'm being arrogant, but some things just don't mix, like orange juice and toothpaste. "local tradition" has too often been used as an excuse for abuse.
liangtu 3 years ago
the church itself is made of traditions from the greeks and or romans, whom ever u choose. now if there is an Orthodox or Catholic church in the middle of the native population of central america, u are telling me to not incorporate local traditions within the actual worship? i am not saying radical changes like using juice instead of wine, no i am saying certain hymns, dresses customs....is that so wrong?
phati129 3 years ago
I agree with you!
Swordman85 2 years ago
Isto não é canto bizantino.
That isn't byzantine chant.
PhGebara 3 years ago 6
que bonito, muchas gracias
nachx2000 4 years ago