@noahf67 That's a great statement. The White Album was a very experimental series of songs, and "Save The Life Of My Child" is a rare instance in which Simon & Garfunkel experimented with their sound in a similar yet unique way.
man, I like this better, actually, you can hear melody better, some of the lyrics better (the caption cried...) some worse (Mc Dougall's line....). But this one would have been nice as an extra with the Bookends album....
The demos posted on YouTube, not just this one but several others, show that Simon played with the lyrics up to the end, and almost every change was an improvement -- one exception. The final version has an "atmosphere of freaky holiday," which now seems dated. I like "the spotlight held the boy against the sky" better.
@leon723 Great point, some real nice examples are Paul's unfinished "Let Me Live In Your City" from There Goes Rhymin' Simon and the original demos of "The Coast" and "Spirit Voices" from Rhythm of the Saints. He's got so much to say its really a miracle when we get to hear the different versions.
This could have easily fit right in on the Beatles' White Album. Could have used it, actually.
noahf67 2 months ago
@noahf67 That's a great statement. The White Album was a very experimental series of songs, and "Save The Life Of My Child" is a rare instance in which Simon & Garfunkel experimented with their sound in a similar yet unique way.
MusicRevisited 2 months ago
Where'd you find this demo?
smedly500 3 months ago
Raw Moog recording! Very few instances of those back then without studio engineering corrections.
petsounds75 8 months ago
man, I like this better, actually, you can hear melody better, some of the lyrics better (the caption cried...) some worse (Mc Dougall's line....). But this one would have been nice as an extra with the Bookends album....
huston3 9 months ago 2
This version is just as great as the studio but raw.
jimmyjames1961 9 months ago
The demos posted on YouTube, not just this one but several others, show that Simon played with the lyrics up to the end, and almost every change was an improvement -- one exception. The final version has an "atmosphere of freaky holiday," which now seems dated. I like "the spotlight held the boy against the sky" better.
leon723 1 year ago
@leon723 Great point, some real nice examples are Paul's unfinished "Let Me Live In Your City" from There Goes Rhymin' Simon and the original demos of "The Coast" and "Spirit Voices" from Rhythm of the Saints. He's got so much to say its really a miracle when we get to hear the different versions.
MusicRevisited 1 year ago
John Simon really helped Paul and Art do a Martinesque Beatles job on
the final album track.
noahf67 1 year ago
So awesome to hear there songs I know so well,without all the fancy studio adornments. Wonderful.
jonahlevin67 1 year ago
Thank you for posting rare simon and garfunkel material
CSBABA 1 year ago 4