Added: 2 years ago
From: emmamc24
Views: 34,359
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (201)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • They should be more like britney and lip sync cos they sounded crap. That was a bad cover too bland. I'm not a GA hater. I just thought that sucked.

  • why do they give nadine most of the songs :/

    so much better than brit tho

  • why do they give nadine most of the songs :/

  • crazykez have you ever heard britney sing one song from circus live?if you did it was such a big dream!!!ah ah ah

  • great song !!!!!!!

  • can you be quiet? at least they sing live and the girls always do two covers on tour just to spice things up.

  • They look really sexy but LucendaLucyLoo is right. Britney does it much better.

  • Im a big girls aloud fan.. but.. in the future.Leave it to Britney :/

  • Thats Fuckin Shit..!!

    Dont Get Me Wrong I Love Girls Aloud But Derr Shit At Singing That Song...=]

  • Wat do u know.

  • this is shit britney is a million times better and always will be

  • Whatever.

  • a hot mess.

  • i dont like it at all... Britney's version is much better

  • Whats the point in covering if itll b the exact same. They made it their own. Duh

  • Comment removed

  • nice cleavage nadine!

  • Girls Aloud are awsome :)

    Love them all :) x

  • It's actually harder for a band to sing a song like that, rather than one person.

  • yeah so hard that they sing the wrong lyrics.

  • five singing live against britney. not fair really theres five of them and one of her. if one member of girls aloud sung live then fair enough

  • Girls Aloud are amazing. I went to the OOC tour twice, and would have went again if I had the money and time to get tickets! Loved it. Can't wait for the tour DVD!

  • are they deffinatly bringing out a tour dvd? plz reply

  • Well, they always do. And the Girls themselves say: "We try to make each tour better than the one before it". And as they always do I can almost assure you that there will be a DVD.

    I am really looking forward to it too.

  • Wow Nicola really carries the other girls in this song heh she is awesome :D

  • Lurve Nicola!!

  • yay! love it, only i think Nadine didn't sung it really well...

  • wow, unlike britney girls aloud actually womanizer live ;) love you girlssss, totally amazing.

  • mmmm nobody like britney !

  • I agree. No one gets a crowd up and going like Brit. When she passes on like MJ did, she's going to be well remembered.

  • Not to mention her accidental slip ups have proven it.

  • Yeah exactly, especially the time her "pussy" was hanging out.

    lolz

  • Oh dear, someone was born yesterday!

    Beyonce does not sing and shake her ass at the same fucking time u complete retard! If she sings and dances, she stops singing and then she does her dance, she dosnt do it at the same time. Coz it sounds bloody awful! U can waste ure time replying to me, but I wont even read it, I'll simply delete it. Coz u have no idea wht ure on about.

  • Actually, it's more the fact that it doesn't sound as good when they all sing together (for this song anyway). If they sang individually it would be amazing.

  • i went 2 see girls aloud at newcastle n they were AMAZING so stop slaggin them off dikheads!!

  • they sing this really well

    is a great version of the song..

    and its nice to hear this song sung live for once ;)

    they're so fit :D

  • at the end of the day Girls Aloud are just five real girls from random places around the UK and thats what makes them so good; they're not inaccesible divas that play everything out in public and have breakdowns, they're just real people having fun doing what they do. its all tongue in cheek; this cover isn't supposed to be serious. They don't claim to be amazing singers or dancers.

  • Normal people have breakdowns too. Britney has one and unfortunately for her she is one of the world's biggest celebrity's and she can't do much in private.

  • Britney Spears will always sing Womanizer better, they come second best.

    I'm tired of people saying how Britney doesn't sing, have you gone to her shows? She kicks ass and looks good doing it. Comment when you've went, I went to her Circus show in Miami and it was awesome.

  • i went to her show during her onyx tour and was bored rigid, but maybe playback just doesn't carry well in the open air and i hated that she spent most of the concert backstage getting changed, one or two costume changes is one thing but theres no need for the amount of changes she does, i left the concert early, never did that before or since

  • nadines voice sounds so pure wen she is singin womanizer

  • yeah I LOVE how she sings it, its amazing <3 its all different but better different, I love it :D:Dx

  • i'm a fan of both(GA & BS) but sounds crappy her version! This song is not made for 5 voices! Another song like "Gimme More" for example could sound better for GA

  • - They Put Britney Spears to shame..........don't get me wrong I like Britney, but she very very rarely can be bothered to sing live - even at her own concert's.

  • actually m8 she sings live when shes not dancing, no one sings live when there dancing, not even ppl like beyonce. Its even been confirmed that she sings on her new show circus, when not doing choregraphy

  • I don't know if Britney sings live when she's not dancing but I'm certain Beyonce and Girls Aloud sing live whether they're dancing or not. They both use backing tracks for the choruses but the verses are all live.

  • Well I do know that Britney sings live when dancing, because I went to her opening night tour in London at the o2 3 days ago, she gave a little bit of eveything, she sang live, danced her ass off and did her own circus acts and stunts. But tbh no one can sing while dancing the way Britney does, U can't sing live well and do fast-paced choregraphy dance routines at the same time, it sounds awful, and its an expecation to have fast slick dance routines in a Britney show, unlike Girls Aloud.

  • Are you being serious? Britney built her career on fast, slick dance routines. It's what's she known and loved for. Britney is to slick dance routines what Madonna is to reinvention. No one can do singing while dancing the way Britney does because Britney rarely, if ever, sings and dances at the same time. And singing and dancing at the same time doesn't sound awful if you're trained to do it like Madonna or Beyonce or Girls Aloud.

  • Mate I went to the show, she did sing when dancing, not in every single song, because there were times when she was upside down in the air being twirled by acrobats. But the point is, is that Britney is someone that gives more than just standing on stage singing. She sings, dances, does circus acts and stunts. She is VERY entertaining, and likes to put on a show. Yoo need 2 realise that every artist is different.

  • only during everytime...

  • No she sang over backing tracks when dancing & when not dancing she sang live with no backing track. Beyonce has backing track when she dances & sings. Plus as I said, I would have rather she mimed some songs, coz otherwise she wouldn't have been able to pull off the show she pulled off. She did everything in that show, danced, sang, did circus acts & also stunts and danced in the air, she did things NO 1 does in shows, which gives more entertainment & variety 2 the audiance, then jus singing

  • Definitely sounds better live. It was a good version of the song.

  • wow, to think these are the girls that won popstars years back.

  • sepbas, was that supposed to be a compliment towards Girls Aloud?

  • in some ways, yes. its quite amazing how they look so profesional and beat many other girl bands when they were manufactured and have lasted this long.

  • Ah! Oh yea. Its amazing. The show found 5 girls with 5 amazing natural voices live, and when put together made such a godly sound! But yea. They have beat out just about every other Girl Band. Its amazing. But not surprising with their talent.

  • Except that they sound great singing it. And yeah, I'm sure one day when Britney finally comes up with a sexy routine that compliments the song it'll be GREAT! But until then I prefer this version to any of Britney's, and I love Britney.

  • when nadine says the word womanizer it sounds so cool cos of her irish accent! AMAZING GIRLS!

  • i think it really suits nadines voice and the rest of them i was there it was friggin awesome

  • I agree

  • i think its good but when nicola joins in with cheryl at the start its not!

  • Last night it was pretty good

  • love Nadine in this song, her voice is amazing and her irish accent is great for the song I think

  • i love girls aloud but this is my least favourite cover they have done, i predict a riot and teenage dirtbag were much better

  • yerr I loved teenage dirtbag, i went to see them at manchester singing womanizer an live it wasnt actually bad, it was good I enjoyed it, and they are brill singers live :)

  • Doesn't sound right in an english accent

  • they may have a record for most consecutive top 10s but NOT sales which is the thing that matters!!!

  • its not bad its jsut the chorus doesnt sound right cos it doesnt suit nadines vopice hers is to deep

    but shes still a better singer than britney

    but i still loved and at least they have sung it live

  • though I like them, but I gotta say, they ruined the song!!

  • By singing it live?

  • most succesful girl band in the u.k to have the most top ten singles. if the spice girls had stayed together longer years ago then they would have loads.

  • hmm.. like girls aloud.. but Britney's Version is a lot betterrr!!xx

  • they done a good copy ae this i like it and good dancing with the puppets

  • i think ur wrong! not arguein with ya, but u are

  • at least there doin womanizer live. has britney done it live. i love britney but she hasn't done a version of womanizer live.

  • This is a bloody cats chorus

  • y porque estas tias cantan el womanizer de britney???????!!!que alguien me lo expliqueeee

  • the is girls aloud they are on tour and everytime they go on tour they cover someone elses song. this is originally sung by britney spears yeah but they have covered it.

  • i can see why britney never sang it live. theres five of them singing it very good. i couldnt imagine cheryl or nadine singing it live on there owm. i love britney and girls aloud

  • at least they are siging it LIVE! AND ITS BETTER THAN BRITNEY

  • ou..please shut up..if you don't like this don't comment..it's that simple..so what if Britney had more success then Girls Aloud..big deal..everyone listens to the music that fits them..I love Girls Aloud and i would give anything to on a concert from the OOC tour..

  • lol!!! spice girs had real talent! ahh thats made my day, thanks 4 that, u have cheered me up, u should try stand up i bet u would be a real hit

  • i love girls aloud, but i'm not a fan of this. ):

  • Oh get you having a hissy fit did I hit a raw nerve how cheap do you dress. If u think Britney makes cheap tarts classy u must have some classy outfits. R U even watching the same clip as me UR trying to tell me that these outfits aren't cheap. Yes Brtiney is cheap but look at Nadine shes told once u have great legs by Louis Walsh (inside the closet) and she hasn't put them away since. It does take the look of her face & accent. Just look @ Cheryls tacky tattoos. Real Class. Claws in Elton.

  • Okay ur obviously have no taste as u appear be a GA fan (I'M SO SORRY FOR U, HOPE U GET BETTER SOON). These bitches can only write their names let alone a song whereas Brtiney has & yeah shes crazy but i'd take that over these 5 who dress like cheap tarts with nothing original to say for themselves only bitchy comments about other more successful ARTISTS who out sell them on a bad day. And only 1 of GA is married and even he's shagging everybody but her. Put your hand bag down & get a life.

  • 5 who dress like cheap tarts?????? Hello have you been walking around with your eyes closed for the past 10 years, Britney dresses like a cheap tart, in fact she makes cheap tarts look class, remember those pics of Britney waljubg around trying to pass of a top as a dress and that one where she showed her fanny to the world, when have GA done any of those things, oh yeah and then there was that time where Brit went out with bloody undies, she's a tacky bitch

  • kimberleys voice suits this song relli well.... cant wait for tommorow x x

  • oh my God its terrible!

  • Wot bunch of whores who cudn't sing a good song if it came up and shagged them cause thats all they're good for. U sad losers to think that they will conqure the world. IN YOU'RE FUCKING DREAMS. These slags are no SPICE GIRLS. Who had real talent just as Britney Spears does who cares if she doesn't sing live she'll be remebered unlike these hos. Who lets face it should just fuck off and die as nobody would miss their shit songs or faces. They should be shot for this crime against a good song.

  • the first bit sounds like you are describing Britney to a tee, she can't sing a good song, she gets the computers in the studio to do it for her, as for GA being hos, how many men has britney had, the slut got married twice in the same year to 2 different men, and had about six others before and after that whereas some of GA are married or engaged so get your facts straight before you want to say something next time

  • i love nicolas harmonising on thi song! and kimbas facial expressions <3

  • you can use the "lip syncing" excuss to put britney down.. but come on guys.. britney has conquored the WORLD not just the u.k and america.. everyone knows her and her music.. shes bein threw more stuff in the last year than each girl in grils aloud will prob ever go threw.. britney is one woman .. theres 5girls there and they still dont compare to her.. plus girls aloud havnt done one step this whole song britney dances threw out all her songs

  • Brit is soooo much beta at dis song its hers lily allen is rubbish 2

  • yous are all hillarious making fun of britney, girls aloud would be lucky to get 1/10th of britneys success

  • Uh. To be honest. Girls Aloud is probably almost as famous as it gets. They just need to take over America like they have the U.K (And we all know they will) and they'll have even more then Britney's success. The only reason Britney has so much success is because she does crazy shit that news reporters like to report in the media. And she was on the Mickey Mouse club. Plus, she used to make good music and has a few years on GA. But if anything, Girls Aloud will become just as successful as her.

  • can i just bring it to you attention that by the time Britney started doing crazy shit she had sold over 80 million albums wolrdwide, add that to her 45 million single sales and you 125 million sold compared to girls aloud 5 million albums and 4 million singles - its gonna take them a lot more than cracking america to catch up with ms spears level of fame and success! But saying that don't think i am a hater cuz i love them both!

  • believe me they will be A FUCKIN LOT more successfull than britney it they conquor americe which as ExMaster says, we all know they will. AT LEAST GIRLS ALOUD ARNT AFRAID TO SING THIS SONG LIVE. unlike britney AND ITS HER BLOODY SONG.

    says alot really.

  • This song is amazin...Thy do it well!

    Love Cheryl's Bits..

    Cnt wait to see thm in 2 weeks :)!

    xx

  • Nadine is clearly the best singer in the band, dunno y cheryl keeps gettin lead vocals when she cant sing very well

  • yes u share exactly the same view as me. nadine is amazin

  • Hey Buy girls aloud new single!

    untouchable Radio edit now on itunes

    help them get there 21st top 10 single !!!!!

    xxxx

    its only no.11 atm its gona break there top 10 hits!!!! : (

  • nadine and nicola own this!

  • nadine sounds the best singing the parts

  • nicola sounds unbelievable! she looks great here

  • Nadine sounds amazing here! They covered this amazingly! People need to stop comparing it to Britney's computer generated album version!

  • lmao are you being serious?It's Britney's song

  • Yes, I'm not retarded. Thats why I said they COVERED it nicely. Just because Britney had somebody write it for her doesn't mean other people can't sing it better. And I do think Girls Aloud sang it better than she could live. But then again, we'd never know how she sounds live because she lip syncs everything.

  • OMFG! best cover evah! GA rulez!

  • omg it was okay nothing like britney who is the best

  • awful

  • britney'z version iz betta evn dow I Lyk GA .. x

  • OMG aaweesoooome

  • I love this video. i love girls aloud and britney. theyre my fave band and brit is my fave singer. this just tops it. :)

    x

  • i was there haha x

    it was amazin

    wooo !!!!!

  • great at least the girls can sing and dance together unlike britney . you should be ashamed britney

  • i didn't think britney fans would like this. just as well GA fans do :) i love it :D cheryl's FIERCE!! nicola's vocals = amazing!

  • Nicola clearly pulls the rest of them together! :D

  • She really does. She may not have that many solo parts but she backs up most of them most of the time and sings the majority of every chorus!

  • Hey i was in the one in belfast look at my new vid ill be posting more... in this concert did they go on this platform and move across the audiance?

  • I love this video!!!!!

    :D

  • wow nicola is beautiful.

  • Good Cover

  • gross.

    britney > these bitches

  • nicole is the best in this BY FAR!!

    xxx

  • i love this nicolas is the BEST!!

  • 1.take ur middle finger and put on ur nose.

    2.say a name of someone u like.

    3.that person will ask u out or say they love u tomarrow.

    4. heres the thing copy and paste to 2 other vids

  • great KIMBA...

  • whoever sat here had reallly really good seats! [yy]  Cant waitt.... 5.5.09 :D:D:D ahhh omggg :D:D

    love this is the best youtube vid everrr xxx

  • What's the point in posting a video when you don't even like the band!? It's pointless, you come across as some pathetic 12 year old who has nothing better to do.

    Haters = FAIL.

  • i actually think this is amazing :D

    x

  • Nicola sounds amazing in this :)

  • yeah Nicola THE BEST <3

  • this is really good, even britney didnt sing this live lol... i do like brit but go GA xx

  • Kimberley/Nicola's verse is clearly the best bit. Such a good cover though considering it's a difficult song to do.

  • Talentless. Anyone can shout over a backing voice track.

  • And yet there they are performing to thousands of people every night with twenty top ten singles under their belts, looking absolutely stunning while they're at it. You must be doing pretty spectacular things with your life to feel like you can pass judgment on them.

  • they're singing live, unlike Britney who can't even be bothered to sing live even though she just walks around, she's pathetic

  • they were amazin! i was there n they wer rerli rerli good! they were great dancers 2. jelous ppl sayin its crap lol rerli when u actually go the concert its so much better. i was amazed. wel done girls loved it! n nicola was the best! xx

  • jeolous?or just having a opinion maybe...

  • i guess im the only person who thinks the puppet dancing thing is stupid and boring. some of theire outfits are cute though

  • I think it's really good :)

  • WOW it does! thanks

  • i dont get why sarahs costume is so different from the others

  • they are really lazy this year, dancing wise

  • im so glad Cheryls on my sidee ALOTT <33333 CANT WAIT!! GONNA BE ACE!!

  • which side is that, cos im going to nia and will be in block c which i think is the right xx

  • how do u know?

  • u know last year when i went cheryl was on the ther side the whole concert, and now this year im on the opposite end from her again, how bloody typical lol, am soooooooo excited only 12 days to my first show, and love this song

    :D

  • :( am i like the only girls aloud fan tht isnt goin to the tour?? :( i have never seen them live, i am so jelous :( x

  • dont wprry i havent been before and i couldnt go this year either dont worry your not alone but i really wish i could go but im guessing it will have to be the dvd again

  • u and me both buddy :( x

  • Just seen them perform this at Sheffield. They did a brilliant job on this song....better than Ms Spears. Remember this vid has been taken on a phone so the sound quality is bound to be poor.

    BTW.....at 59 years old was i the oldest GA 'fan' at Sheffield tonight? Who gives a damn.....i had a great night!

  • yh but has birtney ever actually sung this live

  • Dont think so, if she did I think it would be better.

  • Britney doesn't sing live because she sounds like a frog when she does, i've heard her so i know what im talking about

  • Maybe not but it's a BRITNEY song you cover a britney and not expect some of her most loyals to come over and bash G.A like theres no tomorrow lol plus Womanizer isn't really a band kinda song.

  • Britney doesn't even sing it live! Are you serious?

  • lol. but if she ever decided to, i think it would be better!

  • That's hardly an argument.

  • the only problem is britney doesnt sing live...girls aloud do...britney is fugly and obease...girls aloud are hot and SEXY!! haha

  • Obese? What the fuck? lol!

  • Girls Aloud stand on stage, singing.

    Britney Spears DANCES on stage. That's the difference. And it's not 100% lip-syncing.

    I don't know people who can dance while delievring a good singing performance.

    Britney Spears is the best! And she's far from being ugly or obese....

  • Beyonce can sing and dance at the same time and sound good =] and i totally agree with your comment!

  • Britney doesn't dance anymore, her shows are a rip off, she's not worth the money people pay, and they are just going so they can see her......whats the point in that, thats stupid and proves people are just paying for her rubbish because they feel sorry for her and want to see what she's like now rather than buying her albums and tickets cos she actually good, which she clearly isn't, people need to stop buying into fakeness, Britney's whole career was built around fakeness

  • dats soooo not tru brit is a legend nd shez so strong 2 b able 2 keep her kwl round ppl lyk u

  • the word is spelled cool now kewl you fool, everything ive said is true, even some of her fans have said that they go just to see her so don't talk crap, the girl knows shes a fraud and thats why she had a breakdown cos she's built her career around being fake and doesn't know which way is up and which is down now, she's laughing in the faces of her fans cos she knows that what your buying is manufactured fake shite

  • My god Nadine looks hot there, amazing stomach and great ass in those tight trousers

  • p.s. soooooooooooooooo jelous

  • p.s. soooooooooooooooo jelous [2]