Carrie is as good, or better live. I have seen her live twice now, and I love watching her and her voice is flawless. She is just one AWESOME artist. I don't think there is anyone in the industry that we can compare to Carrie. Even her peers say this. They always talk about Carrie and her singing ability and how she is the greatest artist to come out of Nashville, (OKLAHOMA)!!!
love the idea :) it's soo amazing uhhhhh 1 thing i wanna disagree on is in I Told You So you shoulda picked the one with Randy Travis :) I LOVE THIS VID DO
There's only a few differences when she sings live. Obviously when she's in the studio she's standing still. When on stage she's rocking out so it's harder on her breath control. Sometimes there's an off-pitch here & there. At the People's Choice Awards she had a cold. So she couldn't reach the high notes. Her voice cracked when she tried to go for it. Poor thing! But we Carrie fans are willing to look past that because her voice is still 97% same live. Most singers are only 25% at best.
i think this video was kinda of pointless because as you can see everyone sounds good after they have been tuned with computer... but with carrie her voice is just more clear on the CD thats all!! Carrie has true talents!!!!!!!!!!
Also, I find it very cool that you did a video like this; however, there's a noticeable quality difference between her Live versus CD, it's the audio quality not her vocal qualities, I can hear it on 360p, just saying.
@rytanya26 You misunderstood my point. The AUDIO quality is NOTHING like watching it on 720-1080, let alone comparing to watching her live. The audio quality is on the low side compared to the normal 360 when it transitions into her live performances.
@rytanya26 : im from bedok. no, i couldnt. it was my O level exam week at that moment of time. I was so SAD i could not make it. Hopefully. She will come back. do continue to have more videos of hers. P.S. i bought her PLAY ON CD!!
@r1r2r2 cool.. I'm from Tampines. Sure, I'll keep making videos of her. If not of her, it's with her songs!! :D I did too! I got it all her CDs. And I bought her songs online too.. The best way to show someone our support is to buy their materials, right? :D
Even Taylor herself on a phone conversation agrees that Carrie is just incredible live. It is almost unbelievable that someone of any style can perform live like that. Do people really understand what control it takes to pull off extremely difficult passages as she does so flawlessly and live. It is amazing.
i love both taylor and carrie cause they are both really talented. @MissDvS18 taylor is awsome at both the same as Carrie i have no idea what u r talking about. but there shouldn't be a fight between carrie and taylor because they are both talented and have a gift of singing with beautiful voices. so don't hate one to love one as i say, love them both.
@hakmatmanaa sorry no offence to u im speaking my mind.... I think carrie is a million times better than taylor...i like taylors singing on her cd but once shes live eww I think its terrible
This just shows her talent! I've seen Carrie three times in concert and she sounds phenomenal live and knows how to put on the best show. Entertainer of the Year for sure. Plus she is a great person. I met her last month and she is great! Overall the best person :)
I believe that Carrie is probably one of the best live singers ever. She delivers every single time. Can't wait to see her in Vegas on May 22 Love her
Can someone tell me, HOW DID TAYLOR BEAT HER FOR FEMALE VOCALISTS? Taylor cant hit the notes Carrie Hits. Carrie is the greatest singer that has ever lived. I love you Carrie, your biggest fan... Keep on Rocking.
daaaaang. you could barely tell the difference except that one audio quality is better than the other and one as much more emotional and/or fun than the other. live ftw.
carrie, you, my dear, can siiiing.<3 i'm a metalhead, and i'm not afraid to say i love carrie underwood. gonna see her live at the HB october 2nd. =D
She is better live because she puts more emotions/feelings into the song. She doesn't need any enhancements in her voice because she is awesome. GO CARRIE!!!
What a GREAT idea for a video! Love this! And Carrie is an absolutely OUTSTANDING live singer, I think she is probably the best actually, along with Kelly Clarkson and Leona Lewis. :) It's amazing to think that Carrie hasn't given one bad live performance in her career. :O In fact she is often better live than on CD. :D
3:15 - 4:32 is my favourite Carrie performance ever, it was flawless!!!
Great video...very few people can sound just as good as the CD live. This just goes to show that Carrie doesn't need any extra "studio magic" to make her sound good. Her voice is all she needs. God bless you Carrie and your beautiful music!!!
she's amazing live and on cd. honestly though she sounds better live which is something that only a few artists can do.
FreshTilDeath28 1 month ago
carrie is amazing live shes almost better live then on cd. she has a real gift
nercole94hellyeah 1 month ago
That is just the sound between live and studio... anyway you look at it Carrie kicks butt..!
161170bill 2 months ago
Carrie is as good, or better live. I have seen her live twice now, and I love watching her and her voice is flawless. She is just one AWESOME artist. I don't think there is anyone in the industry that we can compare to Carrie. Even her peers say this. They always talk about Carrie and her singing ability and how she is the greatest artist to come out of Nashville, (OKLAHOMA)!!!
wk1kat1 5 months ago
love the idea :) it's soo amazing uhhhhh 1 thing i wanna disagree on is in I Told You So you shoulda picked the one with Randy Travis :) I LOVE THIS VID DO
KnowYourEnemys 5 months ago
it sounds the same the only thing that is dif is that on cd its volume is inhanced
nathaniel4233 6 months ago
There's only a few differences when she sings live. Obviously when she's in the studio she's standing still. When on stage she's rocking out so it's harder on her breath control. Sometimes there's an off-pitch here & there. At the People's Choice Awards she had a cold. So she couldn't reach the high notes. Her voice cracked when she tried to go for it. Poor thing! But we Carrie fans are willing to look past that because her voice is still 97% same live. Most singers are only 25% at best.
Silver54ful 6 months ago
AMAZING VOICE ONLY DIFFERNC IS THE BACK GROUND NOISE LIVE HER VOICE DONT CHANGE!!!
plove209 10 months ago
i love how carrie is one of the only performers who can actually sound better live than on the cd
underwoodfan96 11 months ago
i think this video was kinda of pointless because as you can see everyone sounds good after they have been tuned with computer... but with carrie her voice is just more clear on the CD thats all!! Carrie has true talents!!!!!!!!!!
CarrieUnderwood2710 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is no difference!!
wormqueen3 1 year ago
She shows more talent when it's live but it's clear when it's not
Either way she's amazing
criminalmindslover22 1 year ago
i would love to see her record in the studio.. it probably takes one take since she's so damn amazing!!
lovela21 1 year ago
you should change the sound quality of the live videos
jlfernandez28 1 year ago
Wow, sounds the same minus the screaming :) good job carrie!
Opichicka4 1 year ago
Also, I find it very cool that you did a video like this; however, there's a noticeable quality difference between her Live versus CD, it's the audio quality not her vocal qualities, I can hear it on 360p, just saying.
Wugdor 1 year ago
@Wugdor That's the point, isn't it? The only difference IS the quality of the audio...
rytanya26 1 year ago 3
@rytanya26 You misunderstood my point. The AUDIO quality is NOTHING like watching it on 720-1080, let alone comparing to watching her live. The audio quality is on the low side compared to the normal 360 when it transitions into her live performances.
Wugdor 1 year ago
Too many screaming in the 1st live performance in Singapore >_>
Wugdor 1 year ago
Thanks for video. This is many reasons why Carrie is and always be amazing. She could release live cd. Her live versions are just as good as studio.
lizzyvance 1 year ago
this video is inceredible! it shows how truly stunning Carrie's vocals are. PERFECTION!
Carries1CareBear 1 year ago
i hate how her voice is as real as possible in the cds as she is live unlike black eyed peas
jrichca 1 year ago
hey u are asingaporean too?? me too!! i thought i am like the only one in spore who loves her!! GO carrie
r1r2r2 1 year ago
@r1r2r2 yep yep yep!!!!!! Which part are you from?? Did you go when she came down??
rytanya26 1 year ago
Comment removed
r1r2r2 1 year ago
@rytanya26 : im from bedok. no, i couldnt. it was my O level exam week at that moment of time. I was so SAD i could not make it. Hopefully. She will come back. do continue to have more videos of hers. P.S. i bought her PLAY ON CD!!
r1r2r2 1 year ago
@r1r2r2 cool.. I'm from Tampines. Sure, I'll keep making videos of her. If not of her, it's with her songs!! :D I did too! I got it all her CDs. And I bought her songs online too.. The best way to show someone our support is to buy their materials, right? :D
rytanya26 1 year ago
@rytanya26 : ooh ok thanks. Yup, the best way is to buy her CD!! plus, shes great!! like of course, shes 2-time entertainer of the year!!
r1r2r2 1 year ago
@r1r2r2 Haha.. true! btw, did you vote for her for the CMTs? The show is tomorow morning(singapore time).
rytanya26 1 year ago
@rytanya26 YUP. she won VIDEO OF THE YEAR and CMT performance of the year invitation only!! yay, carrie
r1r2r2 1 year ago
@r1r2r2 haha.. I know!!! I'm sooo glad she won. Her performance rock!!
rytanya26 1 year ago
@rytanya26 : absolutely...
r1r2r2 1 year ago
This is what you call an amazing singer.
kronicblaze89 1 year ago
Even Taylor herself on a phone conversation agrees that Carrie is just incredible live. It is almost unbelievable that someone of any style can perform live like that. Do people really understand what control it takes to pull off extremely difficult passages as she does so flawlessly and live. It is amazing.
LANDRU227 1 year ago
Is it live or memorex? Carrie is one of the best live singers ever!
vjer1015 1 year ago 2
Apart from the acoustics in change it almost like she lipsyncing she is that close to her CD version amazing!!!!
devildanger09 1 year ago
Taylor Swift sucks singing at AWARD shows. shes amazing on tour.
im not saying taylor has better vocals then carrie, im just saying give her some credit. thats all :) and carrie, AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
eMmaTaYtAy1 1 year ago
wow this video is amazing. it showcases her talent beautifully. her voice is flawless, best on the planet...it honestly is <3 thanks for this vid
Carries1CareBear 1 year ago
i love both taylor and carrie cause they are both really talented. @MissDvS18 taylor is awsome at both the same as Carrie i have no idea what u r talking about. but there shouldn't be a fight between carrie and taylor because they are both talented and have a gift of singing with beautiful voices. so don't hate one to love one as i say, love them both.
hakmatmanaa 1 year ago
@hakmatmanaa sorry no offence to u im speaking my mind.... I think carrie is a million times better than taylor...i like taylors singing on her cd but once shes live eww I think its terrible
lvhmsgirl96 1 year ago
Carrie and Leona! Definitely the voice of the generation! I wish they would do a duet!
Sinf0nia 1 year ago
@Sinf0nia tht wood be so amazing
lvhmsgirl96 1 year ago
hahaha and last name was one of her not better performances and i still thought it was amazing ahahahah
itsBRITTANYbee 1 year ago
outstanding clip,,,
22oozy 1 year ago
BETTER LIVE !!! SHE´S AMAZING !!!
pishu23 1 year ago
No difference she is NOT autotuned !!!!!!
molsson01 1 year ago
This just shows her talent! I've seen Carrie three times in concert and she sounds phenomenal live and knows how to put on the best show. Entertainer of the Year for sure. Plus she is a great person. I met her last month and she is great! Overall the best person :)
kamcclarey 1 year ago
Carrie is just good both ways
UrSoBadProductions 1 year ago
I believe that Carrie is probably one of the best live singers ever. She delivers every single time. Can't wait to see her in Vegas on May 22 Love her
1mondavia2 1 year ago
Can someone tell me, HOW DID TAYLOR BEAT HER FOR FEMALE VOCALISTS? Taylor cant hit the notes Carrie Hits. Carrie is the greatest singer that has ever lived. I love you Carrie, your biggest fan... Keep on Rocking.
MrJrball91 2 years ago 6
daaaaang. you could barely tell the difference except that one audio quality is better than the other and one as much more emotional and/or fun than the other. live ftw.
carrie, you, my dear, can siiiing.<3 i'm a metalhead, and i'm not afraid to say i love carrie underwood. gonna see her live at the HB october 2nd. =D
averagenikki 2 years ago 5
She is better live because she puts more emotions/feelings into the song. She doesn't need any enhancements in her voice because she is awesome. GO CARRIE!!!
carriefan020492 2 years ago 5
This is a perfect example of what I mean about the difference between Taylor and Carrie.
Taylor sounds good on CD's but HORRIBLE live.
Carrie is amazing on CD's AND is AMAZING live! She is actually better live.
MissDvS18 2 years ago 50
Not sure I agree. Taylor sounds decent/passable on CD, but absolutely TERRIBLE live.
Carrie sounds great on CDs and AMAZING live.
mellynumerounoo 2 years ago 7
@MissDvS18 i agree with u when i saw her live i was blown and she does sound better live
lvhmsgirl96 1 year ago
@MissDvS18 Have you ever seen Taylor Swift in concert? Just wondering...
swiftfan4life 1 year ago
live sounds muuuuuuuch better!!! I love her voice !!!
pishu23 2 years ago 5
great job! she sounds better LIVE lol.
mellynumerounoo 2 years ago 5
What a GREAT idea for a video! Love this! And Carrie is an absolutely OUTSTANDING live singer, I think she is probably the best actually, along with Kelly Clarkson and Leona Lewis. :) It's amazing to think that Carrie hasn't given one bad live performance in her career. :O In fact she is often better live than on CD. :D
3:15 - 4:32 is my favourite Carrie performance ever, it was flawless!!!
sharapova4eva 2 years ago 22
Great video...very few people can sound just as good as the CD live. This just goes to show that Carrie doesn't need any extra "studio magic" to make her sound good. Her voice is all she needs. God bless you Carrie and your beautiful music!!!
XxWildfiregirlxX 2 years ago 4
@XxWildfiregirlxX Carrie, Leona, Beyonce rocks!!!!!
gomugomu1987 2 years ago 3