你地追星盲目到無得彈:D自己偶像講一句棒棒堂咪咀就捧到人地上天甘勁.講真一句拉.你地自己偶像咪咀時.你地咪又系話支持自己偶像咪吾咪咀都甘好聽呢種謬論..可能有D棒棒堂FANS系偏激左小小系吾岩.旦系.你地有D人米又系甘..特別系成日叫人收皮改花名個種懶系正義超人既人.真系以為自己好正義?講出黎俾人恥笑你矛盾咋小朋友!.基本禮貌都冇.番屋企搵人教下自己咩叫禮貌先拉^^!
poohmok 1 month ago
@poohmok 返5p啦屌你老母臭西
jacky2113 1 week ago
棒棒糖的确实力不足,不过台湾都有实力Band噶,例如五月天都系very good!
busywoman94 1 month ago
@busywoman94 五月天都唱beyond
Hermanligreat 1 month ago 4
@Hermanligreat so what?我又不是话距地比beyond劲?
@busywoman94 閃靈,heavy metal ~~
hjxcvbnm 1 month ago
黃貫中 好型
Winson3268 1 month ago
咪嘴是關你1un事;)?
lolly9754 1 month ago
@lolly9754 佢串棒棒堂關你7事..
jyes18com 1 month ago 5
@jyes18com 佢問黃貫中關你7事...
@poohmok on9仔我屌你老母呀宜家
@lolly9754 垃圾
唉,,棒棒堂 d FANS 想點?(我兩邊也不是fans) 做野未經過大腦? 咪咀係真係有需要,, 就以為黃貫中串? 棒棒堂原本我都想聽下,, (我起碼也聽過像飛輪海的..) ,,但見到棒棒堂 d FANS 咁既樣,, 我連佢d 歌都唔想聽!!
PETER2005ET 2 months ago
仲有個咩華麗明星賽最後果集草蜢都咪嘴,正仆街
jacky2113 2 months ago
聽咪嘴好撚易聽, 果個咩cctv既春晚人人都咪嘴, 仆佢個街
黃貫中講既野冇錯,
但人地根本冇咪咀-,-
maggie00girl 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 聽得出架on9仔,我夠膽講大部分宜家果d咩偶像派都係咪嘴,屌你老母
果條柒頭vitas咪又係咪嘴,聽得出架,得佢地d on9垃圾fans先話冇
@jacky2113
你有去睇咩??
人講咩就話係,
你又知我唔識聽
仲有我老母生出黎比你屌嫁,
唔識"respect"呢個字,
你就冇資格撐佢啦
@maggie00girl 我有睇,我有聽,一定咪嘴,你咪撚嘈
@maggie00girl 咪得似又話唔係咪,你死撚開啦
@maggie00girl 你咪撚話我撐自己偶像,呢條片佢都有咪嘴, 可以對比架on9仔
/watch?v=6Y-ZwzUg_sw&feature=related
@maggie00girl 你唔識聽你就死撚開啦on9仔
收皮啦 棒棒堂 人地實力派!
alexpig007 2 months ago
冇阿信既五月天, 冇家駒既beyond !?
stevensou 3 months ago
棒棒堂收皮啦 唱歌又唔好聽 beyond勁過棒棒堂好多
棒棒堂算係咩? 型又唔夠人地型 靚仔又唔夠人地靚仔
支持beyond
abc50451 3 months ago 4
@abc50451
棒棒堂根本唔識唱歌,「讀」歌就幾叻既,Beyond個啲先係唱歌
AndrewFaith18 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
lollipop f jpm is the best.
棒棒堂起瑪型過你
TheRachelada 3 months ago
@TheRachelada Your grammar is wrong. You can't even type a proper sentence dude. Please shut up lol.
c147258 3 months ago
我覺得beyond的實力絕對有目共睹,棒棒堂我說實話沒別的意思,他們真的只是偶像團體,離實力還有一段距離,如果他們有看過黃家駒時期的全盛beyond.他們不是只會扭腰擺臀耍花招,而是詞曲創作歌唱獎項與樂器樣樣全能的團體.相較之下差別在哪顯而易見,有實力的路會比較長遠.而且棒棒堂還不是解散了.
anna101059 3 months ago 7
一眾棒迷唔好玩咁多"棒"呀! 傷身㗎! XDD
endlessrain100 5 months ago
030CAT 6 months ago 2
仲有無肉棒堂fans出黎比我串?多謝合作!
BNEjade 6 months ago 2
沒有在現場的 有何資格批評- -''??
mcc9595911 6 months ago 3
Comment removed
jesusyou1994 7 months ago
我相信求其喺街度問人,肯定識beyond既人多過棒棒堂囉...
JJ堂垃圾,剩係識RJ
gundamfrighter 7 months ago
唱得那麼難聽怎麽可能對嘴?
frying0stingray 9 months ago 7
hey guys.. dont let 棒棒堂 compare with paul pls...棒棒堂 just like kindergarden stage.. how to compare??? give young boy chance...honestly their song really terrible must keep to practice,,add oil
sickwoman2005 1 year ago
棒棒堂而家都收皮啦
冇實力 靠個樣又點會紅得耐啊
成班fans都有問題...一百個棒棒堂都比唔上一個黃貫中啦!
好心你地醒下啦
Suetmanman 1 year ago 140
肉棒:]] 一路好走^^~
bbo159753 1 year ago 3
如果家駒係到...棒棒堂一早無得撈啦 收啦
你話棒棒堂好後生 佢都唔夠我後生啦
我今年只係十三歳....搵棒棒堂同我比...
唉 收皮啦 Beyond才是王道!
leo759365 1 year ago 7
@leo759365 你個腦得十三阿? 唔洗咁大聲講俾人聽啵
jokermask2009 1 year ago
20多年的风风雨雨,beyond精神一直没变。感动。
jinfu413 1 year ago
棒棒堂真係唔掂,五音不全,跳舞又唔係話好勁,除咗敖犬同埋阿徫係跳得下既~其餘嗰D仲識D咩? 靠様? 我軆D様都係馬馬虎虎.
pandawsy7 1 year ago
黃貫中收皮啦~!!beyond年代一早冇左~out晒啦~就算唱live都冇乜人會欣賞~
gigichau1983 1 year ago
@gigichau1983 係你地唔識欣賞,唔好講埋我到,反而我真係唔知咩係肉棒堂,好似係咪散左band喇?唔怪得我唔識佢地啦,原來散左..唔怪得佢地既,唱歌都要咪嘴,冇實力就係咁架啦,哎,好似講多左tim,唔好意思喎,唔知你係棒迷....
eason163 1 year ago 7
@gigichau1983 收皮唔該....就算兒家唔係beyond年代都唔係會JJ堂既年代....話時話.....班條豬西死哂邊??
teddyq63 9 months ago 4
收皮啦
人地棒棒堂撚得罪你啊
你要咁話人?
叼
mei761 1 year ago
@mei761
小妹妹唔好成日講粗口啦,肉棒堂班人都無教你講
HKMJfansMichaelia 1 year ago 3
黃貫中型爆=w=
lvtvxq 1 year ago
真係收左皮,預言家!我支持你paul~
michaeliajackson 1 year ago 6
唔洗3年已經收左皮~.~
hiukiny92 1 year ago 7
Beyond,香港著名搖滾樂隊,成立於1983 年。華語樂壇上極具影響力的樂隊之一。Beyond不但在香港、中國大陸及台灣均有大量樂迷,即使遠在日本、新加坡、馬來西亞和海外等地區亦有支持者。
活躍年代 1983年-1999年、2003年-2005年
黃貫中(主音結他手、作曲、作詞及主音,1985年加入。)
ansonkong92 1 year ago 12
3年之後係度先同我講
l6h5k4 1 year ago 4
成班冇腦傻西肉棒FANS
fabregashk 1 year ago 72
人地虛心向學想咪咀又比人鬧
hkgmasterjoe 1 year ago 6
肉棒堂唔洗3年都收左皮
ymcafung 1 year ago 27
@ymcafung Good news. but be aware of the "fans", they gonna fuk u up for saying the truth
imaboy0304 1 year ago
妖,,收聲喇黃貫中
你檢討下自己喇
自己又5係勁'
可能3年後
消失ge係你吖
同埋你又冇去睇
憑咩甘話人吖
lovefabien88 1 year ago
黃貫中 食屎啦你 同唔支持棒棒堂既嘈咩啊?
13312343 2 years ago
棒棒堂靠檥渣!癈!
棒棒堂...你無撚野牙!
s115533b 2 years ago
唔好意思 黃貫中乜水
chung0224 2 years ago
你係唔係果d棒棒堂死忠狗迷?
x_x咪嘴好垃圾呀
on99haha 2 years ago
喂 (如果人地真係咪咁又點啊 ? 垃圾
@chung0224
hm... how old are you?
StitchCKA 1 year ago
棒棒堂?歌没什么特别又难听死,只是他们长得帅才。。阿paul说的好!!
angel0329ai 2 years ago
棒棒西
sportsgaming 2 years ago
棒棒堂...我永遠支持你地
黄貫中..你無撚野牙
sally1929 2 years ago 7
黄貫中..你無撚野牙
咁話人地
你好好咩
哼
emily9601 2 years ago 11
香港有幾十萬beyondfans,未計大陸,你地棒棒食屎,你地想係娛樂圈生存,就唔好串柒柒,你棒棒老闆金牌大都係聽beyond歌大架,0nlun99
sieeewky 2 years ago
我覺得黃貫中講得岩...
5係話佢串mj
係事實歌手有好多時都有咪咀ge必要(etc)
睇返以前d人拍mv咪咀咪得好差
依個係事實.....
gloria123able 2 years ago 61
唉. 點解會咁多無知既人-_-
'' 棒棒堂3年紅過你黃貫中, ''
哩句說話都講得出?
我真系唔明棒棒堂憑乜野可以同啊Paul比囉!
棒棒堂連啊paul既百分之一都比唔上!
Taiji1314hide 2 years ago
棒棒糖是什么东西?
beyondlwm 2 years ago
永遠支持棒棒堂,反黄貫中!!!!!
faifailui125 2 years ago 18
棒棒堂3年紅過你黃貫中,
我係黃貫中就檢討下自己,同埋冇面見人~_~
剩係識係到吠當唱歌,人地又拍戲又主持,
就算以後吾唱歌都會實力做其他節目.
黃貫中呢?拎住支咪吠左咁多年都吾紅
tungbb0129 2 years ago 12
@tungbb0129
黃貫中紅果陣你重未出世啦 on9
hero456441993 1 year ago 6
@hero456441993
講得好...
jackylightning67 1 year ago
who the fuck cares about 棒棒堂
they cant last for long
hei398 2 years ago
yaubaby0207 2 years ago 12
哈哈哈 就是就是!!!
好朋友 我顶你的话!^^
PPCLuvXiaoYu 2 years ago 2
黄贯x
died la~~
haha
shemanlool 2 years ago
佢1年後唔系唔見左
係死左呀~
546833623 2 years ago
0n9 黄贯中
546833623 2 years ago 4
on9 棒棒堂
s061038 1 year ago
棒棒堂真係on9仔先會鐘意
MRJKGOD 2 years ago
听棒棒糖个的都係肤浅
leong6210 2 years ago
你話咪就咪架啦...
唱live都冇事啦...
唔比人地live架..好笑啦..
你又冇去睇到..講咩先大佬...
最少人地紅得起呀..吹咩...
果個黃xx..你唔鬧棒棒堂呀又點有新聞呀...
冇新聞就冇新聞啦..唔好講3講4啦...
a02118 2 years ago 11
beyond當年第一隊hk band o係紅館開concert , fans 坐爆紅館果陣可能你都未出世, 而家冇棒棒堂咁紅又如何, o係台灣樂壇撐到廿年先講野
ady9190 2 years ago 10
PPCLuvXiaoYu 2 years ago
你個黃嘜q嘩.....唉,算了,唔知好過知呀,因為我係唔會記住一d靠話人地而自己上位ga人!! 你咁有本事就做哂棒棒堂ga拿手野出尼睇下.....哈哈.,,,唔得呀呢,,,未見識過棒棒堂ga實力就係度話人 冇前途.....
怪唔知得出道20幾年都冇棒棒堂咁紅啦
pg520love 2 years ago 16
算吧啦..你個黃嘜q e+棒棒堂有冇得罪你呀
你係唔係一定要講佢地ga 自己唔夠紅就係度話棒棒堂有幾差仲同我係度博上新聞.你慳d啦,我同你講我地棒迷係唔會一個廢人講ga野而係度嬲ga,,,,,
pg520love 2 years ago 14
低能既棒棒堂 其實我真係唔識佢地
垃圾不如 冇實力
leoncow 2 years ago
冇親耳聽過場演唱會就收聲啦
關你鬼事
tsz10 2 years ago 8
膠棒堂食shit啦
Keeou 2 years ago
hht5320tw 2 years ago 13
@hht5320tw 乐坛看脸的吗?那需要脸,有实力就够了。
一班几年,一个二十多年,比个屁
greenagnes 1 year ago
窮Paul想出位..因此在尻吹
petpetty44015 2 years ago 2
RUBBIS
what the fuck are that gay guy talking about.
tiffany26yu 2 years ago 3
sayou168 2 years ago 19
no no no
paul 黃貫中 is no 專業
lollipop good
shemanlool 2 years ago 7
@sayou168 有料就唔會比人話咪嘴:]
咪嘴都專業d 呀.. 巨棒底比人串 !
VincentMJMJ 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
棒棒糖是什么来的?可以吃吗?
adam6146 2 years ago
abc87771 唔好再識小小扮代表啦!!!
都係果句, Beyond 出道時肉棒堂仲飲緊奶咋~
rockylouie 2 years ago
棒棒堂 is really circus taem
patrickha1990 2 years ago
棒棒堂果d 叫跳舞勁!!!
好!!! 就唔講黃貫中丫, 人o地 MJ, 呀 Rain, 甚至郭富城,
論跳舞同經驗, 呢三子都勁過你肉棒堂啦~
黃貫中收皮啦
candyandgigi 2 years ago
i dont like 棒棒堂
shittyfuck 2 years ago
肉棒堂借beyond上位
chak1126 2 years ago
beyond 扮串上位..OH MY FUCKING GOD
abc87771 2 years ago
-v-棒棒堂邊有..
我反而覺得黃生批評棒棒堂所以佢演唱會多左報導
mandy31290 2 years ago 13
棒棒堂 can't sing , they shouldnt be called a boy band . they should be named a circus , since most of thier acts are dancing and jumping around.
lwzl 2 years ago
咁呀..我都想知一個問題..
棒棒堂係跳舞方面係台灣算"老幾"呢?
前十名不出者...不要囉出黎哂命~
jefflou11 2 years ago
关你么事啊?死低D
你又知棒棒堂點解作首歌做我是傳奇咩?
你地話我地唔知呀paul既事
你地又知咩?
我是傳奇呢首歌根本就唔係話要自稱自已係傳奇
你地呢d一早對棒有偏見既人
講咩都無用架啦
只係識話佢地唔識咩係音樂
咁paul識唔識跳舞呀?
michelle961129 2 years ago 4
我想同你講,首先阿Paul係一個音樂人,係玩音樂唔係跳舞!
第二,音樂同跳舞係兩樣野,唔好拉埋黎講!第三,係e件事上面係講緊棒咪嘴唔係跳舞,所以你唔可以講話阿Paul"識唔識跳舞?",因為係兩樣野!第四,棒跳舞咁好,不如去做舞蹈藝員,做咩唱歌?
erictang199048 2 years ago
搵黎搞
一個賣跳舞靚仔
一個賣唱歌同音樂
宜家人地棒棒堂吾尊重你咩
係你罵人先喎
又吾見你既fans去炸棒棒堂個Blog?
formocean 2 years ago 4
串得好正~
riversaviola 2 years ago
beyond既歌
真係連小學都教
一睇就知邊個既歌係好歌啦
cks20061 2 years ago 3
對唔住
我冇學過&無唱過beyond既歌
連beyond既歌都無聽過喎
cchkjj 2 years ago 6
咁你真係一d音樂文化都冇...
carman321 2 years ago
請問聽過beyond既歌就會有音樂文化嗎???
有很多人沒有聽過beyond既歌,難道那些人都沒有音樂文化嗎???
cchkjj 2 years ago
sor
beyond is who who who
shemanlool 2 years ago 2
得體
a012021489 2 years ago 4
popo00917
????
rockylouie :sorrysorry,想讚好,禁錯嘢,唔好嬲呀!!!
popo00917 2 years ago
linda95412,
你無o野呀!?!?
你緊係無聽過 Paul d 威水史啦,
人o地黃貫中 Beyond 時代果時,
你果d 肉棒堂仲飲緊奶咋!!!
試下出街問下人肉棒堂受歡迎d 定係黃貫中受歡迎d!!!
仲叫人o地好心檢討下, 唔好笑大人個肚啦,
恐怕佢o地仲未夠資格!!!
作為新人, 唔接受前輩意見, 又點會有進步丫~
rockylouie 2 years ago 4
出街問下人棒棒堂受歡迎d 定係黃貫中受歡迎d.
呢個問題好難講.未有人實驗過.
而且棒棒堂都無唔接受批評
mandy31290 2 years ago 12
棒棒堂 is good
黃貫中想出位
haha nice Paul....
chun30908 2 years ago 3
棒棒堂無料
棒棒堂fans白癡tim....
ai.......
terencelch 2 years ago 3
唉...算啦~~~d 妹妹仔只係識d "偶像派"..一味得個"靚仔"...靚仔佢就識...講音樂wo...哂氣啦~
我想知以家有無電視台會拍下d歌手既心路歷程..
beyond佢地就有拍一套佢地真人真事既心路歷程
佢地既努力,佢地既辛酸...一齊都有講出黎..
同你地既 "偶像派"相比....真係.."無得比"
jefflou11 2 years ago 8
講得o岩 唔識呀paul係你見識少
棒棒堂我剩係知有個叫咩野狗
imissyhy324 2 years ago 6
我聽都未聽過佢個名,棒棒堂受歡迎過佢啦,好心佢檢討下自己.
linda95412 2 years ago
咁係你見識少姐
tys221 2 years ago 2
beyond為樂壇作 出的貢獻唔係棒棒堂可以匹比架,beyond嘅歌有啲仲有教育意義且家傳戶曉,試問棒棒堂有邊首可以到如此地步?好心棒棒堂啲人跟前輩學下野啦,「i am legend」呢句佢地仲未夠資格講,「to go beyond one's depth」就襯晒啦。
chancheungkammic 2 years ago 5
以家係有錢同有歌就可以係紅館開架啦~~~
.....好心佢就咪借棒棒堂上位啦!!
丫paul洗借佢地上位咩..丫paul上位個陣..佢地都唔知係邊到..哈哈
kuen316 2 years ago 5
借棒棒堂上位???你真搞笑
paul洗借棒棒堂上位???
paul搞緊音樂
棒棒堂d人仲飲緊奶
saiku888 2 years ago 3
好似同出道幾耐係無關架波.
mandy31290 2 years ago 5
有無咁既需要呀!? XD
riversaviola 2 years ago 2
黃貫paul話曬都叫前輩吖,90年代beyond 勁過而家棒棒堂多多聲啦,
況且佢只係話佢地咪嘴,又冇話佢地唔受歡迎,
若果棒棒堂有埋唱功,我相信佢地一定唔止而家咁o既受歡迎程度囉,佢地而家只可以叫做偶像派咋!!!
kev817 2 years ago 12
哇. 好委屈啊點算呀? 自己咀賤重扮委屈.
zvxcafsd456 2 years ago
接受吾到批評
唔好出來講啦,無知
jackiechan830 2 years ago 3
棒棒堂正垃圾
jackiechan830 2 years ago
講真,係垃圾就唔會上到紅館
就算上到紅館唔係因為有實力
大家見到紅館坐滿人就知棒棒堂唔係垃圾啦
唔該你自己唔鐘意都唔好去批評人地囉
自己知自己事,依家唔係全世界都唔鐘意棒棒堂囉
仲有大把棒棒堂既忠實粉絲嫁,你咁樣講咪自己攞黎衰,最後又比人話!~!
winnie95130 2 years ago 10
wow..爆左咪好勁囉
你知唔知..2003年beyond係北京開演唱會..個場10萬個位爆左..係場外仲有3000名歌迷賴死唔走..完左場仲係場外丫..
kuen316 2 years ago
話人垃圾你自己咪仲垃圾
vani1204 2 years ago 5
i dont think they know everything cause they didnt really watch lollipop's concert
yumikkelly 2 years ago 8
張信哲踩棒棒堂咪嘴無技巧
23909290 2 years ago 14
這個黄老頭自己沒去過演唱會現場
憑什麼說 (爲了宣傳自己的演唱會借別人的人氣 這種人最可惡了)
只有說現在很討厭他 以前覺得他還好
現在發現他人品真很爛 自己被報導說與莫人開房 還說什麼不要信報導 可是現在別人在被報紙亂說就信了 難道他與莫人開房也是真的? 以後他的八卦我們都相信好了~~
joyvelittle 2 years ago
點進步啊?
yathotang2000 2 years ago 5
ihatepotatocher 2 years ago
你地追星盲目到無得彈:D自己偶像講一句棒棒堂咪咀就捧到人地上天甘勁.講真一句拉.你地自己偶像咪咀時.你地咪又系話支持自己偶像咪吾咪咀都甘好聽呢種謬論..可能有D棒棒堂FANS系偏激左小小系吾岩.旦系.你地有D人米又系甘..特別系成日叫人收皮改花名個種懶系正義超人既人.真系以為自己好正義?講出黎俾人恥笑你矛盾咋小朋友!.基本禮貌都冇.番屋企搵人教下自己咩叫禮貌先拉^^!
poohmok 1 month ago
@poohmok 返5p啦屌你老母臭西
jacky2113 1 week ago
棒棒糖的确实力不足,不过台湾都有实力Band噶,例如五月天都系very good!
busywoman94 1 month ago
@busywoman94 五月天都唱beyond
Hermanligreat 1 month ago 4
@Hermanligreat so what?我又不是话距地比beyond劲?
busywoman94 1 month ago
@busywoman94 閃靈,heavy metal ~~
hjxcvbnm 1 month ago
黃貫中 好型
Winson3268 1 month ago
咪嘴是關你1un事;)?
lolly9754 1 month ago
@lolly9754 佢串棒棒堂關你7事..
jyes18com 1 month ago 5
@jyes18com 佢問黃貫中關你7事...
poohmok 1 month ago
@poohmok on9仔我屌你老母呀宜家
jacky2113 1 week ago
@lolly9754 垃圾
jacky2113 1 week ago
唉,,棒棒堂 d FANS 想點?(我兩邊也不是fans) 做野未經過大腦? 咪咀係真係有需要,, 就以為黃貫中串? 棒棒堂原本我都想聽下,, (我起碼也聽過像飛輪海的..) ,,但見到棒棒堂 d FANS 咁既樣,, 我連佢d 歌都唔想聽!!
PETER2005ET 2 months ago
仲有個咩華麗明星賽最後果集草蜢都咪嘴,正仆街
jacky2113 2 months ago
聽咪嘴好撚易聽, 果個咩cctv既春晚人人都咪嘴, 仆佢個街
jacky2113 2 months ago
黃貫中講既野冇錯,
但人地根本冇咪咀-,-
maggie00girl 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 聽得出架on9仔,我夠膽講大部分宜家果d咩偶像派都係咪嘴,屌你老母
果條柒頭vitas咪又係咪嘴,聽得出架,得佢地d on9垃圾fans先話冇
jacky2113 2 months ago
@jacky2113
你有去睇咩??
人講咩就話係,
你又知我唔識聽
仲有我老母生出黎比你屌嫁,
唔識"respect"呢個字,
你就冇資格撐佢啦
maggie00girl 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 我有睇,我有聽,一定咪嘴,你咪撚嘈
jacky2113 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 咪得似又話唔係咪,你死撚開啦
jacky2113 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 你咪撚話我撐自己偶像,呢條片佢都有咪嘴, 可以對比架on9仔
/watch?v=6Y-ZwzUg_sw&feature=related
jacky2113 2 months ago
@maggie00girl 你唔識聽你就死撚開啦on9仔
jacky2113 2 months ago
收皮啦 棒棒堂 人地實力派!
alexpig007 2 months ago
冇阿信既五月天, 冇家駒既beyond !?
stevensou 3 months ago
棒棒堂收皮啦 唱歌又唔好聽 beyond勁過棒棒堂好多
棒棒堂算係咩? 型又唔夠人地型 靚仔又唔夠人地靚仔
支持beyond
abc50451 3 months ago 4
@abc50451
棒棒堂根本唔識唱歌,「讀」歌就幾叻既,Beyond個啲先係唱歌
AndrewFaith18 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
lollipop f jpm is the best.
棒棒堂起瑪型過你
TheRachelada 3 months ago
@TheRachelada Your grammar is wrong. You can't even type a proper sentence dude. Please shut up lol.
c147258 3 months ago
我覺得beyond的實力絕對有目共睹,棒棒堂我說實話沒別的意思,他們真的只是偶像團體,離實力還有一段距離,如果他們有看過黃家駒時期的全盛beyond.他們不是只會扭腰擺臀耍花招,而是詞曲創作歌唱獎項與樂器樣樣全能的團體.相較之下差別在哪顯而易見,有實力的路會比較長遠.而且棒棒堂還不是解散了.
anna101059 3 months ago 7
一眾棒迷唔好玩咁多"棒"呀! 傷身㗎! XDD
endlessrain100 5 months ago
030CAT 6 months ago 2
仲有無肉棒堂fans出黎比我串?多謝合作!
BNEjade 6 months ago 2
沒有在現場的 有何資格批評- -''??
mcc9595911 6 months ago 3
Comment removed
jesusyou1994 7 months ago
我相信求其喺街度問人,肯定識beyond既人多過棒棒堂囉...
jesusyou1994 7 months ago
JJ堂垃圾,剩係識RJ
gundamfrighter 7 months ago
唱得那麼難聽怎麽可能對嘴?
frying0stingray 9 months ago 7
hey guys.. dont let 棒棒堂 compare with paul pls...棒棒堂 just like kindergarden stage.. how to compare??? give young boy chance...honestly their song really terrible must keep to practice,,add oil
sickwoman2005 1 year ago
Comment removed
sickwoman2005 1 year ago
棒棒堂而家都收皮啦
冇實力 靠個樣又點會紅得耐啊
成班fans都有問題...一百個棒棒堂都比唔上一個黃貫中啦!
好心你地醒下啦
Suetmanman 1 year ago 140
肉棒:]] 一路好走^^~
bbo159753 1 year ago 3
如果家駒係到...棒棒堂一早無得撈啦 收啦
你話棒棒堂好後生 佢都唔夠我後生啦
我今年只係十三歳....搵棒棒堂同我比...
唉 收皮啦 Beyond才是王道!
leo759365 1 year ago 7
@leo759365 你個腦得十三阿? 唔洗咁大聲講俾人聽啵
jokermask2009 1 year ago
20多年的风风雨雨,beyond精神一直没变。感动。
jinfu413 1 year ago
棒棒堂真係唔掂,五音不全,跳舞又唔係話好勁,除咗敖犬同埋阿徫係跳得下既~其餘嗰D仲識D咩? 靠様? 我軆D様都係馬馬虎虎.
pandawsy7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
黃貫中收皮啦~!!beyond年代一早冇左~out晒啦~就算唱live都冇乜人會欣賞~
gigichau1983 1 year ago
@gigichau1983 係你地唔識欣賞,唔好講埋我到,反而我真係唔知咩係肉棒堂,好似係咪散左band喇?唔怪得我唔識佢地啦,原來散左..唔怪得佢地既,唱歌都要咪嘴,冇實力就係咁架啦,哎,好似講多左tim,唔好意思喎,唔知你係棒迷....
eason163 1 year ago 7
@gigichau1983 收皮唔該....就算兒家唔係beyond年代都唔係會JJ堂既年代....話時話.....班條豬西死哂邊??
teddyq63 9 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
收皮啦
人地棒棒堂撚得罪你啊
你要咁話人?
叼
mei761 1 year ago
@mei761
小妹妹唔好成日講粗口啦,肉棒堂班人都無教你講
HKMJfansMichaelia 1 year ago 3
黃貫中型爆=w=
lvtvxq 1 year ago
真係收左皮,預言家!我支持你paul~
michaeliajackson 1 year ago 6
唔洗3年已經收左皮~.~
hiukiny92 1 year ago 7
Beyond,香港著名搖滾樂隊,成立於1983 年。華語樂壇上極具影響力的樂隊之一。Beyond不但在香港、中國大陸及台灣均有大量樂迷,即使遠在日本、新加坡、馬來西亞和海外等地區亦有支持者。
活躍年代 1983年-1999年、2003年-2005年
黃貫中(主音結他手、作曲、作詞及主音,1985年加入。)
ansonkong92 1 year ago 12
3年之後係度先同我講
l6h5k4 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
成班冇腦傻西肉棒FANS
fabregashk 1 year ago 72
人地虛心向學想咪咀又比人鬧
hkgmasterjoe 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
肉棒堂唔洗3年都收左皮
ymcafung 1 year ago 27
@ymcafung Good news. but be aware of the "fans", they gonna fuk u up for saying the truth
imaboy0304 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
妖,,收聲喇黃貫中
你檢討下自己喇
自己又5係勁'
可能3年後
消失ge係你吖
同埋你又冇去睇
憑咩甘話人吖
lovefabien88 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
黃貫中 食屎啦你 同唔支持棒棒堂既嘈咩啊?
13312343 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂靠檥渣!癈!
棒棒堂...你無撚野牙!
s115533b 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唔好意思 黃貫中乜水
chung0224 2 years ago
你係唔係果d棒棒堂死忠狗迷?
x_x咪嘴好垃圾呀
on99haha 2 years ago
喂 (如果人地真係咪咁又點啊 ? 垃圾
13312343 2 years ago
@chung0224
hm... how old are you?
StitchCKA 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂?歌没什么特别又难听死,只是他们长得帅才。。阿paul说的好!!
angel0329ai 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒西
sportsgaming 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂...我永遠支持你地
黄貫中..你無撚野牙
sally1929 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂...我永遠支持你地
黄貫中..你無撚野牙
咁話人地
你好好咩
哼
emily9601 2 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
香港有幾十萬beyondfans,未計大陸,你地棒棒食屎,你地想係娛樂圈生存,就唔好串柒柒,你棒棒老闆金牌大都係聽beyond歌大架,0nlun99
sieeewky 2 years ago
我覺得黃貫中講得岩...
5係話佢串mj
係事實歌手有好多時都有咪咀ge必要(etc)
睇返以前d人拍mv咪咀咪得好差
依個係事實.....
gloria123able 2 years ago 61
唉. 點解會咁多無知既人-_-
'' 棒棒堂3年紅過你黃貫中, ''
哩句說話都講得出?
我真系唔明棒棒堂憑乜野可以同啊Paul比囉!
棒棒堂連啊paul既百分之一都比唔上!
Taiji1314hide 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒糖是什么东西?
beyondlwm 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
永遠支持棒棒堂,反黄貫中!!!!!
faifailui125 2 years ago 18
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂3年紅過你黃貫中,
我係黃貫中就檢討下自己,同埋冇面見人~_~
剩係識係到吠當唱歌,人地又拍戲又主持,
就算以後吾唱歌都會實力做其他節目.
黃貫中呢?拎住支咪吠左咁多年都吾紅
tungbb0129 2 years ago 12
@tungbb0129
黃貫中紅果陣你重未出世啦 on9
hero456441993 1 year ago 6
@hero456441993
講得好...
jackylightning67 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who the fuck cares about 棒棒堂
they cant last for long
hei398 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yaubaby0207 2 years ago 12
哈哈哈 就是就是!!!
好朋友 我顶你的话!^^
PPCLuvXiaoYu 2 years ago 2
黄贯x
died la~~
haha
shemanlool 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
佢1年後唔系唔見左
係死左呀~
546833623 2 years ago
0n9 黄贯中
546833623 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
on9 棒棒堂
hei398 2 years ago
Comment removed
s061038 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂真係on9仔先會鐘意
MRJKGOD 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
听棒棒糖个的都係肤浅
leong6210 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你話咪就咪架啦...
唱live都冇事啦...
唔比人地live架..好笑啦..
你又冇去睇到..講咩先大佬...
最少人地紅得起呀..吹咩...
果個黃xx..你唔鬧棒棒堂呀又點有新聞呀...
冇新聞就冇新聞啦..唔好講3講4啦...
a02118 2 years ago 11
beyond當年第一隊hk band o係紅館開concert , fans 坐爆紅館果陣可能你都未出世, 而家冇棒棒堂咁紅又如何, o係台灣樂壇撐到廿年先講野
ady9190 2 years ago 10
Comment removed
PPCLuvXiaoYu 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你個黃嘜q嘩.....唉,算了,唔知好過知呀,因為我係唔會記住一d靠話人地而自己上位ga人!! 你咁有本事就做哂棒棒堂ga拿手野出尼睇下.....哈哈.,,,唔得呀呢,,,未見識過棒棒堂ga實力就係度話人 冇前途.....
怪唔知得出道20幾年都冇棒棒堂咁紅啦
pg520love 2 years ago 16
This has been flagged as spam show
算吧啦..你個黃嘜q e+棒棒堂有冇得罪你呀
你係唔係一定要講佢地ga 自己唔夠紅就係度話棒棒堂有幾差仲同我係度博上新聞.你慳d啦,我同你講我地棒迷係唔會一個廢人講ga野而係度嬲ga,,,,,
pg520love 2 years ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
低能既棒棒堂 其實我真係唔識佢地
垃圾不如 冇實力
leoncow 2 years ago
冇親耳聽過場演唱會就收聲啦
關你鬼事
tsz10 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
膠棒堂食shit啦
Keeou 2 years ago
Comment removed
hht5320tw 2 years ago 13
@hht5320tw 乐坛看脸的吗?那需要脸,有实力就够了。
一班几年,一个二十多年,比个屁
greenagnes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
窮Paul想出位..因此在尻吹
petpetty44015 2 years ago 2
RUBBIS
what the fuck are that gay guy talking about.
tiffany26yu 2 years ago 3
sayou168 2 years ago 19
no no no
paul 黃貫中 is no 專業
lollipop good
shemanlool 2 years ago 7
@sayou168 有料就唔會比人話咪嘴:]
bbo159753 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
咪嘴都專業d 呀.. 巨棒底比人串 !
VincentMJMJ 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
棒棒糖是什么来的?可以吃吗?
adam6146 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
abc87771 唔好再識小小扮代表啦!!!
都係果句, Beyond 出道時肉棒堂仲飲緊奶咋~
rockylouie 2 years ago
棒棒堂 is really circus taem
patrickha1990 2 years ago
棒棒堂果d 叫跳舞勁!!!
好!!! 就唔講黃貫中丫, 人o地 MJ, 呀 Rain, 甚至郭富城,
論跳舞同經驗, 呢三子都勁過你肉棒堂啦~
rockylouie 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
黃貫中收皮啦
candyandgigi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont like 棒棒堂
shittyfuck 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
肉棒堂借beyond上位
chak1126 2 years ago
beyond 扮串上位..OH MY FUCKING GOD
abc87771 2 years ago
-v-棒棒堂邊有..
我反而覺得黃生批評棒棒堂所以佢演唱會多左報導
mandy31290 2 years ago 13
棒棒堂 can't sing , they shouldnt be called a boy band . they should be named a circus , since most of thier acts are dancing and jumping around.
lwzl 2 years ago
咁呀..我都想知一個問題..
棒棒堂係跳舞方面係台灣算"老幾"呢?
前十名不出者...不要囉出黎哂命~
jefflou11 2 years ago
关你么事啊?死低D
abc87771 2 years ago
你又知棒棒堂點解作首歌做我是傳奇咩?
你地話我地唔知呀paul既事
你地又知咩?
我是傳奇呢首歌根本就唔係話要自稱自已係傳奇
你地呢d一早對棒有偏見既人
講咩都無用架啦
只係識話佢地唔識咩係音樂
咁paul識唔識跳舞呀?
michelle961129 2 years ago 4
我想同你講,首先阿Paul係一個音樂人,係玩音樂唔係跳舞!
第二,音樂同跳舞係兩樣野,唔好拉埋黎講!第三,係e件事上面係講緊棒咪嘴唔係跳舞,所以你唔可以講話阿Paul"識唔識跳舞?",因為係兩樣野!第四,棒跳舞咁好,不如去做舞蹈藝員,做咩唱歌?
erictang199048 2 years ago
搵黎搞
一個賣跳舞靚仔
一個賣唱歌同音樂
宜家人地棒棒堂吾尊重你咩
係你罵人先喎
又吾見你既fans去炸棒棒堂個Blog?
formocean 2 years ago 4
串得好正~
riversaviola 2 years ago
beyond既歌
真係連小學都教
一睇就知邊個既歌係好歌啦
cks20061 2 years ago 3
對唔住
我冇學過&無唱過beyond既歌
連beyond既歌都無聽過喎
cchkjj 2 years ago 6
咁你真係一d音樂文化都冇...
carman321 2 years ago
請問聽過beyond既歌就會有音樂文化嗎???
有很多人沒有聽過beyond既歌,難道那些人都沒有音樂文化嗎???
cchkjj 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sor
beyond is who who who
shemanlool 2 years ago 2
得體
a012021489 2 years ago 4
popo00917
????
rockylouie 2 years ago
rockylouie :sorrysorry,想讚好,禁錯嘢,唔好嬲呀!!!
popo00917 2 years ago
rockylouie :sorrysorry,想讚好,禁錯嘢,唔好嬲呀!!!
popo00917 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
linda95412,
你無o野呀!?!?
你緊係無聽過 Paul d 威水史啦,
人o地黃貫中 Beyond 時代果時,
你果d 肉棒堂仲飲緊奶咋!!!
試下出街問下人肉棒堂受歡迎d 定係黃貫中受歡迎d!!!
仲叫人o地好心檢討下, 唔好笑大人個肚啦,
恐怕佢o地仲未夠資格!!!
作為新人, 唔接受前輩意見, 又點會有進步丫~
rockylouie 2 years ago 4
出街問下人棒棒堂受歡迎d 定係黃貫中受歡迎d.
呢個問題好難講.未有人實驗過.
而且棒棒堂都無唔接受批評
mandy31290 2 years ago 12
棒棒堂 is good
黃貫中想出位
shemanlool 2 years ago 7
haha nice Paul....
chun30908 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂無料
棒棒堂fans白癡tim....
ai.......
terencelch 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
唉...算啦~~~d 妹妹仔只係識d "偶像派"..一味得個"靚仔"...靚仔佢就識...講音樂wo...哂氣啦~
我想知以家有無電視台會拍下d歌手既心路歷程..
beyond佢地就有拍一套佢地真人真事既心路歷程
佢地既努力,佢地既辛酸...一齊都有講出黎..
同你地既 "偶像派"相比....真係.."無得比"
jefflou11 2 years ago 8
講得o岩 唔識呀paul係你見識少
棒棒堂我剩係知有個叫咩野狗
imissyhy324 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
我聽都未聽過佢個名,棒棒堂受歡迎過佢啦,好心佢檢討下自己.
linda95412 2 years ago
咁係你見識少姐
tys221 2 years ago 2
beyond為樂壇作 出的貢獻唔係棒棒堂可以匹比架,beyond嘅歌有啲仲有教育意義且家傳戶曉,試問棒棒堂有邊首可以到如此地步?好心棒棒堂啲人跟前輩學下野啦,「i am legend」呢句佢地仲未夠資格講,「to go beyond one's depth」就襯晒啦。
chancheungkammic 2 years ago 5
jefflou11 2 years ago
以家係有錢同有歌就可以係紅館開架啦~~~
jefflou11 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
.....好心佢就咪借棒棒堂上位啦!!
546833623 2 years ago
丫paul洗借佢地上位咩..丫paul上位個陣..佢地都唔知係邊到..哈哈
kuen316 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
借棒棒堂上位???你真搞笑
paul洗借棒棒堂上位???
paul搞緊音樂
棒棒堂d人仲飲緊奶
saiku888 2 years ago 3
好似同出道幾耐係無關架波.
mandy31290 2 years ago 5
有無咁既需要呀!? XD
riversaviola 2 years ago 2
黃貫paul話曬都叫前輩吖,90年代beyond 勁過而家棒棒堂多多聲啦,
況且佢只係話佢地咪嘴,又冇話佢地唔受歡迎,
若果棒棒堂有埋唱功,我相信佢地一定唔止而家咁o既受歡迎程度囉,佢地而家只可以叫做偶像派咋!!!
kev817 2 years ago 12
哇. 好委屈啊點算呀? 自己咀賤重扮委屈.
zvxcafsd456 2 years ago
接受吾到批評
唔好出來講啦,無知
jackiechan830 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
棒棒堂正垃圾
jackiechan830 2 years ago
講真,係垃圾就唔會上到紅館
就算上到紅館唔係因為有實力
大家見到紅館坐滿人就知棒棒堂唔係垃圾啦
唔該你自己唔鐘意都唔好去批評人地囉
自己知自己事,依家唔係全世界都唔鐘意棒棒堂囉
仲有大把棒棒堂既忠實粉絲嫁,你咁樣講咪自己攞黎衰,最後又比人話!~!
winnie95130 2 years ago 10
wow..爆左咪好勁囉
你知唔知..2003年beyond係北京開演唱會..個場10萬個位爆左..係場外仲有3000名歌迷賴死唔走..完左場仲係場外丫..
kuen316 2 years ago
話人垃圾你自己咪仲垃圾
vani1204 2 years ago 5
i dont think they know everything cause they didnt really watch lollipop's concert
yumikkelly 2 years ago 8
張信哲踩棒棒堂咪嘴無技巧
23909290 2 years ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
這個黄老頭自己沒去過演唱會現場
憑什麼說 (爲了宣傳自己的演唱會借別人的人氣 這種人最可惡了)
只有說現在很討厭他 以前覺得他還好
現在發現他人品真很爛 自己被報導說與莫人開房 還說什麼不要信報導 可是現在別人在被報紙亂說就信了 難道他與莫人開房也是真的? 以後他的八卦我們都相信好了~~
joyvelittle 2 years ago
接受吾到批評
點進步啊?
yathotang2000 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
ihatepotatocher 2 years ago