Dasam Granth and Clarification on Nitnem Banis

[pupinder01]

Plz ppl b4 makin any kind of decision read sikh rehat maryada wich was made in early 50s if i remember and it took over 150 sikh panths vidvhans so plz make a wise decision wjkk wjkf.

[Bachitersingh100]

I AM MEMBER OF GURU GRANTH SATKAR JATHEBANDI (KARNAL),,,,,,,,, SARI SIKH SANGAT NU PRO. DARSHAN SINGH KHALSA JI DA DHANVAD KARNA CHAHIDA HAI,,, KHALSA JI GURU DE SIKH AAP JI DE NAAL HUN,,WJKK WJKF

[CalSingh]

Don' talk trash darshan lal

[aman113]

. Guru ji says himself that one should be able to analyse any words written by guru. Guru ji says saachaa saahib saachee naaee parakhai gur kee baath kharee. Guru ji then himself sets the factors upon which the gurus words will be tested. Guru ji says anthar sabadh niranthar mudhraa houmai mamathaa dhoor karee and kaam krodhh ahankaar nivaarai gur kai sabadh s samajh paree. If Dasam Granth can't pass test based on these factors then it is certianly not the words of guru so lets all unite.

[aman113]

God has given us 5 gyan indrey please make use of them and you will find that our only guru is Shiri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Prof sahib is telling the truth and if you don't believe it then go read dasam granth and if you still don't believe in prof sahib then you are either brainwashed or have no knowledge of gurbani hence you can;t make any comparisons.

[gurtej176]

this guy is not doing the right thing .......waheguru is nu sadbudhi de.....WJKK WJKF,

and who dont know this WJKF is from dasam granth

[aman113]

@gurtej176 If I give you a book which has many useful things in there which will help you in your life and help you be one with god however at the same time I put in some rude things such as inappropriate teaching which may be getting you away from god. You think that because there are lots of good things in the book it means all of the book is good and can benefit you? The answer would be a big NO and that is what dasam granth is all about. Read it to believe it

[1708khalsa]

long live prof saab......u are a true parcharak of sikh kaum

[snowdontop]

PAATH PARYO aur ved vichario nival bhuyangam sadhe, PANCH JANA SION SANG NAAN CHUTKIO, adik ahang budh badhe. Mae en bidh milan na jae main kiye karam aneka, haar paryo swami ke dware, MOHE DEEJE BUDH BEEBEKA.

Still you want to do daily tota-ratni thing??pray to akal purkh for Bibek Budhi, so that u can lead a truthful and honest life.

Bhul chuk maaf for this goor-gyan.

[moneylandusa]

Crazy people these days

[DesiiParii]

rss wi dasam granth nu mandi hai (gurcharanjit lamba)

prof darshan singh khalsa zindabaaad

[punjabsingh08]

When and where did Lamba say :

rss wi dasam granth nu mandi hai (gurcharanjit lamba) ??

If he did say then can anyone deny that Lamba is from RSS ?

[harry8206]

dhan sri guru granth sahib ji......our only guru.......so called baahman granth should be removed.....otherwise babbar khalsa is coming....wjkwjf

[300khalsa]

my message to all jathedaars....es baahman granth nu ....shri guru granth sahib ji naalo hata diyo.........nayi ta babbar khalsa is coming.......bole so nihaal......sat sri akal.....

[harry8206]

prof.darshan singh ji carry on with ur good work.........saari sikh kaum tuhaade naal aa....

[harry8206]

oye dharamyudh......lagda tuhaanu baahmana nu indira gandhi da chete bhul gaya.....lalit maike da chete bhul gaya..........dasam granth(baahman granth) saada guru ni.......our only guru is shri guru granth sahib ji.......bole so nihaal.....sat sri akal

[300khalsa]

dharamyudh baahmana go and read ur shiv pranh and maarkande pranh.....ethe ki karda baahmana....

[300khalsa]

prof.darshan singh true khalsa of shri guru gobind singh ji.....our only guru is shri guru granth sahib ji......dasam granth(bachitar natak) eh saada guru ni....na es nu brabari diti ja sakdi..wjkwjf

[dharamyudh]

Haan, Harry 8206 knows everything. Everybody ask him if you have any questions.

Amar Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Ji was RSS agent. He with RSS changed the name to Dasam Granth.

And Savdhan, I really accuse the Hazoor Sahib wale, Why the hell they didn't ask Prof. Darshan whether or not they should do the parkash of Dasam Granth. Inhan hazoor sahab walyan nu sharam nahi aundi.

Prof. Darshan Singh will decide whether sikhs will read dasam granth or not.

Prof Darshan Ashleel di jai ho

[anandsatnam]

Just by taunting someone the way you are doing won't prove u right. Listen carefully to what Prof. is saying and then think what's wrong in it?

[harry8206]

dasam granth da pehla naam bachitar natak si.....kuch anparh sikha ne RSS waaliya naal ral ke...es da naam dasam granth rakh dita......hun es da naam change karke...dasam shri guru granth sahib ji rakh dita.......hazoor saab vich es granth da parkaash bhi hunda.....ehna loka nu eh karan da kehne haq dita?..

[s00rma1]

Bachitar batak aka dasam granth vich bhot ganda likheya GURU GOBIND SINGH ji baare RSS ne ..

RSS wale chaunde ne BACHITAR NATAK noo sikh matha tekan te ehde piche lagan te sikh kamzor hon sada guru DHAN DHAN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB HAI hor koi nahi

[itit4444]

CANT STAND THE TRUTH? try reading dasam grantha and then see

[gaganjisinghji]

I have read it a few times already. IT says Guru Gobind Singh ji lies as he tries to evade a women who would like to further her intimate relations (I have watered it down).

youtubedotcom/watch?v=vUsHAQSF­57c

[parrylondon]

dasam granth has been writen by kalgidhar patshah, those who are raising doubts, believe me will raise doubts about "bhagat bani" "bhat bani" and will tell you about the difference of "guru bani" (mehel bani), and in the last they will be telling you why its not a gurmat to give"rumala" on guru granth sahib . they will raise questions about hairs ,kirpans. , for just proving we are not hindu they are burning sikh history, what will you do to face the muslims ?

[link2tdss]

Agreed he wrote it, but he also wrote " har shikaan ko hukam hai guru manyeo granth", so why raise an issue about a book, not guru, just a book

[bhangrafan]

so basically Prof. Darshan Singh Ragi is saying to READ the Nitnem Bani such as Jaap Sahib, Tav. Svaiye, and Chaupaye Sahib because they are part of Nitnem, but he is telling us not to Parkash them together with Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. He also agrees with the Ardas as approved by the Panth. Why can't both sides understand eachother with an open mind and reach to a conclusion, but theres ego on both sides.

[khalistani4lyfe]

dashan singh has used derrogatory terms for Sri Dasam Granth sahib... we believe...bani guru guru hai bani.... dasam granth is the bani of sri guru gobind singh ji maharaj... the removal of any part of the dasam granth shall be untolerated by the panth.

[harry8206]

@khalistani4lyfe...oye baahmana khalistani id rakhan naal tu sikh ni ban jaana......sikh banan layi sir niwaa te matt uchi chaidi......jehri tere warge baahman vich kade bhi ni aa sakdi.....bole so nihaal...sat sri akal

[khalistani4lyfe]

u guys use the word bahman as derrogatory term... is it hate? I believe that everyone in the world is equal so go ahead call me a bahman as u have no facts but can only cuss, i know better than to call u names

[singhtothecore]

Does it really matters if the decision on Bhatitar Natak banis was taken 60 years ago. What does not seem according to the sikh way of life of high character and worship on one almighty god must be discarded. Just because we have been going in the wrong direction for 60 years does not justifies even one second of it.

Love and open mindedness to all

[socalleddasamgranth]

Could Guru Gobind Singh write such stories and such stanzas which the readers would find in Chritropakhyan. Not only the Chritropakhyan, some parts in many other Chapters, such as Krishna Avatar are equally erotic. Could readers sit down with their wives, sisters,mothers and children and read aloud these tales? Most of them are epitome of degradation to womanhood. They are as pornographic as the present day adult movies.

[0KARIL2h0]

thanks for taking the time to write those wonderful sentecnes maybe people will come to their sences

[pumagill]

ਮਾਸਹੁ ਬਾਹਰਿ ਕਢਿਆ ਮੰਮਾ ਮਾਸੁ ਗਿਰਾਸੁ ॥ we read this in the presence of wives, sisters,mothers and children, dont we ? & .thats not all. Read Isher Singhs Book on the subject. Not a good book but must be able to provide u some insight About socalled "Bad" words.

[kaalmahakaal]

Choupai, Kavi-o-vach has 405 couplets in Dasam Granth but in Gutkas only 397 to 405 no. couplets are given that too with numbering starting from number one. Sikhs should know who has changed it and why?

[hardeepbhatia79]

Guru Gobind Singh ordained the Sikhs to accept Guru Granth Sahib as the perpetual eternal Guru of Sikhs, which contains the revealed word of God. It completely rejects the Gods and Goddess of Hinduism and their reincarnations and the worship of Idols.

[hardeepbhatia79]

SGPC approved SRM (1927-1945) again endorses only one Granth " Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji" for the Sikhs. Sikh Reht Maryada(THE CODE OF SIKH CONDUCT AND CONVENTIONS)Section Three,CHAPTER IV Joining the congregation for understanding of and reflecting on Gurbani Article V(e) "No book should he installed like and at par with the Guru Granth Sahib".10th Guru Ji Sanctified ( gave Gur Gadhi) only to Guru Granth sahib Ji . Therefore, Dasam Granth Parkash Cannot be done parallel to SGGS

[hardeepbhatia79]

Sikh Nation has only One Granth (Sri Guru Granth sahib Ji),One Panth and One Guru Panth approved Rehat Maryada.

[daylightblub]

I Pray to Sri Akal Purkh. Every Sikh get the sence like You.

Har Har simroe.