I cry every time I watch this. It was bad enough when Casey was voted off. I was just do moved by James in this last song. The emotion was so heartfelt.
So everybody always start talking about Haley, forever and always. Doesn't matter if you love her or hate her, you can't forget her. So yeah, Haley Haley Haley! Woo!
James was absolutly ridiculous when he was voted off!
"Man, I worked so damn hard to get here" like no one else on the show did?
"I did sooo much stuff thats never been done on this show before"
Yes, james does has talent, but he pretty much copied adam lambert, so how is that bringing new stuff to the show? In my opinon Haley Reinhart should have won, you've got to give it to the girl who can sing fleetwood mac,blues,elton john, and even Led Zeppelin! James was sooo overated
@chloeisthename Why Haley has so passionate and hateful fans? if want to know if someone is a bad person, just find out if this person is haley's fan.
new things: let me see: heavy metal to idol, hard rock, to idol, he worked the stage like no one, running around, dancing, flaming a piano, saluting judges in the middle of the song, climbing up the judge's table, crazy theatrical sutff, like in muse's song
he may be not the best singer ever, but he really brang fire to a very very fboring shows, where predominated guys singing boring guitar ballads and divas singing boring mariah carey and celine dion's songs. he really rocked the stage like no one before.
Fuck sakes hes not cocky, hes confident and that's what any professional needs, he can't go on if he said, im horrible everything i do has been done, cocky would be if he said im better then everyone but he didnt say that did he, he should not have gone home, but he could have left months ago and he;d still make more money than scotty, American idol broke 2 records this year, 1 - most talent preformers on the show and 2 - least talented finalist
James, Scotty adn Lauren were my top 3. I stopped voting for James as he got more and more cocky. He lost his humility and it made me not like him. Wonder if any others felt the same way...just wish screamy Haley had gone home before him. This was a good reality check for James and now he WILL go on and record he didn't lose he still do great in life from this oppurtunity!!
This is better for James, his career can start earlier, he is already having a concert, he is gonna be just as successful as Daughtry. If he were to have been in the top 3, and not win, he wouldnt be able to do anything for a year, while him leaving in the top 4 was stupid, he only has to wait 6 months. This is the first year AI has let anyone do anything before that 6 month term.
people are so angry at Haley and her attitude, who was carelessly jubilantly smiling ? Lauren... Haley was poised and professional... poise is threatening even through a screen... smh.... Haley's TALEN TED
Yeah I was hoping James was gonna make it to the finale but kinda knew they were gonna cut him. Sad really. watching this video, i can see the sorrow in his face. Probably the most disappoint out of all the contestants from all the season. Haley and Scotty look moved too. Lauren looks as she dont care, as she poses for the camera at 0:42 .
CRAP! YOUR HEAR THE GIRLS SCREAM WHEN SCOTTY IS SAFE! THAT PROVES THEY JUST VOTE FOR FREAKIN LOOKS THAT MONKEY FACED SCOTTY TEENAGERS ARE SHALLOW VOTING ON LOOKS NOT TALENT UGH! HOW CAN SCOTTY SURVIVE JAMES AND CASEY!!!!!!!!!!!!
AWW MAN I REALLY THOUGHT JAMES WAS GONNA WIN HE IS SUCH A GREAT ROCK SINGER CANT BELIEVE HE GOT VOTED OFF NOT RIGHT AT ALL AMERICAN IDOL IS TAMPERED WITH AND THEY PROBABLY CHOOSE WHO THEY WANT TO CHOOSE FOR ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES
He got voted off because he thought every week he was the best when he was not...all he does is scream...when it comes to singing in ture and normal songs he cannot do it. Haley people is a better singer then James...That is why the producer said she has a very clear and great range. She is not Uglt or fat...its you your looking at in the morror...That girl can sing and the rest got more votes thatr is how it works...I'm so glad he's gone..lol...Thank you god...lol
@niccrant Another clueless uneducated comment made by a an imbecile get educated in music then you won't make yourself look like the imbecile you are! James Durbin is a 5 octave soprano Haley STRUGGLES @ 3 enough said child!
@Momonoski no does he not have a 5 octave range. screaming does not add to a persons range. haley on the other does not scream she simply sings and beautifuly at that. if you were actualy educated at all in music you would realize that. also range has little to do with how good a person sounds which is why i would rather listen to scotty all day than i would james for just one hour. can anyone say MY EARS MY EARS THE HORRINLE SCREAMING MAKE IT STO..... oh, thank you american idol i apreciate it
@cutiecatvbl haley does squeal loud when she sings. She yells in songs, that she should be subtle in. Her attitude won't get her a record deal either. If she can not handle constructive criticism on the show, no big time producers will want to touch her with that eye rolling and back talking.
haley sucks haley sucks haley sucks... at the end of the day, James will be UP there in hollywood.. and haley... well give it 1 or 2 years and she'll be forgotten.
@Momonoski Lol, Haley has inconsistent performances... most of which early in the competition.... she is definitely better than James.... Scotty... and Lauren... but that's just my honest opinion, as one that wasn't really rooting for anybody most of the show... til Haley started sh*ting... and she has a record deal with Interscope... so the people that know better... know better.
James should'nt have been voted off but in the end He's way too talented for this show anyway and he'll be the one laughing all the way to the bank when it's all said and done because, like everyone else, i'm sure there is a few record labels waiting for him to offer him a deal. Great job James everyone knows you should've won.
to all you guys hating on haley... stop it! i agree that james should have won he is the best by miles but haley wait infact everyone of the top 4 have tons of talent. haley in particular has a very strong gritty voice. yes jame should have won but stop hating on haley.
@dudequerky What? She did not do good at all Wed., and her attitude stinks. She is NOT a Diva, even though she thinks that she is. You vote based on each performance, and she was by far the worst of the 4 Wed.
@pris72 yeah ok she may have a bad attitude but when it comes to talent she has plenty of it. so what she stuffed up on Wednesday, she and james should have been in the top 2. you will always find singers/ actors that have a bad atitude but that s not what we are looking at for american idol. we are looking at talent not their behaviour (unless of course they do something totally wrong).
i hate you haley you should of went home, u ugly with and ugly voice..... cant stand youuuuu... DAMMMNN i dont want to watch AMERICAN IDOL .....F#%$% THIS!!!...LOVE YOU JAMES ILL BE WAITING FOR UR ALBUM AND I WILL SUPPORT U AND UR FAMILY!!!
I cry every time I watch this. It was bad enough when Casey was voted off. I was just do moved by James in this last song. The emotion was so heartfelt.
Mom2Patches 3 months ago
love you man! you shoulda won!!
taytaymak16 6 months ago
So everybody always start talking about Haley, forever and always. Doesn't matter if you love her or hate her, you can't forget her. So yeah, Haley Haley Haley! Woo!
halabrdave 6 months ago
James was absolutly ridiculous when he was voted off!
"Man, I worked so damn hard to get here" like no one else on the show did?
"I did sooo much stuff thats never been done on this show before"
Yes, james does has talent, but he pretty much copied adam lambert, so how is that bringing new stuff to the show? In my opinon Haley Reinhart should have won, you've got to give it to the girl who can sing fleetwood mac,blues,elton john, and even Led Zeppelin! James was sooo overated
chloeisthename 7 months ago
@chloeisthename He brought heavy metal to American Idol.
AdiVaporsSuperflyF50 7 months ago
@chloeisthename Why Haley has so passionate and hateful fans? if want to know if someone is a bad person, just find out if this person is haley's fan.
predador21 7 months ago
new things: let me see: heavy metal to idol, hard rock, to idol, he worked the stage like no one, running around, dancing, flaming a piano, saluting judges in the middle of the song, climbing up the judge's table, crazy theatrical sutff, like in muse's song
predador21 7 months ago
he may be not the best singer ever, but he really brang fire to a very very fboring shows, where predominated guys singing boring guitar ballads and divas singing boring mariah carey and celine dion's songs. he really rocked the stage like no one before.
predador21 7 months ago
damn thoses horny 13 year old girls that voted for scotty
xxDeederxx 7 months ago
Fuck sakes hes not cocky, hes confident and that's what any professional needs, he can't go on if he said, im horrible everything i do has been done, cocky would be if he said im better then everyone but he didnt say that did he, he should not have gone home, but he could have left months ago and he;d still make more money than scotty, American idol broke 2 records this year, 1 - most talent preformers on the show and 2 - least talented finalist
AlexArnold1029 8 months ago
NOOOOOOOO!!!!!! RECOUNT! RECOUNT! RECOUNT! WHO'S WITH ME!?
starset21 8 months ago
JAMES IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE THE BEST. scotty mcqueery can go DIE (:
Macy64CP 9 months ago
i think that scotty pia and casey PLus thia were the most talented and stephono
Emmywazhere15 9 months ago
James Durbin WILL rock us in th near future. As for the winner...*cough*Clay Aiken*cough*
TheLongTimeObserver 9 months ago
James, Scotty adn Lauren were my top 3. I stopped voting for James as he got more and more cocky. He lost his humility and it made me not like him. Wonder if any others felt the same way...just wish screamy Haley had gone home before him. This was a good reality check for James and now he WILL go on and record he didn't lose he still do great in life from this oppurtunity!!
cshello 9 months ago 3
@cshello
Yes, I agree. His, "I did stuff on this show no one ever did before" comment really showed his true colors. A bit cocky. I didn't like it.
icatchlife 9 months ago
This is better for James, his career can start earlier, he is already having a concert, he is gonna be just as successful as Daughtry. If he were to have been in the top 3, and not win, he wouldnt be able to do anything for a year, while him leaving in the top 4 was stupid, he only has to wait 6 months. This is the first year AI has let anyone do anything before that 6 month term.
AppleJeZus 9 months ago
people are so angry at Haley and her attitude, who was carelessly jubilantly smiling ? Lauren... Haley was poised and professional... poise is threatening even through a screen... smh.... Haley's TALEN TED
quenquen411 9 months ago
JAMES WAS MY FAVORITE AND THE BEST HOW COULD HE GO HOME?!?!?!?!?!?!?! HE WAS THE BEST THERE HAS EVER BEEN!!!!!!!! HE WILL BE MISSED TERRIBLY!!!
Langforddinnerjacket 9 months ago
lauren is garbage
swtgrl85 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah I was hoping James was gonna make it to the finale but kinda knew they were gonna cut him. Sad really. watching this video, i can see the sorrow in his face. Probably the most disappoint out of all the contestants from all the season. Haley and Scotty look moved too. Lauren looks as she dont care, as she poses for the camera at 0:42 .
believer06 10 months ago
Comment removed
believer06 10 months ago
CRAP! YOUR HEAR THE GIRLS SCREAM WHEN SCOTTY IS SAFE! THAT PROVES THEY JUST VOTE FOR FREAKIN LOOKS THAT MONKEY FACED SCOTTY TEENAGERS ARE SHALLOW VOTING ON LOOKS NOT TALENT UGH! HOW CAN SCOTTY SURVIVE JAMES AND CASEY!!!!!!!!!!!!
IvanGaro 10 months ago 2
@IvanGaro lets vote for haley & kick scotty & lauren to the curb, they need to be on nashville stars...!!
swtgrl85 9 months ago
AWW MAN I REALLY THOUGHT JAMES WAS GONNA WIN HE IS SUCH A GREAT ROCK SINGER CANT BELIEVE HE GOT VOTED OFF NOT RIGHT AT ALL AMERICAN IDOL IS TAMPERED WITH AND THEY PROBABLY CHOOSE WHO THEY WANT TO CHOOSE FOR ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES
kkett12001 10 months ago
@kkett12001 CAPSLOCK TO PROVE PONT
ex2cliff 9 months ago
@kkett12001 point* lolz
ex2cliff 9 months ago
He got voted off because he thought every week he was the best when he was not...all he does is scream...when it comes to singing in ture and normal songs he cannot do it. Haley people is a better singer then James...That is why the producer said she has a very clear and great range. She is not Uglt or fat...its you your looking at in the morror...That girl can sing and the rest got more votes thatr is how it works...I'm so glad he's gone..lol...Thank you god...lol
niccrant 10 months ago
@niccrant Another clueless uneducated comment made by a an imbecile get educated in music then you won't make yourself look like the imbecile you are! James Durbin is a 5 octave soprano Haley STRUGGLES @ 3 enough said child!
Momonoski 10 months ago
@Momonoski no does he not have a 5 octave range. screaming does not add to a persons range. haley on the other does not scream she simply sings and beautifuly at that. if you were actualy educated at all in music you would realize that. also range has little to do with how good a person sounds which is why i would rather listen to scotty all day than i would james for just one hour. can anyone say MY EARS MY EARS THE HORRINLE SCREAMING MAKE IT STO..... oh, thank you american idol i apreciate it
cutiecatvbl 10 months ago
@cutiecatvbl haley does squeal loud when she sings. She yells in songs, that she should be subtle in. Her attitude won't get her a record deal either. If she can not handle constructive criticism on the show, no big time producers will want to touch her with that eye rolling and back talking.
pris72 10 months ago
come on if u mad at when james went home come on u have to vote hard for scotty is not his fault haley should went home first not james
floridagirl20111 10 months ago 2
THIS JUST AIN'T RIGHT AND EVERYONE KNOWS IT!
chabeworks 10 months ago
haley sucks haley sucks haley sucks... at the end of the day, James will be UP there in hollywood.. and haley... well give it 1 or 2 years and she'll be forgotten.
jazzy6788 10 months ago
@jazzy6788 I agree Haley is garbage she should have never made the top 12!!!!!!!
Momonoski 10 months ago 8
@Momonoski Lol, Haley has inconsistent performances... most of which early in the competition.... she is definitely better than James.... Scotty... and Lauren... but that's just my honest opinion, as one that wasn't really rooting for anybody most of the show... til Haley started sh*ting... and she has a record deal with Interscope... so the people that know better... know better.
quenquen411 9 months ago
and this was bad... from a music point of view
quenquen411 9 months ago
@Momonoski
Haley defiently deserved to win.
You have no taste
chloeisthename 6 months ago 2
@Momonoski LOL OMG
haley had the best voice and was consistently criticized by the judges for no fucking reason.
Stickmaleboy 4 months ago
Until it is one vote for one phone # IT WILL NEVER BE FAIR, take notes X FACTOR DO IT RIGHT!!!!!
Momonoski 10 months ago
james is a D-BAG happy he is gone . he sucked the he was on .
fila32 10 months ago
@fila32 Learn grammar before you type fool!
Momonoski 10 months ago
@Momonoski Grammar? You one to talk, you like this guy and again he is a D-BAG!!!!
fila32 10 months ago
@fila32 AGAIN learn english grammar imbecile!
Momonoski 10 months ago
@Momonoski How clear was that? OK MomoBITCHki
fila32 10 months ago
@fila32 ur the dbag are u death???? he had the most beautiful voice!! at least give him some sympathy!! he got beat up by kids lik u!!
ramseyrox5 10 months ago
J-Lo crying at 1:00
JandK813 10 months ago
i'm not watching the rest of the season :(
JandK813 10 months ago 3
James should'nt have been voted off but in the end He's way too talented for this show anyway and he'll be the one laughing all the way to the bank when it's all said and done because, like everyone else, i'm sure there is a few record labels waiting for him to offer him a deal. Great job James everyone knows you should've won.
fallenFSOangel 10 months ago 10
to all you guys hating on haley... stop it! i agree that james should have won he is the best by miles but haley wait infact everyone of the top 4 have tons of talent. haley in particular has a very strong gritty voice. yes jame should have won but stop hating on haley.
dudequerky 10 months ago 3
@dudequerky What? She did not do good at all Wed., and her attitude stinks. She is NOT a Diva, even though she thinks that she is. You vote based on each performance, and she was by far the worst of the 4 Wed.
pris72 10 months ago
@pris72 yeah ok she may have a bad attitude but when it comes to talent she has plenty of it. so what she stuffed up on Wednesday, she and james should have been in the top 2. you will always find singers/ actors that have a bad atitude but that s not what we are looking at for american idol. we are looking at talent not their behaviour (unless of course they do something totally wrong).
dudequerky 10 months ago
i hate you haley you should of went home, u ugly with and ugly voice..... cant stand youuuuu... DAMMMNN i dont want to watch AMERICAN IDOL .....F#%$% THIS!!!...LOVE YOU JAMES ILL BE WAITING FOR UR ALBUM AND I WILL SUPPORT U AND UR FAMILY!!!
alexyjayli 10 months ago
I hate u haley! u go home! james durbin should be the american idol
talilalit 10 months ago
So Upset Haley needs to go home
Alicia20866 10 months ago
FUCK AMERICAN IDOL!!! James doesn't deserve to be out!!! I believe HALEY should be out!!
DemonAssassin31 10 months ago
AWEFUL !!!!
consal68 10 months ago