Added: 4 years ago
From: pinkclimax
Views: 2,170,376
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,593)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You are privileged for having heard this.

  • I bet the blond is good at faking orgasms :)

  • this is one of the songs that you put on auto reverse and play take a couple of hits of acid and just take a little vacation

  • Not a fan of the first womans singing, its beautiful but i dont think it captures what the song really is about.

  • @weoftendisagree your crazy first woman nailed it,they all did

  • If you can hear this it means your dying !!!!!

  • both ladies suck real bad... falsetto? you fucking kidding me?

  • @sexymohms There is loads of falsetto in the original.

  • @kdkn92 towards the end yes, first three minutes none.

  • As to the "white" woman, she had as much or more soul than any other singer there, so what the hell? I hate comments like that, I'm sorry, I couldn't let that go. I love them ALL!!!!

  • All of these incredible women did superlatively in their own ways.. that's what was so fabulous about this .. sends shivers through me every time I listen to it.. fabulous .. timeless,...classic!

  • This is for all the ignorant assclowns who are missing the point of this song by bringing race into this...close your eyes, forget about the "black and white" bullshit, turn it up and I pray to god you only hear an angel.

  • no lie, my nipples are hard just listening to this

  • i get epic chills from the second singer, they're all awesome though

  • This is religious right here...

  • Clare Torry will always be the best.

  • i would love to see clare torry belt this whole thing out on one take. simply beautiful. :,)

  • shittt the black women did better than the white one...amazing performance either way!

  • amazing when this is combined in a milky way footage

  • 4:58 David admires a beautiful lady and VOICE!!!

  • Wow Jesus, this is amazing.

  • one of the greatest pieces of music ever written.

  • who cares if the women are black or white, music is music

  • Where's my bong?

  • im gonna look for the video with the lyrics now

  • Favorite album on Sundays

  • Live Delicate Sound of Thunder version was better. Way better.

  • The sexiest,sweetest, most moving voice I have ever heard! (first)

  • How the fuck is there a white girl singing this!? The original will never be topped. I think Janis would be a cool ideaaa, but no way Janis would be better than the atudio version of this song, its not her style

  • @nickc387 The original was sung by a white girl.

  • @nickc387 Umm dude...a white girl sang the entire original version. And on this version, all 3 have fantastic voices, but Sam Brown (the white girl that sings first) is phenomenal.

  • @nickc387 look up clare torry dumbass

  • @nickc387 are you taking stupid pills?! a white girl does do the original! you're an idiot. know what what you are talking about before you chime in. #poser

  • @titanuser567 you're clearly very riled up about this. yes, i thought it was a black girl in the original, just like probably 9/10 people do. I, of course, was wrong with that statement. I'm just glad i'm not you. so glad.

  • @nickc387 I know the original was sung by a white girl now, please stop commenting to me people. i think most people assume the original is sung by a black girl, so just relax pink floyd fans, just relax.

  • I've heard Clare Torrey and these two are no Clare Torrey. Not even close...Original studio version still abides and probably always will.

  • Even though my voice is too low to sing along to this song I try anyways.

  • the greatest cover that never happened: janis joplin singing this.

  • @1more4carhur dude that would be awesome 

  • @1more4carhur That'd me a masterpiece right there.

  • These girls have such tremendous voices! Love it! Love the soul the give...

  • This song can never be overplayed in my playlist. Ever.

  • Pink Floyd and especially this dvd saved my life and changed me forever...If it wasn't for this music i wouldnt be here..Thank you Pink Floyd

  • @Gilmour3

    why do you think the music changed your life?

  • @plrice1969 because it actually did..I was very depressed until i actually discovered Pink Floyd..Then i regained my strength and started looking at life with optimism..and Pink Floyd were fully responsible for this change..

  • what are you? her husband?Broke brother? any family member? the real star here is the music and the men who wrote it. hanger-on.....she was a back-up singer for a huge rock band, take that and sleep well at night. She was part of something huge and will never be forgotten because of it, be happy with what she got................

  • An excellent rendition from the trio. Claudia , an how Durga and Sam do it with feeling .you had to be there it is simply one of the finest concerts ever staged . An having one of the greatest bands of all time doesn't hurt either . Now if only Roger had been on board !.

  • chills.............

    

  • This will sound good billion years from nowwwwwwww

  • @wvumab yea thanks good to know. I went on iTunes and searched her name. did she sing a song called "call me"?

  • Amazing song, one of my favorites. I've heard better female vocals on this one a number of times.

  • This IS great, but I think "best" Gig is a personal choice for each of us. Have in my Floyd playlist Gig loaded tons of times (my fav tune of all time....raw emotion...mind blowing for a song meant as a "filler".) My playlist has in a row, Clare in Gig album, Clare live. this one, then my fav with Sam Brown it starts with white chick w/dark hair, Sam, then hispanic chick. It just reaches in and grabs my guts/heart/soul. Crowd's reaction is mine. No "best" really, it's each one's taste, imo

  • I love that blond, what a voice.

  • @kennyufc09 Sam Brown

  • wwwgreatbuyoutletscom

  • why no clare?

  • You can tell that when they performed this, they still love their music. They still have fun playing together. And that is a really beautiful thing.

  • If Bianca doesn't preform to your liking. then tell it to David Nick and Richard ,they like them enough and set them front and center on this song. BUT WHAT DO THEY KNOW. hhmm? NO ONE IS EVER GOING TO COME CLOSE TO CLAIR. that's all their is to it

  • I clicked on this then went to a different tab to do something else, looked back in a couple minutes and was like, "What the fuck? She's white?"

  • Comment removed

  • Hey dude up above.. Are YOU kidding? just cause its NOT the original..

    give me a break.. its fuckin UN real what ive watched here.. smoke a bowl

    and relax.. Life dont have to be perfect

    Not tryin to be a dick here.. just some honest feedback.. I feel its even better

    than the original. Its all about the music legacy at the end of the day! take care

  • @floyd6569 Actually, I made a mistake in my comment. I was responding to someone who said, "Bianca copies the orginal well. These ladies make it their own." I assumed that Bianca was one of these singers. I'd never heard of her before. I didn't know he was referring to someone on another video. Now that I know, I agree with him on both statements. I was responding to the idea that these women were close to the original, which, of course, they're not. They are making it their own.

  • EPIC, what a great band.

  • Anyone remember "Demonseed"? I cut the original soundtrack onto the mechanicle forication scene. It was OUTSTANDING! These girls a fair but..........

  • The second girl, kinda butchered it she turned clare's amazing vocal solo into a oprea version, no one will ever compare to her for covering this song.

  • FIRST.GIRL.KILLS.IT.

  • En el 2011 va siendo difícil que algo nos sensibilice. Extrañamente terminan siendo cosas de hace muchos años las que consiguen ese efecto en tiempos en que ya casi nada impresiona. Esta canción es el reflejo de lo posible en medio de lo imposible.

  • THE ONLY THING MISSING IS THAT, IN THE CIRCLE, THERE SHOULD BE HEBREW LETTERS AND NUMBERS.

  • wow!!!!!

  • I already have the DVD

  • best song ever. every time i hear it i get goosebumps

  • OHHH... my god this performance gives me goose bumps EVERY time I listen to it..... imagine that power in that arena that night! this is kick ASS.

  • AWESOME!

  • Why should I be frightened of a dislike button? There's no reason for it — you've got to be a retard to press it.

  • where is the goddamn lyrics? i want my money back. 

  • Weed goes well with this song.

  • i was so wasted during this part of the concert

    

  • Kind of weird... I thought a black man singing...was I way off! No matter... one of the best... although I've heard better versions of this...

  • Not as good as a black woman singing it.

  • 2:05 - 2:10....nailed it. I think at 2:12 David was like like "woah"

  • #1 PF song, first song I learned when I was 12, 20 plus year later sounds just as good!! Here's my take on the 2012 version.. watch?v=BHBiSbzw-mE

  • I listened to this song in the blackout last night... Best Idea I have ever had

  • I'll never forgive Roger Waters for kicking Richard Wright out of Floyd. And Waters got his just desserts, too...his solo albums have flopped hard.

  • @fanofprotopic Well The Wall was 'kinda' a solo album dude

  • I'd like to see Taylor Swift sing that. Yea right

  • The little white girl is Sam Brown and she freekin rocks, as well as all of them!

  • I like I Like I Like I Like I Like x 1000,00000,000000,0000000,0000­0000000.

  • The sencond girl has some long ass fingernails

  • Esto si que te pone la piel de gallina!

  • goose bumps!!!

    

  • i wish my girl made these sounds lol

  • Chills.

    

  • your wrong if you dont like this song. plain and simple

  • wow they play just like the album AND they are even better!!!! lol wish i could see them live!

  • Where can i get the cd??? I would love to have it

  • @nothingelsematterz00 I got the concert DVD at Best Buys and the CD also. The concert is, of course, Pulse Concert. It's so good you won't believe it!!

  • BESTEST SONG  E V E R

  • Now I understand what a woman feels when having multiple orgasms... This is amazing and fucking unbelievable. Pure heaven... thank you.

  • Piel de gallina...

    

  • nothing better than listening to 2 women having an ogasim on the stage

  • Beautiful African American Singers; One of God's many gifts to the world :)

  • Classic Floyd!!

  • i hope this plays when i die

  • Love Pink Floyd but not this one. Singer sounds like she just got flushed from that stupid reality TV program for bad singers, whatever the name of it is....??

  • @jhutch1463

    idk why you even watched this, you are obviously NOT a fan of Pink Floyd. This is one of the most beautiful things on any Pink Floyd recording.

  • This is one of the best songs in one of the best albums in the best band!

    Dark side of the moon is seriously mind boggling! I wish I was alive in 1994

    when this live concert happened!

  • if you don't cry during this you have no soul.

  • Totally agree with comment bellow.

    I can't even tell you how much I miss music like this.

    Please, help bring it back people.

    P.S. I write alternative bluesy music, check out my song Ruthie. :)

  • I eat Pink Floyd for my breakfast, my lunch, and my Dinner! The best part, I never shit Pink Floyd out. Everything stays inside. The feeling = Priceless!

    One of the Greatest bands ever!

  • @abir12501101 a good mix of the two best prog rock bands helps my day go by. i listen to Floyd and Rush all day.

  • @krwatt92 I love Rush!

  • increiblemente fuera de serie

  • sorry for my ignorance, wich was Gilmours instrument??

  • @pinkfloydfan07 that's a steel guitar. pretty cool instrument

  • @randytauren thanks carnal ja 

  • @pinkfloydfan07 steel guitar.

  • simplesmente fantástico, voz e instrumentos em perfeita harmonia!!!

    com certeza esse foi um dos melhores shows do mundo.

  • Yes thats very good....the cry of the heart....makes more impact than words.

  • I wish that I could meet you all and give...Thanks

  • Sam brown kicks this songs ass! she does the best version in my opinion.

  • @Harrisononthesack the best version is by singer Bianca Antoinette

  • @robertref  Bianca copies the orginal well. These ladies make it their own. Even gets The Gil to look over for a sec like, DAYUM!

  • @BlahBlahBlah55209 Are you kidding? These vocals are far from the original. Clare Torry's original vocals were much deeper, richer, and emotional. These women are struggling to come up to par with her. They're doing their own renditions which accomplish the task, but Clare's original was an inspired, unexpected, incredibly fortuitous event which imprints the song forever as much as Wright's music. She well deserves the co-authorship credit and compensation she won in her lawsuit in 2005.

  • @tryptala - I agree to a certain degree, but I don't think Sam Brown does anything to shame herself with her portion of the vocal performance.

  • @tryptala i bet she sings your ass into the fucking ground.

  • @tryptala a perfect moment at a perfect time for the perfect woman ,,,, If she had never lived i could be happy with any one of these talented young ladies , But i am very fortunant to have heard the real thing for many decades now

  • @tryptala do u think she used lsd to find the notes better

  • @tryptala do u think she used lsd to find the notes better?

  • @dopeboyfrmloui duh???

  • @tryptala Bianca Antoinette does a pretty damn good job. She's at least par with Clare Torry. You can find here version here somewhere.

  • @Tressiensia Bianca does the best job of mimicking Clare's notes, timing, and vocal range, but she fails in a major way. The song is about death. Do you hear any death in Bianca's version? Much emotion at all? Is she living and experiencing through the song? You can hear Clare "experiencing" death in the original. That was her assignment and she conveyed the associated emotions through her improvisation with masterful genius.

  • @tryptala I agree with you, but most people who enjoy PF don't know this piece is about death. I grew up listening to Floyd and collecting their bootlegs and reading all about them. I consider myself to be a critic, but when I watch that live performance of Bianca, and all the people cheering and having a ball regardless of the fine print, I just have to get on that wagon. She DOES have a great voice. =)

  • @Tressiensia Bianca makes it look pretty effortless--too much so. Someone should remind her she's a performer. She needs to kick her body into gear. She's obviously got great range. Hopefully she 's trying to challenge that range with energy and raw emotion on some original compositions. I actually like Sam Brown's version here better. She doesn't have Clare's subtle texture, but she DOES kick ass and almost make it her own. I saw the Floyd do this in 1973. It was a wild, memorable concert.

  • @tryptala that's what pink said. you forgot to quote em. :P

  • @tryptala I agree with you on the second and third singers, but Sam Brown just ripped that song a brand new ass my friend......never heard it done that well....ever.......@ 2:06 magic!

  • @wvumab Yep, I said that too. earlier among these comments. She kicks ass. I like Sam's version better than the Clare copy that Bianca does on her video. Still, Clare's textures are much better at relaying the subject of death, which is what this song is about. No one's done that better that I have heard. Clare made it deeply emotional, and vulnerable. Her subtleties are the music itself.

  • @tryptala get off your high horse and show some fuckin respect you twat. honestly your gonna sit there and judge this vocal solo as if your some sort of music critique expert piece of uuhhgghh !

  • @sledog26 Whatever. Sorry you had a bad day.

    Check out what this woman--JulietteVmusic--does with these Great Gig vocals. Very cool stuff:

    /watch?v=jCwVGHSqQ7A&NR=1

  • Perfection at its best....

  • i want this played at my funeral

  • perfect song if you are feeling blue or melancholy

  • If this song and that singing does not move you, you are simply NOT human...

  • Its ok but i still prefer the 1973 version of this song

  • epa cómo canta esa mina, viejo; qué grande!!

  • Love this!

    Brilliant to use the human voice simply as an instrument, no words just pure sound.

  • Cada vez que la escucho no quiero que termine nunca

  • una obra de arte.es verdad,5 minutos de placer...!!!!

  • little white gurl got some power man...

  • @collin863 Her name is Sam Brown... she's great but we all know where the soul comes from! All these sisters can belt it out in their own way!

  • @collin863 Her name is Sam Brown... she's great but we all know where the soul comes from! All these sisters can belt it out in their own way!

  • 5 minutos de placer .....

  • and sarah mclachan thinks she can sing

  • masterpiece.........

  • can I have you...pink floyd

  • i would have called this song "5 minute orgasm"

  • This is the best live performance by Pink Floyd, and yes I do know about the wall concerts, still, to me, this is the best concert..

  • First Girl you might also know from watch?v=muDZD3wgoHI

    Just love her in this song of floyds... amazing allround

  • just everything in a range of notes and tones... absolutely everything! Heaven...

  • No word could define this. I can't find it.

  • Firts gal rocked it!

  • Soul-full

  • Nevermind

  • Where's the black chick.

  • WoooaaaaaOooooooowwwwwww 

  • 2,079,850 o the views are because of me :P i spent all afternoon listening to it over and over again. It's a journey to some place else every time

  • Des frissons à tout coup peu importe les choristes elles ont toutes des voix MAGNIFIQUES .... je suis une Québecoise (Matanaise) inconditionnée de Pink Floyd depuis mes 12 ans ... et plus de 30 ans ...

  • roll up...intake...relax....enjoy..­..yeah memories.

  • Lo que estuve para encontrar esta puta cancion! La amo!!! <3<3<3<3<3<3 !!

  • The Great Gig in the Sky = feel the music, feel the pain...

  • One of the best song ever

  • una belleza.... hermoso realmente! sin palabras. te lleva la cielo... tenes razon!

  • ohhhhhh Dios este tema te lleva hacia el maldito cielo!!!! aguante pink floyd loco