Added: 3 years ago
From: jec20721
Views: 408,527
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (509)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • audi first? above the 911 turbo? waaa, seriously, u guys on drug

  • im only 14 but when i get older i want to drive in 1 of thoes

  • I would take the Aston Martin in a heartbeat.

  • WTF....are you guys serious??? Audi R8 is a Lamborghini gallardo wannabe aka poor man's lamborghini gallardo( of course r8 is not cheap at all, but it's much cheaper than a lambo), Porsches are just the best fucking cars ever made, aston martins are useless, it sucks in every category, a fuck v12 version barely produces 500hp, shame on you aston.

  • @fhhs05

    the audi R8 GT spyder is 235,000 dollars brand new. the GT coupe is 210,000 and the regular r8 v10 spyder is about 190. i wouldnt call it a poor man's anything. a lambo is more...i know. and the only aston martin that would keep up with a porsche 911 turbo is a AM vanquish S. they are 525 HP and over 500 pound ft. top speed is 204 MPH. 0-60 in 3.7 seconds. dont shame on aston

  • Fact if the matter is the 911 is the most efficient and has back seats. If you're talking practicality, look no further. Not to mention the more recent 911s are just as fast as the other two, even in the far less expensive carrera S trim. Sad the GTR didn't come out at the time though, it would have torn those 3 a new one. ;P

  • Porsche still the best !

  • wake me up...

  • Aston Martin or Audi R8 ?

  • Audi ftw!

  • If you want slightly faster track performances, pick the R8 or Porsche (with ugly looks). If you want the utter refinement, beautiful looks, best exhaust sound, the coolest brand emblem, and an interior found in the $250,000 DBS without a hint of plastic and only made with the best materials, pick the Aston Martin.

  • @SemperFeared so subjective...

  • Aston Martin: the most beautiful car ever. oh yeah. thumbs up if you agree

  • aston martin fucking shit box

  • german supercar wannabe club? who is this dumbfuck?

  • @ChrisSmith1189 yeah, he's right. audi makes middle-class cars, and out of nowhere, with no past experience in sports cars, makes an r8. aston martin and porsche have been top of the line sports cars for years.

  • @ChrisSmith1189 oh, but with that being said, audi still rocks

  • Audi R8 is SOOOO Beautiful!!!

  • The audi and porsche are ugly. I'll take the Vantage thank you.

  • @bassistdc eh? porsche has timeless and classic look, nice try dude, none of the porsche look ugly to me. Turbo hand down, each generation faster than the last, a lot.

  • audi is d best

  • audi for the week, aston for the weekend and the porsche for the track :)

  • Z06!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • aston for ever the best

  • Aston Martin is more beautiful, more luxurious, handles better, has a far superior interior, has THE sexiest V8 sound you will ever hear, and this test was unfair. The 2008 model had 380 hp, R8 had 440 hp, and 911 had 480 hp. The newest Astons have 420 hp so the test should be more fair, although I wouldn't care about the slight difference in track time.. nothing beats rolling up in an Aston Martin.

  • Comment removed

  • the audi is the best

  • astons are beautiful online, they are indescribable in person

  • UN FAIR!!!!

  • 1976? I thought the 911 turbo(930) was shown at Paris autoshow in 1974?

  • 1. Porsche 911 Turbo

    2. Aston Martin V8 Vantage

    3. Audi R8

  • aston came in last but ask urself this...does james bond drive a porsche or a audi? i think not. but id be baffled and undecisive if someone made me choose from a audi r8 spyder and a aston martin vantage D:

  • @JungSwon james bond drives an aston because they're both british.

  • Tony Swan is the only guy that can announce me being as a winner to get a billion dollar and still cant get me excited.

  • @ascortjkk would almost make u feel as though ur being punished lol

  • The R8 is the best car in this planet followed by the Mustang Shellby GT 500 cobra

  • @cvalen15

    LOL yeah ok...

  • @cvalen15 fukk off

  • Only Tony Swan could put you to sleep all while watching three of the world's most sexy and exciting cars...

  • I agree that comparing the Vantage and R8 to a car that has almost a 100hp or 60hp over them is unfair. Maybe they are comparing them by how much they cost. I think Aston Martin should up the Vantage's engine size to that of Jaguar's 5.0L since they share engine blocks. What do you guys think? Vantage V8 my favorite sports car hands down.

  • I dont care which is the fastest....i'd take the the Aston Martin and it is the sexiest car out of all of them too

  • THE PORCHE HAS AWESOME POWER AND IT SEEMS TO BE QUICK AND NIMBLE ON THE FAST TRACK AUDI V 10 I'M SURPRISED THAT IT DOESN'T PERFORM A LITTLE QUICKER HAVING A V10 ALL WHEEL DRIVE???

  • im an Aston Martin fan so i would have to go with the v8 vantage

  • Vantage v8, v12, audi r8 v8 and v10 are slow compared to 911 turbo ;)

  • I don't know why, but i never liked Porsche or Mercedes, The only cars i like from Mercedes is the SL black series, and Porsche the carrera GT and maybe the old 996!

  • shitty comparison. the 911 turbo shouldn't be compared with these 2 cars. it's a different class of power. the am vantage has 385 hp and the 911 turbo has 480. does this look fare to you?

  • Aston Martin any day! soo beautiful.

  • Audi Power!<3

  • fuck that r8 looks way better then the other 2

  • New Rank!!!!

    1.- ASTON MARTIN

    2.- PORSCHE

    and the third place it doesn't matter =)

  • ugly audi shit

  • porsche no longer is exotic when you see one on every corner. I don't care if they are the base model or the GT3. They all look the same. Porsche is the dullest "super" car I have ever seen. Aston Martin FTW

  • booooooring we want race not this carp !!?

  • the aston martin may not have won any competition but it won my heart .

  • R8 is the best

  • could this test be any worse? my god even i could have tested and rated these cars better.....i want my 4 minutes back...

  • I love how Jeremy Clarkson gets criticized for favouring Astons, yet most of the other car reviewers place it in the bottom because"it's not fast enough". Also, at the end of the day, you don't buy an Aston for speed, you don't buy it because it is the last word in technology, and you don't buy it for it's practicality. You buy an Aston if you demand the ultimate in sexiness, elegance, luxury, and exclusivity. End of story.

  • The fact is that in the U.S. there is no place where you can drive them to their max. So the decision to buy will be based on looks and price. I like the looks of the Vantage then the R8.

  • dude i would fuck the v8 vantage so hard. thats a compliment. its hawt.

  • Fuck fire the voice over guy PLEASE!

  • why everyone forgets that an audi r8 with 420 hp will always be owned by the porsche turbo ( 480 hp ) , faster, more powerfull , and better cornering ?

  • i wonder how many of the people who are commenting on this own any of these cars? i do, the porsche and whilst they say the audi came out on top that was done to the driver not feeling confident enough with the car (as he says) so thats down to him not the car also the porsche is a 4 seater if you are going to test 2 seaters then where was the carrera gt? bye bye audi bye bye aston enough said

  • @scits1 Audi and Aston Martin are better than Porsche - lets be honest - Porsche make the most ugly supercars EVER. Bye bye Aston? Dont think so somehow? I'd rather have it over a 911, and don't even start on the Porsche being better than an R8 - The R8 has totally outdone it. Better looks, better handling, more quality, spacious and comfortable interior. More fuel efficient, and before you start - i have an people working at Audi in my family and I'v been out in the R8 many times - MAGNIFICENT

  • @davyjones800 are you INSANE! Aston Martin better than Porsche? in what catagory!? Your whole arguments is founded on "looks". Porsche, ANY Porsche, is a mans car. This video/test/experiment is totally biased. THEY felt scared to go full throttle in the curves, that's their fault. No way in hell R8 could beat a Porsche! R8 and Audi are little girls' car.

  • @rmtennis11

    Aston martin's are better in exterior design and build quality. they are not mass produced like porsche 911s...accept for the Carrera GT and the GT3/GT2 rs models. Thats it though. in performance and in handling, Porsche wipes the floor with AM's accept the new AM 77 hyper car. and you said audi and the r8 is a girl's car..you bugging. the r8 v8 is crap...but the v10 and GT models are no joke! they can keep up alright.

  • german cars are the worlds best! ;)

  • If I had to buy one out of those three, I would go crazy... they are all so beautiful... dang..

  • what?!?? turbo is fastest 911?!?

    what about the gt2?

    

  • I swear on Porsche... I like Audi... I love British cars... If you ask me, I couldn't decide... :D All of these are great cars!

  • Audi and Porsche looks like scrap!

  • ugh the porsche may be very fast, however you must agree it is a little shit in terms of its looks

  • stupid review

  • aston martin is the most beautiful. by far

  • @maxorke Too bad its the slowest....If Aston Martins were as fast as they are good looking, they'd be a great car. Too bad they're not, so they are not a sports car....

  • @R41turbo just because they are not as fast as the other two shown, they aren't sports car?

    you're dumb as fuck.

    aston martin is fucking gorgeous and fast as hell. not so fast as the others, but faster than many others too.

  • @maxorke I agree. The AM Vantage is 1 of the best looking cars in the world.

  • @Marcoshary its gorgeous :)

  • @maxorke no man the 911 is

  • @MJRiley878 never...too comon. sorry but almost every Porsche looks like the same!

  • @maxorke not all of them ...

  • @maxorke are you kidding me? audi le mans quattro is for me

  • Comment removed

  • @Hansie1296 the aston dbs is a way better gt car then the porsche and is way better looking and a better all rounder

  • @appplezz101 Excuse me? An Aston Martin may be classy but it's nothing compared to Porsche, you want to race? Get a Porsche, not an Aston Martin, it's freaking ugly too, the R8 takes the spot in this case.

  • @AgonisNewt the porsche looks like a squashed volkswagen beetle with a wing on the back its like taking sarah jessica parker flattening her face and putting snookis poof on her head

  • @appplezz101 the aston martin is shit which looks like a car for old ppl

  • @Gahllardo Yes. Aston is a Man's Car not a boy's toy.

  • noisy cabinnnn!?!?!?!?! its called a SUPERCAR its supposed to be loud and agressive ..and if youre too weak to handle it why are you even comparing them as if you know anything

  • Could they have made this any more boring? Really... Top Gear does all this so mucdh better. They turned some of the most awesome cars in existence into a refridgerator comparison

  • @solo03 Yeah..your'r right...but sometimes top gear is dumb..making stupid comparison..some time i likes top gear sometimes..no..cuz british people are dumb in making comparison...understand??

  • @MrSham1996 ill be amazed if anyone can fully understand you.

  • @MrSham1996

    Learn English.

  • @solo03

    Dude you are so right - couldn't agree more, these car review programs have taken boring and perfected it....Motorweek are the leaders of the artform.

    I want hype, drama and """real opinion""""", not candy coated I'm always right liberal drivel....

    IE "the trunk has lots of room for your voyages to Sonoma, and perhaps room for a small trinket or antique that tickles your fancy while enroute...and I really like the cupholders and lack of road noise....

  • I'd take the vantage.

  • Why does this video about newish cars have such an old feel to it? lol

  • @drumttocs8 because only old guys on viagra can afford these ;p

  • audi r8 is the best from germany

  • @pasillover Man u don´t know anything about Germany !!!

    Audi RS6 MTM 730 hp

    BMW M6 G-Power 750 hp

    Mercedes SL65 AMG Black Series 670 HP

  • @DeathRowWarrenG I heard the Sl65 AMG Black Series isn't that great for the giant pricetag

  • 911 > too common

    R8 > too flashy

    Vantage > Cheap Bond car alternative!

  • the 911 turbo is way out of their league, they shuldve used the base model

  • teh obly thing that that the audi needs is a better and bigger engine, and then its PERFECT!

  • @putadelsol thatsy they made a v10 version

  • @redfoxtrident but its still not powerfull!

  • @putadelsol 520bhp sounds like alot to me, especially in an awd mid-engined sports car that comes from a prestigious rall company

  • @redfoxtrident yeah okay your right , BUT ITS STILL NOT FAST ENOUGH ,don't you inderstand it!

  • @azer09092 compred to what? these two?

  • @redfoxtrident If you mean prosche,then this company has never been a rally company,more of a racing company.Its the Audi,that has the legendary rally history,with their worlds first turbocharged awd rally car.

  • @Henzzman yeah dude thats what i was talking about i said 520bhp, this 911 has 490 so i was talking about the r8 v10

  • "Car and Driver" can you bore the hell out of your audience anymore than you did! My god it did matter what you were testing is was uninspiring and Dull. Search BBC "Top Gear" and take a few lessons.

  • This helped me book my track day :P.

  • dont have one..... have them all!

  • the austin is soo beautiful but people dont buy it cuz its interior isnt that good as the exterior, loses its value way too fast and its just worth every penny, and fuel economy in it is bad

  • @hazemvirus A true believer in an ASTON martin will ay any price to have one, ik, i would, they are the best, their shifting might be slightly rough, but other than that....

  • @207445 thats what im saying, i would own the austin or the audi but i would never own that porsche, everyday i go to that video of the austinmartin v12 vantage by autoblog just to listen to that volcano under the hood

  • German cars are the best!!!

  • guess i'm a whore for looks, aston martin's are some of the best looking cars ever

    1. aston martin

    2. audi r8

    3. porsche 911

  • @InphinityNrG mmhh yes it´s a beauty but the R8 is the best looking car ever!

  • All awesome cars.

    I would pick the Aston martin because I like the look best of all three but you gotta like all of them.

  • @MrFrozenCanuck Gotta like all of them - The R8 and Aston definately, but Porsches just annoy me

  • @davyjones800 I had my doors blown off by a passing R8 today.

    I can testify that they are good cars. :)

  • @MrFrozenCanuck LOL its so funny the way you worded that - been out in 3 V8 R8's and 1 V10 Spyder, which is unreal

  • @davyjones800 Couldn't tell if this was a v8 or 10, it was all just a blur.

  • @MrFrozenCanuck The noise would have given you a hint, and as you maybe know, the V10 has a black plate on the back around the reg plate and has the Y-Spoke alloys

  • LMFAO at the european nutswingers in here. I would put a Corvette ZR1 or turboed Ford GT against any of these overpriced shitboxes anyday...

  • @coryboy345 Both those cars cost more or equal to these in Europe. So not overpriced here, overpriced there. And would you really pay the same for a porsche 911 turbo or a Aston Martin as for a corvette?

    If you would then be happy picking up white trash.

    I love vettes but would not buy one if I could buy a Porsche for the same money.

  • @McDiezel Why wouldn't I? The ZR1 is a superior vehicle in every way to all those vehicles. Speed/Power/Handling... It might lack in the quality department but Ill pay the much less price tag on the ZR1 than on any of those three European ones.

  • @coryboy345 In the US they are much more expensive then the ZR1. In Europe they are not.

    Qualitywise when it comes to the mechanics I think the ZR1 is better then these.

    Old fashined tecnology but proven to be reliable.

    Internal quality like materials and finishing the ZR1 lacks alot though.

  • stupit amercain cant understand what hes saying

  • wheres the American car in this video? o.O

  • ford gt should be shown

  • aston!!!!

  • @gghyt911 - ahaha I loved that comment, especially from elderly gentleman

  • Audi R8 is the SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • aston martin is the best

  • @fabulosocadillac18 all 3 of these things have strengths and weaknesses

  • i would take the aston over the other two anyday!

  • 911 gt2 is the "biggest" porsche

  • @mmooccii this was made before it came out

  • I'd LOVE to see the V12 Vantage! That'd kick the R8's ass!!!

  • its funny how at the end he encourages people to drive fast and take chances lol

  • AUDI R8 IS DA BEST!!!!

  • For all of u guys saying it was an unfair comparison ure wrong because it was compared by price and the R8 wich has the cheapest MSRP won so it was actualy a gret comparison and totaly fair

  • porsche 911 turbo is the best.....!!!!!!!

  • Considering the V8 vantage is heavier and less powerful than the R8 its not exactly fair to compare them.

  • @gav375 v8 vantage is more powerful its 480hp and the audi r8 is 420hp v8

  • @TheSniperman2009 I can assure you the the model in this video is the earlier 4.3L vantage with 380BHP. If you listened at the guy at the at 0:56 then you would know that.

  • @TheSniperman2009 According to Aston Martin's site the V8 Vantage has 420 BHP as well, but the Aston is heavier than the R8

  • Yeah! Audi 4 ever!

  • wow Audi R8 with an Rs4 engine beating the Porsche turbo and Aston martin

  • Actually the porsche Carerra GT is the best weapon in Porsche's arsenal

  • @prcambs there talking about the 911's dumbass

  • Aston Martin..... I WANT

  • Definately the R8, favourite car!!

  • aston rules!!

  • a camaro is just as good as an audi r8

  • @65kewlray Nice try. One word, Quattro. Camaro cant touch it

  • @65kewlray Are you smoking crack? Very little NA cars can compete with Europe or Japanese. Why would you think the camaro could compete with the R8? The Corvette could and maybe even the GT 500 if there was enough straight track but not the Camaro. I used to work for GM too.

  • Audi all the way

  • "Drive fast and take chances"...hell yeah I respect this guy!

  • God Save Audi.

  • @IuseAudi It's so gay to admire Audi over all great brands..

  • @IuseAudi

    bought an A4, the R8 will have to wait.

    Audi....wins.

  • I'd still take the Aston!

  • i'll take all 3

  • pretty sure these are all exotic..

  • V8 vantage can now beat the V8 Audi R8, it now has a 420BHP 4.7L V8, so it's just as powerful and i think it's lighter as well, so i would get a AM vantage, then the R8 than the 911 Turbo, but I think all 3 are great cars!

  • audi always win because audi is best

  • "Drive fast.. and take chances"

    thats a horrible drive slogan lol

  • @moodi12 trollfag detected

  • Id take the Austin Martin over Porsche or Audi any day

  • @PoopnSuch Same.

  • All that and I would still have the Aston over any of the others.

    Given a generation of two more and they should up the BHP too.

  • AuDi r8 ThE bEsT

  • V8 vantage may not win in speed but look at it. its so good looking. they should have put the DB9 on against the other two still not as fast but similar price also the V10 R8

  • Indeed.. besides the new V8 Vantage has 420bhp instead of 380. I mean the 911 is AMAZING but I'd still get the Aston just for the looks and exclusivity.