This is one of my favorite songs, and the Soft Bulletin is just one of the greats. Period. However, if you're thinking in terms of what is to be considered standard music blocking, then yeah, Steven could have done something pretty enigmatic (he's capable) had he thought a bit more on the guitar "solo"--But, It doesn't really sound like he was going for a solo, and it never really does. Steven isn't writing pop songs, he's writing these landscape compositions you can sort of gently fall into.
Music is filled with rules, but they can and have been broken to accommodate new ideas. Unlike a math problem every problem has multiple answers and none of them are correct. Miles Davis is jazz, the genre that gave the middle finger to classical conformity. This song is good because it feels like riding in the back of a car and looking up at the street lights as they rush past the night sky. Thats how feeling yourself disintegrate feels like to me. How could bad and music even go together?
@theelk801 I disagree... It may be simple, but this solo is my favorite guitar solo ever because it's so emotional and beautiful! I saw it played live last year and Steven had added a lot more to the solo too...
@theelk801 A solo doesn't need to be complicated... If you are sacrificing melody just to show off then you could potentially damage the song's dynamics.
@dancecamerondance123@jer1ndie@oddmartian2 What I was saying is not that the solo needs to be complicated but that it's so heavy handed that it just sounds bad. It's largely just going up and down the pentatonic scale and pivoting on the same damn minor third over and over. It doesn't need to be complex, it just needs to be a bit less paint-by-numbers. Miles Davis was very simplistic in his improvisation but what he did play was far more interesting nonetheless.
@theelk801 So what! fuck your gay ass scale, this song is awesome and the solo has emotion and that's all that counts. And funny how you throw miles in there, because he would disagree with your comment.
@tacosaucemafia "gay ass scale"? You clearly don't know anything about music theory, so first of all I pity you, and second of all if you don't know what you're talking about then you DEFINITELY aren't gonna be able to gauge the opinion of Miles. Yes, the solo has "emotion", but it executes said emotion poorly.
@theelk801 Executes emotion poorly???? lmao! bro you are a fucking joke! You do realize Steve Jones of the sex pistols couldn't even tune his fucking guitar, but proceeded to make a monumental album that the likes of vai, satriani, batio, Gilbert could never come close to making with their technical prowess. There are no rules in music!!! Stop setting up standards you clown, How can you possibly execute emotion poorly? You are the anti Miles Davis and you know jack shit about Davis.
@tacosaucemafia See, now you're just showing your ignorance. There ARE rules to music, and you follow them whether or not you choose to acknowledge them. Yes, the Sex Pistols were "bad", but they were performance artists, not musicians. They wanted to communicate their image and ideas and the carelessness with which they played music helped with that. They used music as a means to an end. Miles, on the other hand, was a musician, and definitely followed rules. Kind of Blue was based on new rules
@theelk801 dude, I don't give a fuck what you say. "Feeling Yourself Disintegrate" will be my favorite song until my body rots and I disintegrate. The solo is fucking amazing. If you don't like it, kindly fuck off :)
That last sentence pretty much contradicted the rest of that whole paragraph. If things such as "new rules" actually exist, then couldn't anything that goes outside these supposed 'rules' of music just be called "new rules"?
"Hey man, you can't just bang on that pan and call it music. Music has RULES you gotta follow."
@jumeau1 It's more about capturing the feeling and emotion. I've always felt that the solo for "Have a Cigar" was really in tune with the overall feeling of the song.
This solo makes me feel so good, everytime I listen to this song.
Even better live, travelled from Aberdeen to London to see them play the whole album at Alexandra Palace, a gig that I'll never forget until the day I die!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Nice work covering it.
It really sucks though, when you're looking for a real song but someone has covered it and made the title and videoslideshow to look like the original.
Been listening to the flaming lips for awhile. They emanate such a beautiful calmness about all the intricacies of life, whether scary or astonishing. Their music is like a drug- it's easily identifiable and so smooth and...well, there's nothing like it. Needless to say, next time I pick up some magic mushrooms or acid, I will be listening to clouds taste metallic, in a priest driven ambulance and last but DEFINITELY not least, the grand finale, THE SOFT BULLETIN. This album makes life worth it.
@arinross523 Good comment, really true. I've thought they give a modern Floyd vibe too, not that they necessarily sound the same but that hypnotic awesomeness
Meravigliosa
skying90 2 weeks ago
anti-solos rule.
justanotherjam 3 weeks ago
This is one of my favorite songs, and the Soft Bulletin is just one of the greats. Period. However, if you're thinking in terms of what is to be considered standard music blocking, then yeah, Steven could have done something pretty enigmatic (he's capable) had he thought a bit more on the guitar "solo"--But, It doesn't really sound like he was going for a solo, and it never really does. Steven isn't writing pop songs, he's writing these landscape compositions you can sort of gently fall into.
ultramanballs 1 month ago
I don't hear any music rules being broken in this song. Enlighten me please.
xactxx 1 month ago
Music is filled with rules, but they can and have been broken to accommodate new ideas. Unlike a math problem every problem has multiple answers and none of them are correct. Miles Davis is jazz, the genre that gave the middle finger to classical conformity. This song is good because it feels like riding in the back of a car and looking up at the street lights as they rush past the night sky. Thats how feeling yourself disintegrate feels like to me. How could bad and music even go together?
Footage17 1 month ago
I don't know if this is a coincidence, but on this album in particular, they kind of channel a mid to late seventies Yes vibe....
TheZachReed 2 months ago 2
@TheZachReed I agree! I hear Queen, Pink Floyd and Led Zepp (just to name a few).
SpleenieMartini 1 month ago
@TheZachReed This song reminds me of a Marvin Gaye (eg., Mercy Mercy Me), but slowed down and that bloke from Thunderclap Newman on vocals.
cadmus98 3 weeks ago
Can't help but feel so small when I hear this. It's one hell of a reminder.
ronniedillon 3 months ago
so beautiful i don t even know...
jbp27 3 months ago in playlist News
This is so beautiful. I'm wallowing in it.
Kperson123 3 months ago
Best song ever.
jer1ndie 3 months ago
Rat tat tat rat tat tat rat tat tat forever~ <3
artan234 3 months ago
Two people can't feel themselves disintegrate.
quickieSS 4 months ago
I love getting high to this song.
quickieSS 4 months ago
greatest song ever
jbp27 4 months ago
I like most of this song but the guitar solo is not very good. It sounds like whoever played it learned the pentatonic scale a month prior.
theelk801 4 months ago
@theelk801 The solo is one my favorite parts of the song...It's really simple but it adds a lot.
Oddmartian2 4 months ago
@theelk801 I disagree... It may be simple, but this solo is my favorite guitar solo ever because it's so emotional and beautiful! I saw it played live last year and Steven had added a lot more to the solo too...
jer1ndie 3 months ago
Comment removed
dancecamerondance123 3 months ago
@theelk801 A solo doesn't need to be complicated... If you are sacrificing melody just to show off then you could potentially damage the song's dynamics.
dancecamerondance123 3 months ago
@dancecamerondance123 @jer1ndie @oddmartian2 What I was saying is not that the solo needs to be complicated but that it's so heavy handed that it just sounds bad. It's largely just going up and down the pentatonic scale and pivoting on the same damn minor third over and over. It doesn't need to be complex, it just needs to be a bit less paint-by-numbers. Miles Davis was very simplistic in his improvisation but what he did play was far more interesting nonetheless.
theelk801 3 months ago
@theelk801 So what! fuck your gay ass scale, this song is awesome and the solo has emotion and that's all that counts. And funny how you throw miles in there, because he would disagree with your comment.
tacosaucemafia 3 months ago
@tacosaucemafia "gay ass scale"? You clearly don't know anything about music theory, so first of all I pity you, and second of all if you don't know what you're talking about then you DEFINITELY aren't gonna be able to gauge the opinion of Miles. Yes, the solo has "emotion", but it executes said emotion poorly.
theelk801 3 months ago
@theelk801 Executes emotion poorly???? lmao! bro you are a fucking joke! You do realize Steve Jones of the sex pistols couldn't even tune his fucking guitar, but proceeded to make a monumental album that the likes of vai, satriani, batio, Gilbert could never come close to making with their technical prowess. There are no rules in music!!! Stop setting up standards you clown, How can you possibly execute emotion poorly? You are the anti Miles Davis and you know jack shit about Davis.
tacosaucemafia 3 months ago
@tacosaucemafia See, now you're just showing your ignorance. There ARE rules to music, and you follow them whether or not you choose to acknowledge them. Yes, the Sex Pistols were "bad", but they were performance artists, not musicians. They wanted to communicate their image and ideas and the carelessness with which they played music helped with that. They used music as a means to an end. Miles, on the other hand, was a musician, and definitely followed rules. Kind of Blue was based on new rules
theelk801 3 months ago
@theelk801 dude, I don't give a fuck what you say. "Feeling Yourself Disintegrate" will be my favorite song until my body rots and I disintegrate. The solo is fucking amazing. If you don't like it, kindly fuck off :)
jer1ndie 2 months ago 3
@theelk801
That last sentence pretty much contradicted the rest of that whole paragraph. If things such as "new rules" actually exist, then couldn't anything that goes outside these supposed 'rules' of music just be called "new rules"?
"Hey man, you can't just bang on that pan and call it music. Music has RULES you gotta follow."
"Nah, man, these are the NEW rules."
See what I mean?
ANTIanitmetalclub 2 months ago
@theelk801 What an arrogant prick. Who are you trying to impress? Get off your thrown and leave this page if you're going to spout bullshit.
MassHero 1 month ago
@theelk801 if you are a guitar player and judge the quality of a solo by its complexity, please quit playing.
jumeau1 3 months ago 7
@jumeau1 It's more about capturing the feeling and emotion. I've always felt that the solo for "Have a Cigar" was really in tune with the overall feeling of the song.
This solo makes me feel so good, everytime I listen to this song.
quickieSS 2 months ago
greatest album i've ever heard
rex666777 4 months ago
How do I type nothing
lunasea11 4 months ago
@lunasea11 By ceasing to move your hands over a keyboard.
GoreyOr 4 months ago
RA PA PA
RA PAPAPA!!
sugar1n 5 months ago 5
Comment removed
JKNovoa 5 months ago
greatest album ever in my life.
rex666777 5 months ago
what genre would this song fall under?
Fallingdown232 5 months ago
@Fallingdown232 The Flaming Lips.
spawn22222 5 months ago
@spawn22222 fair enough
Fallingdown232 5 months ago
@Fallingdown232 Truth music
drshoggothshow 5 months ago
@Fallingdown232 Good, its the only genre i really listen to.
musterdsandwich 5 months ago
@Fallingdown232 - 'Genius'
terryperring104 5 months ago
scvman992000,also one of the saddest songs ever written.
Bumbumawangis 6 months ago
WOW dis this sound amazing last night!!!!
BobbyBluntandthafunk 6 months ago
I was listening to this while on 24 dramamine, i really felt like i was disintegrating, but i don't do pills anymore, fuck pills
lslreverbnation 6 months ago 7
@lslreverbnation Whatever works for you
drshoggothshow 5 months ago
This... makes me dizzy. Very very dizzy.
Deathraker88 6 months ago
Saw that live yesterady... and I felt myself disintegrate
DomSaget 7 months ago in playlist Osheaga 2011
@DomSaget One of best shows I've seen
schoenapan 7 months ago in playlist Osheaga 2011
I think that "Embryonic" is a better record EVER-SO SLIGHTLY than this album.
DerrickthePinecone 7 months ago
@DerrickthePinecone This album, clouds taste metallic, and satellite heart are so damn good tho! I'd hate to argue this though, they are all great.
mametz 5 months ago
Even better live, travelled from Aberdeen to London to see them play the whole album at Alexandra Palace, a gig that I'll never forget until the day I die!
Mouse2113 7 months ago 2
Saw it live
demondayssean 7 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Much better than I expected it to be. Oh, thumbs up if you came here because of QC
MusicIsMyWeapon88 8 months ago
best song ever.
jer1ndie 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nice work covering it.
It really sucks though, when you're looking for a real song but someone has covered it and made the title and videoslideshow to look like the original.
GRR!
spacesuitor 8 months ago
@spacesuitor This isn't a cover...
aagold 8 months ago 17
i wish they'd go back to this instead of the "experimental" tuneless weirdness... that stuff is bad trip material.
MarcsYooToob 8 months ago
One of the most beautiful songs ever written.
neonspec 8 months ago
awes0me
Awake2theWorld 9 months ago
Been listening to the flaming lips for awhile. They emanate such a beautiful calmness about all the intricacies of life, whether scary or astonishing. Their music is like a drug- it's easily identifiable and so smooth and...well, there's nothing like it. Needless to say, next time I pick up some magic mushrooms or acid, I will be listening to clouds taste metallic, in a priest driven ambulance and last but DEFINITELY not least, the grand finale, THE SOFT BULLETIN. This album makes life worth it.
MassHero 9 months ago 2
I always tear up every time I hear this song.
PLASTICTOLI 9 months ago 2
Comment removed
TylerEatsZombies 9 months ago
Prepare for take off...
ESCAZO73 10 months ago
I love this band.
TheJerrjer 10 months ago
they are only a few steps behind radiohead, able to invent their own unique genre
arinross523 10 months ago
@arinross523 Good comment, really true. I've thought they give a modern Floyd vibe too, not that they necessarily sound the same but that hypnotic awesomeness
chedwerks 10 months ago
@chedwerks yesss, and i think radiohead are a few small steps behind Floyd
arinross523 9 months ago
Want this for my funeral.
FTZPLTC 10 months ago 2
Makes dying sound like beautiful fun. I bet it is!
georgew985 11 months ago 7
@georgew985 What do you think this is?
Trinnan 9 months ago
@georgew985 That is exactly what I was thinking the first time I heard At War With the Mystics.
MrWoodHimself 4 months ago
One of the best songs ever written. A true work of art.
scvman992000 11 months ago 53
@scvman992000
Your comment does confirm that ignorance truly inspires bliss.
Easleytee 2 months ago
THANK YOU
thewrongsong 11 months ago
whoever you are thank you so much for putting this on youtube because it was no where else to be found<3333333
Ineversayforever 1 year ago 3