Just found out about this song because of a tweet link from @RosanneCash .. She said that she has listened to it "257 times over the last couple of years" ;)
I cannot get this version out of my head! I always liked the B&S version, but never like this. Love the singer - she has just the right amount of soul without over-doing it. More Annie Lennox, less Joss Stone (no disrespect, girl!). What is it about English girls (see also: Amy Winehouse)?
This girl - Brittany Stallings I suppose - is terribly adorable, and clearly has talent. Not a talent that suits this song. It seems to smooth over the ambiguity, turning it into more of a generic pop song. But...thumbs up....
If it draws people back to the well of the original, I can see it's value. It wasn't a disgrace like most covers.
La canción es muy agradable. Me encanta la musicalización y la voz de la intérprete. Sigan adelanten con "God help the girl". Saludos desde Lima, Perú
Please help understan this... is God help the girl a movie, this music project? a soundtack? a old musician? 'cause once i heard a song and it semeed quite old, and there is a movie...because Asy sings a song... son, I don't understand, help ):
While I enjoy God Help The Girl, this cover is completely horrid. Belle & Sebastian's version is perfect, what made the song great was the bounciness. This version makes the song just drag on and on. Meh.
Is this the American Idol version? Was the point to make this soulless and boring? The song feels twice as long now. And it now sounds like the theme song to some terrible new sitcom. This blows. And I'm a huge Belle and Sebastian fan.
I've just came across both this song and B&S's version. I can't say I like the other better; indeed, I really think that this arrangement has got better quality, in what concerns instruments. I also prefer this kind of rythm with Murdoch's lyrics, it really gives it another dimension. Great work!
You must be out of your mind! The Life Pursuit version is fantastic, I agree. But this one is just as good, or even better. The old version was all peppy, and there's no way not dancing to it - but here you get the sadness that's always been underneath the lyrics, the loneliness - it becomes a new song. That's Stuart Murdoch for you.
the girls voices in god help the girl are amazing, but i prefer the B&S version.... is waaayyy better.... it's like more the spirit of the song is kind of lost in this slower version.
I love Belle and Sebastian. I loved this song by B n S. Im glad Stuart Murdoch from the band has a side project. Im glad they've done a cover of the B n S song, i love this versh too! I am going to see God Help the Girl on the 21st Nov!
I really like this reworking (I say reworking instead of cover because GHTG is essentially a Belle and Sebastian/Stuart Murdoch side project) of the song. It could have easily been released by Motown Records in the mid-60s.
I heard this version of the song before hearing the original and I would almost bet her voice and brilliant uptempo will eclipse the Belle and Sebastian version, but I will check it out just the same. Great song and terrific looking video.
Although its executed well, the song lacks Belle and Sebastian's originality. This young performer can belt just like many found in churches and on television. However, belting and scooping before every note is about all she does.
She'll find herself, and invariably the original voice will follow.
I don't think the original sounds stalkerish. I love that the original is sung by a MAN pining for a girl, instead of a girl pining for a man, which seems so much more common. It's such a charming song. The original I favor.
Though I pretty much love everything by Belle&Sebastian (and especially THE LIFE PURSUIT) I really prefer this version of the song because of the nice musical arrangement (the voicing of the backing-vocals... facemeltig! And the solo voice in the last verse (2:46...) is heaven!) and because that female voice has a... soul-attitude which seems to be a surprisingly good match in a B&S-song! Plus... I'm a guy, and the singer is such a natural beauty :o)
Oh, he sings everything perfectly. ha! 2:46 is pretty cool, I mean, it's not like she annoys me, it's just ironic to me that my favorite song by them was changed. Also, I do wish I had known about this and could have auditioned, even though it was obviously fierce competition. I love to sing, and I don't sing like Mariah Carey or any of those types of singers.
On Sundays I put this song on in my living room and dance around my dog. She gets a real kick out of it. Of course, I have to change "frog" to "dog" for her.
It's a great song to begin with but I don't really see the point of this cover. She doesn't really add anything to the original, rather the toe tapping sense of fun has been lost. Trying to make a cover version more emotional than the original rarely works.
her name is Brittany Salling, she´s from olympia, usa and one of the guest singers on the record - but i think she´s just on that one.
i guess catherine ireton (i love her voice) is the main girl, with fellow singers celia garcia and alex klobouk.check out "god help the girl: part 2 of 4
@HazardousN00b405 Sorry, I mean 1:53 for Neil Hannon.
HazardousN00b405 2 weeks ago
Is... Is that Neil Hannon at 2:53? Wow. He is amazing.
HazardousN00b405 2 weeks ago
Love this version
aliethy18 2 weeks ago
thumbs up if you saw the thumbnail and you thought she was suckin on a dick
TheMasterpieceArtist 1 month ago
Lacks the energy of Bell's version. So-so.
dirkbogarde44 4 months ago
its funny little frog in my throw at not throat lol
AdeleCorrenti 5 months ago
I like how she pronounces all the syllables in "irresponsible"
picturechallenged11 6 months ago
I REALLY LOVE IT MADLY (L)
mirim96 6 months ago
Brittany!!! Remember in middle school play when you were the lady in the tooty fruity hat! I'm proud of you for rockin' it in this video!
pspelman 6 months ago
Please! Please! Brittany Stallings HAS to bee a permanet member of god help the girl! Thumbs up if you agree
BrunoUkulele 6 months ago 10
So gooooood to dance
VitaCreations 7 months ago
Haven't got a clue about Stuart Murdoch or the God Help The Girl project (which is all about to change)...but this is brilliant stuff!
didoma73 8 months ago
Brittany Stallings is the lead vocalist on this one.
She was one of the singers selected from the Imeem online auditions for GHTG.
Harmony vocals by Dina Bankole.
stinkymcstinkface1 8 months ago
Comment removed
zorakevora 9 months ago
Who is the singer???
flaviarpdutra 9 months ago
Just found out about this song because of a tweet link from @RosanneCash .. She said that she has listened to it "257 times over the last couple of years" ;)
lauriroset 9 months ago
I cannot get this version out of my head! I always liked the B&S version, but never like this. Love the singer - she has just the right amount of soul without over-doing it. More Annie Lennox, less Joss Stone (no disrespect, girl!). What is it about English girls (see also: Amy Winehouse)?
justinbresler 11 months ago
I have not enough words to express my feelings..
this is one of the most beautiful song I've ever heard..
thank you for this <3
tzamet1 11 months ago
Comment removed
tzamet1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thank you very much - love your taste
pensiontransfer 11 months ago
nice.
mrblack6974 1 year ago
As much as I love Stuart's version of this song, it seems to make more sense with a female vocalist. Fantastic songwriting regardless~
MiraculousTechnique 1 year ago 2
this song is addictive... I love this version :)
bebestrumf86 1 year ago
(Cover of 17) here is a funny song that all teens love. Have a listen...
Rebecca Skye
rebeccaskye 1 year ago
you're my guy and you don't even know it ... i like this version
1234lillie 1 year ago
awww only downside: she dosent say throw-it
jkno21892 1 year ago 4
@jkno21892 My thoughts too :)
whangie1 1 year ago
great tune .... have had it buzzing all day in my head :)
Rebbaaaa 1 year ago
This girl - Brittany Stallings I suppose - is terribly adorable, and clearly has talent. Not a talent that suits this song. It seems to smooth over the ambiguity, turning it into more of a generic pop song. But...thumbs up....
If it draws people back to the well of the original, I can see it's value. It wasn't a disgrace like most covers.
FungusMossGnosis 1 year ago
I don't like this version
desenfocada 1 year ago
What a beautiful song and the girl who sings... she's terrible cute!!!
frecklednose124 1 year ago
The singer name is Brittany Stallings, foir those who are wondering.
ThiagoPCarneiro 1 year ago 3
I think i saw Diane Birch around 0:48
love her
amest12 1 year ago
the song funny little frog is so spectacular
wiibermarulanda 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Really nice video. This was sent to me by a friend of RentAFriend (dot) com. Coooooooooolllllllllll one.
chcharle1 1 year ago
La canción es muy agradable. Me encanta la musicalización y la voz de la intérprete. Sigan adelanten con "God help the girl". Saludos desde Lima, Perú
angelosantamariar 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I WAS eating while watching this.. then her face made me gag.
XXibongoXX 1 year ago
i love her! somebody know her name?
jecagui 1 year ago
just closing tab
csiIIa 1 year ago
PERFECT! I love that song and her voice.
jecagui 1 year ago
que musica gostosa de se ouvir!!
bastosrah 1 year ago
Please help understan this... is God help the girl a movie, this music project? a soundtack? a old musician? 'cause once i heard a song and it semeed quite old, and there is a movie...because Asy sings a song... son, I don't understand, help ):
Violetaa92 1 year ago
@Violetaa92
GHTG is a NEW music project from Stuart Murdoch of Belle and Sebastian....he wrote the songs for an album and a movie still to come.
smcguigan1 1 year ago
While I enjoy God Help The Girl, this cover is completely horrid. Belle & Sebastian's version is perfect, what made the song great was the bounciness. This version makes the song just drag on and on. Meh.
insomniacvendetta 1 year ago
muito bom mesmo!!! very good!!!
roquevivi 1 year ago
Asya 2:19= Awesomeness
AIMExFANTINE 1 year ago
/watch?v=aVqw9WlPa
rpank123456 1 year ago
this is music :D:D
mushroomism 1 year ago
Anyone know iwhere i can get a copy of their song, 'Baby You're Blind'? It features the brilliant vocals of Linnea Jonsson from Those Dancing Days...
TheConstellation72 1 year ago
thanks! thanks!! viva el buen gusto!! clap clap clap!
waltersistemas 1 year ago
Is this the American Idol version? Was the point to make this soulless and boring? The song feels twice as long now. And it now sounds like the theme song to some terrible new sitcom. This blows. And I'm a huge Belle and Sebastian fan.
janetk618 1 year ago
@janetk618 Yeah, this version is trying way too hard and sucks, B&S version is effortless and has way more soul
haroldpark 1 year ago
@janetk618 this was on american idol?? omg........i'm so disappointed.
redrocklove 1 year ago
@janetk618
wow, talk about hate
pesto166 1 year ago
Wow, loved this version!
tatiskywalker 1 year ago
What a great mix of tempo, beat, lyrics, and heavenly vocals. SWEEEEET! This girl sings effortlessly.
ScreamingGrapefruit 1 year ago 2
Hace tiempo me enamoré de Catherine Ireton y su voz. Esta chica tampoco lo hace nada mal ^^
SimbioticRed 1 year ago
Does enyone knows where i can find the titeltrack God Help The Girl? It was always on youtube but now i cant find it enywhere :S
annikajw 2 years ago
buy the album
pavementistradical 2 years ago 4
this girl's voice is absolutely amazingly breath taking. she's so talented. i love this version of the song better!:D
pitadawg14 2 years ago
I've just came across both this song and B&S's version. I can't say I like the other better; indeed, I really think that this arrangement has got better quality, in what concerns instruments. I also prefer this kind of rythm with Murdoch's lyrics, it really gives it another dimension. Great work!
jorgizzmigizz 2 years ago
excelente realización
tadeo811 2 years ago
You must be out of your mind! The Life Pursuit version is fantastic, I agree. But this one is just as good, or even better. The old version was all peppy, and there's no way not dancing to it - but here you get the sadness that's always been underneath the lyrics, the loneliness - it becomes a new song. That's Stuart Murdoch for you.
ellinorengeline 2 years ago
I am totally in love with the girl who sings this song.
cinar96rvn 2 years ago 37
@cinar96rvn
ha, I went to school with her. I just randomly came across this. Weird.
log6778 1 year ago
A bit sickly...
At least the B&S version doesn't try to avoid loud and ridiculous, the way it was meant to be.
nicck 2 years ago
z's sister???
rudyxrudy 2 years ago
How could Murdoch do this for his own music? B&S original version is waaaaay better!
marcsena1 2 years ago
can't say better than og version but nice and since this is B&S front man's side project (producer) only i think it makes it sweeter
gbhcitybaby 2 years ago 2
@gbhcitybaby
I agree, it's just a really different style.
PeaceboneGotFound 2 years ago
this is such a timeless sound.
ItzHal1989 2 years ago 2
i've played this video like 6 times already
i'm in love with her voice!!!!
this cover is indeed quite amazing
antsinmybed 2 years ago 3
This is such an amazing cover. I'm really in love with the whole thing: video, cover, arrangement. Perfection. : )
hellofromsweden 2 years ago
me encantaaa!
alvamoggialepra73 2 years ago
I saw these guys last night at the Usher Hall in Edinburgh with Stuart Murdoch and the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra and they were BRILLIANT!!!!
rich88b 2 years ago
I love this version so much!
I love the original for dancing too, this one is so good to chill out.
In fact, the whole album is one big chill-out ...
1tracklover 2 years ago
Awesome. My channel is full of rare indie bands but I've never heard of this one before!
boGGbeatDown 2 years ago 2
Very Joss Stone, though not as powerful.
papallacta 2 years ago
I prefer B&S, but this version is so good.
nitroxama 2 years ago 4
Great song
RememberJJ72 2 years ago
the girls voices in god help the girl are amazing, but i prefer the B&S version.... is waaayyy better.... it's like more the spirit of the song is kind of lost in this slower version.
MarshKingdomPrincess 2 years ago
i kind of agree with you, i love B&S's version more, but this one isn't bad either :]
Sebaastienne 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sux badly. totally uninspired overpoped version and video...
alarmstrumpf 2 years ago
I love Belle and Sebastian. I loved this song by B n S. Im glad Stuart Murdoch from the band has a side project. Im glad they've done a cover of the B n S song, i love this versh too! I am going to see God Help the Girl on the 21st Nov!
BabushkaFuttocks 2 years ago
Fantástico, adorei esta versão!!!
Terrific, I love it, this version is amanzing!!!!
fxmdr82 2 years ago
this video is very clear and nice .
awesome one !!!!!! love it.
soullove01 2 years ago
at 0:31 is taht michelle branch??
us3indacompz 2 years ago
i like it better sung by this girl.
tookiepretzel 2 years ago
<3 it!
NitrousSunset 2 years ago 2
this is soooo good.
belle and sebastian's version was better though, but this is still amazing
twilightyer 2 years ago 5
Really i rekon this version is better! o well :)
killergerms101 2 years ago
we play this song in my store all the time and it always makes me smile
rshimo 2 years ago 3
i wish i could do that at my store! all i get is network radio and it sucks.
griffinthecity 2 years ago
wow where do you work?!
MichaelBarry1992 2 years ago
Stuart you're a master!!! I love u...
ainat79 2 years ago 2
I really like this reworking (I say reworking instead of cover because GHTG is essentially a Belle and Sebastian/Stuart Murdoch side project) of the song. It could have easily been released by Motown Records in the mid-60s.
GHTG is terrific, great album.
tamaravel 2 years ago
I heard this version of the song before hearing the original and I would almost bet her voice and brilliant uptempo will eclipse the Belle and Sebastian version, but I will check it out just the same. Great song and terrific looking video.
slungjank 2 years ago
IDK they are just very different, the original to this version...
dany9012 2 years ago
My God, Aaronblowers. You are an ignorant prick.
spudboybeta 2 years ago 3
Although its executed well, the song lacks Belle and Sebastian's originality. This young performer can belt just like many found in churches and on television. However, belting and scooping before every note is about all she does.
She'll find herself, and invariably the original voice will follow.
aaronblowers 2 years ago
I like it better than the Belle & Sebestian version, it's more adorable, less stalkerish, with a woman singing it.
LosAngelesWriter 2 years ago
I don't think the original sounds stalkerish. I love that the original is sung by a MAN pining for a girl, instead of a girl pining for a man, which seems so much more common. It's such a charming song. The original I favor.
entertainer106 2 years ago
Though I pretty much love everything by Belle&Sebastian (and especially THE LIFE PURSUIT) I really prefer this version of the song because of the nice musical arrangement (the voicing of the backing-vocals... facemeltig! And the solo voice in the last verse (2:46...) is heaven!) and because that female voice has a... soul-attitude which seems to be a surprisingly good match in a B&S-song! Plus... I'm a guy, and the singer is such a natural beauty :o)
MrHolzfeld 2 years ago
Well you see, I am a girl, and I think Stuart is a terribly handsome man, besides being talented. So, just like you, that helps me love the original.
entertainer106 2 years ago 3
:o)
...really talented, that man, and there's no other angel who could sing "...so fuck them, too" as softly as he does in "dress up in you" :o)
MrHolzfeld 2 years ago
Indeed, and there's no other angel who could sing the words "...so fuck them, too" as softly as he does in "dress up in you".
:o)
...but what about min 2:46? That always kills me!
MrHolzfeld 2 years ago
Oh, he sings everything perfectly. ha! 2:46 is pretty cool, I mean, it's not like she annoys me, it's just ironic to me that my favorite song by them was changed. Also, I do wish I had known about this and could have auditioned, even though it was obviously fierce competition. I love to sing, and I don't sing like Mariah Carey or any of those types of singers.
I am curious to see how this musical turns out!
entertainer106 2 years ago 2
On Sundays I put this song on in my living room and dance around my dog. She gets a real kick out of it. Of course, I have to change "frog" to "dog" for her.
papallacta 2 years ago 79
@papallacta That is the best thing I've ever read in a youtube comments box
wjow1 1 year ago
this version isn't bad, but it pales in comparison to the original. it somehow sucks all the life out of it.
NARPEUL 2 years ago 4
Absolutely prefer the original one, but this is very nice.
SrtaPelo 2 years ago 2
Much better than the original. Gives the song new legs. It was novel before, but now it's somewhat profound. It's her voice.
dabruin2 2 years ago
It's a great song to begin with but I don't really see the point of this cover. She doesn't really add anything to the original, rather the toe tapping sense of fun has been lost. Trying to make a cover version more emotional than the original rarely works.
burkebiscuits 2 years ago
This is far better than Come Monday Night. Far better.
iancurtis51880 2 years ago
I think the essence of the band is gone missing with this version. Not bad, though.
getmeawayfromhere 2 years ago
somewaht better than the version from B&S, the fem vocals make all the difference.
Angbandz 2 years ago
nice
soullove01 2 years ago
Cute :) Like it
fritzo62 2 years ago
Comment removed
ericmendoza1251 2 years ago
Great vid. Scalenenorthey hasn't a clue.
valiumsummer 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
man this video is crappy, all the other belle & sebastian music videos are brilliant
scalenenorthey 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lick my pussy
nathalypussy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love b & s, and i guess the next album it¨ll be great... but this song (this cover, not the original) sucks.
and the video, could be avril lavigne, or the hell she´s called
dmhb17 2 years ago
What genre is this?? Please? Someone tell me!!!
keroceno66 2 years ago
If James Morrison was a girl
bigobriener 2 years ago 2
Indie pop/chamber pop.
13thSeason 2 years ago
Thank you!!
keroceno66 2 years ago
I guess some would call it indie pop...
Planetarium51 2 years ago
how come ?
soullove01 2 years ago
because I beleive Belle and Sebastian are on an independent label. I could be really wrong though...
iCelerypoke 2 years ago
i see
soullove01 2 years ago
indie pop
littlepinkbutton96 2 years ago 4
vraiment magnifique! Superbe!
mitta28 2 years ago
god,,, best song ever !
soullove01 2 years ago 2
yeah man. banana bread
MrPregshnaw 2 years ago
Comment removed
jtstallings 2 years ago
Stuart is a genius.
arianenani 2 years ago
I seriously think he is. I do prefer the original B&S version of this song though...I adore his voice in it.
entertainer106 2 years ago
I can't stop listening to this, I love the strings and her voice is immence.
kingchrisuk2009 2 years ago
1:27 Most damn motivated drummer EVER
Muesliriegel1 2 years ago 26
Brittany Stallings is simply incredible.
dabruin2 2 years ago
i bought this album few days ago , it just more than what i expect , truly talented girl
westmanon9 2 years ago
funny little frog in my whaaat?
labarradelsainz 2 years ago
throat but she sings it to rhyme, which makes it a lil quirky
GoYouBigRedFireEngin 2 years ago
lovely song, anything this guy does is just lovely
ziggyplayguitar 2 years ago 2
Or you mean Belle and Sebastian, but whatever.
snuuub 2 years ago
That's hard, I can't choose my favorite, the original, or this one.
zerogouki5 2 years ago 2
This is cool! Is Asy looking at a fly or something?
GreatSkies29 2 years ago
love love love her voice. can't stop playing it over the huge sound system in the theatre i work at!!!
Can't wait for the album...
guardianista 2 years ago 2
BEST
caykahve 2 years ago 2
who is the vocal ? i want her name. someone helps?
mathildamiu 2 years ago
her name is Brittany Salling, she´s from olympia, usa and one of the guest singers on the record - but i think she´s just on that one.
i guess catherine ireton (i love her voice) is the main girl, with fellow singers celia garcia and alex klobouk.check out "god help the girl: part 2 of 4
ersatzalex 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3:24 I'm so in love
icarow 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3:24 I'm so in love
icarow 2 years ago
Comment removed
icarow 2 years ago
Stuart's throwing some flirty glances there...
SuzannaM 2 years ago
Can't wait to grab the album.
magicbuspass 2 years ago 2
2:19
BarProphet 2 years ago
do want!
juanheloreloaded 2 years ago
I like it sooo much :)
I believe in God help the girl too!
camylita 2 years ago
i belive in God help the girl)
hlup 2 years ago 3