Tim Urban singing Come Back to Me by David Cook on AI

[breezecowgirl]

Well all the comments about Tim not having the voice so much... well those were from a year ago, Now look at him! HE IS A AMAZING SINGER!!!!!!! Yes he totally has the looks but also he was the talent that God gave him! He is amazing! :) I love Tim Urban! :D I Thank God for him!

[FordF1502001]

He has the looks and the talent!

[MrSqueakers10]

Tim for me is the one that shakes things up and causes utter chaos, he has the potential to outlast the more deserving contestants, due to his fans (tweens) who are suckered in by his looks..honestly , he doesnt have a horrid voice, but it's not good enuff for this stage in the competition..He may even outlast Lee or Crystal or Siobhan, thats so damn sad

[AdamGontierGerardWay]

Well, Tim is definitely adorable, and his voice, while not out-of-this-world like Siobhan's or Michael's, is definitely smooth and something that would chart high on a Top 40 station. I don't think he'll win, but he has the potential to make it far and maybe do what Daughtry did, start up his band again and use his platform to make them famous. You hear Daughtry on the radio more than you do Jordin Sparks sometimes.

[superstar7soso]

to be honest i really do like him..hes cute..good voice..but not good enough to be in the top 12.... sorry ,,but its true!

[GodBlessBieber]

He didn't just get through on looks even though he is the hotess man alive...watch our Johnny Depp theres a new kid in town. But anyway he sing's like an angel and will WIN THIS THING! The only guy I like is him and Im upset they kicked Lily off she was amazing.

[emilyvictoria89416]

I thought he did an absolutely amazing job with this song. And... no. he didn't get through because of his looks. His audition was amazing, Hollywood week was good, his first performance wasn't that great but I still love him and his performance last week was better than the week before. Have you even heard his music on his myspace?

[musiclivesalways]

he's got more of an archie voice and i'm sorry but he shouldn't have made it through based on looks and looks alone this is a SINGING compettion

[DavidCookStalker]

Thank You! Finally someone gets it! Ha!

THIS IS A SINGING COMPETITION PEOPLE!

[l0r3st0]

@musiclivesalways actually he's more like jason castro; aaron kelly is more like archuleta, but not as good.

[BathroomBear]

Totally agree with you guys.

[Randm03]

@musiclivesalways He's Got Both The Looks N The Talent!!

[superfreakiee]

HOTTIE. love.

[inuluver5]

D:

i can't believe they put him through!

and not my beloved Tyler Grady D:!!

[mhmxnoelle]

i love him(:

[foxylove91]

damn he's hot

[bejayful]

Anybody who likes my AI David Cook and tries to sing his song is fine with me, I hope he can make it though.

[OCgirliechick]

Pah-leeze David Cook has the whole package. David  is one in a billion.

[jengersnaped]

Shoulda done "Lie". It already has an acoustic vibe and would have helped him smooth out the shakies in his voice. But he does have a nice voice.

[callmerenna]

ii love him<33333

hess deffitantlyyy gonna win(:

i hoppppe(: he has an amzaing voice & hes so cuteee<333 i love him <3

[bluebreezzie]

he is SOOO HOTT!!!!!!!! i'm glad he got through

[Inuyashafan5677]

I looooovvvveee this cover! I think he did very good. He has such a great voice. I'm gonna be voting for him for idol...well that's if my mom let's me get unlimited text so I can text a whole bunch of times and vote for him. Him and Casey James are the ones i'm going for, I won't care if either win as long as they go to the last round and one of them win. <3

[DavidCookStalker]

Alright, here's what I think. First off, bad song choice for him, though I think David would appreciate the fact that he's being remembered on idol after 2 years. I think Tim has a decent voice, but he was way too nervous to pull off a good cover. He made it through to the next round, so the judges must see something in him . . . If he is able to "get out of his shell" and not be so nervous, he may have a chance of succeeding in this competition.

[jgmm322]

at 00:31 he's like "fuck"

[mhmxnoelle]

no he doesnt? your stupid.

[taylorb22]

He's no David Cook, but he's good!

[princesslizann]

I have mixed feelings about anyone singing one of David's songs. However, he did do it justic. Not as good as David by a long shot. But he had to like the song to sing it and Im sure David will be pleased when he sees it. & be pleased that someone did cover it.

[36frannie214]

I agree with wissphoto, David would love that someone sang "Come Back To Me" He is always encouraging new talent and what a compliment to him. I bet he is very happy.

[mlarracuente]

the power of AI was on full swing last night, Come BAck To Me single benefited with a huge bounce on iTunes charts!! Yay!!

[Powerchain]

I genuinely believe he chose CBTM because he likes it . The fact that he would place his faith and his fate singing CBTM at such a crucial time as Hollywod week is a BIG COMPLIMENT.

[Powerchain]

read my post again, my apologies, I should have said HUGE COMPLIMENT

[sarah5937]

this guy is awesome, such an amazing voice.

[LMM2856]

I meant to write he did a decent job, not jop! Lol!

[LMM2856]

What does Simon mumble while he is singing? I can't make it out.

It is always risky singing a song by a former winner, especially when he is as popular as David Cook is. David has one of the best voices to ever come out of Idol, so I give him credit for choosing this song. I think he did a decent jop. I would need to hear more. The fact that he chose to sing a David Cook song shows he has great taste in music! I would like to see him stick around.

[OCgirliechick]

I can't BELIEVE this guy thought he could sing this better than David Cook. Poor choice of song for him, seriously NOBODY has a voice like David Cook! This just makes me miss David Cook so much!!! Bring back David Cook I love that guy!!!!!!

[SPN7191]

i don't think he ever mentioned he could sing better than david.

[SPN7191]

no where did he say he could sing better than david.

[wissphoto]

I agree David sings it better, but I think David would think it is pretty cool that someone is covering his song two years after he competed. Didn't someone really butcher his TOML last year on keyboards?

[gmarn17]

Nice try but NO ONE will ever sing that song as good as DAVID, in my opinion!!!!

[DavidCookStalker]

@gmarn17 I agree! 100%

[patyac48]

I prefer growly Dave!!

[racheljonas143]

no i think he made it better...ughh i want him too winnnn

[DavidCookAndDC]

Ugh! I think he ruined a perfectly good song.