U2 - With or Without You [Croke Park, Dublin 24th July 2009]

[CastletoKarma]

I'm reliving the moment, this moment they really did it for me that night, great stuff. I regret they took so long tho', I felt just here they were in top gear.

[jackzilla927]

this concert was incredible!! We came all the way from Salt Lake City to see U2 in their hometown and it was a night I will never forget. To be one of over 88,000 fans was a chance of a lifetime! I'd follow them anywhere.

[jughfreind]

'with or without you' will never lose its feeling.

[santiheladero]

i don´t like this new u2 show concept... it´s to relaxed.... more power needed

[CastletoKarma]

I was down on the pitch; mighty! I'm playing this to recall probably my best moments in 2009 - I hoped the song wouldn't end.....

[Sheelanight]

I've listened it and it was beautiful: D

I wasn't at the concert, but very close (at St. Patrick College) what a beautiful memorie and what a beautiful song

[scootboy2]

what a night top tier cusack atmosphere electric

[chrissycroken]

scotland and ireland to of the best places to see the worlds greatest band :)

[fretkillrfan]

Half a Song...!?!

What's up with that?

[smurf022]

Check out the the hitler salute on the 1 min 6 sec mark, must be the section where the irish nazi party got tickets for

[TheVistabell]

my brother was at the concert and he said it was amazing ! ♥

[anfodoc]

Awesome. And this def song of the night!!!

[EdenDD]

Electric atmosphere at this gig, what a show, what a band, magnificent!

[SuperHappydays]

Stadium/setting looks fantastic! Sound brilliant -Bono doesn't sound too strong on the old vocals. Doesn't seem to be a lot of atmosphere - perhaps this was at start of the show before crowd got going! Watch some of the TT footage from 13 June to get some real crowd participation!!!!

[GaryORLFC]

Nah, was actually at the end of the show. It was the second last song. The atmosphere was great throughout the whole gig, could be because it's a slow song.

[jenio]

well where you there?because I was and there was ALOT of atmosphere.and bono was great at the vocals

[SuperHappydays]

No Jenio obviously I wasnt there otherwise I wouldnt have put in the comment!!! Viewing it as someone who wasnt at the show and just looking at it as it was posted there didnt seem to be a lot of atmosphere during that song. That is all I was saying... people are entitled to an opinion you know!!!

[jenio]

ok yeah I see ya point.

But it really was great ya well shoulda went superhappydays.ya defo wuda had a super happy day if ya where there.this was 1 of the last songs so a bit more quiet y'know:)

[superdonna13]

show historico!hino mundial!so emoçaooooooooooo

[sile14]

Class...

[Yoso11]

k well... GaryORLFC I mean they are good... but they arent the BEST band ever..

[GaryORLFC]

That's your opinion.

[ActorJH]

Oh BUT THEY ARE!!! Guaranteed by the time U2 retire, they'll have more no.1 albums and Grammys than any other in history. They are already a record holder for Grammys(22) in counting, they ARE the biggest LIVE act in the world and have been for sometime and in the top 3 of no. 1 albums OF ALL TIME! With a no. of years left on the clock mate.

[AntiRellik]

Well, Bono's voice is showing the changes we all go through by age... But I'm glad he's still singing all these old songs... they are wonderful...

[drgangel3]

Of course Bono is gonna lose his voice, look at Sting for instance. Sting used to sing great, but now he's trying so hard, but that's why you have hard core fans, then they wouldn't care what you sound like. :-D No matter how old they get I'll love them forever \m/

[AntiRellik]

His voice has somewhat changed of course... but I don't think he has been losing it, I think its not as flexible as it was when he was younger. He still sounds awesome... it's like he doesn't have to kick his own ass trying to sing, his voice can handle it. IMO anyone can sing and sound good, you just have to know how to control your voice =P some people have a more stunning voice tone than others... and I think Bono's voice is just awesome.

[HolaDeco]

@AntiRellik Changed, yes, Lost, hell no. With proper technique, he can put his voice back into the 1980s. Watch the Little Noise Session videos.

[doylealand]

bleeding deadly

[BlockedParty]

He had a nightmare at the end of the song. Lost his voice a bit over the years.

[GaryORLFC]

I was at the gig on Saturday night and I was blown away. U2 are the best band in the world, maybe even by far. For those idiots that think U2 are rubbish then seriously, you do NOT know what music is all about, U2 are pure emotion, that's what music is suppost to be. Keep up the great work U2, you guys are the best!

[kavochavo]

r u serious U2 are like de best band ever ye sap

[roadrunners6986]

u2 r shit

[Burn462]

have you evr seen them live?

[cnocnacille76]

why was the stage not in the middle, was that not the point ? the fans in front of the stage in the stands were far too far away...

[aidyspady999]

nah i was back of the furtheset stands almost and was amazing

saw the stage in ful view so was alright

and also i think sumone sed it just wouldn't have worked

like its too wide but y'no

amazing gig

[kenhes]

It is in the middle.

[jenio]

brilliant gig.cusack stand.wouldve loven to be standing though...

[chocoholiclaney]

beautiful song beautiful view! goin tonight cant wait!!

[mixtape4melfi]

I was in the Hogan Stand, section 734 Upper Tier! Super seats and only got them on Tuesday! Was no where near a sell-out but great gig.

[Burn462]

man your right next to me XD

[roadrunners6986]

yes and there are shit

[Burn462]

like em or not i find it very hard to believe any1 could say that. You mightnt like their music or watevr bt the atmosphere was amazing and the musician ship between them all was great. Nt to mention the fact that bonos an awesum singer.

[weezerpleaser18]

obviously they arent shit?240,000 people over 3 days amount of hits they have?

[ingdrago]

from which sectror did u take this video?

[conordonnellan88]

Was working at it, they're pretty amazing, iv never seen a crowd been so up for a gig...

[dymphna1]

larry playing bongo..brilliant

[paul202]

dude that was fast...good job.

[maddogwally]

FIrst Comment!

The most exciting place on Earth this weekend! U2 Go Home!!!! 360!

Band sounds great Bono having a little trouble with the high notes at the end, but who cares!