Added: 4 years ago
From: emarum
Views: 29,224
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (151)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • u2 far away ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

  • What are you talking about? The songs are in different keys, have different chord progressions, and use different instruments. Even U2s bridge (the "touch me" part) uses a different chord progression. Even if these two parts were translated into the same key Ahas progression would be (em, c, g, d) and U2s would be (em, f, c, g). Even though these might sound similar to the naked ear by some, they arent. In fact the only real similarity is the words "touch me". So no its not a rip off.

  • @viperdude281 who cares,you are talking about something that most people dont know and when you heard the "teach me" from bono if you know the sun always shines on tv you immediately think of it,but if you dont know the a-ha song you probably think that its something original the teach me part but is copy from them.and for someone who says that was a tribute to a-ha it was not beacuse when bono was asked about it he says arrogantly that a-ha has always been stolen for them,and that is full of

  • @viperdude281 shit!..luckily a-ha has nothing to with u2 wich in fact I never liked...just this song wich some parts where stolen by bono from a-ha!

  • Seriously Loling at all the blind U2 haters right now.

  • no one is best to the other, the difference between aha and u2 is that the best aha songs are bsides and only people who buy their reccords know that, and the best u2 songs are always singles, aha had a very commercial beggining while u2 was always about music, but even in the most commercial reccords aha have hidden greate songs, and by the pace of time u2 became weaker while aha became better

  • Comment removed

  • i knew it all the time when this u2 version came out the first time!!!!!

  • 100 per cent copy off class aha

  • You know,maybe I could hear the similarities if you played them separately instead of this cacophony. Thanks for making that awful picture though.

    Both good bands though. U2 is better, but both are good.

  • @JoyousInsurrection NP fuckhead!

  • @emarum

    NP? What is that?

  • @emarum Oh, I looked it up. No problem. Oh well, thanks.

  • I respect A-ha, they are a great band, but what I'm about to say was dragged out by all these idiot A-ha fans/U2 haters. U2 are a far superior band in almost every way. In terms of originality (A-ha's music is indistinguishable from other mainstream pop from the 80s), influence (U2 have influenced many current artists), Live performances (U2 are regarded as one of the best live performers ever), and consistancy (although their early work was much better, their current stuff still tops charts)

  • "Two words "touch me" and here Bono also sings "the sun always shine on tv". As Bono was asked about this two words he said, that he had the song "the sun always shines on tv" of a-ha some how in mind as they made "a beautiful day". He also added something like "A-Ha is the most underrated Band ever i know of". He is dead right with this statement. You see, there is a kind of relationship between "A beautiful day" and "the sun always shines on tv"."

  • Here is the similarity in a nutshell where the part in the chorus of the "Beautiful Day" song where Bono sings "touch me" sounds like the guy from A-ha when he sings "touch me" in their "the sun always shines on TV "song ....woop-de-fucking-do other than that both songs are completely different in intro,verse and bridge

  • A-ha/ UP x U2/ down... low... small

    A-ha the best forever!

  • A-HA > POP  ...U2 > ROCK......NADA A VER!

  • A-HA!!

  • OMFG, I'm a huge fan of both, but have never noticed that... 0_o... :) Maybe, this is just a coincidence?

  • God damn. Never heard that a-ha song before, but just looked it up to confirm for myself (friggin top song too!): the similarities are undeniable - not just in the MUSIC, but also in the CHORUSES & the way they sing! Frigging identical!!! Just when I thought I couldn't respect bono any LESS... beautiful day was a weakass excuse for a song anyways, but now finding out they stole the bloody thing just makes it worse! Man u2 really are hasbeen pooftas. Suck my cock.

    FFFFUCK

    YOU

    BONO

  • @JohnoEAL vai te fude palhaço

  • @JohnoEAL ..go fuck yourself.....barely a resemblance between these two songs..a stretch at best....but some how you're turning it into Under Pressure and Ice Ice Baby...you stupid fuck

  • "wolfennyc" - Lemme guess: youre a U2 fan....

    Lemme guess: you're American

    Lemme guess: you suck dicks

    Lemme guess: you've sucked bono's dick

  • @JohnoEAL you can stop guessing ...here are the facts

    1.) I am your father.......reluctantly so

    2.) The best part of you ran down my leg

    3.) I told your mother I don't want kids but the bitch failed to use contraception like I asked her to.......so when I told her I didn't want you she went and got the coat hanger in an attempt to abort your ass..somehow you survived the abortion and that explains why you are such a dumb fuck today.

    P.S. your mom died years ago from shame..you living

  • A-ha all the way :P

  • fuck you man you don't any thing about music

    u2 is the best band of all times

  • a-ha is the best forever, U2 is good but a-ha is perfect

  • @emarum Good one, but not a true one :D

  • who the hell is A-ha?

  • @TheAmiyakumar lol...

  • Did U2 not even credit A-ha with anything?

    That's murder.

  • @zakilaouira no dude. u2 sucks. no offense

  • @hOmEsKiLlEtZzZz u know something u r the sucks not u2

    u2 is the best band of all times

    fuck you stupid

    u have to learn what kind of music u choose

    free ur mind and ur ASS will follow u2

  • no competition, AHA. u2 does not even come close.

  • AHAUHUOHOHO!)))

  • I'm glad it wasn't just me... What a rip-off!!

  • I prefer A-ha.

    Morten likes to save the world as well, but he's not annoying as hell.

  • A-ha The Best!!

  • A ha definitely, U2 are shite

  • @TheMrbollox fuck you

    u dont know anything about real music

    u2 the best band of all times

  • I didn't mean that this is the best song, but everybody knows with or without you.

  • thats not u2s biggest hit, where the streets have no name is

  • a-ha marcana brazil 196,000 people

    guns n roses same show 66,000?

  • @rockondon U2 BARCALONA 3000000

  • as for me a-ha is just better

  • A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha A-Ha

  • Chris Evans played the a-ha tune this morning on Radio 2 and the first thing I thought was, "U2 ripped this off". I feel vindicated!

  • And Beautiful Day is other version of U2 - Always.

  • @martilook

    Hello,

    A-ha and U-2 are my favorite bands and two are from the 80. As you can see I'm a democratic person. Can you tell me the conclusion you about it? I'm curious ...

    E. T.

    Martilook, the band A-ha has in its history more than a famous song.

    A hug for us!

  • @mirnareginaortiz in fact "take on me" was the first song a-ha made(i mean, to promote themselves worldwide) ..if you want good lyrics i tell you some songs from the early albums("scoundrel days","living a boy´s adventure tale","out of blue comes green","rolling thunder","sycamore leaves","locust" and since their return in 2000 "mother nature goes to heaven","barely hanging on","there´s a reason for it","white dwarf"..most of their songs are way above of "take on me".

  • @dayargrosario

    Aha is my pop band of all time and I agree entirely with you. "Take on Me" is great, but they go far beyond that song. Do not worry .... I know all the songs ... They are beautiful ... Sorry for my bad English. A hug!

  • @mirnareginaortiz ahahaha sorry i confused you with other guy/girl..you keep your good taste and congratulations for not following the mass opinion in something so special like music..another hug! ;)

  • I hadn't listened to the A-Ha song in years (nearly forgetting it even existed) and the "Beautiful Day" connection jumped out at me immediately. Both are beautiful songs.

  • This is a very basic 4 chord progression--U2 plays it in a different key than the a-ha song. I don't see the "ripoff." If this is a ripoff then so are 90% of new songs out there.

  • Oh and just try to compair their lyrics. with or without you: See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails she makes me wait And I wait without you take on me: reading a book lady brings a new cup of coffee peek in the window she would rather keep on reading Yeah it's really deep and touching lyrics.
  • @martilook

    Are u seriouse !!!?!?!? :-)

    Are you cynical?!?!

    The lyrics you just mentioned belong to the funny cover song here on you tube, these are not the words!! LOL ! you are awsome man!! :-)

    Now seriously, are u seriouse or it was for fun?! LOL

  • @israeliwarriors I'm glad someone answered. Thanks.

    And yes I was cynical. I'm not such an idiot ;). It was for fun. But now seriously:

    Talking away

    I don't know what I'm to say

    I'll say it anyway

    Today's another day

    To find you shine away

    I'll be coming for your love okay."

    I don't think it's ambitious at all. Come on. Just another song about love. I know lot of people like such things but sorry not me. I must be a weirdo. But it's just my opinion. For u With or Without You can be creepy song.

  • Hi again... :-)

    Im glad you just joked about it :-)

    Anyway.. i really like U2, but i have all the albums of a-ha.

    I think that u chose to do a silly comparation :-) these early days brought a lot of weird lyrics, and besides, why did u compare such a seriouse (and beutiful) U2 song to an 80s rytmic popular song? most of a-Ha songs are really nice written and timeless in their lyrics and melody, and they got deeper trough time as the band got older.

  • OH...

    and you are definatley not a weirdo! just need to come up with a different comparation :-)

    I'm pretty sure that out of the 100s of u2 songs i can find some silly one's.

    Do you know a-ha's songs, besides their hit "take on me"? I know a lot of U2 songs, but I really think you are going to like a lot of the aha's ! i want to show you some but i realy don't know where to start ! :-)

    Overall, They really have good songs both famouse and not, want to hear my favorates?

  • take on me.sun always shine son tv

    top us 20/living daylights james bond

    velvet on usa movie one night at mc cools

    summer moved on,huge uk hit.crying in the rain BY THE EVERLY BROTHERS?

    see these are just a few great hits.a-has

    been huge for 25plus years :0) you dont

    know them.THE PEOPLE THAT ONLY SAY TAKE ON ME ARE PEOPLE LIKE CONAN OBRIAN,A-HA HAS SOLD OUT

    SATADIUMS FOR YEARS EX 196,000 IN

    MARCANA BRAZIL. GO SEE EM IN MAY

    IN NYC or chicago or los angelas

  • @emarum Even if it is I prefer U2's version. I don't like A-ha. For me it's just another 80's pop band and U2 changed (for me) the music. And A-ha has only one really famous song but everybody has their own tastes.

  • Wait. A-Ha has songs other than Take On Me?

  • @nopantsman320 Hahaha. I'm wondering too.

  • U2 obviously stole Beautiful Day from a-ha's Sun Always Shines, but a-ha can't sue because Pal Waaktaar of a-ha routinely steals HIS music from obscure New Age artists and the Beatles. One huge difference between U2 and a-ha is that the members of U2 all get along very well. Pal Waaktaar and Morten Harket of a-ha despise each other.

  • Bono's a douche but he needs to do things for the community and he does help lot of unknown causes by only speaking of them.

    Never heard of A-ha =/ ill get into it lol

  • thx man ive been searching for the name of that song for quite a long time now...

    ''I will climb Highest mountain.. OOooonly to be with you''

    come on Bono thats 3rd grade style romance

  • wow - that IS kind of embarrassing....

  • a-ha is as good as u2 ....sometimes even better

    y punto

  • really the best band u2 is

  • I like U2 but not Bono. I know that sounds weird, but it's true. I'd fall at a-ha's feet just to get their autograph rather then go to a U2 concert. I know U2 have had many good hits and a are a great band, but I just like a-ha a lot more. They are my favourite band. Everyone has their own tastes.

  • crap

  • what's crap? in case you mean bono, i totally agree.

  • i like a-ha but u2 are more special just look at the live shows.

  • take on me got to number 1 in usa and number 2 in the uk so they didnt do to bad did they

  • yes fuck you 10000000000 one

    u2 your masters

  • fuck to this video and the guy who put it its just shit

    hey stupid u2 is the best band ever

    go to the fucking hell

  • fuck ME? go jump cliff with mister dollar-boner, wanker.

  • @zakilaouira

    I like how you put "the" hell.

  • lo de u2 no tiene nombre.

    great a-ha.

  • Comment removed

  • Big A-Ha fan here in the USA.

  • hey you should mix this

  • hmmm,the"boy band"a-ha turnd up to be an inspiration for many of the big bands of today,il got all a-ha albumes and just have to say if a-ha was a native english/us band ,well forget take on me and the synth years,this band now is a lot more rock;n roll+ a singer at world class than you ever would belive

  • I love U2 & A-ha !!

  • A-ha is not interested in commerial, success since 2005. Neither has to compete.

    For 2009, no more musicians on stage.

    no myspace, no facebook, no youtube Official A-ha

    Bono insult Chris this week

    U2&Coldplay who win ?

    lol

  • oh come on. We all know it's not a rip off, it's a tribute to a-ha. Others have done the same, like Coldplay and Madonna. a-ha forever though!

  • The original A-ha forever, my Mexican heart loves you!!!! u2 and coldplay do something creative please

  • THANK YOU SO MUCH! for posting this.

    i've been screaming it at people for years. and for all the fucking lamo's who talk about relevance; pleeeeeeeease. that died a long time ago with you too

  • a-ha are better!!

  • well said!!

  • Comment removed

  • This video is so stupid, the melodies are very different at all !, Only concidence is the use of the phrase "Touch me", this can be copyrighted ? The answer is, clearly NO.

  • It is not a coincidence. The two phrases are sung almost identically.

  • that's right it is obviously NOT a coincidence

  • I will repeat... you cannot copyright two notes only, those were used in "touch me", how many songs in pop, or classical music used that combination of TWO notes ???,...; Millions...

    Better go to check the coldplay true plagiarism... , they copied sequences of 8,10 notes in the same order , from a song of Joe Satriani, they were sued by the author.

    Don´t lose time with this, BTW, I'm fan of both bands, since 1985...

  • Love Love Love by James Blunt is a very plagia of "keeper of the flame" by A-ha

    Paul, Magne Morten becomes Bob Dylan

    and I need to revive A-ha by beautiful day clip .

    give me this cake free thanks

    ok any sense for the comment but a riddle

  • They didn't ripp them off, A-ha and U2 are great bands, and I love them both!

    Just that A-ha is a bit underrated, but those who know what A-ha is - well they very well know it!

  • a-ha has and will always have my vote there

    purely more talented..mortens voice isnt raspy

    pauls a killer guitarist WISHED THEYD DO A US TOUR WITH DM -A-HA-U2 AND MORRISSEY THAT WOULD SELL BILLIONS?

  • I think A-ha is a very underrated band. And U2 overrated. Thinking of A-ha as a 80s teen pop phenomenon is stupid. One hit wonder boybands don't perform in Albert Hall and get Q magazine prizes. I see Bono in every newspaper, and there's no need for Morten, he's talented enough not to demonstrate his "feelings" for African children. Take On Me video was a revolution. Hunting High And Low are covered by Coldplay. Even Liam Gallagher and Leonard Cohen like A-ha.

  • There not exactly a one hit wonder, considering Take On Me and The Sun Always Shines are BOTH hits,,,

  • I loved it! Both are my favorite bands!!

  • popmarter is an ass farter. if he cannot find time to listen to the work of a-ha and is blindly obsessed with u2 then he has clearly made his choice and will not be swayed. Both bands are fantastic, with my preference being for a-ha. Their music has many similarities, but I would not want to say who has copied who at times, as there are many cross-overs.

  • It's not copying you frube, it's sampling!

  • it's not at all sampling,,, come on.. "frube".

  • Of course it's sampling. Kid Rock sampled Werewolves of London with All Summer Long, and this would never be described as copying. He sampled his melody...

    PS check your YouTube more often... My comment has kinda been here for like a month, so your reply was near irrelevant...

  • Nice job illustrating your point...

  • a-ha beats the shit out of u2

  • A-Ha are so much better than U2.

    Perhaps dead and gone for the medias, but not from the real music lovers.

    They became underground with the time, but their three latest albums can't be compared with the U2 one's.

    They just not need celebrity as U2.

  • a-ha is better !!

  • ola I am Brazilian a-HA and U2 is the best bands of the world! Moacir of Brazil!

  • Cóż, obydwa zespoły są bardzo popularne, natomiast patrząc na ilość sprzedanych płyt itp no i wokal przede wszystkim to A-ha jest najlepszym zespołem! Żaden zespół nie ma tak barwnej historii, takich cudownych piosenek! Oni zawsze trzymają sie raze a u2...tam tylko o bono słychać o ile słychać... A-HA is the best of the best and you can't deny it!

  • These 2 songs are not alike all they share is the word touch me then some twat starts saying U2 were ripping off aha,Bolloxs U2 are in a completely different league to aha ,Aha write happy discountable pop songs and are no longer relevent or heard of ,not enough space to describe U2 ,Biggest and Greatest spring to mind.

  • Ignorance is a bless, ain't it? Have you ever read any of A-ha's lyrics? Have you ever heard what Bono or Adam Clayton have said about A-ha?

    Who do you think have been credited as an inspirational source by bands like Coldplay and Keane? U2 might be biggest and greatest on selling records, but get some meat on your bone before you start chewing...

  • Somebody is touchy alright. But to get this "debate" on to a more constructive fase:

    I still don't think you have enough meat on your bone for making the comments you are doing. To me it seems like you are one of the millions who still thinks of a-ha as a boy band with a one hit wonder. Further, you're showing a bious attitude with a little hint of unhealty nationalism when you are saying non-native speaking english bands can't put a deeper meaning into their english lyrics. (to be contiuned)

  • But I guess you have a superiour clue on good english lyrics. Better than Coldplay, Keane, Adam Clayton(!), Bono(!), Sarah Brightman, Robbie Williams...and the list goes on and on.

  • You don't know A-ha's lyrics good if you say that. And what about Bjork, an artist from Iceland, who's native language is not English?

  • feces or chocolate is better?

  • a-ha and U2 both share great successes, very different bands. i've had far more play from a-ha's material - the guys are way cooler than bony and his buddies.

  • A-ha and U2 share great success? you are clearly blinded by your obsession of a scandinavian band that stopped being rellevant decades ago. Aha can only hope to begin to scratch the surface of the success U2 has achieved both creatively and commercially. Not even close.

  • A-Ha is very popular to this day in many countries, but don't even release their stuff in the states anymore.

  • Exactly, why would they release their stuff in the states if they remained relevant? I rest my case! I can understand if you're saying A-ha remains great creatively and I wouldn't question that. But U2 is an one of the most acomplished bands and is on another league not just commercially but also creatively. On 3-03-09, U2 is will release their best reviewed and creatively speaking, one of their greatest albums to date.

  • I get it; you really, really like U2.

  • hear hear. and i wouldn't mind, i'm from U2's home country and even I don't like them that much. they're very in your face, whereas a-ha are much more sly with their song meanings. as they said of 'foot of the mountain', they like to make 'uptempo songs, but not necessarily upbeat songs'. In my eyes, a-ha are so much more than the infamous hit that launched them into superstardom. A-ha will always be the superior, regardless of how much fame U2 have.

  • i <3 u2

  • A-HA IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

  • You should compare the latest a-ha and u2 albums.

    Analogue from A-ha is so much better.

    U2 is the best media band in the world.

    A-ha is the best creative band in the world.

    They still not need celebrity as U2.

  • A-ha the best

  • What the crap LOL

  • i prefer a-ha

  • I think so ・・・It's a little bit likeness.

    but They still to now U2 and a-ha is great

    bands.

    will be Forever!

  • A-ha began their career in a commercial way, and finish it in a very artistic and beautiful way.

    U2 did the inverse, very too commercial nowadays.

    The medias prefer U2.

    As for me, i'll always prefer A-ha.

  • wasn't it like a kind of tribute to a-ha?

    wikipedia:

    "a-ha was always kind of a misunderstood band in my ears. They were perceived as a teenage group for girls, but in reality a very creative band." (Adam Clayton, U2)

    "When we heard U2's "Beautiful Day" for the first time, the part where Bono sings "Touch Me", we thought right away that that sounds like a-ha!" (Keane)

  • I THOUGHT "beautiful day" sounded oddly familiar! This explains why!! Nice catch!

  • thanks ;-)

  • a-ha are better !!!

  • the sun always shine on tv! love it (u right, u2 suck!)

  • what have talent to do with ripping off..? u2 suck.

  • Come on!I like A HA,I dont believe U2 suck,let see it this way,It's a tribute..

    and everyone happy.both songs are great dont you think?

  • if you look better you could find the solo projects and band projects from the members of a-ha, if you just thought a-ha is "take on me" well we might thought u2 is only a comercial band now, and off course they are not as well as a-ha is more than just "take on me" they are teaching now to a new bands like cold play for an expl.

  • LOL! My thoughts exactly!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more