Added: 2 years ago
From: MrTrashcan1
Views: 49,894
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (119)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song was so out of its time. It came out in about 1979 and really belonged at least 10 years prior to that.

  • @Wolfsky9: actually this song predates Brian's '76 comeback. It was first recorded at Caribou in Colorado as you say, but before 15 Big Ones and Love You. Brian and Carl wrote the song. I think there was an additional lyric, which Brian mentions in (I think) the 1976 Crawdaddy story by Timothy White.

  • @TellYerMa Timothy White do not know anything about Brian!!!

  • too short!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Their best harmonies, in my opinion... Thanks for posting !!

  • I was living in Albuquerque when this came out.

    Kirtland Air Force Base.

    Man, I love hearing the music, but I really don't miss that place.

    Must find the rest of that album now.

  • Song was so underrated,,a shame excellent..RWB

  • At their best the Beach Boys sounded like somebody'd opened up the sky a bit and the sound of angels on waves could be heard!

  • @Everyone

    Stop talking.

  • Like fine wine and yes so many more tunes should have been hits.

  • Not really. I grew up with Lionel trains & have remained in O-gauge. One

    big difference between 1950's America (when many of my friends were into toy

    trains, & there were train shops everywhere) and NOW: you can find many,

    many models of "Q" engines and cars in O-ga. Back in those days, few, and they weren't accurately decorated (in colors and paint schemes.) I was a local train club president for nine years, we built a local museum and made it into

    national mags, have ramped it down since then.

  • Yet another BB jewel that kinda got lost in the shuffle. They cranked out so many.

  • No, Mr. Trashcan, not Burlington NJ or elewhere... I'm a railroad buff and the "Burlington" refers to the old Chicago, Burlington & Quincy" (famous for the Zephyr) or "Burlington Route"...also what the "B" stands for in its modern-day descendent, "BNSF". My great-grandfather worked for them, and I've always been a fan (just like with the Beach Boys). Now you know :-)

  • @burlingtonbill1 I know it well.  CB&Q, then BN, now BNSF. Been a railroad buff and model railroader since childhood. I grew up with the eastern roads in PA like Reading, PRR, B&O and CNJ. Nobody in my family ever worked for a railroad or even had an interest. I must have been infected at a very early age. Are you a modeler?

  • Because the BB's all knew this masterpiece was ALL CARL, it was done onstage only briefly. There is just no way The Guys--at the time--could do this note-perfect, as Carl did, much less: who would hit the Falsetto, knowing only Carl could do it as it is on record?? Carl's concern over his Brothers & thier demons--plus his own struggle with Annie & he divorcing--all led him to : 1. Leave SoCal, for Colo. & 2. Record his solo album, in Late '80. Wolfsky9

  • Uhhhh folks--are you all aware that this song is --completely, totally, Carl Wilson?? The Falsetto, The Backgrounds, the guitars & drums, are ALL --ALL, Carl. He did this himself, frustrated by the guys & his older Brother especially, unwilling to do this, NOTE-PERFECT. So, he did it himself. Listen carefully. It's all Carl. Wolfsky9

  • nothing happens this song

  • This song is one of the greatest songs ever written!

  • Hey, Mr. Trashcan1. Thanks so much for posting!!!! I love this song. LOVE IT!!!!!!!

  • When this BBs song came out, it was astounding as a long-lost harmony sound by The Boys. In that context, it was largely regarded by many expert, longstanding fanatic followers of the band - at that time - that THIS SONG constituted their BEST piece of sweet-harmony work in a decade. It still stands the test of time today. And we need to hold on to it, as anything else that'd be precious to us, because this pure, peerless harmony calibre of sound will never ever be created again in the future.

  • @colindominy I'm with you when it comes to voices in harmony. That's why it's one of my favorites.

  • @colindominy I actually enjoy the LA Album. Not groundbreaking or amazing but pretty at times and very relaxing. Except for that stupid disco song. Oh well. The real horrors int he band only came after that album.

  • @colindominy Uhhh, I am truly sorry to say this, but it needs to be done: this is NOT==NOT, The BB's. This is Carl Wilson! Lead, Falsetto, Backgrounds, & instruments! Listen--just listen closely. In '79, Carl wanted the B oys to do this, but he could not get everyone together, & BW was so erratic in his singing, that At Caribou Recorders, he did it all --ALL-- himself. Just Listen closely--tell me who's Falsetto that is. Wolfsky9

  • @Wolfsky9 That's very interesting. But where did you get that from?

  • @rpm88able Sir, I have 2 sources : 1. My own ear --from the very 1st, the song sounded like Carl, all the way. 2. Good friend, who knows more BB info. than I ever will, & who lives in Colo., knows people at Caribou. This was not done at Miami, where the group attempted to do much of what eventually appeared on " LA -LIGHT"--this was done by Carl, fed-up with BW's erratic singing & the disasters of " Big Ones " & " Love You"--total bombs, especially BW's singing. Wolfsky9

  • @Wolfsky9 Mr Wolfsky, this song was made for the BB L.A. Album which was not a big hit for the boys. This was the come-back for Mr Bruce Johnston. Anyway this was problaby the best song out of the album!

  • This should have been a much bigger hit, but it was released at the height of the disco era (1979), and it sounded a little too retro to appeal to many people. I remember liking it so much that I went right out and bought the album.

  • @OceanKingNY right on. my senior year in high school. my mom was a huge beach boy fan. me, not so much. but i heard this song, and loved it. i bought the album out of curiosity, and within a few years, I was a beach boy fan like my mom.

  • This is simply one of their best, reminds me of my time in california in '79.....Malibu Beach, etc...

  • Ahhh! My last year in college and disco was on the wane. Bitter sweet memories. Thanks for the post.

  • I had this album and there were a couple good songs on it. Such great harmonies on this beauty.

    It reminds me of good times in the late 70's.

  • The boys hit #40 in Billboard, 6-9-79. God bless ya, for postin' it. Thanx! RIP, Dennis and Carl Wilson.

  • OK, now I'll spell harmonies correctly. LOL

  • The great CARL WILSON voice...... blows us all away once more on this one.

    Background harmaonies 100% retro BEACH BOYS.

    Add to the mix that this awesome post is produced by MrTrashcan1 ................ and being familiar with HIS story and appreciating HIS body of work, we've got ourselves another YouTube treasure here. THANK YOU MT1.....again.

    You're in a CLASS of YOUR own;

    just like the legendary Brian Wilson and The Boys Of Summer.

  • @mysterytrax Couldn't agree more about Carl and the boys, and very much appreciate the kind words, Ed. And I'll even cut you a break on the typos. LOL

  • @mysterytrax Uhhhh sir--U R aware I trust, that this is NOT--NOT, the Beach Boys--this is Carl--Lead, backgrounds, falsetto, guitar & drums. ALL OF IT, sir, is Carl. All of it. Actually, anyone who knows the sound of The Beach Boys, would know in 30 seconds or less: it's ALL THE LATE--GREAT, CARL WILSON. PERIOD. That's not BW's " whine falsetto"--it's Carl. Great, great song, & it's also part of why onstage--it sounded so different!!! It's all Carl. Wolfsky9

  • Recorded in Colorado at the Caribu Ranch by James William Guercio

  • I saw the Beach Boys several times in the 70's. The concert where they showcased this song was by far and away the best. Berkeley Greek Theater. Another awesome tune they did that day was Sumahama. That and Good Timin' are two of my all time faves.

  • Such tight harmonies... amazing !! Thanks for posting, MrTrashcan !!

  • As long as there is the season of summer somewhere in the world someone will be listening to the legendary Beach Boys! Thanks guys for all your good vibes!

  • listen to the vocals. amazing!

  • another great song under their belt

  • Im glad i lived in the era of the Beach Boys!

  • This is indeed an under appreciated and overlooked Beach Boys tune. Reminds me vividly of summer vacation in 1979 camping and lying on the beach. Why wasn't it a bigger hit? I think you have to remember the times. Disco crap was all the rage...songs like "Hot Stuff" and "Bad Girls" by Donna Summer..."Good Times" by Chic, "Ring My Bell", etc. One of the worst periods for popular music.

  • @michaelpc64 No, one of the GREATEST times in music! Disco was great, Post-Punk and New Wave were happening, great Pop music, Hip Hop was just coming up, and this late period Beach Boys masterpiece was one of the great things happening!!!

  • Way to go Mr trashcan, and radio still sux.

  • hay man, just wanted to say you did a great job on the video. I listened to your song and then watched a live performance of the same song. It is amazing what the studio can do for the sound.

    Mike

  • @blinko7777 Thanks. I understand the excitement of seeing a live performance, but no question, the studio versions are always the best.

  • @MrTrashcan1 I used to think so too until heard Boston in concert, also Fresh Aire (Mannheim Steamroller). It just takes a ton more effort in concert to try to come close & most don't apparently make the extra effort. (continued)

  • @MrTrashcan1 If you want to be absolutely BLOWN AWAY by how great the concert sound can be in a Beach Boys context, listen to the harmonies on the Fendertones' Dance Dance Dance, here on youtube. It just takes a BUNCH of people to attempt to replicate Brian's studio mastery and layering!

  • @burlingtonbill1 Bill, I see your point. I watched the Fendertones and they are terrific. Is your handle referring to Burlington, NJ by any chance?

  • Such tight harmonies... amazing...

  • this song can be summed up in 1 word..... "F***en Beautiful"... sorry I guess it needs 2 words!

  • Unfortunately, no Beach Boys song released after 1966 gets much play on oldies stations. In fact, the only one I've ever heard get played at all is "Do It Again".

  • @dudemanbearpig

    R U serious? "Kokomo" = most overplayed BB hit!!!

  • @majaman1978 Oh yeah, I forgot about that one, it must have slipped my mind.

  • I think this track more than any other shows how important Carl Wilson was to the Beach Boys! He covers the parts Brian would have taken years earlier.

  • mr trashcan who is doing the falsetto in the bac ground, or does any ony else know thanks

  • @bradleycandler Either Adrian Baker or Jeff Foskett. May have been too early for it to be Jeff.

  • @bradleycandler

    I'm not sure i think it is Carl... by 1979 Brian had totally lost his beautiful falsetto so i guess its Carl but maybe Al too who knows. Those harmonies tho... only the beach boys!!

  • @bobshenix - I don't think Brian had lost his voice by '79 b/c I saw them sing 'Their Hearts Were Full Of Spring' for president Reagan's 2nd inauguration in early '85 and it sounded like he still had it. Either way, it's definitely Carl singing the harmonies in this song. His voice may have even been a little purer than Brian's but that's totally splitting hairs as far as I'm concerned. Sweet song. :)

  • @mattyreich

    He rebounded - he sounds better today than he did in the mid to late seventies.

  • @bobshenix Carl lost his voice after Jimi Hendrix stuck his 12 inch dick in his fat ass.

  • One of my BB favorites!!! Thanks for posting!!

  • This is my all-time favorite Beach Boys song - and I, too, cannot believe it wasn't a hit. It was on the juke box at my favorite hangout, and me and my friends would have a few pops and sing this at the top of our lungs. GOOD TIMES - !!

  • can any one tell me who is singing the falsetto background vocals thanks

  • ...yes..I AGREE, Mr Trashcan..

    wondering WHY it WASNT as HIT-HIT-ish as say,

    FUNFUNFUN..

    Id like to believe its these, incredible, not-so-widely-known tunes that clearly draw the LINE, though.

    You and ME, and the rest of us,

    dont choose our FAVORITES because of their MASS-APEAL and "Hit-Status"..

    RIGHT..?!

  • This is Fantastic........One of the Best Songs they did........What a Great Time it was to have grown up with the Beach Boys songs when I was in School.

  • i to cant see how this one got over looked.i discoverd it by accident when i bought there greatest hit cd.but now when i play it i open my H.S year book from 1974!!

  • This has got to be equal to Don't worry Baby, in my humble opinion. RIP Carl and Dennis Wilson.

  • Rest in peace, Carl & Dennis. Gone but never forgotten.

  • This is just beautiful...I love this!

  • Hit me with your rhythm song.

  • why this song wasn't a hit I'll never know. It sounds fantastic, there are so many beach boys tracks from the 70's on that are so horribly underrated, and I really don't know why.

  • @ninman58 Well, technically it was a hit -- #40 on Billboard--but I agree that it should have been bigger.

  • i totally agree with you this song is too smooth....RIP denny

  • @ninman58 So true. Last truly great BB's song. Did make the top forty though

  • @ninman58 I very much agree with you for sure!!

  • I have asked myself this same question over and over and over again. This indeed was some good music. I love and appreciate this song so much. Oldies, but goodies. It's where it's at. Love it!

  • Toooooooooo smooooooooooooooootttthhhhhhhh­h

  • Thanks for posting this......great song

  • The haunting voice of Carl lives on forever

  • not heard this for 30 years.Brian Wilson the Legend.

  • Effortless Beauty

  • HEY who is doing the falsetto part in the background??? Carl is singing lead. Doesnt sound like Brian. Hope you know. Thanks

  • NICE Bruce Johnston production, also.

  • Just love it! Beautiful Beach Boy song, and my favorite.

  • Beatiful song, great !!!

  • Great song - Carl had such a beautiful voice. I remember buying this album back in 1979!

  • Even if my favourite song of B.B. is God Only Knows this is the second one, WONDERFUL

  • How about "I Can Hear Music"? That has to be up there.

  • Oh yes ' I can hear music' is very nice but i like better those songs of B.B. for their vocal harmonies and atmoshere... good vibrations!

  • Man first time I've heard this and I gotta say it doesn't just rank high in the Beach Boys catalogue...it ranks high in the catalogue of ALL music! Thanks for posting this treasure

  • The vocal and background harmony arrangement is incredible, will never be another group like these guys, A+A+A+

  • I remember this from 1979--I always liked it. This might be compared with George Harrison's song "Blow Away"  2 great under-rated songs!

  • trevor do you happen to know who is doing the whooo whooo in the background of this song . It doesnt sond like Brian. Carl is singing lead. Id appreciate it if youd let me know if you know. Thanks

  • Released in Spring 1979 on the LA/Light Album. Also on the album was a couple great Dennis Wilson songs, Baby Blue/Love Surrounds Me.

  • This is another great song by the Beach boys. So many people have not heard this one, it really is a hidden gem.

  • Excellent BB song......WHY didn't it receive much airplay back then?? I never heard this until I borrowed one their albums from a friend years ago...

  • an amazing song, I agree it should get more air time then it does.

  • Could be my very favorite of theirs.

    Funny but it caught me just 2 years ago at a concert in NH when Mike Loves son Christian was singing the lead of it!

    It just grabbed at me at that moment. (I think in '79 I was too preoccupied having and raising kids & working).

    Thanks for the post and thank you Brian Wilson.

  • Oh geez...so beautiful. Can barely take it.

  • quick andy close your ears before you explode from joy!

  • yes, this is so beautiful, still love this track after all these years! sometimes it brings tears to my eyes...

  • wonderful and priceless all those great Beach Boys tunes thanks for the great post

  • This is life's theme song. Words cannot describe how beautiful it is.

  • This is the best beach boys song in my opinion and given their backlog of songs that says a lot!!

  • I have a hard time disagreeing with you.  :-)

  • @MrTrashcan1 I totally agree. It's my all-time favorite, even though it's splitting hairs. They were in effect a barbershop style group set to rock n roll music. They're tight harmonies just can't be beat!

  • beautiful treasure. is this a Brian composition?

  • Yes, with brother Carl.

  • This song unfortunately is omitted from most of the Beachboys greatest hits compilations on CD.

  • It's included on their 2000 Best of The Brother Years collection.

  • one of my favorites

  • A divine melody.

  • Thanks for uploading, I havn't heard this song in about 10 years!

  • Great song and nice video!

  • Thank you!

  • thanks man! I first heard this on the Good Vibrations box set. the harmonic blend is flawless on this track

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more