Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,231)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • rachel already was a vegatarian in episode theatrically rememner when jesse throw those eggs on her?

  • the thing with these kinds of shows is that in the first season it's not popular so they don't have a big budget to autotune and prerecord and lip sync. and then when they get more money it seems like they autotune and don't sing anymore when taping; they just prerecord and slap the audio on top.

  • Comment removed

  • I just saw it in late, late Australia. It wasn't that bad! The christmas special was corny but it was intentionally so! It was fantastic when Klaine danced and sang together.

    As with most Glee it needs rewatching on dvd to remember all the little bits and better performances.

  • 2:03 "and there is neil diamond her self" hahahahahahahahahah!

  • And I enjoyed Brittany's Christmas song even though I can't remember what it was.

  • I re-watched the Christmas episode and just laughed my ass off at Lea Michele's on purpose over-acting. It was perfect.

  • You know the weird thing is Jews don't eat pigs.  Not trying to be offensive

  • I just loved Blaine's reaction to "young Burt Reynolds". He looked sincerely flattered and it cracked me up!

  • #BesidesFinn ;D

  • the only part i liked was my favorite things and let it snow with kurt and blaine untiil the song was over then everything else was cliched and nonexistent. WORST EPISODE EVER IT WAS SOO BORING. i had recorded it because i had a choir concert that night and i SKIPPED THOUGH MOST OF IT BECAUSE IT WAS SO PREDICTABLE!!!

  • actually it was said many times before that Rachel is a vega ;) (for example in The First Time)

  • The last okay glee show. It's boring now. I mean, do some rock!

  • I like GLEE but he has a point.

  • the only good scene to me was when mercedes started sing all i want for christimas. to me she was better than mariah.

  • @TristanShout1 it isnt. its a winter song

  • As much as I love Kurt and Blaine....This may quite possibly be the worst episode of glee ever! (Next to the New York episode)

  • It was boring. Just... boring.

  • It was horrible. Like painful horrible.

  • My cousins were extras in the homeless shelter scene. -3 it So cute to watch my uncle play that over and over again just to see their faces on tv briefly -3

  • as both a special and episode, i was offended to think the writers thought i would watch that poo and consider it to be cute and entertaining. twilight zone random anyone? lol

  • They were all imitating the old-school actors- Rachel was Judy Garland, Kurt was Lucy...

  • Ya I was sooo confused as to why Rachel and Puck were participating in the Christmas special if they're Jewish.

  • "i'm equally enjoying it yet tortured by it" hahaha soooo true!

  • *meat

  • Rachel has been vegan since season 1, they stated she was in the episode Funk she has only eaten meet in The First Time when Finn gave it to her and she thought it was substitue meet.

  • what about where artie makes kurt and blaine 'holiday roommates'? seriously? and where was sugar? Yes rachel and puck are jewish..thank you! And the lack of 'Santa Baby' and a brittana kiss. #worst episode ever...well, almost, first time is still my most hated Faberryftw.

  • I think you precisely hit the mark on this one, Buck. I fully agree. I did think they certainly got the flavor of the old Christmas specials pretty spot on though. I loved the way Chris played host. Haha! Other than that, yeah, not much value or content as a Glee episode.

  • lol, Brittany's face at 4:43

  • I knew she and Puck was Jewish and I barely watch Glee.

  • Comment removed

  • yes she is jewish, which is why she says happy hanukkah at the end

  • Do people realise that Do they know it's Christmas is a really depressing song? Why was everyone so happy and smiling whilst singing about people who have nothing?

  • I literally saw one episode, and even I knew Puck and Rachel were jewish. It was only mentioned a thousand times when Rachel wanted a nose job.

  • Rachel was a vegan for a while... there was that joke about Finn preparing the best artificial meat she's ever eaten, implying that he forgot she was vegan and cooked her real meat.

  • I used to love Artie, especially in last year's christmas special where he was super sweet, but this season he has become so bitchy

  • When did "My Favorite Things" become a Christmas song?

  • "all i want for Christmas is you.. and 5 things on that list"

    "Holy Crap im dating Kim Kardashian"

  • My favorite line was when Sue was all like, "Wheels, Porcelain, Other Gay..."

  • Isn't it bad enough that Mercedes and Kurt aren't even GBFF's anymore? Isn't bad enough that Rachel's hair in the first number of the episode looked like Princess Lea / Messy Bun? Isn't it bad enough that the Glee club constantly contradicts itself (no budget? Let's get tons of Xmas decorations in a public school. Also, let's AuTo-tuNE our VOiCes) Then AUTO-TUNE EVERYTHING? Ryan Murphy, how you disappoint me. I miss Glee season 1 where every time you heard a Glee cover that it was UNIQUE.

  • @JennifersXBody mmmmm which song is autotune????

  • Rachel's always been vegan...

  • Let It Snow was my favourite because it was Darren Criss! ....and Chris Colfer, he's pretty awesome too!

  • Wait, didn't Artie say that their Christmas special on PBS got cancelled because they managed to convince their previous performers to do the show?

  • This is why I have stopped watching glee, and just get the CDs. The music is usually good, but I can't stand how they change characters and major plot points from one episode to another. But you're always great Buck :)

  • i dont watch glee, but this is funny!!!

  • They've mentioned since the beginning that Rachel's a vegan, though she was seen eating a pizza with meat on it when with Finn... continuity in Glee? What's that?

  • all i knew was that Matthew Morrisson directed the christmas episode. hmmm

  • ugh i didn't wanna admit because i love glee so much, but after watching this, i've come to realization that you're so right.. the music was good, but that was about it.

  • My favorite scene? When Rory (Damien) asks Sam to be his "Valentine's Sponsor" :D

  • @TheTeresa24 In The Rhodes Not Taken (1x05) when she went bowling with Finn.

  • In season one, probably in the egging episode, they mention that Rachel is a vegan, and I believe that Lea Michele said in her interview with Jay Leno that she was a vegetarian.

  • It was soooo cheesy it was the oddest episode yet :) didnt understand why they sung favourite things :/ did you notice how at the end they slipped in rachel saying happy

  • I thought it was AWFUL. Was glad to be watching it on Hulu so I could fast forward over the awfulness of awfulosity of almost the entire episode. GAG!

  • "feed the world, let them know its christmastime again" are the lyrics

  • YEAH. All I could think of when Rachel was asking Finn for a ridiculous amount of presents was "Wait, isn't she Jewish???" I think Glee missed out on a huuuuge opportunity to make an episode that embraced all religions this season.

  • Was NOT expecting you to reference Scotty in this. BAHAHAHAHA

  • youre a waste of human resources...fucking vblogger

  • THE BOX SCENE THOUGH. -:(

  • @THEgirlONfiire same

  • did u see santanas song 'santa baby' that was deleted from that episode. I think that wouldve made it alot better

  • <3 Darren Criss <3 AVPM/S anyone?

  • I think Rachel should have sung Barbra Streisand's version of Jingle Bells.

    And she did eat meat once! The episode when Finn made dinner she was like this is the best tasting meat substitute I've ever had! and Finn is like right cause it's not real meat...cause you're a vegan...and I should know that...

  • They've mentioned that Rachel's a vegan plenty of times

  • Buck, you shouted SHAZAM and I just about died. I was in that show when I was nine and it changed my life. Major soft spot for Herdman children. : )

  • :'3 Kurt and Blaine= Cutest glee couple ever

    In my opinion o. o

  • What the Buck? I'm sorry but your overly obnoxious.

  • Rachel's Jewish because her biological mother is Jewish on the show. You've got to remember her character's been raised by two gay men. She never says she celebrates Hanukkah or the Jewish faith. I know a lot of Jewish people who celebrates both.

  • rachel was so annoying! can't wait til she graduates!

  • i love that song too! and it's "feed the world" :D

  • They threw in Rachel wishing "Happy Hanuka" at the very very end.

  • Hated it the first time but then I rewatched it and it made me happy and put me in the spirit. Lol.

    Oh and the last line of the show was Rachel saying "Happy Hanukkah" while ringing that bell. Lol. They just kinda threw that in there.

  • Rachel's been vegan since season one. They mention it when the Vocal Adrenaline kids egg her. :-) And I was so pissed that it took them the entire freaking episode for either of the Jewish kids to mention Hanukkah!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I was forced to watch it with my best friend and i was practically begging her to turn it off. It was horrible and superficial and they just look like a bunch of super spoiled little high school bitches. Just like the rest of Americas youth. Totally hated it and will never have anything to do with glee again.

  • Blaine was my favorite part :D

  • I like to think I have my own opinions.

    But then I watch WTB and I suddenly know exactly what to like and why to like it.

    #Impressionable

  • haha it was kinda weird... idkk it was just.... LEA SO FARTY!

  • Throughout the WHOLE episode, I was saying "Isn't Rachel Jewish?"

  • This episode confused me with the whole "isn't rachel jewish" thing. Jewish people don't ask for presents for christmas. Maybe for Hanukkah, but she gave him a CHRISTMAS list. so... nice continuity, Glee writers.

  • go Glee! Season one Rachel came back! She is at her best when she is all fame obsessed and psychotic. poor Finn, but go Rachel!

  • @gennyphuur fuuuucccckkkk you. Hard. His name is Blaine Anderson. And he did not ruin glee. RIB ruined glee.

  • Rachel said happy hannikah to someone in the end :D so she did embrace her Jewish heritage :D. :D :D

  • I loved it, and totally would have watched a whole hour of the black and white stars wars special with Kurt and his holiday roommate blaine

  • The whole thing was torture, I didn't enjoy a single moment of it. Disappointing, but kind of predictable at this point with Glee.

  • I was also equally enjoying it and tortured by it.

    Love the Best Christmas Pageant ever reference.

  • Last year's glee Christmas special was way better than this year's.

  • I don't get how people don't know she and Puck are Jewish, they only say it a million times in season two.

  • I love how every single photo you have has at least one person making a wierd face! Oh and yes Rachel and Puck are Jewish, but they apparently enoy christmas music a little too much!

  • RYan Murphy needs too remember his story lines form the 1st nd 2nd season

  • She was originally a Vegetarian Buck :)

  • yes, Rachel Berry is Jewish! I don't think most people know this, but Puck is too! :)

  • @metoolawson i dont know how people wouldnt know puck is,almost every time rachel talks to puck she mentions being jewish XD

  • maybe it's just me who thinks this, but isn't rachel berry ALWAYS annoying? she's always that self centered in every episode.

  • The glee christmas episode ROCKED! A++! I can't get the song My Favorite Things out of my head! Love ya buck!

  • You're description of how you felt during the Special was SPOT ON. Equally enjoying and tortured at the same time. HA!

  • is he gay =(

  • @2010Nodari yeapp

  • @2010Nodari Yes, he mentions it like every five seconds.

  • Blaine's hair was EURGH. Too much gel. Worse than Ross Geller.

  • Boy, Buck~ now I feel so stupid for having liked it so much... Thx.

    ps I luv bunnies.

  • My favourite line was when Kurt said 'And then I said to Justin Timberlake 'That's not eggnog!'' #yaycumjokes

  • In the episode of finchel's first date Rachel eats a peperoni pizza :) so much for vegan!

  • i don't know if anyone wrote this but in that Christmas song, they are saying "feed the world"

  • @WHATTHEBUCKSHOW Did you notice that the part near the end where (whatshisface the Irish kid) says "Lights please" and reads the Christmas story is an homage to the Charlie Brown Christmas?

  • 'A creepy faceoff!' I DIED LAUGHING OMG THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT IT WAS!

  • I really liked the song Brittany sang.

  • "Damian who has not spoke since the first episode".- Hahahahaha I've been thinking the same. Best Line.

  • favorite line: oh my god im dating Kim Kardashian!

  • I would absolutely LOVE it if you did an SNL recap each week. I love when you recap shows/movies, and your SNL character impressions make me smile like no other. I think it would be really fun. Think about it :)

    Happy Holidays!

  • I loved the episode completely

  • You pretty much described my feelings of the episode exactly, except for once I think you actually liked it better than me.

  • Favorite line? So I told JT, that's not eggnog"-Kurt O_O

  • No Klaine gift scene was such a disappointment! :( 

  • well everyone on T.V. are jewish

  • This basically sums up how I felt about the show! So very conflicted!

  • I actually fell asleep on this Christmas special. =\ I'm sorry, I thought it sucked (Glee).

  • WHERE THE FUCK WAS SUGAR MOTTA?!!?.........

  • YOU QUOTED "The Best Christmas Pageant Ever!" (I was in that play a few years back!) - PS I'm Jewish :)

  • In an early episode in season 1 when Finn and Rachel are at a bowling alley (possibly "The Rhodes Not Taken"?), Rachel is eating pepperoni pizza. I know this because I recently watched it, haha. So... the veganism thing was sometime after that...

  • Yeah i loved it as a Christmas special, but not as a GLEE episode. I even gave a copy of it to a friend who hasn't even watched season 3 and told them to just view it as a Christmas special, which it is.

  • I liked the Santa Baby performance .. wait, the editors cut it off -.-

  • What does your shirt say!!!!?????

  • Comment removed

  • Two major previous references to Rachel being a vegan: Season one when Jesse and other Vocal Adrenalists egg her in the parking lot. Girl says "Aren't you a vegan?" and something about how all the baby chicks' souls are on her head or something. And then in season three, "The First Time," Finn makes her dinner with meat and she says "Wow this meat substitute tastes like the real thing!" and he's like "Right, because you're a vegan which I remembered because we've been dating for so long." Oops!

  • Damian finally got some lines!!! :D

  • finn was just too good of a boyfriend to rachel<3

    

  • "Feed the world" Buck

    

  • @KyleCapone I hope he's kidding that he didn't know that. I mean its a famous song for being in many ways... so inappropriate and self-congratulatory. "Hey you starving people, we are singing about how awesome we are for feeding you!" :lol

  • The black and white thing was the only part I really liked. :)

  • I like the Sam and Rory scenes #ishipit

  • #BESIDESFINN HAHAHAHA

  • The whole motherfucking time, I was sitting there like, "For fuck's sake, Rachel is fucking JEWISHHHHHHHHHHH."

  • i think in the script, ryan murphy tells lea sofarty to make ugly faces.

  • GLEE IS BRILLIANT NO MATTER WHAT, THIS EPISODE WAS VERY CHRISTMASSY, AND FUNNY ---- YOU ARE A VERY ANNOYING TWAT, YOUR VOICE IS CAUSING MY EARS TO ALMOST BLEED, RU GAY? PROBABLY, "DRAMA QUEER", GO AWAY AND READ BOOKS TO THE ANTS ON THE STREET, OR DEAF PEOPLE!!!

  • @gmcboo71 wow. you're a fucking idiot oh my god

  • "She'd be better than Katy Perry" YES

  • "Feed the World" are the lyrics to the Band Aid song...

  • this is my best friend and holiday roommate :)

  • GAY!

  • Let it Snow was supermegafoxyawesomehot ;)

  • check out the episode where finn and rachel are in the bowling alley, she eats pepperoni pizza :)

  • The first time I think they said that Rachel is a vegan was the episode when Vocal Adrenaline throws eggs at Rachel, and then one of them says "i hear you're a vegan, now all the spirits of those dead chicks is on you" or something like that.

  • Always enjoy your shows but I have a quick question for you about your questions - who is Rachel Berry? Someone on TV or movies? I haven't watched prime TV since Survivor and shows like it started several years ago.

  • Again, the Glee jokes are getting old. If you don't like the show, or well, can't find anything good about it, stop watching it. Go back and watch the show, they talk about where they get the money for the decor and Rachel says "Happy Hanukkah" at the end. Yeah, they should have made it more apparent, but the ep. was still fun. It's funny that you point out the jokes of the show and are offended by them, yet you bully by making fun of Lea's last name. Hmm...

  • I absolutley loved this years Christmas episode! With Glee though, here lately I can't tell what I love and what I hate, so I just so I love it all!

  • rachels been a vegan all the time :') when vocal adrenaline threw eggs at her, it was mentioned then :p

  • Finn's Christmas sweaters > anything

  • We need a Buck Christmas special....show glee what they did wrong!

  • It was the worst episode ever...gahh!

  • Totally Agree! Glee is going down the drain...............

  • personally i agree because they had time to show the 3 present scene for rachel and finn but they couldn't give kurt and blaine 2 mins to show his present NOPE they have to show it in the dvd pack. and now we don't know what itis but doo to myresearch itis a promise ring madeoutof gumwrappers

  • FAGGOT

  • it was terrible!!!

  • Glee is shit

  • HAHAHAHA PRESSS 4 OVER AND OVER AGAIN!!!

  • I loved mersadies song, amazing :D 

  • @LIAMODEARME mercedes like the car not " mersadies "

  • For people who are saying Glee has a plot: No, just no.

  • And 95% of the Glee audience says, "Wah? Who's Burt Reynolds?"

    Spent all the money on Blane's hair gel, lol.

  • um i loved this episode!

  • I LOVED THE EPISODE hhaha :P

  • IT BLEWWW LIKE THE WIND ON A MOUNTAINNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!ahhh gleeeeee fail:P

  • I think that it was good! (-: I really LOVED the start when Mercedes started singing!

  • Actually, Rachel has been a vegan since the very first season. That's why they made such a big deal about her getting pelted with eggs. But other than that side note, I enjoyed Glee this episode. I feel like it was meant to be cheesy and some things sucked, but that's television for ya.

  • FEED THE WORLD BUCK, FEED THE WORLD!

  • GLEE CHEESY ? This video very good.  Watch mine.