Added: 4 years ago
From: garysevern
Views: 662,409
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (527)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • hayley williams has a good voice,but not sure about the passion that natalie merchant displays. she is pretty spectacular. it's moody, melodramatic, and soulful like no other.

  • Can barely hear it , but great song.

  • beautiful.....

    

  • There is only one "Natalie", such a beautiful voice and emotional delivery.

  • This song really touches my heart. it reminds me of good time when we lived in LA. A very good friend of ours spent nights singing to us & this is one of the songs that i used to make her sing over & over again. we love you Sarah you are always in our hearts. I really do miss the sound of your voice. Be sure to have an Enchanting Christmas with your amazing Husband & your beautiful baby boy :)

  • I stand corrected! Thanks to everyone who spoke of Sara Bareilles, her music is beautiful.

  • I should have been clear! RECENT artists. you named me 100 artists that I agree with you that they were good. Sarah mcLachlin, the Sundays, Even the Go, Go's. My point was to tell me who in the year 2012 still has that emotion All your bands/singers are great, but many from earlier or the same time.

  • ALL those names are about 1/1000th of the incredible female names on a mainstreem level ALONE, i left out thousands. And I Have not even Included Famale artists on an underground level. Legendary cult classics like Kristin Hersh ("your ghost"), and less known like Alana Stewart, Suzanne Vega, Since the beggining of man, there have been MILLIONS of female artists with creativity and soul. Not two. famales are at least half of humanity! sorry, but that comment just stressed my OCD out to MAX

  • just amazing...

  • How can so much beauty exist? How can so much emotion come out of a human being? Breathtaking.

  • so glad i got to see them in 93 just before they broke up.

  • Phew! That was beautiful.

  • GORGEOUS!

  • Happy Birthday Natalie. Throughout my life, I have had so many incredible events happen on October 26th. Some sad, and some very happy. It was a real surprise to find you were born on this day. Thanks for all your happiness you give to the world with your music.

  • Happy Birthday Natalie (Wednesday 26th) The Joy you have brought is endless too all who hear, don't stop performing can't wait for your next visit to England.

  • The Voice is the most beautiful instrument....

  • i concurr

  • i want to listen to a voice when i'm walking in the woods that needs no visual and this is what natalie brings me. total peace and a kind voice.

  • she is in the same class as carrol king.i would love to see theme tour together.natalie's voice is soooooo nice.

  • Natalie Merchant is magnificant !

    I can't say the same about Jonathon Ross though.

  • Comment removed

  • Love this song. This second only to Noah's Dove, which is my favorite Maniacs song.

  • @absolutsf Ahh noah's Dove... such a beautiful, yet forgotten song, my favorite also!

  • I know it was a while ago,, but what an arse Jonathan Ross makes of the introduction to such a sweet, soulful and intelligent song.Gotta love Natalie.

  • I appreciate that, too! You may want to see my music. Search for Kaia Fowler singer-songwriter using Google or other search engine.

  • Great music from 10,000 Maniacs. Always soothes me and makes me see the world better for more than 20 years now.

  • She sounds like my singer-songwrier friend Tara Leigh Cobble. I heard one of them on the radio, wasn't sure who. It was probably Natalie though, the more I think about it.

  • just beautiful! :)

  • que payasa piensa que va llegar lejos cantando estupideces

    no la conoce ni su abuelita me retiro de este misero videoo jajajajaj

  • @XxMissdarkfordxX Jajajja no la conoceras tu porque de seguro tu concepto de grandes cantantes se debe de limitar a Justin Bieber y Lady Gaga. Natalie fundo 10000 maniac y fue mu popular a finales de los 80 y principios de los 90, tiene junto a la banda un Unplugged que es genial y luego fue solista.

  • With the exception of Adele, show me a female artist with passion and I'll show you a girl/women without a deal! So sad!

  • @zemog311 Sara Bareilles

  • @zemog311

    In answer to your question >> Sarah Bareilles

  • @zemog311

    Check out " Sara Bareilles - Gravity (Stripped: Raw & Real) " on You Tube and then rethink your comment.

  • @zemog311 Recent, i can't say but hey some good female artists are still around including Natalie, PJ Harvey and Tori Amos :)

  • @zemog311 Tori Amos ("cruicify (live)"/"me and a gun") Bjork ("joga", "unraval", and all the string/quartet versions of her songs from her family tree album prove her to be a musical genious) Stevie Nicks, Heart, Fionna Apple ("never is a Promise"), Sara Bareilles("gravity"), The lead singer of The crannberries, Amy Lee of evanescence(any of their songs), The Gathering ("broken glass piano version" and "saturnine"), Tracy Chapmen, Bonnie tyler, Grace potter ("Cortez the killer), Alicia keys

  • @zemog311 Janis Joplin, Mama Cass Elliot, Joni Mitchill, Mary from Peter paul and mary (these were some of the first infependent femail musicians), Cristina Agulara/Avril lavigne when they are not filthy sellout sluts ("I'm ok" and "hurt"/"slipped away"), Cristina Perri ("the lonely", "jar of hearts"), dido, dixie chicks, etta james, Flyleaf ("cassie acoustic"), frou frou ("let go"), Mary J. Blige ("destiny"), Mazzy star ("fade into you"), Nelly Furtado ("all good things", "like a bird")

  • @zemog311 Noisettes ("never forget you"), Pat Benatar, Regina Specktor ("us", "sampson, songs version", "laughing with", "blue lips", "et", "laughing with" and all of her "far" album), sade, Sarah McLachlan ("angle", "fallen"), Patti smith, Roberta Flack, Anna nalick (breath), Portishead, Florance and the machine ("shake it out", plus their new album), The Mamas and the PApas, Feist, Within temptation, No Dbout, The civil wars, Laura marling, KT tunstall, Lyran hill,

  • Exactly. Just a great voice, and well written songs were all you needed not that long ago. Thank You MTV. Thank you for relegating talented musicians to coffee houses and bars while talentless hack with "the look" buy gold plated bidets.

  • Revisted. Natalie HAD an amazing voice.I guess that nothing lasts.

    ego is a bitch. gets you to the impossible to reach, scary cliff, but

    your ego always encourages you to jump off.

    the "sorry about that" was a not directed to Natalie, but to her ego that

    almost took over the whole room.

    I have the privilage to hear an amazing voice on sundays - I do not

    know why a lady in her 60's still has an amazing voice. Why does a woman embrace and share her gift, yet Natalie feels animosity towards us?

  • Natalie's best song.

  • @fletcherarc

    I agree, it's always been my favorite, I was completely obsessed with this song when it came out...imagining the man, imagining the girl listening...

  • Can someone please edit this video to take out the Joker who hosts this show. He is like the court Jester before the queen.

  • Too beautiful :)

  • the two above need to get together, with strings like that there has to be violens

  • I just saw Natalie perform in her hometown of Jamestown, NY with the Chautauqua Orchestra and in middle of the concert she sang this song !!!!!!! AMAZING !!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • we've been taken over by the senseless MTV crowd.

  • @327409427 ironically this was the music that inspired mtv and 'like the weather' was one of my favorite early videos, it epitomizes early mtv for me. hard to believe it was actually an alternative channel initially

  • ...an all-time favorite. She is such a storyteller. Her songs are an experience.

  • This is arguably the best song from her/their best album. I loved it at the time and that hasn't changed ...

  • @StephenPring I know wasn't it a great Album? I loved it as well!

  • this is honest art

  • I get chill from the beauty of her voice and lyrics pure crisp ever since 10000 manics her voice was the fuel behind the grops success

  • I get chill from the beauty of her voice and lyrics pure crisp

  • I get chill from the beauty of her voice and lyrics pure crisp

  • I love her music and I love this song. My favorite song by her is Motherland, truly one of the most beautiful songs ever written. Just a little observance from a fellow musician, in this video natalie hits a wrong note towards the end at around 4:19-4:21. If you listen and watch close you can see her look at the orchestra right when she hits the last note of the song..about 4:34, and she kind of giggles, says "oops" knowing she hit the wrong note. It may sound odd, but I think that is classy

  • Sings well and knows how to play an instrument. She is a true artist with talent unlike most of the crappy artists of today who are only famous because they look pretty in front of a camera.

  • This is metal, and I mean that in the most honest way possible.

  • 200 years from now artists like this will still be argued about on places like this, a sure sign they're good. NM is very good.

  • Can we just enjoy this performance without putting down other artists? That would be very nice.

  • absolutely gorgeous woman and music

  • One of the many times I saw Natalie solo, someone from the crowd yelled out "Verdi Cries" to which Natalie said something to the effect of "let me see if I can remember that one." Obviously not a part of her set, she sang it for the crowd and it was every bit as awesome as this clip!

  • beautiful!

  • Comment removed

  • comparing gag a to Natalie is like comparing a pork chop to Mother Mary..

  • @teec19 If I could marry this comment I would. You fully just made my week.

    I'll be listening to Natalie Merchant 'til the day I die.

  • This song transports me every time I hear it. So vivid and beautiful. No wasted words or notes. Just lovely.

  • totalmente de acuerdo con ellos ......que tiempos que musica

    saludos dese Torreon ,Mexico

  • totalmente de acuerdo con ellos ......que tiempos  que musica

  • I cry every time i hear this

  • Fantestic!

  • just discovering Natalie, for myself. She is fantastic. I love the way she sings and dances. There is a sincerity in her music, that's kind of rare these days. She completely, totally, absolutely rocks.

  • she has the voice of a angel.

  • Oh Mr. TV show man, could you speak just a little more cockneyed and faster? I don't want to understand you JUST enough.

  • @macksf98 yOU´RE COMPLETELY RIGHT, BUT IT´S ALSO GOOD BECUASE GRAMMYS ARE DESTROYING INDEPENDENT MUSIC BY MAKING THEM STARS. NATALIE DOESNT NEED GRAMMYS TO SHOW HOW TALENTED SHE IS

  • would hum this to my baby nearly 21 yrs ago!miss it!

  • I get chills when Natalie sings the word Aida at 3:04. I gotta go see Aida.

  • I can't stop watching her.......................

  • Thumbs up 5 stars. Love Barbara

  • verdi cries...verdict rise?

  • Soo good, soo beautiful! I smile, I cry!

  • this is the song that made me totally fall in love with this band

  • i was at that same show in Nasville. I miss music like this.

  • Very talented in such a soothing way.

  • Watching the Grammys and the whole zygote egg bit with Lady Gaga, I thought, "Where is Natalie Merchant when we need her most?"

  • @barques95 U are soooo right!

  • @barques95 U are soooo right!

  • @barques95 Excellent comment! So Underrated....She;s Fabulous x

  • @barques95 seriously

  • I miss the days when great singers told stories set to music. No sex, violence or vulgarity.....just impecable music that took you to a place you could feel through the artist.

  • @barrywroteit You mean back when there was some talent.

  • @barrywroteit they are still there jack johnson for example.

  • @barrywroteit Please. There were plenty of hacks at the top of the charts in the early 90s, selling sex and violence. We just remember people like Natalie because they brought more to the table. I'm sure in the early 90s you were complaining about shitty artists as well.

  • @MrGsullivan Oh yes, there was bad music in those days. The biggest difference is the percentage. I wont even listen to the radio anymore because of the void of talent and taste. The 90's music was bearable because the majority was worth bearing the bad. Miley Cyrus, Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, the Black Eyed Peas and so on and so on....it never seems to end.

  • @barrywroteit amen i love the days of the song that told a story. Kate bush. carole king. etc

    

  • the most perfect song in the world

  • Heck yeah!!!

  • shivers..... wow, this is beautiful..... natalie is beautiful beyond words. thanks for sharing this.

  • it's from 2:54 to 3:05 .... can't stop replaying

  • Comment removed

  • Actually I'd love to hear her do a version of Freebird, I imagine it would be amazing!

  • Takes me back to college in Charleston, SC in the late 80's...I used to listen to this song sitting on a bridge watching the sunset over the Wapoo Cut. Aaahhh...

  • reminds me of the years i spent at chautauqua new york

  • I wish I had a time machine.......................­.................. I was oblivious to 10k maniacs back then.... I want to go back and watch all these shows and buy all their albums on day of release... why wasn't I paying attention to them ? What was I so engrossed in??? I feel like I missed out on a great moment in music history......

  • great voice great song good sensations

  • Even Funnier: Michigan 1989 she hits the first chord on Piano and the crowd just literally goes crazy. Natalie stops the song and ask the audience to be quiet. For the next three - four minutes you could here a pin drop. I miss those days and I miss that moment!

  • damn hot lips on her :)))

  • Damn shame I never heard of her before this year, I believe in all music but stuff like this needs to be heard more :(

  • im naming my daughter natalie (merchant) & (maines) 2 of the most meaningful voices ive heard while on this earth

  • Does anybody know when is she comming to U.K next?

  • This is a beautiful song sung by a beautiful woman

  • Brilliant, such talent. I tear up listening to this

  • Who is Verdi

  • @MultiKswift A very fortunate man, to have Natalie sing of him. Her voice cuts through my soul, oh, so good...

  • @MultiKswift Guiseppe Verdi

  • @MultiKswift and Aida is one of his masterpeace

  • Comment removed

  • So their minds are soft and mushy -- YUM -- give zombies what they want.

  • ha Jonathan Ross definitely talked a lot faster back in the days..lol.

  • this is a true gem. pure honest talent! can not hear it enough.

  • this is one of those songs that makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up... in a good way. I miss the original 10,000 Maniacs.

    very rarely does that happen, Ella Fitzgerald singing Miss Otis Regrets does that as well.

  • I love the way Natalie smiles, almost apologetically, for doing a great job on the piano. It's not her natural instrument.

  • Her voice was so pure back then. I'd forgotten it had that temper to it....

  • The only female singer that could carry on for the great Sandy Denny.

  • @beefoneeto Perhaps no coincidence that I had exactly the same thought when I started to hear this track.

    June Tabor does a superb (though different ) version of this song too.

  • Simply beautiful.

  • I was never a 10,000 Maniacs fan, but perhaps I should've been.

  • Goodness me Natalie, this is great. I love the album this is from 'In my tribe' One day I decided to skip school, ride 20km to the record store and I bought the album for 7 bucks in 1990 on vinyl and then rode 20km home, bent it slightly on the journey home, but still have it 20 years later! I love it, so great!! I love 'Our time in Eden' the best out of all the 10,000 maniacs music though. Love you Natalie.

  • @simonlusco wonderful story!

  • ok, fellow 10,000 Maniacs/Natalie Merchant fans, I just realized after 23 years that the humming in Verdi Cries could be from a Verdi opera. Can someone tell me if it is and what part? Would be fitting if it were from Aida, I suppose. An unspeakably beautiful song from a flawless album.

  • LOL @ how young jonathon ross is! omg.

  • thank you for being the channel.

  • so beautiful...love her

    

  • Natalie has surely been sent from up above,so angelic. All her songs take me to another place whether im reduced to tears or just totally calm from within.Thank-You Natalie for sharing your gift with all of us.

  • Her voice gives me goose bumps every time. :)

  • All this praise for natalie just makes her more reclusive then she was before. Truth be known, she's a leftist liberal who supports barack obama (are you fucking kiddding me?) NO! actually she's my favorite female singer, I love her vocals and her writing's, i just dont care for her leftist political veiws..... peace out. Have a nice day :)

  • @kieleed48, Well if you do not care for her political views, why do you even bring them up? This video is about Natalie singing a beautifull song. Not about you slamming people with a particular political point of view.

  • @kieleed48 and I'm sure a lot of people feel the same about your views. was there any point to this? xD

  • This song give me chills it's so good. One of the very few artists who can move me to tears.

  • Jonathan Ross is like the court Jester before the Queen. His lack of respect makes him look foolish. I love this song, and Natalie is so incredibly talented.

  • música adorável de se ouvir....

    quanta sensibilidade ela tem....

    demais mesmo !!!

  • This is the most beautiful song I have ever heard!

  • good lord, is this lady an angel?

  • She is a godess of song - Not much more to say :)

  • I cannot think of a human being more attractive than Natalie.

    Her voice is unbelievably sweet and beautiful.

    Add that to her persona and you have a once in a lifetime superstar.

  • SO BEAUTIFUL!

  • Och ..I could watch her all night , and her voice is as sweet as ever ..But...its not the same without 10000 Maniacs buzzing around behind her . Mother the War, Death of Manolete and Katrinas Fair get my old arse bouncing every time i play them..this is not arse-bouncing enough for me. And I love her dearly.

  • Not for nothing but, Natalie is by far one of the greatest musicians of any modern time she has always stayed true to her music and created some great music throughout her career . She has never sold out . I love her and she should be recognized as one of the greatest musicians of all time!

  • oh my gawd....as beautiful as I remember this. Thanks so much for sharing this.

  • I've always loved this song....

  • So beautiful, she is my favorite.

  • this song is great!!

  • loooove it :)

  • Natalie,

    I have followed your beautiful music for many years.

    All i can say is thankyou, and i envy your husband.

  • Personally I think of Natalie Merchant as a storyteller. Her songs are so true to American History and Heritage. Her haunting voice and her way with words its beyond comprehension. Her inner beauty has no equal.

  • @wingedsniper ....I totally agree with you...always regarded her as a beautiful storyteller. The entire album of IN MY TRIBE is a perfect example. Verdi Cries is from that album...and I regard it as one of my all time personal favorites.

  • Amazing voice. This song is timeless. I can see people 100,200, 300 ... years from now listening to this song. And from the same singer Natalie merchant. She is truly blessed with a gift, She weilds her beautiful voice like a powerful sword.

  • Puts over hyped artists like brittany spears to shame.

  • @gardenchicks you said Brittany Spears and artist in the same sentence. You have to drink. Brittany is a media company fabrication. Mickey Mouse bares crotch, news at 11.

  • I want to punch Johnathon everytime I listen to this. I don't know what it is. He just really annoys me.

  • She has the voice of an angel.

  • Funny story: Nashville, TN, 1989 - 10K Maniacs playing at Perf Arts Center. Natalie sits down to begin this song. There's a momentary pause and some redneck yells out at the top of his lungs, "Freeeebirrrrd". Natalie is NOT amused, perhaps unaware that this outburst is a staple of concertgoers in the South. She regains her composure and gives an absolutely haunting rendition of the song. A moment I'll never forget.

  • @mattwilker Nice one!

  • @garysevern She does seem a touch humorless... she seems like the girl in college who would abandon the date if you ordered a steak...or would sit across from you and moralize a bit while you either ate it or gave up. None of which doesnt detracts from the beauty of her voice or the joy that listening to her songs gives me.

  • @yadkinable Hahaha! As much as I respect her as a composer and musician -- and presumably a decent person -- her lyrics seem preachy and slightly pretentious. Maybe profundity and beauty combined can't avoid pretense; I don't know. I also notice her fascination and exaltation of non-American art forms, as if America is too mundane and lowbrow for her. Lighten up, Natalie. Anyway, my wife and I love her music and she seems authentic and very nice. We saw her Monday night in Boston; great concert.

  • @59penrod Strange. As an European (an Italian, that is) I perceive Natalie as being deeply American. She seems to come out of a mix of Salinger novels, Bradbury short stories about the Depression, memories of a long-gone America which you can no longer visit. And in a way, she's modern, too. To me, "Gold rush brides" is (also) a celebration of the American spirit, if not of the American way.

  • @peterpuck365 Natalie is definitely a homegrown American phenomenon. I based my comments on some posts she wrote for a web site she maintained a couple of years ago in which she praised Japanese arts and some other foreign arts that I can't remember. Maybe my view was too narrow and based upon too little info. I do notice that many Americans seem to have an inferiority complex when comparing American culture to the rest of the world. In any case, Natalie is one of our national treasures.

  • @59penrod maybe it is you that has the inferiority complex about your culture? You seem petrified to acknowledge any worth in any cultur outside your own. What are you afraid of? Is your view of patriotism so rigid that no good can be recognised in any culture outside your own? It's kind of ironic given america is a melting pot with no real culture of its own but a wonderfully diverse hybrid of all the cultures that has formed your extraordinary country. Be proud not paranoid.

  • @peterpuck365 That is a great description, wow spot on!!!

  • @peterpuck365 I know exactly what you mean.  She'd fit right into to something like Capote's The Grass Harp.

  • @59penrod Yes--well said. I have always loved her music, but got the impression that she was too cool for school!