Added: 5 years ago
From: davidrlewis
Views: 1,477,007
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,669)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Good Cover but I love neil young's version

  • As a Canadian, I approve of this cover...big time! Oasis is the best!

  • liam's a hero on guitar.

  • What was after this? Any1 know..

  • @Mcfc2Rich Champagne Supernova

  • What a shitty version, Oasis is a good band but this cover sucks!

  • So pissed off because of a youtube comment

  • love neil, like oasis, hate this version.

  • I love Noels voice ;D but Liams is more of a dirty voice, messy and husky, i love that.

  • neil young is just supergreat!

  • vata faka GREEEJT!

  • el rOck no se puede mOrir nunka!!!!

  • I like turtles.

  • love oasis nd neil young thumbs up if u do 2

  • I really love this cover..

  • Simply great

  • Thank you Neil young

  • Great job. Love this song.

  • Why wont youtube let you change it if you hit the dislike button accidently. That has to be why oasis videos have dislikes.

  • Is linkin park a band fom chicago that doesnt know how to spell?

  • Neil Young in the crowd 2:20 !!

  • Comment removed

  • Rock and roll will never die.

  • Noel's power, as ever!

  • how does oasis have more views that neil young? he wrote the song!

  • @Norocmorth Because they took a great song and made it mind-blowing.

  • @AmpburnerUK ah idk they seem to just flood it with sound and the drummers not doing it right so i prefer the original imo

  • @Norocmorth I'm a big fan of Neil Young, but a massive fan of Oasis. To my ears, this is just perfect. I like the original too, but to me this just sounds so much better.

  • @Norocmorth because it doesn't :P niel young : 3,3mill, oasis : 1,4mill

  • A original com Neil Young na minha opinião ficou melhor

  • Hey hey Maaah maaaaaah

  • hmmm, dont like this version at all. pop at its best, no rock n roll in this.

  • Im pretty sure thats Gem...Liam is good for denying hangovers and suing people that says he is.

  • Ahhhhhhhh! They are butchering this great song!! Make it stop!!!

  • einfach nur geil!

  • @sislacs? i think he should play this with his new band? it's really cool

  • Comment removed

  • @gurudev91 yeah so our younger generations will slit their wrists and masturbate over transformers?

  • @gurudev91 shite talk gaylad

  • @gurudev91 So paying your respect to one of the greatest rockgods ever by playing one of his songs is 'stealing'? It would be theft if he said that he was the composer of the song, but he literally said that it Neil's song..

    You fucking moron. That's all I can say...

  • @V00D00CHILD100 I agreee although oasis used to be my favourite band when i was like 6, they can't do it like neil young, but who can, this is far from stealing noel young has an utmost respect for neil young, i met noel when i was a kid and i have a lot of respect for him even though his bro is a complete twat

  • @gurudev91 i'm part of that "generation" and noel inspires me more than shitty linkin park!

  • @gurudev91 linkin park fucking sucks and did you ever hear about covering? stupid idiot

  • @watwillwedonext LINKIN PARK DOES PROPER COVERS. CHESTER'S COVER OF WONDERWALL WAS BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL.

  • @gurudev91 the linkin park version of wonderwall was absolutely terrible, it was absolute bullshit.

  • aguante la version de LA RENGA

  • @ElChescoTumbero chupala Noel la rompe, Oasis live forebver lastima que la renga no jaja igual esta buena le version pero Noel es Noel y Gem es Gem no hay con que darle!!!

  • Liam plays the guitar *__________*

  • @extremestuntman95 you obviously haven't seen the video for songbird 

  • @extremestuntman95 well yeah he does, but he isn't in this video. that's gem archer.

  • @extremestuntman95 That's Gem. Liam plays the guitar in Songbird, kiddo.

  • rock 'n' roll will never die

  • Neil Young and Noel are the best musicians ever. I like Neils version better than this, but it's still cool

  • I like it but it doesn't compare2 Neil Young.His voice is all wrong,too melodic.

  • there's nothing conceptually better than rock n' roll

  • noel's voice is fucking perfect for this song, fucking powerful & rock n' roll!

  • @Garrybhon Yeah!

  • @Garrybhon your a fucking idiot if you think anything other than noels voice being too weak and bland for this song and every other fucking song he's ever written or covered !!!

  • 255 peoples should throw theirselfs away, as they dislike Neil Young & Oasis !

    Thumbs up if you agree!

  • Oasis is bigger than the Beatles!

  • @scott4152 Shut the fuck up. Of course not.

  • @scott4152 wat

  • Fucking brilliant !!!

  • 2,988 Are Amazing!

  • Noel gallagher can cover most songs and make them sound amazing.

  • 251 people must burn in hell.

  • Does noel play this song on his new tour? Anyone know?

  • @MegaTrainspotter no i was at his first gig and he didnt play it

  • one of their best cover

  • Comment removed

  • I definitely am one to side with Liam in the brother war but Noel actually makes me like this song, something Neil Young could not do.

  • the vocals are really good but i much prefare neil youngs acoustic version

  • Comment removed

  • whoever prefer this to the original song by young is an idiot with no rock culture...

  • @inokpati you are a fucking idiot

  • neil young

  • there should be a law against anyone covering neil young songs

  • @wissbyt agreed!

  • @wissbyt What was wrong with this cover?

  • @wissbyt If such thing exist, you wouldn't have heared this amazing cover

  • @wissbyt this is actually a really good cover. I love both versions.

  • @oneloveninja absolutely agree.. and just to complete the list.. i think he should also hear: Lyla, I'm outta time, Let there be love, Stop Crying your hear out, Little James, Who feels love, Songbird, Champagne Supernova, Live Forever, Supersonic, Wonderwall, Roll With Me, Cast No Shadow, She's electric , Acquiesce , Rockin' chair , the masterplan, Little by little, Rock'n'Roll Star, Don't go away, All around the world, Whatever. In fact, i think he should hear all Oasis songs.

  • i'm not a massive oasis fan, but i actually prefer this to the original. great version.

  • la rengaaaaa!

  • Neil Wrong..

  • theres more to the picture than meets the eye.........fucking right noel!!!

    NOEL IS THE SHIT!

  • oh shit i thought they'd rape this song but wow not bad.

  • just discovered this, why isnt it on the Familiar To Millions album? One of my favourite live albums and this song on it would have made it even more incredible. feels cheated.

  • @olliemad I have that album and its track 15, maybe you got a bad copy or its from a bonus edition or something.

  • @Thenowhereman42 hmm maybe man, how many songs on that album? mine ends 13 with rock n' roll

    star.

  • @olliemad Yeah mine has 18 tracks and rock n' roll is 17

  • @Thenowhereman42 ha sik, cheers mate gotta find myself the real version now 5 new songs, this shits gonna blow my mind! 2nd favourite live CD ever.

  • @olliemad I downloaded it from iTunes and it was on there. I'm assuming you bought the CD? Guess it wasn't included until the digital release.

  • Nothing can be compare to Noel's power!

  • Oasis write great songs but they are average musicians at best which is a lot more obvious when they play someone else's song

  • HE'S PLAYING A DUOJET?!

  • @scoundrel5555 it's not a duojet it's a 50's gibson les paul custom with p90s

  • wankers

    

  • im sick of this Kasabian ad, theyr a good band, but c'mon...OASIS!!!!!

  • Oasis and Neil Young=Best artists ever (together with Beatles)

  • @dannemannen18 and weller ;)

  • I would be interested in what neil young thinks of this great cover? i think he will approve.

  • mademancze u must be having a laugh mate

  • Nailed it!!

  • Noels fucking rocking roll voice, in this song

  • Y'know, it's no Neil, but this ain't half bad.

  • Great Version by a great band :)

  • He looks like a glorious statue :)

  • for me better version than Neil :)

  • @MaDemAncZe no way

  • This song is strong...

  • so powerful

  • absolutely impossible to write a bad comment about this! never and ever....i believe that 246 peeps till now probably had ear that didn't work! what's the problem with u guys? u maybe prefer a playback singer than a real band with energy? i'm warned about those kind of people.....for real! as Noel-Liam sad: shit's all!!

  • wow great performance

  • They do such a good job with this song. Oasis rocks!

  • Now go check Hey Hey My My by Battleme. So much better!!

  • @PaulD132 go in the toilet and lock yourself please!!!

  • Neil Young sounds like Archie Bunker's wife....no?

  • knowone heard of neil young till noel did this. keeping him relevant

  • @MrTrevormctrevor Are you seroius you spastic??????

  • @MrTrevormctrevor Excuse me?! Anyone with the slightest idea of Rock and Roll knows Neil Young.

    Stupid people dont, it is true...

  • @MrTrevormctrevor don't even need to respond to this comment because Noel says it all in this video youtube.com/watch?v=icrXg0wR8Q­8

  • He is just doing this as a tribute. He sure doesnt need to show off idiots

  • This is approximately 10 times better than the original but hey whatever floats your boat.

  • I like Oasis but this isn't that good at all! !

  • I like it.

  • pairc ui caoimh 1996 was ended with this...mind you the backstage party had only started to say the least, was there,...in body, ...mind was in nirvana.

  • I can appreciate this version, but I still prefer the original. Must say, the guy has a god voice. I think if these guys did an acoustic version, it would probably rival Neil's. I'm not going to say this sucks because it isn't Neil, because it doesn't suck. I find it difficult to compare this to the original.

  • @okalov yes if they did this acoustically, it might be better but there's something missing in this! Maybe it is recorded from a distance or something? I feel it is missing some passion! Not even close to the Original!

  • such a cruel version, this guys just cant sing, how come ???????????????

    such posers

    is that noel who sings ? why doesnt liam sing, could be better (?)

  • @beeblebrokkx

    TROLOLOLOLOLOLOL

  • @beeblebrokkx HOW OLD ARE U?

  • hey hey my my! rock and roll and oasis will never die!

  • Wow I AM Canadian, Neil Fan too the end . Started Listening to Oasis As unknowns over here in Canada 93-94, Very underated Oasis they are, very Beatles Inspired. Now I find Noel singing Hey Hey My My By Neil the man! YAAAAAAAA MANNNNNN

  • @LEAFSMAN Oasis suck, but did you just offend The Beatles?

  • @SwingStu Oasis suck?? Are you an idiot??

  • Absolutely amazing.. thanks for the post!

  • noels version trounces the original,and i bought the original,,i wonder if he could play it accousticaly though,,coz he is a bit of a musical genius with a buisness head on him

  • @friginnutz I'm going to fucking murder you. Neil is God. That's just the way it goes.

  • I can't believe how good Noel sounds on this...

  • this is how a mate of mine got into neil young.when i played him the original he still preferred the oasis version but after a while he was asking to borrow a few albums off me.we have seen neil young together twice now and both times were the gigs of our lives...

  • Of course, this is not as good as the original, but all i can say is that version is very respectfull and fucking englishly cool. And, for our sake, it's noel singin', not his brother !!!!

  • I wish I could move to the UK so I could buy his solo album earlier. :( It sucks living in America, we get the good music later and when we do it's destroyed by the rap shit. Oasis forever!

  • noel young ?? ))))))

  • @andrx04 young YEAAAAAAAAH HOLLYWOOD UNDEAD LOLZ!

  • @matheusgondin и что значит этот высер 7???

  • @andrx04

    neil young

  • @swingingfriend1999 выебнулся что ли ? мать твою !!! иди на хуй блядь !! я знаю как его зовут - мне не надо чтоб здесь всякие пидоры умничали !!! понял сука ?? ещё раз напишешь мне - я тебя в ноздри выебу 1!!!!!!

  • @swingingfriend1999  google translater : vyebnulsya what? your mother! Go to dick whore! I know his name - I do not want to here any fag clever! understand bitch? write me again - I'll fuck you in the nose one !!!!!!

  • @andrx04

    wtf???? why are you responded so seriously?? fuck you too, and btw your mom is a whore and your father was drunk when made you.

    you son of a bitc* , you are born accidentally

  • @swingingfriend1999 you did shit comment thats why ! никто не просил тебя соваться и писать хуйню 1!!!

  • @mellkor you are an idiot, listen to: i hope i think i know, falling down, slide away, some might say, d'you know what i mean, the shock of lightening, the importance of being idle, she is love, dont look back in anger, sunday morning call and gas panic. All these songs are fucking brilliant. Just because your ears are tuned for shiite music doesnt mean u have to hate on the artists that you obviously cant understand. Wait til october Noel Gallagher will blow your mind

  • @oneloveninja - I agree mate. Well, apart from She Is Love - which is shit ;-)

  • @Mubble No it's not...?

  • @oneloveninja Good post man.

  • Neil Young sings better(worse = better when were talking about him)

    But damn, this isnt half so bad.

  • i like that other sight of them .. singing that song made me like them even more.... :D

  • Good sound.

  • nice guitar, noel. never seen him playing one of those before.

  • @FretLegendSmithy It's like Neils guitar "Old Black" that he's had for years. Love Noel and Neil!

  • @colm147 early les paul custom's are just sexy. And yeah, they're both legends.

  • Where is your god now? Mine is in this page...

  • Looking forward to the Olympia Theatre, Dublin in October!

  • Amazing sound at that concert :)

  • Check out Neil Young performing the track at Phoenix Festival. This is good, but doesn't match that performance. Noel is still a legend though.

  • I fucking love Noel

  • Neil Gallagher

  • Fantastic!

  • I love Oasis and I love Niel Young!

  • This was a fucking great cover!

  • Nobody pwns Neil Young, kid.

  • Noel can pwn every other singers just by singing their songs

  • I'm a huge fan of Neil Young and a huge fan of Oasis. Noel and the boys did a great job. Rather surprised that they pulled it off so well, and I'm happy they did!