before america entered the war i heard that germany and austria and ottoman were winning and owned all the eastern europe? any truth to that? it sounds like it makes sense seeing as how russia surrendered and had revolution after?
@Smock24 I think so, though I'm not entirely sure. Certainly the Allies had lost on the Eastern Front, but I'm not sure how much territory was taken from Russia. I've seen a map before with huge amounts of land ceded to Germany, but I don't know whether that was just a plan or whether it actually happened for about a year before Germany's defeat.
@GordieMacumAndOther Wrong. They did, and it has been historically documented everywhere you look. YOUR facts are wrong! Don't you remember Napoleon storming across the Enlish countryside, and the Kaiser eating Christmas Dinner in Westminster?
@MervueMeringue the last battle fought on british soil was in the 1700s between scotish rebels and the british troops so how could napoleon invade in the early 1800s and germany invade in ww1 so plz get your facts right and i sould know being from england how does it fell knowing that a 12 year old knows more than u
@GordieMacumAndOther No it wasn't, it was the battle of Inverness in 1943, where the British army valiantly defeated the Nazi invaders. I should know, being from Scotland.
Also World war 1 started a bit wrong in this, an Serbian terrorist assasinated the Austrain Crown prince or something so Austria declared war to take "revenge" and it dragged in Russia, Germany etc
@XandarMax they were on germanys side at the beginning. they didn't go into the war, but they were on the side of the axis, and supported them. but after seeing that the axis will lose they changed their side, and went with the allies. idiot.
@XandarMax first, yes i know the germans/ Austrians weren't called 'axis'. i just couldn't remember their name. and second, my fucking school book, and history teacher ( who btw knows A LOT of history ) said that Italy supported germany and austro-hungary in the beginnig of the war. so stfu idiot.
@XandarMax Who the fuck do you think you are? First of all its HE, and HE has been teaching History for a very long time. And WOW. i mean your so mature and tough, when calling me a child and telling me to grow up. You didn't give me any facts. When My School book, My History Teacher, Wikipedia, ALL say that Italy was in the beginning on Germanys side. so just stfu.
@XandarMax lol what a fucking moron you are. i just gave you three sources which tell that Italy was on the same side with Germans and Austrians in the beginning. you have gave me ZERO. Why don't you give me ONE source that says Italy was on with UK and France FROM THE BEGINNING. Maybe then ( MAYBE ) i could somehow believe you. if you do not find any sources, than just don't bother you respond anymore. your fucking pathetic btw...
@FinMilkku@FinMilkku Come on the dude is right, i'm from italy and this is common knowledge here, italy was neutral in the beginning of war, even the german were pissed at the austrian behaviour, but they had their own imperial aims and joined the war with the austrians.
just read the wikipedia page on ww1 or this one from the italian wikipedia page that focus only on that year of neutrality
@johnpetrucci84 So your saying that My History teacher, History school book, and Wikipedia are lying? all of these say that Italy had a pact with Germany and Austria. but then Italy left the pact later and fought against them
@FinMilkku this is correct italy had a pact with germany and austria, from 1882 to 1914, but the nature of the pact was to defend each other from foreign aggressions, since austria declared war on serbia italy could easily break the alliance, the pact himself allowed this.
But the fact is that in this video there is a conquest of french territories by italy, wich is funny. The aggression of france by italy appened in ww2 and italy conquered only few km.
@FinMilkku ok but italy was already out of the alliance when the war began, more precisely at the moment of the ultimatum by austria italy quitted, and then started the war, so at beginning of the war was neutral, yes it's a matter of few days but italy was alrealdy out.
However think on this, at the time italy was a democracy, a Constitutional monarchy like UK, they would never support a war of aggression, the pact does not allow this, the people of italy were liberals and had symphathy for fre
@MervueMeringue The Allies divided Anatolia amongst themselves and left the Ottomans with a small piece of land around Ankara. Then the Ottomans changed from empire to republic and fought back and regained the land. Just pointing it out but overall still a great video.
@xistion I'll answer your complaints in reverse order: they're supposed to be, and I know, I hadn't researched it enough, I plan on making an updated video sometime.
@MervueMeringue ok. you said we could critizice this video because in this one you DID do research and thought it. IS THERE ANY VID I CAN CRITIZICE PLEASE!!
@1111hola Oops, sorry, I missed out 7. Yeah, same as 5. Were they? In History we didn't really cover much of the politics other than how it began and how it ended. Though I do know that Britain wouldn't have tried for peace either, but Germany's foreign policy was quite aggressive also, surely?
@MervueMeringue that actually was the Prussians, the Germans tried to soften them. but remember that during the stalemate in the western front Germany tried peace quite a few times, but Britain wouldnt accept it. anyways they were both very agressive.
1. No, that's an imaginary war. The Prussian war's in the previous part.
2. Yeah.......
3. Well. Nyeh.
4. It's no more confusing than the reality!
5. The eastern front is the one thing I regret about this video. I got it so wrong, and it annoys me so much.
6. Yep. Yep.
7. Well, being British, I'm a bit biased... (though I've noticed that Britain has been a bit too nice in my videos, so this will be rectified in a future one!).
2. I mean that the war in morocco was first fought between spain and m., then the second one s.&m. once again and the THIRD one was between morocco, france and spain... so its kinda messed up.
@1111hola Ooh, I forgot to respond to your response to my response!
1. Dramatic license.
2. It is indeed.
3. Nyeh nyeh!
4. I am!
5. :(
6. Where is 6?
7. Oh, I never answered your 7... The answer is it's missing.
8. (answer to your 7) - I've also noticed how I make France automatically the 'bad guys' during the Napoleonic Wars, when really they were trying to spread liberty and democracy and such (until Napoleon went crazy with power, at any rate).
Actually Germany was the one sending the peace offerings, not France and Britain. Austria even accepted too. France wanted revenge for their land losses after the Franco-Prussian war.
@TheSarenarass Were they? I know about Austria accepting (to Germany's dismay), but I thought Germany (or the Kaiser in particular) was extremely insistant that Germany would win the war.
@MervueMeringue Germany was insistant on winning, though they were collapsing on the inside. They sent several peace offerings that would end the war all together, but declare Germany as victor. Austria's peace offerings were just directly aimed at Austria-Hungary leaving, not all of the Central powers. Thats what angered the Germans :P That and the Austrians were taking some of the food shipments heading to Germany since they were running out of food..
@TheSarenarass Ah, yeah, that sounds more like this. Sorry if I'm being critical of the points, it's just we're doing this as school at the moment and I feel all super knowledgeable about it (I'm not).
@MervueMeringue just wondering...from 2:40 and onwards what sound track did u use, the music totally struck 1 of my memory cords but i cant seem to remember... there are many verisons of "Gray's Theme" so if u can help me, that'll be really helpful =D
I'm afraid you missunderstood at 1:16. Germany beat the crap out of France in the war of 1871, that's when Germany was formed. France didn't win, Germany did.
@Orca8472 Sorry, the 1871 war isn't the war shown at 1:16. That's a fictional war, to show the rivalries between Germany and France forming. The 1871 war happens at the end of Part 5 (Napoleon).
before america entered the war i heard that germany and austria and ottoman were winning and owned all the eastern europe? any truth to that? it sounds like it makes sense seeing as how russia surrendered and had revolution after?
Smock24 1 month ago
@Smock24 I think so, though I'm not entirely sure. Certainly the Allies had lost on the Eastern Front, but I'm not sure how much territory was taken from Russia. I've seen a map before with huge amounts of land ceded to Germany, but I don't know whether that was just a plan or whether it actually happened for about a year before Germany's defeat.
MervueMeringue 1 month ago
@mervuemeringue
i googled "battle of inverness". There wasn't anything about a battle at the british islands during the wwii or wwi.
isydor97 1 month ago
@isydor97 hes being sarcastic
cg123ize 1 month ago
germany never invaded england and in part 5 france never invaded england WERE HAVE U GOT YOUR FACTS FROM
GordieMacumAndOther 1 month ago
@GordieMacumAndOther Wrong. They did, and it has been historically documented everywhere you look. YOUR facts are wrong! Don't you remember Napoleon storming across the Enlish countryside, and the Kaiser eating Christmas Dinner in Westminster?
MervueMeringue 1 month ago
@MervueMeringue the last battle fought on british soil was in the 1700s between scotish rebels and the british troops so how could napoleon invade in the early 1800s and germany invade in ww1 so plz get your facts right and i sould know being from england how does it fell knowing that a 12 year old knows more than u
GordieMacumAndOther 1 month ago
@GordieMacumAndOther No it wasn't, it was the battle of Inverness in 1943, where the British army valiantly defeated the Nazi invaders. I should know, being from Scotland.
MervueMeringue 1 month ago
Comment removed
GordieMacumAndOther 1 month ago
@GordieMacumAndOther Sorry, I stand corrected. It was the battle of Inverness 1983, and Communist forces were defeated.
MervueMeringue 1 month ago
Comment removed
GordieMacumAndOther 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MervueMeringue sorry that iq is 4 and that this histroy is beond your knowlage plz stop digging yourself a deaper hole
GordieMacumAndOther 1 month ago
it's funny, BUT
1. italy never was allied with germany in the WWI.
2. german troops never landet in england (3:53)
isydor97 1 month ago
@isydor97 Keep telling yourself that.
MervueMeringue 1 month ago
why was the baltic just called lithuania? There are 3 countries there.
freakyDJ901 2 months ago
@freakyDJ901 Space.
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
germany never took over parts of england
queenpaes06 2 months ago
@queenpaes06 That was to simulate the battle of Britain. And to please the nazis on youtube, though strangely there don't appear to be any.
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
@queenpaes06 Oops, wrong war. Though there were still bombings in WW1.
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
Also World war 1 started a bit wrong in this, an Serbian terrorist assasinated the Austrain Crown prince or something so Austria declared war to take "revenge" and it dragged in Russia, Germany etc
MrJohanBorg 4 months ago
@MrJohanBorg Difficult to show on a map...
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
Also, Germany beat France in that first war, and it was France that was vengeful
TheMightyKing100 4 months ago
i think xandarmax is right, by the way this video is funny :D
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
since when did germany get control of london?
lovelawnangle2 5 months ago
I love the way that Belgium said *sigh* while in real life they said no and fought until the last man standing!
stroboticjr 6 months ago
@stroboticjr Not much space to show it
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
I loved these videos! History is really interesting, so thanks for making these :D
TheMonkeyPoke 6 months ago
italy didn't switch side in WW1, what are these bullshit on italy attacking france in ww1? lol
XandarMax 7 months ago
@XandarMax italy did change sides you idiot.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku italy joined the war in 1915 with the entente and never changed side, pick a history book dumbass
XandarMax 5 months ago
@XandarMax they were on germanys side at the beginning. they didn't go into the war, but they were on the side of the axis, and supported them. but after seeing that the axis will lose they changed their side, and went with the allies. idiot.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku
1 austria already violated the pact before the war annecting bosnia-herzegovina
2 austria held italian land
3 italy did not support the central powers, in any way
4 the triple allience (the axis? hahahaha) was a defensive pact, since austria declared war on serbia italy could easily exit the alliance,
5 they joined the war in 1915, note the '17 or smthing, when nobody could predict the victory of the entente
come on pick this book ignorant
XandarMax 5 months ago
@XandarMax first, yes i know the germans/ Austrians weren't called 'axis'. i just couldn't remember their name. and second, my fucking school book, and history teacher ( who btw knows A LOT of history ) said that Italy supported germany and austro-hungary in the beginnig of the war. so stfu idiot.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku yeah she has told u that santa claus doesn't exists?
come on child, grow up, i've written FACTS, now u have to explain in wich consist this "support"
this is very entertaining
XandarMax 5 months ago
@XandarMax Who the fuck do you think you are? First of all its HE, and HE has been teaching History for a very long time. And WOW. i mean your so mature and tough, when calling me a child and telling me to grow up. You didn't give me any facts. When My School book, My History Teacher, Wikipedia, ALL say that Italy was in the beginning on Germanys side. so just stfu.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku repeating the same bullshit doesn't make that true, so, yes, grow up kid and learn some real history, greetings
XandarMax 5 months ago
@XandarMax lol what a fucking moron you are. i just gave you three sources which tell that Italy was on the same side with Germans and Austrians in the beginning. you have gave me ZERO. Why don't you give me ONE source that says Italy was on with UK and France FROM THE BEGINNING. Maybe then ( MAYBE ) i could somehow believe you. if you do not find any sources, than just don't bother you respond anymore. your fucking pathetic btw...
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku @FinMilkku Come on the dude is right, i'm from italy and this is common knowledge here, italy was neutral in the beginning of war, even the german were pissed at the austrian behaviour, but they had their own imperial aims and joined the war with the austrians.
just read the wikipedia page on ww1 or this one from the italian wikipedia page that focus only on that year of neutrality
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 can't post the link, read with google translate, the name of the articol is Neutralità italiana (1914-1915)
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 So your saying that My History teacher, History school book, and Wikipedia are lying? all of these say that Italy had a pact with Germany and Austria. but then Italy left the pact later and fought against them
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku this is correct italy had a pact with germany and austria, from 1882 to 1914, but the nature of the pact was to defend each other from foreign aggressions, since austria declared war on serbia italy could easily break the alliance, the pact himself allowed this.
But the fact is that in this video there is a conquest of french territories by italy, wich is funny. The aggression of france by italy appened in ww2 and italy conquered only few km.
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 yes i never said Italy went to battle. i only said that Italy was supporting The central powers in the beginning.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku ok but italy was already out of the alliance when the war began, more precisely at the moment of the ultimatum by austria italy quitted, and then started the war, so at beginning of the war was neutral, yes it's a matter of few days but italy was alrealdy out.
However think on this, at the time italy was a democracy, a Constitutional monarchy like UK, they would never support a war of aggression, the pact does not allow this, the people of italy were liberals and had symphathy for fre
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 oh. cause i remember that Italy was an allie of Austria when the war began, and left the pact only after the war began.
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku np these are particulars, the important is that italy won that war xD the major mistake is in the video ^^
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 btw i love your country dude :D. i just came back from Rome like a week ago, and i had the time of my life there :D
FinMilkku 5 months ago
@FinMilkku good :), come back in future and visit Florence and Venice bye from Apulia(south est) :D
johnpetrucci84 5 months ago
@johnpetrucci84 i surely will :) greetings from Klaukkala ( near Helsinki ) :)
FinMilkku 5 months ago
Germany won the war between it and France, it didn't loose it. Germany unified in that war.
Nuclearwaste13 7 months ago
History with an added touch. Excellent work :D
unifieddynasty 7 months ago
I really enjoy these videos, but Turkey was formed after the allies took over the former Ottoman Empire.
traindude80 8 months ago
@traindude80 That's basically what happened here, was it not? Surely the allies never occupied all of The Ottoman Empire!
MervueMeringue 8 months ago
@MervueMeringue The Allies divided Anatolia amongst themselves and left the Ottomans with a small piece of land around Ankara. Then the Ottomans changed from empire to republic and fought back and regained the land. Just pointing it out but overall still a great video.
traindude80 8 months ago
I truly enjoy this...i cant say I dont, it is soooo good
irulandina 8 months ago
@irulandina Thank you!
MervueMeringue 8 months ago
that map doesn't show the realistic warfronts and these comments on the left side are stupid
xistion 9 months ago
@xistion I'll answer your complaints in reverse order: they're supposed to be, and I know, I hadn't researched it enough, I plan on making an updated video sometime.
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue ok. you said we could critizice this video because in this one you DID do research and thought it. IS THERE ANY VID I CAN CRITIZICE PLEASE!!
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola Oh, I did, didn't I? Well, criticism annoys me less here than in the other! That's probably as good as it'll get.
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue oh thats great! unluckily now I havent got the time but expect my trolling comments by tomorrow at noon =)
1111hola 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue
ok, lets begin this:
1. the war at 1:00 would be the french prussian war right? Wasnt it that germany had won it?
2. the war with morocco is totally messed up.
3. the taking of israel was during WW1, not before it
4. wtf did you do in the balkans?!?
5. so... germany lost east prussia before declaring war on france?
6. invasion of britain? portugal joining the war?
7. where is the german taking of estonia and ukraine?
8. 3:22 yeah, the allies are always the good ones.
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola in 8 i meant that the germans were the ones triying for peace, not the allies.
oh and in 5 germany never lost east prussia in the war with russia
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola Oops, sorry, I missed out 7. Yeah, same as 5. Were they? In History we didn't really cover much of the politics other than how it began and how it ended. Though I do know that Britain wouldn't have tried for peace either, but Germany's foreign policy was quite aggressive also, surely?
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue that actually was the Prussians, the Germans tried to soften them. but remember that during the stalemate in the western front Germany tried peace quite a few times, but Britain wouldnt accept it. anyways they were both very agressive.
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola This'll be fun!
1. No, that's an imaginary war. The Prussian war's in the previous part.
2. Yeah.......
3. Well. Nyeh.
4. It's no more confusing than the reality!
5. The eastern front is the one thing I regret about this video. I got it so wrong, and it annoys me so much.
6. Yep. Yep.
7. Well, being British, I'm a bit biased... (though I've noticed that Britain has been a bit too nice in my videos, so this will be rectified in a future one!).
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue wow... that was one fast reply;
1. wtf...
2. I mean that the war in morocco was first fought between spain and m., then the second one s.&m. once again and the THIRD one was between morocco, france and spain... so its kinda messed up.
3. ? ok...lol
4. lol, you're absolutelly right =D
5. ha!
7.well, at least you recognized it.
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola Ooh, I forgot to respond to your response to my response!
1. Dramatic license.
2. It is indeed.
3. Nyeh nyeh!
4. I am!
5. :(
6. Where is 6?
7. Oh, I never answered your 7... The answer is it's missing.
8. (answer to your 7) - I've also noticed how I make France automatically the 'bad guys' during the Napoleonic Wars, when really they were trying to spread liberty and democracy and such (until Napoleon went crazy with power, at any rate).
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
@MervueMeringue umm thanks lol but now I am totally messed up... So i will take your answer as good. Have a nice day!
1111hola 1 month ago
@MervueMeringue oh and I forgot that the north-east Italy was under austria, not under italy
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola Don't I have that? *checks*. Oh, no. I really have learnt lots since making this. A remake is looking more likely!
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue oh, I like the sound of that... hope to see it soon =)
btw stop repliying faster than me, it makes me look like a 5 years old... lol
1111hola 9 months ago
@1111hola Sorry. Was that better?
MervueMeringue 9 months ago
@MervueMeringue haha see? you're being agressive now! >=D
1111hola 9 months ago
GREAT MUSICK FROM PART 2 UNTIL 6 I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE THE USICK PLS
MrThePsychologist 11 months ago
how did you make this ?
L1qu1dN1trog3n 11 months ago
to me, in this video, germany looks like west virgina... nice vid
trekkiefans04 1 year ago
be good if you ha da timeline
Wondefullwood 1 year ago
Actually Germany was the one sending the peace offerings, not France and Britain. Austria even accepted too. France wanted revenge for their land losses after the Franco-Prussian war.
TheSarenarass 1 year ago
@TheSarenarass Were they? I know about Austria accepting (to Germany's dismay), but I thought Germany (or the Kaiser in particular) was extremely insistant that Germany would win the war.
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue Germany was insistant on winning, though they were collapsing on the inside. They sent several peace offerings that would end the war all together, but declare Germany as victor. Austria's peace offerings were just directly aimed at Austria-Hungary leaving, not all of the Central powers. Thats what angered the Germans :P That and the Austrians were taking some of the food shipments heading to Germany since they were running out of food..
TheSarenarass 1 year ago
@TheSarenarass Ah, yeah, that sounds more like this. Sorry if I'm being critical of the points, it's just we're doing this as school at the moment and I feel all super knowledgeable about it (I'm not).
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue Not trying to offend the video or anything! Just being constructive/attempting to be helpful.
TheSarenarass 1 year ago
@TheSarenarass Don't worry, I like criticisms if they're not insults. It's nice to learn stuff!
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue just wondering...from 2:40 and onwards what sound track did u use, the music totally struck 1 of my memory cords but i cant seem to remember... there are many verisons of "Gray's Theme" so if u can help me, that'll be really helpful =D
J1N6666 1 year ago
@J1N6666 That bit isn't Gray's Theme, it's from a game called Napoleon Total War. Gray's Theme starts at 3:39.
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue ahhhhh thx man, i totally remember nao =D
J1N6666 1 year ago
The desperation of the losing red side at the end of WWI, with the sad music... ;_; How bravely Germany fought...
Vocaloidict 1 year ago
@Vocaloidict And pointlessly.
MervueMeringue 2 months ago
very nice sums it up nicely ^^
RAG1923 1 year ago
I'm afraid you missunderstood at 1:16. Germany beat the crap out of France in the war of 1871, that's when Germany was formed. France didn't win, Germany did.
Orca8472 1 year ago
@Orca8472 Sorry, the 1871 war isn't the war shown at 1:16. That's a fictional war, to show the rivalries between Germany and France forming. The 1871 war happens at the end of Part 5 (Napoleon).
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue Oh. Well, in that case, my bad. :)
Orca8472 1 year ago
@Orca8472 Well, I shouldn't be going around adding in fake wars either!
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
Better, still amusing, but still not perfect, but I'm not going to go make fun of your work so in the end it was a great job
ListWritingMachine 1 year ago
@ListWritingMachine Thanks. To make it perfect I think I'd need more than just paint and some history books, though.
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
cool vids I love learning about history by seeing a map
Hellgrox101NT604comm 1 year ago
@Hellgrox101NT604comm Thanks! I wouldn't take this as a history lesson though, as it's not 100% accurate, but I hope you enjoy it nonetheless!
MervueMeringue 1 year ago
@MervueMeringue not 100% acurrate, you had germany landing in brittan lol
MyNameIsRobert100000 1 year ago
@MyNameIsRobert100000 It adds to the suspense!
MervueMeringue 1 year ago