Kaylie Stewart- American Idol Season 8 Audition

[kaylees545]

You are AMAZING! Somebodys gonna be famous... :)

[Metzgervideo]

your pretty darn good. i am thinkin about tryin out when i am 15 can you check my videos and tell me if you think i will do good

[AllThatShimmer96]

well your not actually bad. you just need a little practice thats all, if u got a practise like voice lessons, you would be GREAT! =D

[Katarzyna101]

Ok sweetie. Being brutally honest... You aren't bad at all. You do need some training and a good voice coach but you do have talent. It's really raw talent though. I think with some voice lessons you would be AMAZING. You have the goods... Just need to be brushed up a bit more. But other than that, you are way better than people here are giving you credit for. Haters gonna hate. Check out my vids! I'm auditioning for Idol next week.

[krazi4k]

I've watched your other videos, but this doesn't compare at all.

You would have totally made it if you chose 'Your Eyes' or, like you mentioned somewhere below, '2AM'.

[ChristopherTwoFace]

Kaylie,

I like your voice. Though I don't think your song choice was the best. You need to have something that will wow the producers in the first round and obviously wow the judges when you get to audition in front of them. You should really consider auditioning again in the future though. Just use a better song.

[Sorasen]

You're a bit out of tune, I'm afraid, and that makes a huge difference. I know this is a bit of a necropost but I think I'm the first to say that you already have the solution. Might i suggest next time you audition, you use your guitar? An instrument will often serve to sort of tune your voice properly throughout a period of time, and from your other videos I can tell this is how you seem to work. With that and a couple years of experience, you'll do really well.

[aznmimi1]

oh well im sorry if you took that in a offensive way. i would just trying to give you my honest opinion and you did say be simon!

[kbear1228]

if you look at other comments, people gave constructive criticism without being rude and saying "you suck"

and for future reference and some social skills advice, just cuz you say "no offense" after saying something mean, it doesn't make it any less rude. im not hurt by it cuz i know i have talent and i know this isn't my best performance, but other people might might be hurt by your comments like that or think your a jerk. you can be constructive without being mean.

[aznmimi1]

you kinda suck no offense! you need vocal lessons. your voice is off pitch and very winey

[kbear1228]

uh how is that NOT offensive??

[niggabigs]

ur pretty good but i think u should sing a diff. song!

[TheButtheads010]

hmmm...

your voice is a little whiney

maybe you should try when you are like 18 or something, when your voice matures a bit

[karlaaa03elle]

i agree with assdancere! you're really good!

[ChristineH90]

granted, you were in a small room and the sound was bouncing off everywhere, you could have sung stronger and with more conviction. i love that song and i think that you would have been better off staying out of your head voice. but that was good! better luck in a few years when your voice has matured?

[victoriacipryk]

you definately have talent!

your really good, but your voice needs to mature a bit, wait a couple years for your transition from girl to woman

maybe when your 18, i definately encourage you to try out

ill definately be a fan if you make it! :)

[Bree1059]

I think you should try again in a few years....When your voice is able to mature

[longhornchick37]

/u should audition again when u r older :D

[SweetaRoxious]

Oh and also work on your diction. But that is also a part of technique

[SweetaRoxious]

Your voice is not bad. You have a good voice colour but very very bad technique if any. Try taking singing lessons. They'll be able to help you with your breathing. Use your diaphragm. You really have to work on your technique. But you're still young so just keep practicing

[youdontseeme2]

Your voice sounds a bit shakey...

sounds like you have potential. i advise more breath support: use your diaphragm more, bigger breaths and just keep practicing.

Good luck :)

[assdancere]

I can see y u didn't make it.

[operations1000]

Seems like your voice is gonna really mature soon, then try back. This could be anywhere from next month to 4 years from now so..keep at it.

[icecreamchute]

You have a great tone- you are still young, so your voice hasn't matured yet. You could benefit from lessons to learn some techniques that would help you project your voice- it was a little airy. Pick something that feels comfortable to sing. keep working on it and you will do great!

[reichow1]

your not bad you just sound kinda whiney in parts

Also you should try to find tht one rythem that you can hold, because you started off kinda mdeium and then got really high..

just keep practicing and find a song tht compliments ur voice:D

Hope this helps:D

[evil221884]

i think you should keep practicing and wait a couple of yrs and try again....ur voice still sounds like it needs maturing from a girl to women...your kinda in the middle at the moment

[niqnaq23]

My son also auditioned in San Fran. He's on here to under yayeezie. One thing I noticed, they did by pass a lot of good singers. Don't give up, good things will come. Good luck to you in your musical dreams.

[jaymejean28]

its pretty good:) a little off in some parts over all I liked it a lot!! that sucks u didnt make it past 1st round.

[ToryFromTheBlock]

It was alright. Your using your head voice i can tell. But your not that bad.

Try belting it

[Oranje9]

That was just some comments, and it's not to be mean :) We should just all help each other improve

[kbear1228]

Oh no offense taken =]

Yeah, when I DO get this song right, it's amazing, but unfortunately, it's hard to ever get something perfect. And it's REALLY hard when there's sooo much pressure on you! That's what happened. I freaked out, my throat dried up, and yeah. But they let me make it through the whole thing so that was good.

Thank you for those suggestions. It makes me think that I should have gone with my other audition song (2am by alexz johnson)

[Oranje9]

It's pretty good, but not great. I think you made the big Idols audition mistake. A lot of people think they have to show all they've got and pick a difficult song that doesn't fit very well with their voice. I thought the same when I heard this. Watch the autditions of your examples Brooke and David and you'll see that they picked which they could sing while they were sleeping. Pick a song next time that fits with your voice better and is easier. Like Only Hope or Your eyes

[mzarchuleta1290]

Really good!

But like,Im not trying to be mean or anything, Im a signer too

But I think your using your nose a little bit. I could be wrong, but it just seems liek it. Otherwise you are great! =]

I hope you make it next year! =]

[drenikrios]

Eeeee purty little lady wiff her purty little voice :]

[YrendenQ]

COOL!!!! 5 stars

[kbear1228]

Thank you all soooo much! You guys are way nice!

Don't forget to rate it! please =]

[donaldthepwnerer]

Omg Kaylie, you're so kick ass.

[islandchicpnay8]

yeeeee. go kaylie ! idk how u didn't get in with a voice so beautiful and an awesome song! ily kay<3

[sassychartermonkey94]

wow your amazing!

[kcdelacruzz]

YEEEHH thats my girl! haha dude i personally think you should have made it past the first round. like FOR SURE. so talented and pretty m'dear. good jobb =)