In the third example (at time 3:00), he invents another rule. But in fact, if you visualize his second method you can see that it would also work on this shot.
I enjoyed this video. It was a very complete and well thought out approach to a special case situation. Making note of the last two parts especially helped create a general approach to an already uncommon situation.
Finally, does hitting through an OB frozen to a CB impart any spin on the cue ball (especially closer to a half ball hit)? And if not, then couldn't this system be used for banks, or getting safe?
Really cool !! I wonder if there's a relatively easy to understand physical explanation of why these rules seem to work. I also wonder if the effect varies with the force of the shot.
I don't know of any simple explanation because multiple-object impact situations are very difficult to analyze and predict. The systems are "empirical" ... not theoretical.
The interesting thing is that there's only going to be one instantaneous contact between the tip of the cue and the cue ball. BCA nine-ball rules draw a distinction between this kind of hit and a push-through, which involves a prolonged contact and an accelerating stroke that "herds" the cue ball along the line of the stroke. Try it out on the table and you'll see the difference!
Excellent post. If people want to see this, I have some high-speed-video clips on my website (see the link in the video description) clearly showing the non-prolonged hit with a frozen CB (e.g., see HSV A.97).
When the cue ball is frozen to the object ball, you are allowed to hit into the cue ball toward the frozen ball with a normal stroke. There is no double hit.
In the third example (at time 3:00), he invents another rule. But in fact, if you visualize his second method you can see that it would also work on this shot.
Nice, useful info. Thanks!
GetMeThere1 1 year ago
@GetMeThere1
Agreed ... you're welcome ... and thanks.
DrDaveBilliards 1 year ago
I enjoyed this video. It was a very complete and well thought out approach to a special case situation. Making note of the last two parts especially helped create a general approach to an already uncommon situation.
Finally, does hitting through an OB frozen to a CB impart any spin on the cue ball (especially closer to a half ball hit)? And if not, then couldn't this system be used for banks, or getting safe?
konryunakara 1 year ago
Thank you for the kind remarks.
This system can definitely be used to help with kick shots and safeties.
Regards,
Dave
DrDaveBilliards 1 year ago
Really cool !! I wonder if there's a relatively easy to understand physical explanation of why these rules seem to work. I also wonder if the effect varies with the force of the shot.
GetMeThere1 1 year ago
I don't know of any simple explanation because multiple-object impact situations are very difficult to analyze and predict. The systems are "empirical" ... not theoretical.
DrDaveBilliards 1 year ago
The interesting thing is that there's only going to be one instantaneous contact between the tip of the cue and the cue ball. BCA nine-ball rules draw a distinction between this kind of hit and a push-through, which involves a prolonged contact and an accelerating stroke that "herds" the cue ball along the line of the stroke. Try it out on the table and you'll see the difference!
cptCrax 2 years ago
Excellent post. If people want to see this, I have some high-speed-video clips on my website (see the link in the video description) clearly showing the non-prolonged hit with a frozen CB (e.g., see HSV A.97).
DrDaveBilliards 2 years ago
so that wouldn't be a double hit?
califoolio 3 years ago
When the cue ball is frozen to the object ball, you are allowed to hit into the cue ball toward the frozen ball with a normal stroke. There is no double hit.
Dr. Dave
DrDaveBilliards 3 years ago
@califoolio
No; although, some leagues don't allow this type of shot.
DrDaveBilliards 1 year ago
brilliant
bklynceez 3 years ago