1 hammer toe (the big toe) 5 little toes, & all toes have bunions. Oprah why are you such a cheapskate invest some of that money on yourself, your feet look Alain!
errrr, actually it's not a 6th toe...its named a bunion where part of the bone deforms from the side of the big toe or either the end toe, when too much pressure is put on it i.e heels!
Ok... people, I have an explanation for this... My mom has feet like that (She has the same age too, I think) and she has that from wearing pumps/ high heels for decades (hehe, decades... geez my mom is old). She has to wear that at work and Oprah did that too, I guess, so from walking on those all day, their feet has been shaped by their footwear and that's why their feet looks like that! ^ ^
@aussersein THANK GOD! I was going crazy thinking i was the only one that can count. Then i saw your comment. Its pretty obvious she has eighty-three toes. I don't know where everyone else is coming up with 10, 11, or 12. Its clear as day, 83. Thank you for restoring my hope in humanity. For everyone else that cant count (or take a joke) then have a nice day!
Mis-shaped foot from years of shoe abuse. The last part by her small toe is just tissue shaped around her foot. She could get them fixed but probably isn't that important to her. She is attractive nonetheless.
OK just cause she has 6 toes doesnt mean she a bad person or just cause she has a camel toe!!!! like gosh lots of people hav cmel toes and did u know tht catherine (elizabeths the 1st mother) had 6 finger on both of her hands!(i red some books bout her)
I wonder if the closeup picture of Oprah's feet has been photoshopped because it looks like the picture of her feet have been altered. On the full picture of Oprah, it's kind of hard to see if her feet actually looks like the close up picture. Sometimes you can't believe everything that you see because some people can photoshop pictures to make them look different than they really look.
On the cover of this month's O magazine she's wearing sandals. Of course they could have used a foot model and Photoshopped the feet. Christina Aguilara has deformed feet, serious hammer toes. She has the confidence to wear open toed shoes.
Oh my god she has six,Put please don't say tha about any people.Please no more. Can you put your picture we will see if yo'r complete full or like moon!!!!!!
FUUUUGLY!!! OMG on top of that, she has six toes!!! ewwww... ok, nothing wrong with having six toes, but it's only adds one more toe that looks in horrible conditions, it would be ok if the six toes were on a cute female with beautiful feet who would take care of them.
Oh my fucking God......Holy Motherfucking shit.......Holy Smokes!!!!!!!! Those are the worst toes I have ever seen. I really feel like throwing up and shitting on my myself. What some disturbing shit there.
Hahahahahaha...Her feet are pointing North while her toes point to the West. Now I know why she has this North Westerly walk, I always wondered about that. Thanks for posting, now I can put this behind me and move on with my life, lol. ( 5 toes with a Jimmy Dean sausage patty being squished out the side, that`s my answer. ( < :
Gosh, so what IF she has 12 toes and a cameltoe somewhere else, I'd rather have 12 toes along side my billions of dollars then my current account status and 10 toes ;)
Wooow, Oprah. You have TOO much money for your feet to be looking like that. I'm pro-Oprah and all but gracious; that's like an ULTIMATE bunion. SheEsh.
Omg it looks like six! don't want to be mean but her feet is ugly she shouldn't wear open toes shoe. for god sake u have money go get surgery on your foot
Can everyone who thinks she has 6 toes *please* go get an eye test?
Count: 1 big toe.
2nd toe, seperated by small gap,
3rd toe slightly sitting above
4th toe -sitting beneath
5th 'pinkie' toe
The "extra toe" is because her foot is on an angle and the skin under her foot is paler (just as most african people have paler palms than the rest of their skin.
Dude, I am black and the skin on my palms and feet are pale, however, I am counting 6 toes in that photot. I don't know that they are Oprah's, but damn they sure are plentiful.
omg i always hope my feet dont end up like this when im old... this is what happens when you wear heels and uncomfortable shoes your whole life. TAKE CARE OF YOUR FEET PEOPLE! LOL
Well u can argue she has only 5 toes, since the last one does not have a nail, neither is it a toe, but some bone/meat that has been pushed to the side to look like a toe;)
If you had as much money as her you would have a load of toes extra too mofo, maybe install some pocket billiards down there in the panties too, maybe a fold away bbq set in that big momma ass of hers too. Would hate to think what would be stored between the wobblies up top...
Oprah, SHAME ON YOU to claim there are many ways to God! Shame on you for leading drones in this direction. Oprah, you are a false teacher and may the deity of your latest whim, find favor in your existence.
Oprah is a billionaire in her own right! More power to her! Hahaha......you guys are just jealous so you added an extra toe to make yourselves feel better!
Although that pic can be photo shopped probably very easily to make it appear that way. There are people with extra fingers and toes out there. It's called pollydactyly (not sure if I spelled that right) But it exists. In fact I have a cousin who was born with only four fingers on one hand. and the bones for that finger that is missing don't exist even within the hand, it just never formed. But I'm gonna have to investigate these Oprah toes more to see if its real!!
OMG! this is absurd! lol! If you look caregully, youll see that she has 10 like everyone else... Her feet are just large and relatively wide. She also suffers from bunions (often painful distended bony tissue on the inner ball of the foot area) as well as corns and extra fat on the side (making it look like a 6th toe/2nd baby toe with no nail.) Only way to fix all that is with surgery, and I guess its too painful and risky for her to have it done.
OPRAH STOP WEARING CHANKLAS!
a7xbaby978 20 hours ago
Comment removed
a7xbaby978 20 hours ago
LMAO!!! Those feet jacked up!
blakmannn1 4 days ago
THAT'S FUCKING NASTY YO.NO WONDER WHY OPRAH GETS NO PLAY...Check out the thouwow on youtube and tell a friend before somebody tries to tell you!!!
MrTHOUWOW 1 week ago
Billion Dollar Bunions.
lsmith1981 3 weeks ago
She's got some Hooves like Jagger-_- those are terrible!
rudegyal321 1 month ago
@rudegyal321 creatively funny LOL!!!!
nmbr8of11 4 weeks ago
uggggggggg
8066Don 1 month ago
eww i see six
sheri1977 1 month ago
she has five toes.its just that she has xtra fat there.so it looks like 6
amandys7878 1 month ago
Ewwwwwww! I dislike ugly feet. All that money she has and her toes looks like throw up
sexynaitalia 1 month ago 2
my son has 11 fingers :)
MandaMayLuvsCash 1 month ago
6 toes
autumpai8 1 month ago
i go with 1613cupcake i do see 6 tose
sassy31100 1 month ago
for more search bolder gazet van antwerpen
vergiber 1 month ago
6? on 1 foot
Domosarecool 1 month ago
Wow just had a thought, does Stedman like to get down on those toes? Laffin, never thought her feet would look like that thanks TMZ!
StrwbryMuffin 2 months ago
how she gonna have all money!
and can't get her toes to look good
and she got an extra toe o.o
NiKKiBSEXCii 2 months ago
got toe mighty mighty lol thats nasty hottdamn ah bear.................
derbythapimp 2 months ago
1 hammer toe (the big toe) 5 little toes, & all toes have bunions. Oprah why are you such a cheapskate invest some of that money on yourself, your feet look Alain!
0116711107 2 months ago
what the hell!!!!
residentevil448 3 months ago
WARNING!!! do not eat lunch while watching this vids, enjoy your safety
15551cue 3 months ago
errrr, actually it's not a 6th toe...its named a bunion where part of the bone deforms from the side of the big toe or either the end toe, when too much pressure is put on it i.e heels!
emelia2411 3 months ago
Ok... people, I have an explanation for this... My mom has feet like that (She has the same age too, I think) and she has that from wearing pumps/ high heels for decades (hehe, decades... geez my mom is old). She has to wear that at work and Oprah did that too, I guess, so from walking on those all day, their feet has been shaped by their footwear and that's why their feet looks like that! ^ ^
L3NAHC 3 months ago
gross
cablemanager1 3 months ago
She has eighty-three toes
aussersein 3 months ago
@aussersein THANK GOD! I was going crazy thinking i was the only one that can count. Then i saw your comment. Its pretty obvious she has eighty-three toes. I don't know where everyone else is coming up with 10, 11, or 12. Its clear as day, 83. Thank you for restoring my hope in humanity. For everyone else that cant count (or take a joke) then have a nice day!
845MX5 3 months ago
Im about 22 related videos away from what i started watching...
gar654321 3 months ago 5
I can't believe I'm looking a video of some frickin' feet
UsernameJones 4 months ago 4
Mis-shaped foot from years of shoe abuse. The last part by her small toe is just tissue shaped around her foot. She could get them fixed but probably isn't that important to her. She is attractive nonetheless.
SmittyHeWasNumber1 4 months ago
Wtf.
ScrubifyHD 4 months ago
all that money she has she can have it removed,that's if it is her toes which I doubt it.
melaniemcgill1 4 months ago
Joke right ?
Gabyevo 4 months ago
if that's not a sixth toe, that is huge ass pinky toe. I vote 6 toes who knows what the fuck is going on the other pata
biffvonwrinkle 4 months ago
she needs the extra hooves in order to kill its prey while hunting around waterholes in africa
BayouBluesMan 4 months ago
U can c where its bn photo shoped dumb asses!!!! Put ur finger on the added toe and u can c the way they realy look!!
martha8253 4 months ago
Comment removed
MsKianaBooh 4 months ago
naw thats six toes
euniquemore 5 months ago
whats the name of the song????
Mega7assoon 5 months ago
she have ten toes. It only looks that way because of the the pinky toe it has the extra meat on the side making it looke like another toe is there
vastlyspecial 5 months ago 17
Yall are so wrong for that! wow!
lawandasharriese 5 months ago
What is wrong with the big toee ?
DuperWithS 5 months ago
OK just cause she has 6 toes doesnt mean she a bad person or just cause she has a camel toe!!!! like gosh lots of people hav cmel toes and did u know tht catherine (elizabeths the 1st mother) had 6 finger on both of her hands!(i red some books bout her)
MsCrazylizzy 5 months ago
i just can't get yr enfatuation with that fat bitch fellow Americanos
BayouBluesMan 5 months ago
All that money and she can't buy a new pair of feet? Lol
lizzyBcoo 6 months ago
6 toes. Oprah has 6 toes one foot so she has 12 toes total
afroqueendancer 6 months ago
WHAAAAAAA OPRAH HAS 7 TOES!!!!!!'
wesal13 6 months ago
I see 6 also. NO TEST NEEDED!
livendapast 6 months ago
5 toes and a beautiful bunion - Bunions are so sexy on women's feet
mozatart 6 months ago
6 is all i see ;)
MrSlik777 6 months ago
I don't care what any of you say, I see SIX toes and no, I don't need an eye test. Shutup.
1613cupcake 6 months ago 20
@1613cupcake or maybe ur just so retarded that uve neva heard of photoshop and what it can do... i can make myself have 100 toes in it if i wish!
sarahkul 4 months ago
@1613cupcake lol, I think they call bony protusions BUNIONS!!! I'm wondering why with all her money doesn't she fix that its TOTALLY do able!!
stalker2121 1 month ago
Comment removed
SharMusiQ 2 weeks ago
I wonder if the closeup picture of Oprah's feet has been photoshopped because it looks like the picture of her feet have been altered. On the full picture of Oprah, it's kind of hard to see if her feet actually looks like the close up picture. Sometimes you can't believe everything that you see because some people can photoshop pictures to make them look different than they really look.
tommiexander 6 months ago
Dam.... i see 6
MsLazygirl28 6 months ago
There's a drag queen up in New Haven here goes by the name Bubblelicious and she indeed had six toes. I think she had one eventually removed.
OrangeVanillaSky69 6 months ago
I See 6
ILoveYouForever2828 6 months ago
Damn!!!...look at those BUNIONS........
ZingZee123456789 6 months ago
On the cover of this month's O magazine she's wearing sandals. Of course they could have used a foot model and Photoshopped the feet. Christina Aguilara has deformed feet, serious hammer toes. She has the confidence to wear open toed shoes.
TheClubMantra 7 months ago
10
Zepoch1 7 months ago
5 and some flab hanging over the side
TEX10261 7 months ago
i see 7,,,,,
ArthuroSmooth 8 months ago
5 toes like everyone else ..
xxboomsamxx 8 months ago
SIX!
lightsgrowakshun 8 months ago
Well gooot damn .Since she got the money , she can go buy her a new pair of feet .
kkgirl300 8 months ago
she has 5, she just has really jacked up lookin feet, and she NEVER needs to wear open shoes again... EVER!!!, they're hideous
Pred4tor419 8 months ago
I say ten, five on each foot.
chucknchar 9 months ago
eeeww like six but no boy wants to see that
XxInvaderZimforeverX 10 months ago
Deformed Eeeww !
TheChefKev 10 months ago
Black people have ugly feet anyway
EGF813 10 months ago
@EGF813 bitch im black i have beautiful so umm not all
samirahbhadd 9 months ago
Oh my god. Fuckin' FREAK!
Bulgarboy1 10 months ago
she has 6
SuperPrettyperfect 11 months ago
OH MY GOD!!! ilove pretty feet, ihave a fuckin fetish... And now im gonna havin fuckin nightmares
spideyTB 11 months ago
her feet are fucked up!!!!!!
koolkevification 11 months ago
6 toes or not, they shouldn't be exposed lol
stardood50 1 year ago
Yuck amputate that shit of
MyMillions123 1 year ago
It's not an extra toe, it's a bunion on the end of her foot. Hallie Berry has the same thing.
trulybridget 1 year ago
Dat shit is fucking triflin...! smh
lilempre 1 year ago
she doesnt have 6 toes. but she has 2 bunions on both ends of her foot.
szelosza 1 year ago
i c 6 toes
silentnina 1 year ago
Them fuckers are nasty!!!!
19thaman79 1 year ago
lolololoolololol!!!!!!
retstamuv 1 year ago
HOLY CHIT I SEE 6
xtremeiv1 1 year ago
She needs surgery on those bunions. She should have them remove. That could help her a lot.
andersport 1 year ago
she has five ; i saw it on her show when Venus or Serena was doing her toes
readmylipx 1 year ago
So the devil made a mistake when disguising in human form ...
sooperfukker 1 year ago
6 toes
katie22233 1 year ago
she has 10 billion toes how many does bill gates have????
7mvproy 1 year ago
OOOOOOOOOO MYYYYYYYYYY GAAAGAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWWDDD IT BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
UUUUUURRRRRRNNNNNSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
freddygroger 1 year ago
Its photo shopped
maaudiosubs 1 year ago
@maaudiosubs yes it is.
katie22233 1 year ago
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARGH !
AnnoyingTypoSyndrome 1 year ago
she just has excess skin and refugee toes
tsume12 1 year ago
lord them shits sooooooooooooooooo fucked up
imserious2187 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've counted at least 8! :p
luisrochinha 1 year ago
bitch gots 6 damn toes
spinch1488 1 year ago
She has 5! Look closely when u look down at ur feet don't u see the bump after ur pinky toe...goodness y'all r so gullible!
umunnamichelle 1 year ago
Oh my god she has six,Put please don't say tha about any people.Please no more. Can you put your picture we will see if yo'r complete full or like moon!!!!!!
MrNajla22 1 year ago
I'm not sure how accurate they are in this day and age, but I just saw a couple photos showing 6 toes on Michelle Obama's left foot too.
What are the odds of that?
thegoodlocust 1 year ago
nephilim
MsCread 1 year ago
I am scared for life
ThaRealestRican 1 year ago
get a life.....
nebulasxtv 1 year ago
I would say five toes and two bunions.
Wyliesmom 1 year ago
OMG SHE GOT ALL DAT MONEY AND HER DAM TOES LOOK LIKE DAT? SHE SHOULD BE SLAPPED FOR DAT SHIT..LMAO
MZQUEENBITCH1982 1 year ago
All that money and she got her toes looking like that..
Wow! that was a huge shock!!
tasha1985 1 year ago
looks like 5 toes with bunions
negative100 1 year ago
if my toes looked like that they wouldn't see the light of day!
aqueencee1 1 year ago
FUUUUGLY!!! OMG on top of that, she has six toes!!! ewwww... ok, nothing wrong with having six toes, but it's only adds one more toe that looks in horrible conditions, it would be ok if the six toes were on a cute female with beautiful feet who would take care of them.
landarriux 1 year ago
OMG! I just PUKED all over my keyboard...PLEASE remove this video so others do not have to suffer....
inhuman0id 1 year ago
eeeeeeeeeeeeeeewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
ObssesiveTeal 1 year ago
lol ^_^
INVIZIBULLOVE2012 1 year ago
Didn't you know Oprah was the neighborhood whore in her small town of Mississippi?
cookiesonsteve 1 year ago
dam O!....uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuugle!
omenra12 1 year ago
lol ugle:P
INVIZIBULLOVE2012 1 year ago
um ew!
MrGooshness 1 year ago
5 with a side :)
bep205 1 year ago
ewwwwwwww nasty gross cut the toe off
mowmer1 1 year ago
uuuuuuggle....o0000h! no ...no flip flop!........I am a toe man ....i have to pass on that...uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuugle!
omenra12 1 year ago
eeeeeeeeeeewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
HelloImMindy 1 year ago
Oprah has a bonion
nerdguy825 1 year ago
DAYUUUUUUUMM!!! SOPHIA!!!!
taymonet17 1 year ago
Oh my fucking God......Holy Motherfucking shit.......Holy Smokes!!!!!!!! Those are the worst toes I have ever seen. I really feel like throwing up and shitting on my myself. What some disturbing shit there.
sirleibl1 1 year ago
hammer time !
cybersoufiane 2 years ago
haha 6 on the left and 5 on the right foot
mattsson20 2 years ago
Hahahahahaha...Her feet are pointing North while her toes point to the West. Now I know why she has this North Westerly walk, I always wondered about that. Thanks for posting, now I can put this behind me and move on with my life, lol. ( 5 toes with a Jimmy Dean sausage patty being squished out the side, that`s my answer. ( < :
REFORMEDSTUDIOS 2 years ago
liam gallagher has 6 toes as well
MsOrlandos 2 years ago
Gosh, so what IF she has 12 toes and a cameltoe somewhere else, I'd rather have 12 toes along side my billions of dollars then my current account status and 10 toes ;)
eric79boz 2 years ago 14
Wooow, Oprah. You have TOO much money for your feet to be looking like that. I'm pro-Oprah and all but gracious; that's like an ULTIMATE bunion. SheEsh.
Fayme20 2 years ago
that usually comes from wearing shoes that were too tight over time.
Still love her though...
deatha44 2 years ago
Just as nasty as the rest of her.
DankMcstankey 2 years ago
Girl has 5 with a bunion. Damn people.
jrzy49 2 years ago 2
Some people have no life looking at people's feet. Get one!
Yeshuajesus 2 years ago 2
@Yeshuajesus Well, there's nothing wrong with a little foot fetish. But this picture here, it gives me the chills.
sirleibl1 1 year ago
@Yeshuajesus (look whose talkin!!)
JazyGirl26 9 months ago
@Yeshuajesus And that is why you're watching a video about feet, LOOOL
Verdinial 8 months ago
It just looks like fat near her little toe, which is of no surprise!
messiahjonz 2 years ago
holy shit!
skankinga 2 years ago
relax ppl its five toes. damn.
pnklmonade127 2 years ago
omah gawd! that is a sure sign of the devil! :P
wattever333 2 years ago
I love oprah to death but
Omg it looks like six! don't want to be mean but her feet is ugly she shouldn't wear open toes shoe. for god sake u have money go get surgery on your foot
Astwa2 2 years ago
@Astwa2 ....and on her face LOL
musicxcraze 2 years ago
Can everyone who thinks she has 6 toes *please* go get an eye test?
Count: 1 big toe.
2nd toe, seperated by small gap,
3rd toe slightly sitting above
4th toe -sitting beneath
5th 'pinkie' toe
The "extra toe" is because her foot is on an angle and the skin under her foot is paler (just as most african people have paler palms than the rest of their skin.
Get glasses. Seriously.
zoerickard 2 years ago 6
Dude, I am black and the skin on my palms and feet are pale, however, I am counting 6 toes in that photot. I don't know that they are Oprah's, but damn they sure are plentiful.
Dkelsmith 2 years ago
omg i always hope my feet dont end up like this when im old... this is what happens when you wear heels and uncomfortable shoes your whole life. TAKE CARE OF YOUR FEET PEOPLE! LOL
PeachykeenLNG 3 years ago
gosh,this woman don't have a life,now i understand her,she don't want to go out..
ogwmmj 3 years ago
Well u can argue she has only 5 toes, since the last one does not have a nail, neither is it a toe, but some bone/meat that has been pushed to the side to look like a toe;)
MopacMurtaza 3 years ago
SHE HAS 6 TOES LOL
MTJL11 3 years ago
i saw 12 eeew
prinsesslaylay 3 years ago
I knew she was a fucking reptilian from the constellation Draco. DAMN YOU CIA, NFA, FBI, NSA, KGB, and other 3 letter spy agencies!
LOLDISNEYLAND 3 years ago
At 200 lbs., and counting ............
she is growing so fast that she is sprouting extra toes, fingers, and what not.
Damn O., STOP EATING.
Your starting to look like a fat Rosie.
bobbytiger 3 years ago
En-Ay-ES-TEE!!!
ahhfr3sh 3 years ago
Oprah has 12 toes and 2 bungholes.
seka1986 3 years ago
If you had as much money as her you would have a load of toes extra too mofo, maybe install some pocket billiards down there in the panties too, maybe a fold away bbq set in that big momma ass of hers too. Would hate to think what would be stored between the wobblies up top...
mattyabsley 3 years ago
i don't know but her feet looked a little nasty there
DivaahhPrincess26 3 years ago
Oprah has trillions of toes, she owns the world!
rrw2007 3 years ago 2
SHE HAS OVER 9000 PENISES
and toes
MustangTheCat 3 years ago
12!, 6 on each foot!.
cannonflower 3 years ago
Rofl.
viacarlton 3 years ago
Oprah, SHAME ON YOU to claim there are many ways to God! Shame on you for leading drones in this direction. Oprah, you are a false teacher and may the deity of your latest whim, find favor in your existence.
bRadicalmagic1 3 years ago
i've heard of "cankles" but this is the first time i've seen "toekles"
machenga 3 years ago 2
Oprah is a billionaire in her own right! More power to her! Hahaha......you guys are just jealous so you added an extra toe to make yourselves feel better!
maalat 3 years ago 2
send in your guesses lol
somerandomdude11 3 years ago
my great gramma has a misplaced toe.. its up on her foot..
i noticed it not too long ago..
RavenousRawr 3 years ago
Although that pic can be photo shopped probably very easily to make it appear that way. There are people with extra fingers and toes out there. It's called pollydactyly (not sure if I spelled that right) But it exists. In fact I have a cousin who was born with only four fingers on one hand. and the bones for that finger that is missing don't exist even within the hand, it just never formed. But I'm gonna have to investigate these Oprah toes more to see if its real!!
lilhappygirlhere 3 years ago 9
yeah but i thought she had 4 toes on one foot. 8/ either way theres somethin messed up with her toe situation because it was on an episode.
narutoluvshinata1994 3 years ago
@lilhappygirlhere the right word is polydactyly
Root121212 1 year ago
i see six on the zoomed in foot, she does have some pretty ugly feet but with all that money i'm sure she could care less......
lbbenton 4 years ago 2
I heard that! Oprah could have 25 toes-- that girl is still RICH! Okay?
EdieBlount 3 years ago 11
@EdieBlount That Bitch doesn´t deserve a fuckin Cent PLUS she´s ugly AND got ugly Feet ! So fuck Oprah.
TheElephant79 1 year ago
I'm so glad to see that even billionaires are ugly feet, wrinkles, get fat, etc. Whew, I feel better now.
Ricangal 4 years ago
Lolz
sweety105105 4 years ago
OMG! this is absurd! lol! If you look caregully, youll see that she has 10 like everyone else... Her feet are just large and relatively wide. She also suffers from bunions (often painful distended bony tissue on the inner ball of the foot area) as well as corns and extra fat on the side (making it look like a 6th toe/2nd baby toe with no nail.) Only way to fix all that is with surgery, and I guess its too painful and risky for her to have it done.
brownfoxx76 4 years ago
no, she had it removed and they found it had a little spine, and some teeth... yes, it was her twin.
mutedmajority 4 years ago 4
hahaha......lmao. Love you for saying that ;)
qwertyass215 3 years ago