Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (99)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he's not double bassing?

  • i wanto play my guitar but i just jerked off to internet porn feel too depressed and dont wanto wash my hands

  • So don't give up :p

  • @rickericardo69

    Quit being a bitch.

    I know I am not helping your "deppression" but still, quit being a bitch. Besides, this songs about defiance, not depression.

  • wish it was in HD

  • throw it away

  • Sounds like double bassing , i wish NIN would double bass

  • They do... on certain songs.

  • Really , which ones?

  • BYIT version of Wish.

  • after everything i've done..

    i hate myself for what i've become

  • Comment removed

  • wow sounds a lot different than the one in 1992 filmed in the tate house but still amazing

  • My favourite NIN song! It's so fucking energetic!

  • WOW!! 1:08 FTW!!! :O

  • Fucking awesome. I could kill people to this song....or atleast fight them. lol

  • ha! the broken movie did exactly that!

  • yea. that thing was pretty freakin disturbing...more so than happiness in slavery.

  • Nine Inch Nails is one of the best bands of this fuckin world. Period.

  • Amazing in EVERY WAY!!!

  • My favorite song live. Can't get any better than this.

  • so how again is this DTS 5.1 surround? BULLSHIT! YouTube doesnt support Dolby, let alone DTS.

  • On the dvd it is. this upload isn't

  • AH YEAH!!!

  • i think the best thing about NIN is that they sound AMAZING live. This isnt the case for most bands XD

  • agreed

  • youtube needs to stop deleting videos cuz i cant afford to buy the cd and im not going back to limewire

  • 2:38 = Trent Just A Little Bit Less Awesome

  • LOL

  • LOL

  • Lmfao

  • yap it isnt surround !?

  • 1) Not DTS surround. There is no DTS stream and Youtube doesn't support DTS. Fail.

    2) Closed captioning not seen and no CC file uploaded, so you can't enable them.

    Come on Universal. Your interns can do better.

  • I love this song. It is amazing.. My favorite:

    "Just watching it burn a nice scteady, systematic delcline"

    <3

  • It's actually "Just watching it burn in my steady sysrematic decline"

  • Sysremetic isn't even a word.

  • Sorry. Poor typing skills make for lots of typos. It should say systematic.

  • Neither is scteady, ya dummy.

  • everytime ive broken up with a girl I listen to this song, cheers Trent (stops me from killing them) joke or is it :)

  • sounds like it's on cd

  • this is the kind of intensity at a nin concert

  • charlie the beast clouser

  • Trent says his current line up is the strongest. Even if so, the fragile line up kicked so much more ass. Everything was so epic.

  • fuck universal music group!

  • no fuck interscope and universal

  • He may be sweaty, but he's still fucking hot.

    NIN do a brilliant job live. My favorite album is their live one.

  • hes sweaty

  • The best performance of Gave Up ( IN MY OPINION)

    fucking epic , the whole AATCHB set is just immense and amazing

  • this is the one song i really like from them

  • They always do such a perfect job. You could tell though that Trent didn't want to risk it near the end when in the album version he hits those really high pitches. Can't blame him though, that stuff really hurts your vocal chords.

  • everytime i hear that song i almost cry near the end. You can feel the pain and agony in his voice at the end.

  • Absolutely.

  • Fucking epic.

  • NiN: Got sensitive hearing? We'll fix that! Don't know if you have epilepsy? We'll fix that too!

  • hahaha, hilarious

  • LOL

  • hahahaha

  • LMFAO that was great XD

  • Synth solo is fucking awesome... <3 NIN

  • Sweet! This is what I call industrial music! Pure raw energy!

  • I wouldn't say I like this version better than the Broken version. Although this IS very good of course.

    One live version of a song that I like better live than the album version is Piggy.

    Anyone ageree with me?

  • March Of The Pigs live is the vastly superior to the CD version ... the whole extra minute of furious thrashing at the end after the quiet part is is great.

  • I think that its one of the remixes they play at the end of the live version. I do agree tho the live version is 10x cooler.

  • I love hearing Closer live, mainly for how they use the guitar differently.

  • i sure like this live performance alot i dno i still like broken verson too

  • anybody else like this song better when its live?

  • damn trent has an awesome scream!

  • KICK ASS SONG!

  • bad ass...anyone with epilepsy would have had NIGHTMARES of seizures.

  • good voice here

  • Génial

  • oh to have been at this concert...

  • That's more than FUCKING GREAT!!There is no word to decribe this!!

    Good-Better-NIN!!!!

  • OMG it's amazing! Fuc*** great!

  • cool i have cd of this concert

  • trent's guitars have the most awesome body graphics ever

  • Thank god for NIN. I took a friend to a NIN concert that did not really care for them too much but after the concert he said it was the best fricken band he had ever seen live. Whats that tell you?

  • You are a damn good friend.

  • thank god they're actually coming to the US this summer, they keep fucking touring in Europe and Asia and it REALLY pisses me off.

  • robin finck owns my soul.

  • yaaa

  • coooooooooooool

  • NIN is fucking amazing live!

  • dts 5.1 surround version?

  • Look at the video description. Notice it says "Nine Inch Nails With Trent Reznor" Haha. They wouldn't say "The Rolling Stones with Mick Jagger", would they?

  • No, but NIN IS Trent Reznor :P

  • i love the song so so so so much !!

  • Cool. I haven't heard this in a while.

  • And this sounds great.. But I mean really there!!

  • As all their songs(Trent's) do.. Incredible on CD or DVD(Check out Beside You in Time and And All That Could Have Been), but live is the shit!!!!!!!!!

  • And this is my #2 NIN song.. Fucking sounds soooooooo much better live!!!

  • Greatest band EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!! Fuck the Beatles whoever.. Trent is God!!! Plays all the instruments, writes the music and lyrics(produces bands.. Manson.. And writes scores for movies.. Natural Born Killers, etc..).. WTF? And the best live band EVER!! Seen them(him) 5 times.. The GREATEST!! Been around since the early '80's and still rocks harder than anyone.. And writes the best slow songs 2.. "Something I Can Never Have" and "Hurt".. The best EVER!!!!!!!!!!

  • Greatest NIN song ever, i can't stop listening to this

  • this is the most favorite song in the NIN

  • great song

  • This is the song I lose my breath screaming to whenever I see them in concert. Awesome effing song.

  • Good song, too bad the video quality isn't as good as the music, you'd think Universal Music Group would have a better quality of the video.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more