Moulana Imtiyaz Sidat - Ya Sayyidi, Rasoolana

[alf786]

amazing subhanallah mashallah Great very touching

[wdfknow]

tell me, whats the difference between you guys and barelvis? at one time, the Deobandis would say its Shirk to use "ya" for teh Prophet alayhisalatu wa salaam, now your doing it yourself, this is a genuine question, please enlighten me, whats changed?

[baigy21]

@wdfknow

actually moulana shara ali thanvi (ra) has written a article regarding saying 'ya'. i suggest you read it

[wdfknow]

@baigy21 Thankyou for the answer, please send me a link to this article and i will read it InshaAllah.

[wdfknow]

@baigy21 ok, please point out a website/link where this article can be read, how do i find it? much appreciated.. for as far as I know, the Deobandi Jamat always called anyone who said Ya Rasool'Allah alayhisalatu wa salaam, a mushrik, I have heard this with my own ears from a local Deobandi A'alim in our City.. so please enlighten me :)

[baigy21]

@wdfknow

I can't seem to find it however i have read something on the subject. There are deobandi ulema sitting in the back, I'm sure they would have objected. look around on some deobandi websites.

[wdfknow]

@baigy21 thank you for your answer and info, appreciated, ramdhaan kareem ;)

[baigy21]

@wdfknow

No problem. ramadhaan kareem to you too

[sippy111]

@68uni99ted08 -- listening to nasheeds isn't about the quality of the voice, it's about how it affects your heart and eemaan. And in case you haven't realised it, you have just done badghumaani (slander) which is a major sin. Make tawbah and recite some portion of the Qur’an and do thawaab for "that dhorat guy" (and if you're referring to Asad Dhorat, he just happens to be an Aalim, graduated in South Africa. To denigrate the Ulama who are the warathul anmbiya is also a sin).

[68uni99ted08]

That dhorat guy has the worst voice in the world! Ppl cum to listen to Maulana not his awful voice!

[RuffDiamond2K7]

MASHA'ALLAH.