and for u people who think shes ugly and uses that as a reason for not liking her, just proves you love the looks and not the voice, you shouldnt even be here
Leona by far, she sang it how its supposed to sound, she's also the only out of the two to sing on the same stage as Mariah as an equal, not a contestant
@alexburkeisamazin Is she? is that why she's no longer famous? or why she never broke America? Though Alexandra retired or something, where is she when Leona is currently number 2 in the charts?
@DaleMaloneMusic yes she is..what are you on about shes no longer famous??:L:L....she hasnt braught her music to america YET,but that will change very soon.and alexandra has a new single out next week fyi....i love leona to but i think alex is a better performer...
@hihello121 alexandra was born with the talent she has leona was taught how to sing. alexandra is better looking better at dancing better perfromer and better singer.....
@alexburkeisamazin not a better singer, clearly not leona has a 3 octave range, Alexandra has 2 and thinks shes beyonce, thats why no one gives a shit about her
I love them both, both have incredible voices. if i was judging... id probs say alex sang that song better but leona has the better voice overall i think... depends which songs really! 1-1 i think! :)
@joshpheonix irrelevant? lmfao, leona and alex sang it just like mariah's version.. not the jackson 5 or michael jackson version.. leona sang it in faster tempo, alex sang it the same with mariah's tempo but in lowered key.. both leona and alex copied mariah's ''iiiyeah iiyeah iiyeah iiyeah'' signature belt of mc, so what's irrelevant now? lmfao
leona lewis is well better people are forgettin that this was leonas first week on the xfactor and all shes done since is get better, so leona hands down although alex is good herself leona all the way
I'm Sorry But Who is Alexandra Burkes? I Love Leona Lewis. Leona Wins Cux Shes A Million Times Better And Because No One Comes Close To Her Beautiful Voice.
i think its whatever im in the mood for because my opinion changes on which i prefer on any given day. both voices are great and its clear that they have both went for different paths of music that they produce. alex is more pop and leonas is more rnb.
neither of their voices are completely leona is a replica of mariah, and alex has hints of whitney , but alex has more soul i would rather listen to alex
On this song, Alexandra is far better, Leona sound like a little girl screaming in the chorus, Alexandra has a powerful and soulful voice, which is exactly what this song needs :) However, there is no denying Leona's voice is also amazing :)
LEONA LEWIS! Alexandra has no fuckin chance against herl! Like Leona's voice is more soft and just perfect unlike alex's manly ass deep voice!LEONA LEWIS LOVER FOREVER! FUCK ALL YOU HATERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love Leona and I'm afan of Alex's too, but she has never had the voice like Leona. I think Alex sings in a different key as she can't sing high like Leona
its hard to say who is better,i however think alex is best she sings up tempo better than leona,come to think of it what fast up tempo songs has leona done. as far as allround performance is concerned alex wins hands down. i would like to add they both have excellent voices.
Simon said it himself. She is the best talent to ever come out of the X Factor. She is as good as Mariah and maybe even Whitney. (I haven't even said her name, I bet you all know who I am talking about lol)
I think Alexandra's version was better in my opinion. Im not saying Leona doesnt have a beautiful voice because she does but the other songs she did on the show were way better than this for her. just my opinion :)
Alexandra has the more powerful voice like a Whitney Houston type, while Leona's sound a little different range like a Mariah Carey type. My opinion anyway! and i prefer Leona's voice btw!
I think these two are UK's biggest and baddest divas! I love them both! I hope Alex can follow in Leona's footsteps and be just as successful cause she deserves everybit of it!
Theyre both brilliant but theyve both become different types of artists so you cant really say whose better, their voices are suited to their style of music
but if i was to say who i thought was better in this song... I'd have to say Leona - cz her voice is amazing and i just love her <3
but on the other hand if we were talking about who is the better dancer... I'd have to say Alexandra ofc!!
Alexandra Burke is the one- she knows when to sing it straight - and when to discover a new note - without trilling.
And ha ha unfortunately for Leona, Simon hit the nail on the head by not even commenting on her vocals. 'Something special' aka you 'look like a pop star'
Alexandra by a clear mile Leona has the most annoying habit of putting extra notes at the end of one syllable words like "I'll be thee-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-re" its unnecessarry and grates on my nerves x
i prefer alexandras voice, although leona is outstanding. i think alexandras is much more stronger and powerful whereas leonas has quite a high pitched voice, but they are both amazing.
leona is an other level than alexandra! alexandra is just level:beyonce, christina and leona :mariah and celine! but i love both the same! alexandras music is bether for dancing! XDD
i don't like leona's movements, i think that is why now she keeps us entertained by enthrawling us with her voice and not by dancing - as she doesn't look professional when she dances about. However, she is still fantastic. Alexandra is also amazing, and can own the stage with dancing aswell as belting out the ballards.
not being horrid to leona but its only when u put her voice alongside alexandras u realise how out of tune she actually sounds at some points, spesh between 3.30 onwards
alexandra was clearer but the sound of her voice is control and sound like the majority of good singers. they don't need that they need a different voice which is leona.
We need to stop comparing these two singers-yes they both came from the same talent show but that doesnt mean we have to chose the best one! We, britain, should be proud to have such great talent such as these two-both have gone in two different pathways of music, alex-uptempo and leona-ballads! Lets be proud of these two great singers! I love both!
leona is truly the best singer, ever come from an idol show WORLDWIDE! really, truly amazing. she's got everything! voice, beauty and most of all the most wonderful character. pure inspiration! we need more people like leona! biggest idol ever! but alexandra is also really great. belive me, in germany we have idols not half so good like leona and alexandra.
leona is truly the best singer, ever come from an idol show WORLDWIDE! really, truly amazing. she's got everything! voice, beauty and most of all the most wonderful character. pure inspiration! we need more people like leona! biggest idol ever! but alexandra is also good.
Both Voices are great, when Alexandra sings that song it sounds more clear and stronger, but Leonas voice has a special sound, it's different than usual singers it has a special note would i say. So Leona is here definately better!
@96raindrop96 I like also both, they are great singers, but seroiusly mate i heard a lot of good voices, but leona has a special Voice sounds really feminine.
@WindofVerdure yeah, I get it, but alexandra has got a very deep and powerful voice that gives me goosebumps... they're very different and actually should't b compared like this just coz they're from x factor :) and leona's a brilliant artist too, I have all her albums, so it's not like I hate her, I just like alex better ;)
I seriously feel I need to put my point in on this debate! I think for this song Alexandra won - however overall based on more singing talent - Leona is by far superior to Alexandra.
Those who are saying GaGa is the best singer - go clean your ear's out - she is about performance & shocking people, singing talent - jesus there not there at all, don't be so pathetic!
Up to that point, Leona Lewis was a more highly trained singer who had a record deal with a company, that didn't do anything with her before X-factor. Alexandra is a more of a raw singer that is still developing. So a comparison now would be a lot different than back then.
Def Alexandra all the way, has a better voice & 100% got the hole pacage. Leona can sing but for me there has always been some thing missing & dont like her stuff, dont no why but def Alexandra for me!!!!!!!!! <3 :)
IS EVERYONE LISTENING TO THE SAME THING I AM LISTENING. IT SOUNDS LIKE LEONA IS DYING AND CANT PERFORM LIVE! it sounds like she is trying to replicate the notes that Mariah Carey and not the feeling of songs or purpose of song. SO ALEXANDRIA WINS HANDS DOWN
P.S. her name is ALEXANDRA not Alexander DAMN IT THAT ANNOYS ME lol.
Leona is overall better but i think alex won it here :) It may be because leona got the song during the first week and elex had had time to develope her voice,
leona wasn't at her best here. As Simon pointed out, she was extremely nervous being the last to perform after hearing all her talented competitors. I think both are great, very talented singers.
Alex by a mile a smooth world class performance , Leona sounds like a cat on a hot tin roof her voice is up and down and all over the place with no control, and simon is an utter arogant controlling prick.
Both have diff'rent vocal tones and ranges. Alex has a cool dark tone compared to Leona's light and distinct voice that can be compared along renowned divas like MC, etc. I prefer Alex moves here coz she performed with class and grace.
Just found this video. I don't even know which one is which. I like them both (from what you can hear from this clip), but I like the gal with the black hair somewhat better.
Are you serious guys? Alexandra clearly. She's got so much more oomph/power behind her voice. Just because Leona's tones are more like Mariah's does not mean she's a better singer. It's not 'who is mroe like Mariah' it's 'who is a better singer'. In this example Leona lacks power and control in comparison.
Don't get me wrong - I like Leona a lot. But Alex is a class above here.
But I'm so spoiled by Leona's voice. it's been awhile we heard a voice that's in a league with Mariah, Whitney, Celine. I'm not comparing her to any of these artists. as Leona is LEONA.
Yes this performance was a bit pitchy. but it's unfair to judge by juz one performance. Now she's an international star.
personally iliked alex way better.!! imen dont get me wrong im a fan of leona lewis but in this song alex's voice is way strong and the way she sounds is amazing...she doesn't over do it at all and she jus sounds great.!!!
I really really think leona is better than alex. i mean, lets be fair people. Lets not compare what they have achieved. Leona has a much better, more friendlier and distinctive tone than alex. Artistes like alex are good, but she can not be compared to mariah or whitney, whereas, Leona, who might not be there yet, has what it takes to be the next mariah or whitney.
@darren246x I think what he meant is that we've already had a strong female whitney/mariah-esque X Factor winner and we don't need another one. That's why I think he liked her more when she sang candyman, because it showed another side to her.
i don't know why people are comparing sales when it's a video to show the difference of the performances of the song. personally, i think alex's version of this song was much better, more control, power and an overall strong performance.
This isn't even a contest. Alexandra stomped Leona with this song. Leona was so flat and pitchy throughout the whole performance, it wasn't even funny...That is, until 3:16 when she started doing the chicken dance. I laughed so hard, I was in tears! XD
Both are awesome.
BarbraKing 1 month ago
leona sounds like an angel and so sweet..
and for u people who think shes ugly and uses that as a reason for not liking her, just proves you love the looks and not the voice, you shouldnt even be here
hihello121 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if you mistook leona for an angel singing
getitherereloaded 3 months ago in playlist X Factor
LEONA MAKES ME CRY AND IM A BLOKE
getitherereloaded 4 months ago in playlist X-Factor
Comment removed
getitherereloaded 4 months ago
Leona has a great voice, but not for this song
Alex has an amazing voice in this song, but i don;t see her do Bleeding Lvoe as good as Leona
tim8511 5 months ago
Leona by far, she sang it how its supposed to sound, she's also the only out of the two to sing on the same stage as Mariah as an equal, not a contestant
DaleMaloneMusic 5 months ago
Alex made this song's note lower to make sure that she won't fail at this song~
that not fair to compare them together~
cantbeliev 7 months ago
alexandra wins this and anyways alex is a far better performer.....
alexburkeisamazin 7 months ago
@alexburkeisamazin Is she? is that why she's no longer famous? or why she never broke America? Though Alexandra retired or something, where is she when Leona is currently number 2 in the charts?
DaleMaloneMusic 5 months ago
@DaleMaloneMusic yes she is..what are you on about shes no longer famous??:L:L....she hasnt braught her music to america YET,but that will change very soon.and alexandra has a new single out next week fyi....i love leona to but i think alex is a better performer...
alexburkeisamazin 5 months ago
@alexburkeisamazin just give it up, alex can't beat leona......
hihello121 5 months ago
@hihello121 alexandra was born with the talent she has leona was taught how to sing. alexandra is better looking better at dancing better perfromer and better singer.....
alexburkeisamazin 5 months ago
@alexburkeisamazin not a better singer, clearly not leona has a 3 octave range, Alexandra has 2 and thinks shes beyonce, thats why no one gives a shit about her
DaleMaloneMusic 5 months ago
@alexburkeisamazin better looking? LOL no cavalli invites for her now is there? And 2.2 octaves is so much better than 3.1 *sigh*
DelightFoolVlog 4 months ago
@DelightFoolVlog LEONA WILL ALWAYS BE A BETTER SINGER
getitherereloaded 4 months ago
I love them both, both have incredible voices. if i was judging... id probs say alex sang that song better but leona has the better voice overall i think... depends which songs really! 1-1 i think! :)
1994rollercoaster1 8 months ago
Leona Lewis = Ryu
Alexandra Burke = Ken
Pixie Lott = Chun-Li
And Cheryl Cole is................
Bison
Bellamyfanboy 9 months ago
both are shit compare to mariah FACT.
carshe209 10 months ago
@carshe209 Who said anything about Mariah, this is how the comparison starts...this is Leona and Alex. Mariah has no relevance.
joshpheonix 9 months ago
@joshpheonix irrelevant? lmfao, leona and alex sang it just like mariah's version.. not the jackson 5 or michael jackson version.. leona sang it in faster tempo, alex sang it the same with mariah's tempo but in lowered key.. both leona and alex copied mariah's ''iiiyeah iiyeah iiyeah iiyeah'' signature belt of mc, so what's irrelevant now? lmfao
carshe209 9 months ago
@carshe209 Yep...They sang her cover but this is comparing Leona and alex while singing a mariah song, Mariah isn't singing in this.
joshpheonix 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alex is ALOT better at this song. Leona sings it way to high!!!!
xReesx17 10 months ago 69
@xReesx17 Leona sings it high cause thats how high it is and cause she can sing it high, she can only sing it low. Alexandra is one sided
DaleMaloneMusic 5 months ago
@xReesx17 In her dreams
getitherereloaded 4 months ago
@xReesx17 STFU up you fat bitch..
getitherereloaded 3 months ago in playlist X Factor
i think alexes voice is grate i went to her concert and it was grate so i think alex 4 eva i love you alex well done for winning the x factor
Faiigyyy 11 months ago
leona lewis the best everyone knows that
1leonalewisfan 11 months ago
leona lewis is well better people are forgettin that this was leonas first week on the xfactor and all shes done since is get better, so leona hands down although alex is good herself leona all the way
MrBenterry 11 months ago
No way can alex can be beaten she is millins way better dabn leona but i love leona
sephyy135 1 year ago
I love them both exactly the same amount.
TheFear1611 1 year ago
I'm Sorry But Who is Alexandra Burkes? I Love Leona Lewis. Leona Wins Cux Shes A Million Times Better And Because No One Comes Close To Her Beautiful Voice.
OMGImJustToAwesome 1 year ago
i think its whatever im in the mood for because my opinion changes on which i prefer on any given day. both voices are great and its clear that they have both went for different paths of music that they produce. alex is more pop and leonas is more rnb.
giggles628000000 1 year ago
neither of their voices are completely leona is a replica of mariah, and alex has hints of whitney , but alex has more soul i would rather listen to alex
bigteerules 1 year ago
Leona Lewis. Burkes Aint Got Shit her.
TheSarah1213 1 year ago 2
Would like to see them two doing a duet together, that would be a Sellout thats for sure!
Lauraukify 1 year ago
Leona Lewis! Duh! Shes The Best! I dont Evenn Know Who Alexandra Burkes Is.
xxMarvinAxJLSxx 1 year ago 3
Alexandra- 10 times the soul
99cachorro 1 year ago
they are both amazing
MrsLautner1992 1 year ago
Deifnately Alexandra!!!
Dollykirsty 1 year ago
leona 4sure who's alexandra?
bigdaddyfranchise 1 year ago
Definitely Leona. Her voice is so much more unique. I don't think this was the best song for Alexandra.
thatchickulike89 1 year ago 3
alexandra is much better! team alexandra x
XsxcannieX 1 year ago
On this song, Alexandra is far better, Leona sound like a little girl screaming in the chorus, Alexandra has a powerful and soulful voice, which is exactly what this song needs :) However, there is no denying Leona's voice is also amazing :)
PorkPieish 1 year ago
ALEXANDRA!!!!!!!!!!!!
didi2ufo 1 year ago
LEONA LEWIS! Alexandra has no fuckin chance against herl! Like Leona's voice is more soft and just perfect unlike alex's manly ass deep voice!LEONA LEWIS LOVER FOREVER! FUCK ALL YOU HATERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Musicluv3R4life1997 1 year ago 2
Alexandra reminds me Withney, Leona reminds me Mariah. Both are divas!
JoaoEliezervi 1 year ago 14
I love Leona and I'm afan of Alex's too, but she has never had the voice like Leona. I think Alex sings in a different key as she can't sing high like Leona
love4musicuk 1 year ago 2
leona is absolute winner, when alexandra sings high tones it hears like she cant
nika0zibrat 1 year ago 2
its hard to say who is better,i however think alex is best she sings up tempo better than leona,come to think of it what fast up tempo songs has leona done. as far as allround performance is concerned alex wins hands down. i would like to add they both have excellent voices.
6REYAL6kcirb 1 year ago
1º mariah carey
2º leona lewis
3º alexandra burke
lufemaciel123 1 year ago 5
alexandra you are amazing. But against leona. dream on x
DanScot19 1 year ago
as "clearer" as her voice is, cant compare to such an interesting and angelic voice...
yaznel1 1 year ago 4
Simon said it himself. She is the best talent to ever come out of the X Factor. She is as good as Mariah and maybe even Whitney. (I haven't even said her name, I bet you all know who I am talking about lol)
theone225 1 year ago
Leona is better obviously! more unique!
Alexandra's voice is not unique at all...
CharmingBabyDoll 1 year ago
Leona missed a lot of the lower beats though; and everybody forgets that because shes very good at singing up-tempo =/
teamxtreme2000 1 year ago
Both are very good, they have different colour of voice...great singersxxx
marykeyooo 1 year ago
leona... she's amazing. but the competition is very interesting... they both are so good
valebsbnsync5 1 year ago
Leona kind of reminds me of mirah then you get alexandra who is Whitney haha *not being racist or any thing but they do sound kind of the same* x
amylouise145 1 year ago
LEONAAAA MUCH BETTER! though Leona did some weird gestures... :P
mariliap 1 year ago
LEONAAAA
mariliap 1 year ago
Simon said it all !
wwwfungodoctorcom 1 year ago
I think Alexandra's version was better in my opinion. Im not saying Leona doesnt have a beautiful voice because she does but the other songs she did on the show were way better than this for her. just my opinion :)
thebunny14 1 year ago 3
Leona Won Easily.
DanScot19 1 year ago 3
Leona has a better voice....
StunnaLadyy 1 year ago 3
leona wins!
MultiAshrocks 1 year ago 3
Alexandra has the more powerful voice like a Whitney Houston type, while Leona's sound a little different range like a Mariah Carey type. My opinion anyway! and i prefer Leona's voice btw!
Takeshiii 1 year ago
alexandraaa
MsxKiimx 1 year ago
leona :)
dinagape 1 year ago 3
Alex sings it way Better, Leona sounds horrible!! love them both though
xReesx17 1 year ago
i love both of them but i prefer Leona's voice.
Lien0120 1 year ago 2
leona lewis again x x x
twinsmummy119 1 year ago 2
leona is 100% better hello
BabyTroublezz123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Call me mad but I actually prefer Alexandra's voice.
Mongoose015 1 year ago
Comment removed
Mongoose015 1 year ago
I think these two are UK's biggest and baddest divas! I love them both! I hope Alex can follow in Leona's footsteps and be just as successful cause she deserves everybit of it!
AlexandraBurkeFanS2 1 year ago
Theyre both brilliant but theyve both become different types of artists so you cant really say whose better, their voices are suited to their style of music
but if i was to say who i thought was better in this song... I'd have to say Leona - cz her voice is amazing and i just love her <3
but on the other hand if we were talking about who is the better dancer... I'd have to say Alexandra ofc!!
laughingqueen78 1 year ago
Well - there is 1000,s like Alexandra out there
But there is only one Leona - FACT
BTW. Leonas first performance on X-factor - and it could be seen, she was very nerveus -
DaJokern 1 year ago
Alexandra !!
merister124 1 year ago
Both are Amazing!!<3
Krystof123456 1 year ago
leona woudl weep alexandras voice is muchhhhh sweeter.
gercc89 1 year ago
i vote for Leona...
Mapuiasailo 1 year ago
Alexandra Burke is the one- she knows when to sing it straight - and when to discover a new note - without trilling.
And ha ha unfortunately for Leona, Simon hit the nail on the head by not even commenting on her vocals. 'Something special' aka you 'look like a pop star'
Delmundo2002 1 year ago
Comment removed
Delmundo2002 1 year ago
nobody can beat leona....LEONA the best
mhafizan 1 year ago 4
Alexandra by a clear mile Leona has the most annoying habit of putting extra notes at the end of one syllable words like "I'll be thee-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-re" its unnecessarry and grates on my nerves x
Mattbroon2468 1 year ago
Comment removed
Jin3011 1 year ago
Hey...Leona's voice cant be beaten...alex's voice is usual, there is not something original about her voice and her songs..
LEONA 4 ever!!!
BraiNfreeZee3 1 year ago 11
@BraiNfreeZee3 hard out ! Leona's awesome and has more soul
trishybbi 1 year ago
@BraiNfreeZee3 Sorry as music producer Leona is a copy voice.. she hasnt a own style.. and she is screaming only!
Bragko 1 year ago
The difference between these two is simple: Leona is about singing the high notes, while Alexandra is about singing the right notes.
clavix88 1 year ago
ummm both different artist but leona is way better! whos made it worldwide!
LEONA LEWIS X
Richard91James 1 year ago 3
Leona. Idon´t like Alexandra´s voice, it´s so low just like a man
Nafijasecret 1 year ago 2
i like both but favor alexandra....
Scorpionchula88 1 year ago
i prefer alexandras voice, although leona is outstanding. i think alexandras is much more stronger and powerful whereas leonas has quite a high pitched voice, but they are both amazing.
WeLoveAlexandraB 1 year ago 4
i like leona's voice more normally, but I like alexandra's version of this particular song more.
SugarLoveForever 1 year ago
How can you destroy a such a beautiful song with all this clip ???
Manne18 1 year ago
Alexandra's voice is stronger than Leona's alot of the time i think
littlegemzi 1 year ago
ALEX ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!! Leona's also good, but nowhere near to alex, she's got such a powerful and beautiful voice!!!!!!
96raindrop96 1 year ago
leona is an other level than alexandra! alexandra is just level:beyonce, christina and leona :mariah and celine! but i love both the same! alexandras music is bether for dancing! XDD
EtNiEsBoY0016 1 year ago
alex sounded so much more controlled than leona's version...but she was younger then...
stopteasinme 1 year ago
i don't like leona's movements, i think that is why now she keeps us entertained by enthrawling us with her voice and not by dancing - as she doesn't look professional when she dances about. However, she is still fantastic. Alexandra is also amazing, and can own the stage with dancing aswell as belting out the ballards.
TuneeTube 1 year ago
Both songs are different keys....
dahomosapien 1 year ago
not being horrid to leona but its only when u put her voice alongside alexandras u realise how out of tune she actually sounds at some points, spesh between 3.30 onwards
Kelmurf313 1 year ago
alexandra was clearer but the sound of her voice is control and sound like the majority of good singers. they don't need that they need a different voice which is leona.
mtgcollector2005 1 year ago
lol black people Americas a shithole and you know it
sanjayproduction 1 year ago
We need to stop comparing these two singers-yes they both came from the same talent show but that doesnt mean we have to chose the best one! We, britain, should be proud to have such great talent such as these two-both have gone in two different pathways of music, alex-uptempo and leona-ballads! Lets be proud of these two great singers! I love both!
superman0798 1 year ago
leona lewis!!!!! la adoro!!
crisinguer 1 year ago
I have to admit in this comparison Alexandra gives a more solid vocal performance - but I think Leona has a better vocal ability.
eatmyshorts4321 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
leona is truly the best singer, ever come from an idol show WORLDWIDE! really, truly amazing. she's got everything! voice, beauty and most of all the most wonderful character. pure inspiration! we need more people like leona! biggest idol ever! but alexandra is also really great. belive me, in germany we have idols not half so good like leona and alexandra.
w1o2n3n4y 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
leona is truly the best singer, ever come from an idol show WORLDWIDE! really, truly amazing. she's got everything! voice, beauty and most of all the most wonderful character. pure inspiration! we need more people like leona! biggest idol ever! but alexandra is also good.
w1o2n3n4y 1 year ago
they were both terrrible, but if i had to choose ,, the chick with the black hair.
funnyfacerful 1 year ago
@funnyfacerful hey, alex's amazing!!! she's the 1 with the black hair, she's def not terrible!!
96raindrop96 1 year ago
Both Voices are great, when Alexandra sings that song it sounds more clear and stronger, but Leonas voice has a special sound, it's different than usual singers it has a special note would i say. So Leona is here definately better!
WindofVerdure 1 year ago
@WindofVerdure no, leona's normal alex is the exeptional 1 in here!!! well like both, but alex is A LOTLOT better!!!!
96raindrop96 1 year ago
@96raindrop96 I like also both, they are great singers, but seroiusly mate i heard a lot of good voices, but leona has a special Voice sounds really feminine.
Thats why she is my favourite.
WindofVerdure 1 year ago
@WindofVerdure yeah, I get it, but alexandra has got a very deep and powerful voice that gives me goosebumps... they're very different and actually should't b compared like this just coz they're from x factor :) and leona's a brilliant artist too, I have all her albums, so it's not like I hate her, I just like alex better ;)
96raindrop96 1 year ago
I seriously feel I need to put my point in on this debate! I think for this song Alexandra won - however overall based on more singing talent - Leona is by far superior to Alexandra.
Those who are saying GaGa is the best singer - go clean your ear's out - she is about performance & shocking people, singing talent - jesus there not there at all, don't be so pathetic!
JFletch87 1 year ago
Alex for Sure, Leona sounds horrible!!
xReesx17 1 year ago
Up to that point, Leona Lewis was a more highly trained singer who had a record deal with a company, that didn't do anything with her before X-factor. Alexandra is a more of a raw singer that is still developing. So a comparison now would be a lot different than back then.
Sojujinn 1 year ago
leona was off tune oh so very slightly in parts. Alexandras was excelent. They're both amazing xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Brukzy2693 1 year ago
Alexandra :)
arahnamantos 1 year ago
Obie są świetne i obie bardzo lubię, ale jak mam wybierać to wolę Leonę:)
16weronika 1 year ago
im sorry i love leona but she failed in this song
tornzy 1 year ago
Alexandra :)
IsriBlubb 1 year ago
i prefer leona (:
enelozful 1 year ago
Def Alexandra all the way, has a better voice & 100% got the hole pacage. Leona can sing but for me there has always been some thing missing & dont like her stuff, dont no why but def Alexandra for me!!!!!!!!! <3 :)
misscoyotelove 1 year ago
Leona is way better!!!!!!!!! Alexandra is just a copycat :PPPPPPP
xR0cKabiLLYPriNcEsSx 1 year ago
IS EVERYONE LISTENING TO THE SAME THING I AM LISTENING. IT SOUNDS LIKE LEONA IS DYING AND CANT PERFORM LIVE! it sounds like she is trying to replicate the notes that Mariah Carey and not the feeling of songs or purpose of song. SO ALEXANDRIA WINS HANDS DOWN
P.S. her name is ALEXANDRA not Alexander DAMN IT THAT ANNOYS ME lol.
claudettelover 1 year ago
@claudettelover bog off leona dusent sound like she is dying dam you sucker
merlinsnape 1 year ago
Alexandra definately wins, 100%
booooth 1 year ago
Leona is overall better but i think alex won it here :) It may be because leona got the song during the first week and elex had had time to develope her voice,
puresapphire4eva 1 year ago
As a singer I prefer Alexandra but for this song Leona is defo better ! :) xx
Youknowmexx 1 year ago
leona wasn't at her best here. As Simon pointed out, she was extremely nervous being the last to perform after hearing all her talented competitors. I think both are great, very talented singers.
marklung 1 year ago
Alexandra's voice is much clearer!
RihannaFanNL 1 year ago 28
1:0 Leona.But,Alexandra is also AMAZING!Love her Duet with Beyonce.
hjs480 1 year ago
I love them both. WELL DONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Disneyrocks3211 2 years ago
I think there both amazing singers, just down to whose sound you prefer really
Also have to remember that 'i'll be there' was the first song leona done on the show so she might not have been as confidence...
protenc 2 years ago
the one with the blonde hair
2sissylalas 2 years ago
Alex by a mile a smooth world class performance , Leona sounds like a cat on a hot tin roof her voice is up and down and all over the place with no control, and simon is an utter arogant controlling prick.
alextwowin 2 years ago
I loveeee both of them .. but Leona's voice is absolutely amazing, it's unique!!
kkkvicente69 2 years ago
They're on the same level, just in their different ways... Voices are completly different... but equally amazing...
VivaLaBaditude 2 years ago
Alexandra I think is the better performer though...
VivaLaBaditude 2 years ago
Both have diff'rent vocal tones and ranges. Alex has a cool dark tone compared to Leona's light and distinct voice that can be compared along renowned divas like MC, etc. I prefer Alex moves here coz she performed with class and grace.
ramosity 2 years ago
Leona, i like Alexandra too, but leona can make more thing with her beatuful voice, it¡s more happy, not serious as alexandra's voice
cl0daxx 2 years ago 3
Leona by far but at the end of the day they are both great singers so what people prefer is down to personal preference.
lol @alextwowin your the kind of stan that I dislike - yours opinion isnt fact!
zccajj 2 years ago 2
Just found this video. I don't even know which one is which. I like them both (from what you can hear from this clip), but I like the gal with the black hair somewhat better.
MaxWindshear 2 years ago
Are you serious guys? Alexandra clearly. She's got so much more oomph/power behind her voice. Just because Leona's tones are more like Mariah's does not mean she's a better singer. It's not 'who is mroe like Mariah' it's 'who is a better singer'. In this example Leona lacks power and control in comparison.
Don't get me wrong - I like Leona a lot. But Alex is a class above here.
123444122 2 years ago
Both are GREAT.
But I'm so spoiled by Leona's voice. it's been awhile we heard a voice that's in a league with Mariah, Whitney, Celine. I'm not comparing her to any of these artists. as Leona is LEONA.
Yes this performance was a bit pitchy. but it's unfair to judge by juz one performance. Now she's an international star.
ArtKu33 2 years ago
Get ready for the arrival of Leona's new single, 'I Got You' making it's way via download this coming Sunday, then CD the following Monday!
Richard91James 2 years ago 2
obviously leona wins hands down. alex is great nonetheless
ash62646582 2 years ago 3
Alex is miles better it is so blindingly obvious, you Leona stans make yourselves sound rediculous to say otherwise or you are actually tone deaf.
alextwowin 2 years ago
Alexandra is really good, but I love Leona and think she did a better job.
Kathryn0505 2 years ago 3
LEONA!!!!! Alexandra has a beautiful voice but Leona is a little better
KellyLuvsHockey 2 years ago 35
@KellyLuvsHockey Alex way better.
tarny11 1 year ago
@KellyLuvsHockey nooo way, if to consider all parameters Alexandra is waaaaay better!!!!!
KZDishka 1 year ago
personally iliked alex way better.!! imen dont get me wrong im a fan of leona lewis but in this song alex's voice is way strong and the way she sounds is amazing...she doesn't over do it at all and she jus sounds great.!!!
HisMrsBrown22 2 years ago
Leona sang Ill be There Better,,but ii still liked Alex
javarie19 2 years ago 3
alex the bomb!!!!
MIMIGLITTER 2 years ago
I really really think leona is better than alex. i mean, lets be fair people. Lets not compare what they have achieved. Leona has a much better, more friendlier and distinctive tone than alex. Artistes like alex are good, but she can not be compared to mariah or whitney, whereas, Leona, who might not be there yet, has what it takes to be the next mariah or whitney.
ash62646582 2 years ago 3
i like the both of them
shinjuya 2 years ago 3
I like Leona's performance better because it was more agile.
silentknight826 2 years ago 3
i do have to comment about simon's comments about alexandra, 'whitney last week mariah this week' erm isn't that what leona did? (not leona bashing)
darren246x 2 years ago 3
@darren246x I think what he meant is that we've already had a strong female whitney/mariah-esque X Factor winner and we don't need another one. That's why I think he liked her more when she sang candyman, because it showed another side to her.
silentknight826 2 years ago
Comment removed
CheezyCheez2008 2 years ago
i don't know why people are comparing sales when it's a video to show the difference of the performances of the song. personally, i think alex's version of this song was much better, more control, power and an overall strong performance.
darren246x 2 years ago
I think that alexandra is better than Leona. She have a beautiful voice, and she have a better voice control than leona. I think she's amazing.
Taniinha 2 years ago
This isn't even a contest. Alexandra stomped Leona with this song. Leona was so flat and pitchy throughout the whole performance, it wasn't even funny...That is, until 3:16 when she started doing the chicken dance. I laughed so hard, I was in tears! XD
superx57 2 years ago
LOOOL Leona is flat the whole song, you have what they call Leona worship selective hearing.
alextwowin 2 years ago
1. Michael
2. Mariah
3 Alexandra AND Leona Love them all!
Raoulirshan 2 years ago
leona is better,,,hands down!!!! like at 0:57/0:58 alex waz defo a bit flat! and at 1:13 alex went flat again!!
i mean come on like!!! at 1:30 look at that powerful note leona gives!!!! shes amazing
i luv dem both but i defo perfer leona!x
shanzx0x 2 years ago
@shanzx0x I AGREE WITH U TOTALLY!