im a skins fan, and even ill admit hester is number 1. he broke the record in 5 seasons, it took mitchell his whole career to set that record. i really appreciate what he did for us, but be serious, hester is obviously #1
I grew up in Lafayette, Louisiana, and got to watch Mitchell at ULL (USL then), and it was an amazing treat. It's ridiculous that anyone would rank him #2.
I grew up in Lafayette, Louisiana, and got to watch Mitchell at ULL (USL then), and it was an amazing treat. It's ridiculous that anyone would rank him #2.
I remember that kick he had against the Giants with no time left on the clock at the Meadowlands where basically the Eagles usually won singlehandedly all the time when they played the Giants.
PPL have to give D.Hest some time! He already surpassed b-mitch records and returned a FIELD GOAL for a touch...noobdy ever EEEEVER saw Mitchell return a short FIELD GOAL for a touchdown ...never EVER. Hester #1 Superbowl BEARS 2010-2011!!
devin hester is CLEARLY better than him... hester has the record now and as @MeastMusic said he is barely even a returner now... plus he has at least 4-5 more years in him
i disagree with the list...mitchell held all the records. even though hester had one amazing season, its to early to say hes the best returner of all time...i agree with Campbell7204...he hasnt done anything lately
How can you be second in NFL history in total yards from scrimmage, only behind Jerry Rice and have the most returns for TDs and be second? What because Hester is close to breaking the returns record? Well until Hester breaks that record, he is second. He doesn't have the yards and tds. Sometimes these lists try to outsmart themselves. Get over yourself analysts. Mitchell is no question the best return man in NFL history, period flat!
Mitchell is no where near being number 1He was in the the Nfl for 20 years so of course he has alot of records . This is called "compling" where a good or average player accumulates alot of numbers because they where around a long time . Anybody who knows anything about return men Whites johnson and deion sanders are at the top
mitchell was the greatest. longevity is part of being great. any guy who can return kicks and punts for 14 straight seasons is the best. better than deion, and better than white shoes.
he has the 2nd most total yards from scrimmage in NFL HISTORY!
that counts every position. not just returners. guess whos number one? Jerry Rice. hes not only the best returner, but he is one of the best PLAYERS in nfl history. he is so underrated.
hester might break his td record, but he will never break his yard record. this guy averaged so much yards per return in was unbelievable. he had like 75 returns of 50 yards or more.
I dont think there is any doubt that Brian Mitchell is number 1. They got it wrong on this one. Im not saying that Devin Hester isnt a good player but he had a great year in returns not a great career.
Wow, how can they put Hester at #1? You have to do it for an entire career. Not just two years. Hester is barely a kick returner now, since the Bears moved him to WR. That's a joke. B-Mitch should clearly be #1.
sike Devin Hester is the best Hester's career was never over he should have the record right now (14) but he'll stick with the 13 he has. The league now now respects Hester and teams don't want to kick to hester anymore- Brian Mitchell was never a great as Hester....Hester returned 13 TDs in only 5 seasons!
I rather kick to everyone on this list except Hester.
@DeeJayDPGC Hester have the record now, it took Mitchell 1,047 kickoff to get 13 TDs, it took Hester 237 kickoff to get 14 TDS, Now He deserve the Number 1 spot
@MeastMusic Here the list of top 10 returns in my opinion 1.Brian Mitchell 2.Eric Metcalf 3.Dante' Hall 4.Leroy Little (60's Halfback for Broncos) 5.Antwaan Randle El 6.Leroy Kelly (60's Halfback for Browns) 7.Cliff Harris (70's Free Safety for Cowboys) 8.Josh Cribbs 9.George McAfee (50's Halfback/Conerback for Bears) 10.Hester
@MeastMusic Hester have the record now, it took Mitchell 1,047 kickoff to get 13 TDs, it took Hester 237 kickoff to get 14 TDS, Now He deserve the Number 1 spot
@MeastMusic i would have agreed with you when you posted this, but now hester beats Mitchell's record and it only took him 5 seasons vs 13 or so that brian had so, he is for sure #1
@hester23allday hahaha I've seen it all now. A 10 year old ginger kid telling me to get a life. you'll be lucky if you ever get a girl to come within 20 ft of you, you little fuck.
no one in the history of the NFL has had more than 4 kickoff and punt return touchdowns in a season; hester has done it twice. AND he now has the record.
@MeastMusic you are snorting crack. well i guess cuz you said it 2 years ago. it took brian mitchell 1081 kick/punt returns to get 13, it took dhest 289 to get 14, nuff said
ik he is, look at da status
ComeGetDylified 2 months ago
Hester is better
ComeGetDylified 2 months ago
@ComeGetDylified YOU WISH
Lilwanye4ev3r 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When this show aired, maybe Hester wasn't the best yet. But Hester is definitely number 1 now.
thisisntme 3 months ago
im a skins fan, and even ill admit hester is number 1. he broke the record in 5 seasons, it took mitchell his whole career to set that record. i really appreciate what he did for us, but be serious, hester is obviously #1
HKISfreak1 4 months ago
Hester has the most Returns for a TD & has done it in the least amount of time so.... ya he's #1 guys sorry
cbcw24 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I grew up in Lafayette, Louisiana, and got to watch Mitchell at ULL (USL then), and it was an amazing treat. It's ridiculous that anyone would rank him #2.
rbstubblefield 11 months ago
I grew up in Lafayette, Louisiana, and got to watch Mitchell at ULL (USL then), and it was an amazing treat. It's ridiculous that anyone would rank him #2.
rbstubblefield 11 months ago
I remember that kick he had against the Giants with no time left on the clock at the Meadowlands where basically the Eagles usually won singlehandedly all the time when they played the Giants.
WEINBAUER 1 year ago
PPL have to give D.Hest some time! He already surpassed b-mitch records and returned a FIELD GOAL for a touch...noobdy ever EEEEVER saw Mitchell return a short FIELD GOAL for a touchdown ...never EVER. Hester #1 Superbowl BEARS 2010-2011!!
irishbearsfan12 1 year ago
hester makes this guy look like my little sister
hokeyboi11 1 year ago
HESTER HESTER HESTER
DaBearsManiac 1 year ago
thats like telling me dora the explorer the greatest cartoon over bugs bunny
TheFreeRunningKrew 1 year ago
any hester doubters anymore? thought so
captainbrush 1 year ago 2
devin hester is CLEARLY better than him... hester has the record now and as @MeastMusic said he is barely even a returner now... plus he has at least 4-5 more years in him
ey2578 1 year ago 2
devin hester just broke the record
threezy350 1 year ago 2
If any one needs any questions about Brian Mitchell's life, tell me I will ask him (I have ways)
iSmugglez 1 year ago
I was at the mall today and brian mitchell was in one of the stores signing autographs!! He is gettin old
beernuts100 1 year ago
Watching him in an Eagles jersey makes me want to say something.
Dan Snyder, go to hell.
Tork110 1 year ago
Hester is coming bitches!!!
TheFanofeminem 1 year ago
yeah hester will be the greatest of all time when its done
DaBearsManiac 1 year ago
I think about half of the highlights were against the Cardinals.
johnskudris 1 year ago
how many return TD's did he get?13...Devin Hester got 11 in 2 seasons. He is the greatest return man ever
TheCOLTSallDAY 1 year ago
Brian has 13 total special team touchdown returns> Bull krap he should be #1. They put hester at 1 cause of his ROOKIE season, GAY!
1001Meat 1 year ago
I Like A Fight... :)
A Legal One.
Z3koD3vo 1 year ago
i disagree with the list...mitchell held all the records. even though hester had one amazing season, its to early to say hes the best returner of all time...i agree with Campbell7204...he hasnt done anything lately
skinfan18 2 years ago
hester's only 1 away......
sweatyteddy2012 2 years ago
hester hasnt done anything significant in 2 years.
Campbell7204 2 years ago
who was number 1
5857612 2 years ago
How can you be second in NFL history in total yards from scrimmage, only behind Jerry Rice and have the most returns for TDs and be second? What because Hester is close to breaking the returns record? Well until Hester breaks that record, he is second. He doesn't have the yards and tds. Sometimes these lists try to outsmart themselves. Get over yourself analysts. Mitchell is no question the best return man in NFL history, period flat!
mcarey032 2 years ago
Mitchell is no where near being number 1He was in the the Nfl for 20 years so of course he has alot of records . This is called "compling" where a good or average player accumulates alot of numbers because they where around a long time . Anybody who knows anything about return men Whites johnson and deion sanders are at the top
blaq7427 2 years ago
mitchell was the greatest. longevity is part of being great. any guy who can return kicks and punts for 14 straight seasons is the best. better than deion, and better than white shoes.
Campbell7204 2 years ago
@blaq7427
your a dumb ass
he was in the nfl for 13 years.
he has the 2nd most total yards from scrimmage in NFL HISTORY!
that counts every position. not just returners. guess whos number one? Jerry Rice. hes not only the best returner, but he is one of the best PLAYERS in nfl history. he is so underrated.
hester might break his td record, but he will never break his yard record. this guy averaged so much yards per return in was unbelievable. he had like 75 returns of 50 yards or more.
sedro32 1 year ago
He should be Number 1
Ur right
Damon089 2 years ago
this is exactly why randle el cnt return punts
troy6492 2 years ago 8
I dont think there is any doubt that Brian Mitchell is number 1. They got it wrong on this one. Im not saying that Devin Hester isnt a good player but he had a great year in returns not a great career.
sharks27 2 years ago
Wow, how can they put Hester at #1? You have to do it for an entire career. Not just two years. Hester is barely a kick returner now, since the Bears moved him to WR. That's a joke. B-Mitch should clearly be #1.
MeastMusic 2 years ago 7
exactly, thats wh at i think too
DeeJayDPGC 2 years ago
@DeeJayDPGC
foot in mouth
HesterOwns4Chii 1 year ago
@DeeJayDPGC
sike Devin Hester is the best Hester's career was never over he should have the record right now (14) but he'll stick with the 13 he has. The league now now respects Hester and teams don't want to kick to hester anymore- Brian Mitchell was never a great as Hester....Hester returned 13 TDs in only 5 seasons!
I rather kick to everyone on this list except Hester.
D3V1NH3ST3R23 1 year ago
@DeeJayDPGC Hester have the record now, it took Mitchell 1,047 kickoff to get 13 TDs, it took Hester 237 kickoff to get 14 TDS, Now He deserve the Number 1 spot
freezer70 1 year ago
1001Meat 1 year ago
@1001Meat probably you mean FLOYD Little of the Broncos, anyway I think Devin Hester should be higher on your list, bye from a Broncofan
turboreattore 1 year ago
@MeastMusic lol he tied brian mitchell`s record in only 4 years.basically 3
davidisraw 1 year ago
@MeastMusic Hester have the record now, it took Mitchell 1,047 kickoff to get 13 TDs, it took Hester 237 kickoff to get 14 TDS, Now He deserve the Number 1 spot
freezer70 1 year ago
@MeastMusic You should recheck your stats...hester now holds the record, and is going to smash Mitchell's by the time hes finished
keeponkeepinon88 1 year ago
@keeponkeepinon88 look when I posted the comment dipshit...
MeastMusic 1 year ago
@MeastMusic NO I know I saw that, but even a year ago, he was two away from the record .....still obviously the most electric kick returner
keeponkeepinon88 1 year ago
@MeastMusic i would have agreed with you when you posted this, but now hester beats Mitchell's record and it only took him 5 seasons vs 13 or so that brian had so, he is for sure #1
geabus1043 1 year ago
@MeastMusic WRONG!!!!!!!!!
hester23allday 1 year ago
@hester23allday Look when I posted the comment dumbass.
MeastMusic 1 year ago
@MeastMusic who gives a crap u said it
hester23allday 7 months ago
@hester23allday Way to reply to a comment 6 months after it was made, kid.
MeastMusic 7 months ago
@MeastMusic im sorry i dont sit home and stay on youtube all my life loser
hester23allday 6 months ago
@hester23allday hahaha I've seen it all now. A 10 year old ginger kid telling me to get a life. you'll be lucky if you ever get a girl to come within 20 ft of you, you little fuck.
MeastMusic 6 months ago
@MeastMusic
well hes number 1 now isnt he?
hester is the best ever BY FAR.
no one in the history of the NFL has had more than 4 kickoff and punt return touchdowns in a season; hester has done it twice. AND he now has the record.
spyhunter1223 1 year ago
@spyhunter1223 ya seriously. hester is #1. no doubt about it
ThemagicPerson100 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MeastMusic what are you saying one year later on this subject?
bissoc14 7 months ago
@MeastMusic now, he is the greatest. he got his talent back. the only reason he did poorly was because he got terrible kicks during 2008 and 2009.
TheCarolStreamKid 4 months ago
@MeastMusic you are snorting crack. well i guess cuz you said it 2 years ago. it took brian mitchell 1081 kick/punt returns to get 13, it took dhest 289 to get 14, nuff said
miamihurricanes471 4 months ago
@MeastMusic
I agree i think Brian Mitchell was the best, but look at Devin Hester now. I think he is clearly the best now.
futurenflstar123 3 months ago
Who was 3 and 5-10?
Coganboy 2 years ago
devin hester was number 1
DaChemist13 2 years ago
1st comment
DaChemist13 2 years ago