This is a fantastic cover, made even better by the fact that the singer just sort of switches into gibberish occasionally. No disrespect meant, it's cute.
gente, la band è meravigliosa. Trovo "leggermente" invasive le tastiere...e il cantante, mi dispiace, ma proprio non si affronta :( sembra un ragazzetto di 13 anni che si approccia per la prima volta alla musica...pronuncia a parte, le linee di Wilson sono davvero semplici...e avere problemi su di esse, è un chiaro segnale che si deve cambiare "mestiere". MA LA BAND è MOSTRUOSAMENTE BRAVA e precisa. Chapeau.
This is a very, VERY good cover of a great song. As for the singer, he has a really nice voice, maybe a little more work needs to be done on the pronounciation but all in all very nice guys!
I'm not crazy about the vocals only because of the accent......Would have much rather heard it in a Italian. Other than that, everything was great! Excellent drumming!
Seriously. Had a listen to a few of your covers and like them. Singer is only a problem as english is not his first language. Otherwise, all good. Keep up the good work. S
I was going to say, 'very good apart from the vocals' until I read other comments and realise you guys are Italian. Very difficult to sing anything in a foreign tongue. If you did not win the school talent contest I would love to see who did; you should have swept the floor. Well done.
@2182248 Thank you. It's not a school talent contest but only a school contest; I appreciate your words but the true is that our singer isn't to fit the other components of the band, so there is a big difference from the voice and the instruments...
band is really good. singer needs some work, a lot in the area of feel. wilson lets his singing have space, an "air" in delivery. don't push the singing. it comes across as over done. tone and pronounciation will come with practice, but delivery is a huge factor with p tree songs
i understand why the pronunciation sounds a bit funny, but give them a chance, i mean, they r italians. i see hundreds of bands here in mexico trying to sing proper english but its hard... =D keep rocking
@hybridgti Definitely positive, gentlemen. As for the voice, I'd like to hear it in a context other than a Porcupine Tree song. I think you would fit really well in some of the Aviv Geffen of Blackfield's work, like "Pain". Your voice really is fine, but of course, we're used to Wilson's :)
If you are really a tribute band than you have to work with your pronunciation. Your voice is ok, but yyou need to know what you are singing. Maybe you know, but because of your poor pronunciation it sounds as if you didn't know what you are singing. And that's the problem. Apart from that - really impressive:) Keep up the good work.
@hybridgti Hey, thanks for your response. I was also playing in a band once and our lead singer had even worse pronunciation:/, so I know somethin' about it. When people hear that somethin' is wrong (and it's easy to notice bad accent), they just don't treat you seriously. And I believe that you have great musical skills and you should be respected. Good luck :D
@jekyll66 Great man! You aren't the first person that notice this! This is a great problem for the foreign people...next step is "emulate" steven wilson, firstely in the pronunciation!!! Hola!
Fortissimi ragazzi :) se devo proprio trovare il pelo nell'uovo non mi piace molto il cantante ma avete un sound molto ben assemblato :) ottimi il batterista e il tastierista :D
strano ciò che i diga che le chitarre xe basse ciò! Mai successo soprattutto anche ultimamente...e la cosa inizia a stancarmi la prossima volta me li metto come dico io...stessa cosa me lo ha detto il gestore del barbie, il gestore del timonchio (e mi ha detto che anche altre gente gliel'aveva detto) e anche il cantante dei Toni..
What a horrible singer! And I think some of the volumes are quite low. You are all alright players though. But seriously, the pronunciation and singing was really annoying to hear, it didn't serve the song at all.
The guitars and Bass, maybe even the drums could be a little higher in volume. Don't get me wrong, you guys are very decent instrument players, I just couldn't stand the singing, because of the pitch and mainly the pronunciation.
@Fox622003: You are wrong big time. The vocals are very sensitive and real. You are pointing out things in the wrong way, try to be positive rather than that negative shit you spit out. I guess you can't reach that level yourself so please stop judging he's singing skills before you even try yourself.
They are not a cover band. The voice didn't go at all with Wilson's(nor the song, obviously), but that aside, he didn't even pronounce the words right in several parts, which makes it worse. If your voice doesn't go, and you insist on doing a cover of that song, then at least pronounce it right and hit the notes tightly.
I don't think they should play this cover with that singer, I haven't seen *their* stuff, so I can't say the singer just has a bad voice. But he does for this.
Maybe you should consider something else, then. Having a COVER band is pathetic to start with, I mean, can't you make your own music? But to be a cover band, and to suck at it, is even worse. The vocals are basic for a cover band, at least learn to pronounce in a darker way, your vocals sound too mellow or something pronounced like that, nothing to do with Steven Wilson. As I said earlier, the instrument players are all fine, the drummer's very similar to Gavin.
Loved to watch this, pretty damn well performed as a group. Takes abit courage to play this live on such a stage. And you got a kick as drummer there ;.) 5 stars
Great guys. Thanks for rockin'. ;)
clamorosissimo 2 months ago
The Drummer is My man!!! Give me his Youtube Channel!!! (if he Has one..)
PanoSsDS 2 months ago
@PanoSsDS looking for "jack furia" on facebook
hybridgti 2 months ago
Comment removed
RuneGERPlayer 3 months ago
That was really GOOD. okay, the singer could do some work, but great song covering. I overlooked the english issues.
Azured665 3 months ago
wow.
LeperAffinity 3 months ago
ok, the singer's english could use a little work, but other than that. holy wow what talent.
lanseri 3 months ago
This is a fantastic cover, made even better by the fact that the singer just sort of switches into gibberish occasionally. No disrespect meant, it's cute.
captainironears 3 months ago
Great drummer
vageosy 4 months ago
Grandi ragazzi! Solo una pecca: la chitarra troppo bassa.. Per il resto davvero un ottimo lavoro! :)
FluorescentAd7 4 months ago
The vocalist have to work in his dynamics & pronunciation otherwise the overall performance is good....
vishal1986ish 5 months ago
that guy can drum!!!! :O
sound quality is also great for a high school event!! fair play :D
bobpower 6 months ago
Wow, cool to see another band like us! I have a Porcupine Tree cover/tributeband up here in Sweden. Thou I'm italian myself =)
Work on the accent and this would be really good!
XGLDF 6 months ago
Wahahahahahha the singer suck, my flarts sounds better haahha
soywert7 8 months ago
Grandissimi!!!!! Peccato per l'audio!!
phragomen 9 months ago
I'd be shitting bricks if someone played this in my highschool!
SebVettel18 10 months ago
gente, la band è meravigliosa. Trovo "leggermente" invasive le tastiere...e il cantante, mi dispiace, ma proprio non si affronta :( sembra un ragazzetto di 13 anni che si approccia per la prima volta alla musica...pronuncia a parte, le linee di Wilson sono davvero semplici...e avere problemi su di esse, è un chiaro segnale che si deve cambiare "mestiere". MA LA BAND è MOSTRUOSAMENTE BRAVA e precisa. Chapeau.
bastardsonofBFO 1 year ago
Very good! I´m not a big fan of Mesa Rectifiers but this guitarplayer sounds great.
monspons 1 year ago
You guys are really good. The accent didn't even bug me, I would love to see someone singing in a language that they didn't grow up with.
junitsadelheid 1 year ago
The drummer looks like a cross between martin lopez and gavin harrison....and plays just as good as them too.
trouble48708 1 year ago
WOW
really fucking great cover dude..... keep rockin'
scarsickED 1 year ago
TALENT! drummer was good
killercreek450 1 year ago
I don't know what people are saying about the singer. He may have a bad accent but he's got a really good voice!! Good cover guys; I enjoyed it!
ThePurgatoryfire 1 year ago
This is a very, VERY good cover of a great song. As for the singer, he has a really nice voice, maybe a little more work needs to be done on the pronounciation but all in all very nice guys!
333Masi333 1 year ago
drummer ws awesum!!
04andrewjoseph 1 year ago 16
I'm not crazy about the vocals only because of the accent......Would have much rather heard it in a Italian. Other than that, everything was great! Excellent drumming!
SmileysRevenge100 1 year ago
hybridgti, No worries. By the way, i was at the most recent Porcupine Tree concert at the Royal Albert Hall in London. It was superb!
shearnden1 1 year ago
Seriously. Had a listen to a few of your covers and like them. Singer is only a problem as english is not his first language. Otherwise, all good. Keep up the good work. S
shearnden1 1 year ago
@shearnden1 Thank you very much! I'm happy for this comment...
hybridgti 1 year ago
From a massive Porcupine Tree, Excellent cover. like your PT stuff.
shearnden1 1 year ago
@shearnden1 Seriously? I'm surprised :-) And what about languages? You are from England....I know the singer is a problem
hybridgti 1 year ago
Well, that drummer played his ass off....
nhl22222222 1 year ago
seems like a pretty intricate set-up for a high school :D
HumanLarva 1 year ago
I was going to say, 'very good apart from the vocals' until I read other comments and realise you guys are Italian. Very difficult to sing anything in a foreign tongue. If you did not win the school talent contest I would love to see who did; you should have swept the floor. Well done.
2182248 1 year ago
@2182248 Thank you. It's not a school talent contest but only a school contest; I appreciate your words but the true is that our singer isn't to fit the other components of the band, so there is a big difference from the voice and the instruments...
hybridgti 1 year ago
@hybridgti the singer is alright! Pretty damn good actually
Traconiz 10 months ago
Little bit different lyrics than the original, but still sounds really good.
beefjirky 1 year ago
@beefjirky What you mainly messed up on was "I got writing loose inside my head." It's "wiring", not writing.
beefjirky 1 year ago
amazing, check my cover with my friend! i will subscribe, do it too if you dont mind :))
RedrumsJB 1 year ago
thumbs UP this guys are amazing
FarmACDCFreak 1 year ago 9
did you won?
FarmACDCFreak 1 year ago
@FarmACDCFreak YES!!!;-) no, it's only an highschool concert!
hybridgti 1 year ago
@hybridgti it is amazing man
FarmACDCFreak 1 year ago
drummer is amazing, he nailed it perfectly
docterblack 1 year ago
nice drums
WickedCrawl 1 year ago
I hope you guys won.
iwanttoliveinnorway 1 year ago
band is really good. singer needs some work, a lot in the area of feel. wilson lets his singing have space, an "air" in delivery. don't push the singing. it comes across as over done. tone and pronounciation will come with practice, but delivery is a huge factor with p tree songs
d3rjackal 1 year ago
very cool, congrats.
nickcasabona 1 year ago
i understand why the pronunciation sounds a bit funny, but give them a chance, i mean, they r italians. i see hundreds of bands here in mexico trying to sing proper english but its hard... =D keep rocking
FlyteDanny 1 year ago
AWSOME use of synths.
saxmachine123 1 year ago
@saxmachine123 I hope you mean that it's POSITIVE ;-) What do you think about voice? Terrific? Awful? please write sincerly
hybridgti 1 year ago
@hybridgti Definitely positive, gentlemen. As for the voice, I'd like to hear it in a context other than a Porcupine Tree song. I think you would fit really well in some of the Aviv Geffen of Blackfield's work, like "Pain". Your voice really is fine, but of course, we're used to Wilson's :)
saxmachine123 1 year ago
@saxmachine123 I can give you only an other live song by my singer whit his band, but not Wilson's project. It's made himself...
hybridgti 1 year ago
If you are really a tribute band than you have to work with your pronunciation. Your voice is ok, but yyou need to know what you are singing. Maybe you know, but because of your poor pronunciation it sounds as if you didn't know what you are singing. And that's the problem. Apart from that - really impressive:) Keep up the good work.
jekyll66 1 year ago
@jekyll66 you are right man! We'll try to improve our pronunciation!
hybridgti 1 year ago
@hybridgti Hey, thanks for your response. I was also playing in a band once and our lead singer had even worse pronunciation:/, so I know somethin' about it. When people hear that somethin' is wrong (and it's easy to notice bad accent), they just don't treat you seriously. And I believe that you have great musical skills and you should be respected. Good luck :D
jekyll66 1 year ago
@jekyll66 Great man! You aren't the first person that notice this! This is a great problem for the foreign people...next step is "emulate" steven wilson, firstely in the pronunciation!!! Hola!
hybridgti 1 year ago
Awesome!!!
platypus2501 1 year ago
Good Playing , but worst Audioquality ever!!!
Still good ;-)
Stanislav253 1 year ago
Good one guys...10/10
BuzzieBee77 1 year ago
Fortissimi ragazzi :) se devo proprio trovare il pelo nell'uovo non mi piace molto il cantante ma avete un sound molto ben assemblato :) ottimi il batterista e il tastierista :D
Psycorock92 1 year ago
damn you guys rock...
themaliced 1 year ago
very great interpretation...very good the keyboards in the intro..good arrangement..
aretusa1412 1 year ago
THX! I'm the keyboard player; in the other events my stage are 4 synths
hybridgti 1 year ago
Grandi ragazzi! Onore a chi tributa un gruppo tanto sottovalutato!
zadva 1 year ago
@zadva Grazie, non è facile apprezzare un genere così di nicchia!
hybridgti 1 year ago
Fox...te si gay...ti e toapà! magnameo
GiulioTrust 2 years ago
strano ciò che i diga che le chitarre xe basse ciò! Mai successo soprattutto anche ultimamente...e la cosa inizia a stancarmi la prossima volta me li metto come dico io...stessa cosa me lo ha detto il gestore del barbie, il gestore del timonchio (e mi ha detto che anche altre gente gliel'aveva detto) e anche il cantante dei Toni..
GiulioTrust 2 years ago
What a horrible singer! And I think some of the volumes are quite low. You are all alright players though. But seriously, the pronunciation and singing was really annoying to hear, it didn't serve the song at all.
Fox.
Fox622003 2 years ago
@Fox622003 What kind of volume?
hybridgti 2 years ago
The guitars and Bass, maybe even the drums could be a little higher in volume. Don't get me wrong, you guys are very decent instrument players, I just couldn't stand the singing, because of the pitch and mainly the pronunciation.
Fox.
Fox622003 2 years ago
@Fox622003: You are wrong big time. The vocals are very sensitive and real. You are pointing out things in the wrong way, try to be positive rather than that negative shit you spit out. I guess you can't reach that level yourself so please stop judging he's singing skills before you even try yourself.
taaken1986 2 years ago
They are not a cover band. The voice didn't go at all with Wilson's(nor the song, obviously), but that aside, he didn't even pronounce the words right in several parts, which makes it worse. If your voice doesn't go, and you insist on doing a cover of that song, then at least pronounce it right and hit the notes tightly.
I don't think they should play this cover with that singer, I haven't seen *their* stuff, so I can't say the singer just has a bad voice. But he does for this.
Fox.
Fox622003 2 years ago
@Fox622003 WE ARE A COVER BAND! WE ARE THE TRIBUTE BAND OF PT IN ITALY! If you don't like us, go to another chanel!
hybridgti 2 years ago
Maybe you should consider something else, then. Having a COVER band is pathetic to start with, I mean, can't you make your own music? But to be a cover band, and to suck at it, is even worse. The vocals are basic for a cover band, at least learn to pronounce in a darker way, your vocals sound too mellow or something pronounced like that, nothing to do with Steven Wilson. As I said earlier, the instrument players are all fine, the drummer's very similar to Gavin.
Fox.
Fox622003 2 years ago
Loved to watch this, pretty damn well performed as a group. Takes abit courage to play this live on such a stage. And you got a kick as drummer there ;.) 5 stars
taaken1986 2 years ago
Thanck very much! We love Porcupine and progressive rock and music is our passion!!!!
hybridgti 2 years ago
^___^ Thanx!
FABBBBB87 2 years ago
Bravi bravi ragazzi!! Bravo anche Giacoomo!! Complimentoni collega!! :)
FABBBBB87 2 years ago
graziie! Riferirò a chi di dovere....prog on!
hybridgti 2 years ago
Great Cover! Not easy to do
awdpth 2 years ago
tank you man! Prog on!
hybridgti 2 years ago