I learned Chinto from Shihan Frank Harvrove and he from Sensei Nagazato in Okinawa and we do it the same way as shown here.As was said 8months ago,it's a matter of interpretation
a comment on the video, you are doing a good job on Chinto, nice power. I like a little more flow. I'm not saying your are not doing it incorrectly , your style is a little different than mine is all.
Perhaps I should clarify what I mean by softening (I can only speak for myself on this)... in my opinion he needs more relaxation and overall body recruitment in his technique. Not that his technique should be soft but that he should explode and then relax. Softer as in involving less tension.
Infelizmente, faltaram os dois KIAI do KATA. Provavelmente, ele executou o CHINTO sem se preocupar com o fato de que seria gravado e exibido no YouTube... de qualquer modo, muito bem executado! Parabéns! Uma prova de que a escola do mestre Yoshihide Shinzato ("in memorian") possui KATA bem executado e esteticamente apreciável!
A shodan rendition of Chinto. He does a good job. Bunshido is correct though, his technique needs softening. And yes emotionumist he does need to include the two kiai. ;)
@reaperblacku With regards to "his technique needs softening", this kata was designed by Matsumura Sokon, the inventor of linear impact technique. There is no need to make it softer.
@MrNickjannini you need to watch a video of Master Soken (direct lineage from his great great Uncle Bushi ) doing the kata. It is a flowing kata, not rigid.
@MrNickjannini if it is a matter of interpretation why did you bring up the point of Sokon 'Bushi' Matsumura? And what Master Soken taught that was handed down to him from Bushi through Nabe Matsumura and from Master Soken to a few other, myself included. Others studeid under Bushi and incorporated it into their styles and changing the kata, and this has continued with most individuals. It's not say others are wrong, just different. But the original was a softer flowing kata.
He respect the form of Chinto but it is too rigid to be an Okinawan Shorin ryu Chinto . In Okinawa "Muchimi" is very important . Muchimi is like the waves of the sea !
Não entendo nada de karate
mais ficou bem legal o seu kata
parabéns tshio XD
AndersonDiasxD 5 months ago
I learned Chinto from Shihan Frank Harvrove and he from Sensei Nagazato in Okinawa and we do it the same way as shown here.As was said 8months ago,it's a matter of interpretation
enrique4111 7 months ago
a comment on the video, you are doing a good job on Chinto, nice power. I like a little more flow. I'm not saying your are not doing it incorrectly , your style is a little different than mine is all.
OkinawaShorinryu 1 year ago
Perhaps I should clarify what I mean by softening (I can only speak for myself on this)... in my opinion he needs more relaxation and overall body recruitment in his technique. Not that his technique should be soft but that he should explode and then relax. Softer as in involving less tension.
reaperblacku 1 year ago
Comment removed
wateronthesmoke 2 years ago
He's performing it like a Shotokan student - exactly how i (incorrectly) do Shorin-ryu kata after relocating to an area without a Shotokan dojo.
neilflat 2 years ago
It is the influence of kata's competition . They execute it too rigid as Shotokan guys , but Shorin is very flexible .
FiasaPower 2 years ago 2
Infelizmente, faltaram os dois KIAI do KATA. Provavelmente, ele executou o CHINTO sem se preocupar com o fato de que seria gravado e exibido no YouTube... de qualquer modo, muito bem executado! Parabéns! Uma prova de que a escola do mestre Yoshihide Shinzato ("in memorian") possui KATA bem executado e esteticamente apreciável!
ronnersa 3 years ago
Parabéns! muito boa apresentação desse kata.
alonsokarate 3 years ago
A shodan rendition of Chinto. He does a good job. Bunshido is correct though, his technique needs softening. And yes emotionumist he does need to include the two kiai. ;)
reaperblacku 3 years ago
@reaperblacku With regards to "his technique needs softening", this kata was designed by Matsumura Sokon, the inventor of linear impact technique. There is no need to make it softer.
MrNickjannini 1 year ago
@MrNickjannini you need to watch a video of Master Soken (direct lineage from his great great Uncle Bushi ) doing the kata. It is a flowing kata, not rigid.
OkinawaShorinryu 1 year ago
@OkinawaShorinryu It's a matter of interpretation.
MrNickjannini 1 year ago
@MrNickjannini if it is a matter of interpretation why did you bring up the point of Sokon 'Bushi' Matsumura? And what Master Soken taught that was handed down to him from Bushi through Nabe Matsumura and from Master Soken to a few other, myself included. Others studeid under Bushi and incorporated it into their styles and changing the kata, and this has continued with most individuals. It's not say others are wrong, just different. But the original was a softer flowing kata.
OkinawaShorinryu 1 year ago
@OkinawaShorinryu I think you missed my point.
MrNickjannini 1 year ago
He respect the form of Chinto but it is too rigid to be an Okinawan Shorin ryu Chinto . In Okinawa "Muchimi" is very important . Muchimi is like the waves of the sea !
bunshido 3 years ago
Estou muito feliz neste dia pois eu precisava muito ver kata que durante muito tempo atras não vejo parabens
sergioemilly 4 years ago