D-12-How Come

[reapercrewful]

WOW that is fucked up. shit to listen to when someone close fucked you over real bad. been there, had it done to me too much!!

[SIENEKEFTWLOL]

i used to make arrow to the knee jokes, then i took a vagina to the penis

[TheOriginalSimpL]

@SIENEKEFTWLOL so you been a virgin till now haha sicko no only joking haha

[YouthOfAmerica1]

This is a really good song by D12

[yankeeguy02]

this my favorite chorus in any song

[dshrute7]

rip proof. rip bugz. sad that em left. d12 was pretty amazing...

[willbrennan100]

@dshrute7 Em never left he just has other projects.... an D12 wanted to prove they can have succes without him thats half the reason u havent seen him in any D12 tracks lately.

[BuddahBuddahBuddah1]

I used to hate this song but then i took an arrow to the knee

[TheMariachi7]

@BuddahBuddahBuddah1 seriously dude.. That shit's not even funny anymore when it's commented on a video that has something to do with Skyrim.

[TheNeoNInfinite]

@BuddahBuddahBuddah1 yea no one gives a shit.

[BuddahBuddahBuddah1]

@TheNeoNInfinite I used to give a shit, but then i took a constipation to the asshole

[BuddahBuddahBuddah1]

Lebron Traveled

[vzxvvzxv123321]

sad that d12 lost the 2 best members :-( slim left and proof got shot R.I.P big proof

[MrYahtzee93]

@vzxvvzxv123321 but Em's coming back for the third album which is said to be released this year.

[dshrute7]

@vzxvvzxv123321 bugz died too. </3

[wigimanXx]

Rap died and it was buried (Underground)

[KingOfEden12]

@wigimanXx no rap turned into a mountain

its white at the top from the snow (aka eminem)

[K4inan]

Most people here probably don't know that Proof shot a man in the head over a pool game, that's why he got shot.

[degeneratelifecycle]

@K4inan Have you ever really gotten into a serious game of pool? I would do the same

[lip7100]

Proof rocks, Eminem is a hero

[DaBricks1521]

dis shyt goes hard

[XJT2010X]

Why the hell can i not get this song out my head!!

[thetechman000]

Leta get rid of all the stupid rapers that ruin this type of music

[rkholton29]

@thetechman000 I think you mean rappers, but some of them are probably rapists

[thetechman000]

@rkholton29 HAHA that is runny and i did mean rappers

[gordyy67]

:DDD <3

[JiuJitsuNate]

actually lets keep Kesha she turns me on

[MoJoThundRpants]

im glad that we no longer keep touch, fuk that bitch yo

[Bstoccs]

This that shit u listen to when 1 of ur homies bullshit or fuck u over

[slimshadyr4l]

no more xD

[MrTupacmontana]

R.I.P PROOF,R.I.P BUGZ LIKE THEY SAY THE GOOD DIE YOUNG SHAME LIL WAYNE BIEBER AND THOSESFAGS DIDNT DIE INSTEAD

[DICKIEMONSTER]

yO i used ta lov thiss yan.o ...choon

[TheMauricera]

Eminem is best....

[killa65074]

R*I*P PROOF

[montanadash20]

mr porter was ALWAYS da best in d12... n canibus actually IS kinda good... he jus neva made it cuz he wasnt consistant... PLUS he got SMASHED by too many ppl... lol.. ll cool j, eminem, etc... lol

[khausungcodon2000]

fuck kpop



[TopTenScooter]

I swear, it's like Eminem is speaking to me in his lyrics...

[AkyovNorthWest]

@TopTenScooter why? was you there when ronnie died with a bucket to catch every tear he cried inside it?

[akat024]

@TopTenScooter fag

[nabarro31]

HOW cOmE ?

[MrYessse]

fuck it i even enjoyed the last minutes of silence!

[MrYahtzee93]

@idontubewithyou and Rev of avenged sevenfold and the dead guy from slipknot. and for the wacka/gucci thing id probably say lets get rid of all 4 just because they all 4 suck

[hearts1010]

"i dont even feel the same love when we hug" i love that line so much. i was like wow i definitely feel that way with some people.

[almondswag]

kon artists part is incredible. if youve seen the music video its even more powerful

[omar52916]

best music in the world

[pimpster122]

Enjoying this ART untill our very last day with power

[kllrby]

wayne has nothing on eminem.

[xStayyyBeaauutifulx]

@kllrby uh.

their friends?o-o

[sean60c]

@kllrby There both sell outs who gives a fuck!

[TrueSomename]

@sean60c i thought record sales didn't matter? you doing the same exact thing that canibus fans do go around saying ''just because eminem has million records sold doesen't make him better'' then turn around and say eminem is a sellout see they fail logiec, the point is record sales don't make you any better or worse.

[sean60c]

@TrueSomename Nah man im saying this because before eminem was big he was political and was trying to ake a change, but as soon as he had the power to actualy do something he didnt! You will never see him release a song like mosh again hes all about the record sales now not the music!

[cooke890]

@kllrby No shit, it's gettin' old...

[jcunt100]

whats up with the awkward silence at the end of the song

[kchoodsta]

people need to stop with these gay azz comments talkin bout people dying cuz all these people are living for someone!!

[TtownSoldiers]

3 words describe this song.....REAL FUCKING MUSIC!!!!!!!

[GodDamnMonkeys]

yeah the three assholes who disliked this song must have down syndrome n hit dislike by accident

[lewis2718]

@GodDamnMonkeys no they prob thought it said, dis i like :)

[mrman3810]

3 motherfuckas dislike this song they must of not been family!!

[cortney3436]

this songg remindes me of this summer (: HELLA MEMORIES !!

[codzombiesrftw]

happy bday eminem happy day big

proof last week

[MrYahtzee93]

lets trade beiber for proof, wayne for tupac, rick ross for biggie, canibus for big L, DJ khaled for jam master jay, and wiz khalifa for bugz. and the backstreet boys and Nsync for the dead members of the outlawz, and hell why not this, lady gaga and kesha for michael jackson. at least his music had some messages that were good

[THFC96MITCH]

@MrYahtzee93

I agree with all that apart from wayne. Wayne gets bad press but he still keeps it real

[pinkdice07]

@THFC96MITCH he keeps it fake.

[TrueSomename]

@MrYahtzee93 wow your brave bro ''canibus for big L''

[MrYahtzee93]

@TrueSomename canibus has big words but no themes. of course we should trade him for a true lyricist. Big L was the most underrated rapper that had the same skill as Nas, Pac, BIG, or anyone. plus Canibus dick rides a lot for guest appearances. and picks beefs that he knows he cant win. Ex: trying to diss Eminem = career suicide

[TrueSomename]

@MrYahtzee93 yeah if canibus got into a freestyle battle with big L that would be something i would like too see, and F.Y.I. canibus did have a freestyle rap battle with eminem and proof. little while ago though.

[theoldslimshady64]

@MrYahtzee93 I would love all of these dudes back, but they would be offended if we traded those other losers for them.

[RZAGZAGFKODB]

@MrYahtzee93 why canibus?



[MrYahtzee93]

@RZAGZAGFKODB cuz canibus has been trying to pick beef with people who would squash his ass, and his music isnt even that good. big words. nothing else.

[Tha4thLetterr]

@MrYahtzee93 canibus!?!? you're acting liek canibus is part of this garbage radio pop bullshit...what hte fuck u on??? seriously.. canibus is more real rap than 99% of artists out there..open your ears

[rkholton29]

@MrYahtzee93 Bro, I agree. Let's start rounding those motherfuckers.

[MrYahtzee93]

@rkholton29 i personally think canibus had a great opportunity to expand his career when he was rapping with nas and the firm back in 97', but he missed it now he disses anyone who gets big. Em, Royce, J.Cole, Wycleaf, and Joe Budden? seriously stop with the jealousy shit, and since he tried to re-ignite the beef with Em he's fallen the fuck off, and hasnt been able to get back on

[degeneratelifecycle]

@MrYahtzee93 you sir should stand proudly atop the highest pedestal man can build

[bikefucker]

@MrYahtzee93

why canibus ? i didnt really listen to him, but hes got few good songs that ive heard

[MrYahtzee93]

@bikefucker i aint saying hes got nothing. but a lot of his shit is just really big wordplay with no meaning. its like an action movie with no plot. its nice to see all the explosions and hot actresses, but when you look at it under a microscope you realize how dumb it was.

[HSVKingRS]

@MrYahtzee93 You have hit the nail on the head, I must say. I'd happily accept these changes if you are up to granting them. :( "they say the good die young" want PROOF of it? I believe you have just shown the younger people that never experienced real rap who to actually search on youtube and what not.  R.I.P Proof, Tupac, Biggie, Big L, Jam Master Jay, the passed members of outlaws and MJ. last but not least - R.I.P REAL RAP.

[KingOfEden12]

@MrYahtzee93 shut the fuck up.

[kohlyn1]

R.I.P proof thumbs up if u still listen to proof today.

[totallyawesomespider]

Eminem's verse and the chorus reminds me so much of one of my best friends that I had known for 10 years then out of nowhere just dipped out

[Phantomtwinz99]

thumbs up if you would trade justin bieber to have proof back

[KingOfEden12]

shut the fuck up with

beiber

bieber

bieber

ALL I HEAR IS BEIBER

from fucking guys!?!

are you guys fucking gay

fucking listen to d12 not bieber... fuck

[vzxvvzxv123321]

@KingOfEden12 nobody is talkin about him but you...

[KingOfEden12]

@vzxvvzxv123321 read the passed comments, smarty

[narutoz3em]

eminem ??

[ChivasBarcelonaMex]

@narutoz3em Why the question mark?

[freakk9]

happy birthday BIG PROOF. R.I.P 

[BALDHEADEDCOBOBBY]

Eminem is soo damnn Sexyy♥ ;D Hee turnns mee onnn, [;

[tyggar2169]

the 1st published d-12 album

[NoZite79]

Which CD is this from?

[LiftingForLife]

@NoZite79 D12 World, D12's second album.

[Z97Scopez97Z]

right, lemme make this simple...this song is utter amasing. fact. enough of these stupid spam comments. this song is beast.

[remorrs]

dam whenever i listen to this it makes me think about ma boy, we aint as tite as we used to be hes like changin it fuckin sucks

[rmthegod]

@remorrs faggot .....

[Bullzown]

RIP Proof!!! :(

[TheBharatdarira]

who was this song made for ???????

[free00to00ryhme]

@TheBharatdarira this song was made when D12 was breaking away from eminem. but they back together now, they makin a new album together, the old beefs are in the casket.

[gluby3owns]

yay dora woot goo dora!!!!

opps wrong vid

[RobbingHoodMovies]

@gluby3owns shut up 

[GODvsAbc]

my teacher made me read a short story and i read the lyrics for this song :D

[zepiti1]

@GODvsAbc Good choice.

[GODvsAbc]

@zepiti1 i dont regret it either :O

[zepiti1]

@GODvsAbc :D

[EMBvideos]

Love this song. :/

[GODvsAbc]

the 5 rappers i respect D12

[drummerkid2397]

Dang... thats some good rap..

[MrFwong42]

i dont get it do u win a prize or something if u get a top comment???

[EMBvideos]

@MrFwong42 Yes

[WWEandGuitarMan]

stop posting "thumbs up if your watching this in 2011" to get likes your pathetic go away

[slimshadypotter]

@WWEandGuitarMan i am listening to this in 2011. but im not saying it to get likes,but to say that its still amazing after 7 years!

[orthn01]

@orthn01 thumbs up if you hate it when people ask for thumbs up this is aimed at you bro

[ManFanUtd]

Why this is sooo goood :> :>  ???

[Rhcpeppers21]

haroldolt is an idiot. Wiz is the shit though. Em and Wiz just aren't comparable, Wiz is a good times, smoke to, and party rapper, and Eminem is getting-through-problems-rappe­r. It just makes me angry when people say shit like this harold kid cuz then everybody starts hating on someone who doesn't deserve the hate

[Mago0Zle15]

mad beef in the comments

[TheMW2sponsors]

i love this song

[12baked]

ass

[Purplebullet13]

R.I.P Proof. People say forget the past. Theres times when you can't forget the past. We will never forget you.

[haroldolt]

wiz khalifa is better bitches and i came here by mistake ...taylor gang over everythang

[GunnerProductions20]

@haroldolt Wiz khalifa doesn't rap about anything other than hoes and weed. He's fucking trash compared to Eminem or D12 in general. Learn some proper sentence structure and grammar faggot. Go home.

[chron1cman420]

@GunnerProductions20 exactly man. i mean shit he aint bad..for smokin music..but shit man d12 n eminem is bomb shit..most songs have meanings and make sense..eminems freestyles are whack as fuck too..couldnt see khalifa EVER spittin like that. ever.

[dethklok831]

@haroldolt wiz khalifa isnt worth eminems shit stains fucking retard. eminem actually has meaning in his songs, something wiz doesnt even understand how to do. hes a joke. slim doesnt even consider him a threat thats how much he blows. wiz blows. fucking retard.

[alchemistEXE2]

@haroldolt Yay a bitch ass gang that can't even bang is better. So bullshit. The fuck are you, 10, trying to act all hard? Little cunt.

[TOSxMonster]

@haroldolt lmfao....

[mylesCPFC]

lets play hide and seek with the dislike bar

[CKingNC313]

Mr. Porters verse was so damn real

[doobie42]

who is Denaun talkin about?

[CKingNC313]

@doobie42 Em

[CKingNC313]

So I changed huh? You got a phone, pick it up, call me

How come we don't even talk no more

And you don't even call no more

We don't barely keep in touch at all

And I don't even feel the same love when we hug no more

And I heard it through the grape vine we even beefing now

After all the years we been down

Ain't no way no how, this bullshit can't be true

We family and ain't a damn thing changed, unless it's you

[arose0630]

eminem is in it

[dongdongco]

to me its So much better in "A Drop in the Ocean Remix"

[daniele19964ever]

proof !!

[Thebrownelementsk8er]

This song i about Royce. For sure.

[dudeperfect0]

@Thebrownelementsk8er are u fucking retarted?

[aDyerSituation]

@dudeperfect0 how is he retarded? You can't even spell an insult right and this song IS about Royce.

[Thebrownelementsk8er]

@dudeperfect0 My bad dude, I meant to put is*. sorry typo, just like you put "U" instead of "you" oh wait! that wasn't a typo you're just a dumbass thats too lazy to put 2 more letters next to "u". and thats not even why I decided to write back to your stupid ass. Royce had beef with the boys from D12 other than Eminem YEAHYEAHYEAH Eminem is in D12 but Royce didn't have that much beef with him. Royce had hard beef with everyone else from D12. Royce kind of dissed Em in a small matter in malcom x

[dudeperfect0]

@Thebrownelementsk8er i know im way smarter then you fucking idiot. And nope its not about royce

[Thebrownelementsk8er]

@dudeperfect0 And dissed everyone else from D12 before he already had diss songs. This song is just a like "what the fuck man what happened to us?" song from Eminem to D12. Oh and also I like how your name is "dudeperfect0". Queer.

[Thebrownelementsk8er]

@Thebrownelementsk8er Eminem to Royce*

[dudeperfect0]

@Thebrownelementsk8er hahahaha i love how mad you get you pussy



[Thebrownelementsk8er]

@dudeperfect0 Im not mad, I just explained what is was about. Wow you actually are dumb. O:

[Cardeala79]

4 Bugz' Muthafucka' R.I.P. :(

[MagicallyFat]

im 87 years old and ive been listening to eminem since i was 3 

[megvagyimmartizenyol]

@MagicallyFat wtf? XD

[MagicallyFat]

@megvagyimmartizenyol i know its bad lol but im trying to tell people it doesnt matter how old you are d12 is the shit lol

[megvagyimmartizenyol]

@MagicallyFat :D:D

[thenewslimshady9]

@MagicallyFat i don't see how since eminem wasnt even alive then

[MagicallyFat]

@thenewslimshady9 im obviously not 87 years old... smh

[megvagyimmartizenyol]

@thenewslimshady9 lol he obviously was joking XD

[UniqueEverlasting]

@MagicallyFat FUCKIN AMAZING! xD

[Dardi356]

@MagicallyFat HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHHAAHHAA­HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA

[liverpoolkidchambers]

im 14 and ive been listening to eminem since i was 3

[DonAlonzo91]

@Tyilight07 lol since you were 5? you must have shit parents if they let you listen to eminem when you were that age.

[TheChemi]

@DonAlonzo91 and listeing to him wheny our 13 or 10 is anybetter bad is bad nomatter how old you are :)

[frandon441]

if u dont like d12 u dont like rap thumps up if u agree

[tyilight07]

im 15 and have been listeining to eminem and d12 since i was five so fuck you all

[bostonneverforgets]

Look up, A Drop in the Ocean- Eminem ft Wiz and Kanye!

[Sm0k3gr33n420]

i cried when proof died

[joshyouwanna]

that new old spice guy is no good.

[ksbassmaster]

i hate d12 ....... so now that i got your attention i would like to say d12 is the best

[spideyO10]

I Hacked my youtube so nobody could Thumbs up my comment.

*Trollface*

[fuckyoumusicTV]

adf(dot)ly/2B3s5

thats all i have to say

[itzzsoucyy]

now i feal a vibe i cant describe as much as ya pride trys to hide it

[CrazyKarl93]

You're all thumb whores and it makes me siiiiiiiick..