Carrie Underwood - When Will I Be Loved

[fusion2000]

The arrangement is HORRIBLE....she is a GREAT singer

[Lindafan21]

OK, she can sing, but sorry folks, she did not come close to Linda's version. Granted, it's an Everly Brothers tune, but everyone in the Western Hemisphere knows Linda's interpretation. Thumbs down for not even mentioning Linda as an influence. I'm not impressed.



[bam6684]

Sounds like Randy and Paula were using the same dope that night .Get off the dope Paula.

[tommysgurl2o1o]

love this version!!!!!!

[kimberlyrae1969]

She copied Linda Ronstadt on this, and she did not come close to sounding as good as Linda. STFU all you haters, Carrie is great, but she sounded like crap here.

[irishangel101297]

ok this version of this song (sorry undrwood fans) sucks

jamie belushi did better singing this song!

[pinecone1999]

Really Paula really When she takes risks you say you miss the old her when she does the country songs she loves you say she needs to take a risk

[Neptunemoon20]

a little pitchy, but who doesn't get like that once in a while? i love this performance cause you can really see right here the shadow of who she's become today.

[evilslore87]

paula is to stone to even know where shes at let alone able to judge this performance..!!

[bearskwillman]

lol cingular wireless

[MissDDHeather]

God, why can't I sound like this!

[TheRickrock007]

Simon was the only real credible judge on this crappy karaoke show ....he just said that Underwood was a good singer here....but she really sucked this song up!!!

[iHeartCharmed]

God I love her so much.

[malibu64]

haha, it's so great seeing her sing on TV pre-super stardom

[kippenkanoodle1]

Wow! What a voice!

[perixanfin]

before he cheats =P

[1955jamie]

there was notthing like the real everly brothers when they sung this sone but its not a bad thing to have it sung as in a new way specially from a female it was a nice touch there notthing like the original in any song so anything its sung diff by someone or in the 90s or 2000s but she did it rather well for the song to be sung by a female im like sinmon it was a nice touch

[stephaniekaylive]

not her best performance but shes stil really an amazing singer =)

[Neptunemoon20]

wth does anyone else think paula and randy are giving out conflicting advice?

[restinpeacejimi]

i'll love you carrie

[pjz11261231]

i have heard goats sing better thasn this

[perixanfin]

@pjz11261231 are you serious!!!??? she has the best voice ever!!!

[pjz11261231]

@perixanfin try the dolly parton version thats somthing else

[perixanfin]

@pjz11261231 i`ve done that and i like her 100000000 times better!!

[perixanfin]

@perixanfin when i say her i mean carrie

[pjz11261231]

@perixanfin your opionon not mine she holds the notes out to long to much of a fake accent

[perixanfin]

@pjz11261231 noo!!

[ringbolt9]

i have heard her sing good stuff but this aint it!! check linda ronstats version  no comparison.

[TheKogunEnjou]

Yeah, this song didn't fit her voice. It's nowhere near Linda Ronstadt's version.

[Millard97]

No she just totaly ruined the song ! , god she sucks

[BettorOffSingle]

She mails it in a lot, because she can get away with it.

She's very boring, too perfunctory, and lacking in personality or originality.

[tallorder9]

What a voice!

[Jazie81]

randy and paula are on crack



[Lanny1966]

Proof that Simon is the one with a clue!

[jjmeowmeow]

My chorus class is singing this. It sounds awesome as a choir song!

[tallorder9]

What a voice on this girl!

[sugarmiesje]

This song does not suit her voice at all! If you hear Linda's version this one makes you cringe a little inside. It's kind of like singing an old W. Houston song. If you are going to do it you better bring your A game. Carrie's awesome though!

[shinbrien]

talk about destroying a great song, why does everybody think that people pouring notes is 'great singing' its bloody terrible.

[yazooconwayfan]

Randy & Paula have Tourette's Syndrome. Simon finally showed some sencse!

[amyanda]

I think it was incredible. idk what they are talking about. Yeah!!!!! Simon!

[mrmuffer69]

I was blown away by that performance and I'm a huge fan of Linda Ronstadts version. Carrie is great.

[tigeramigos]

They'd make a pile of money if they made these available on iTunes!

[tigeramigos]

What's not to like?!

[albr0330]

I really hated the song, but her voice is simply amazing

[Bntnredsox]

Its not bad considering she made it big, but I like Linda Ronstadt's version better.

[hofnerbass24]

she just butchered this

[fordude60]

You go, girl!

[dwward]

It's great that she credits the Everly Brothers who originally recorded the rock classic written by Phil Everly -- but the arrangement she uses is all Linda Ronstadt.

[cj7849]

I like Carrie's version of this song and I respect that she identified this song as an Everly Brothers song, however I believe it is best know as a Linda Ronstadt hit and Carrie does put her own spin on it but clearly keeps much of Linda's changes to the original EB version. I think Carrie should have acknowledged Linda also.

[CarrieIsDaBomb]

does someone has this song?

It's the last one I want of her Idol days that I don't have,.

[mintheman7]

I stumble across this video right after watching Linda Ronstadt's version of the song, and there is just no comparison. I wouldn't normally agree with Paula and Randy but they are spot on this time. Go ahead and compare for yourself!

[heartfan82]

Very fun, entertaining song....Carrie was already standing out as a star by this time, what was up with Paula and Randy?

[whitepoeticwarrior]

"Safe and boring"??? hahah ... what a laugh. Man, Carrie could sing "Old McDonald had a farm" and it would be better than most people singing today.  Simon was spot-on.

[20Shelbi12]

I absolutely LOVE this performance. :)

I think it's one of my favorites from her journey on idol. Go Carrie <3

[slangestorm]

fucking shit.. everly brothers is much much much much better then this shit

[jww047]

What the hell? Are Randy and Paula drunk? I have seen them comment much better on performances much, much worse than that. THAT WAS A FANTASTIC PERFORMANCE! For once, go Simon!

[tommyboy61106]

The 2 of them must have been smoking crack. This was a kick ass performance. Better than the rest of those clowns. Like what teeftaller said, "What has bo donce since idol? He's done shit. Carrie is the one who's won the grammys, cma awards, been inducted into The Grand Ole Opry. Among a whole lot of other awards. Too many to list.

[bigwillietheb]

I'm sorry but in my opinion Bo bice is the real season 4 winner not Carrie

[teeftaller7]

What has bo done since idol??? and look what carrie has done..

[limitedplay]

Paula only roots for black men under 21 she can screw, randy doesnt have a clue what to say if he goes before Simon. Partly because hes wondering why Paula hasnt blown him yet since hes black and she loves sucking black meat, second because hes a pussy.

I thought she sounded great. I guess they didnt like her the whole season because she doesnt seem like the type to jump into bed with any black man off the street she meets like Paula does

[babe1579]

hahahahha thats soo funny and probably true!!

[hailtothebuckeyes]

um she was amazing.. randy and paula are retarded...

[sourlips92]

i believe she is great... we sing this song in choir and no one can sound as good as her

[netteo2]

Carrie is just great singing anything!

[Handnote]

Randy and Paula are right. Choosing a country song that suited her voice doesn't mean this was a good performance.

Vocally, it was very okay.

[Antonio811]

Her voice sounds great singing anything!

[CarrieJunkie]

i totally agree. paula and randy are crazy