Tchaikovsky October "Autumn Song", Charlie (8), Improved Version

[PanjiPoe]

Smart kid.

[sarakwee]

hey that's... very nice! love it...

[gerardbedecarter]

A mature and expressive performance - as was the Chopin Eb Nocturne opus 9 no.2. It goes without saying that Tchaikovsky's piano pieces should be played very expressively. Tchaikovsky himself was a rather torured soul and his music expreses this, don't you think?

[samuelngkee]

Amazing!!! beautifully played*****

[thomandy]

Love the performance :) Great piano, handsome young boy, great piano, Awesome dynamics in a Great piece :) That is more than we can ask :) 5*

Thomas

[blueyoyi]

played with sensitivity .... maturing very well as a pianist.

[farah73]

great student! must have a great teacher. congratulations to both

[vivian2nana]

Beautifully played, Charlie!!!

[cdvorpiano]

Oh, after I wrote it I thought it might have sounded like I was being critical. I agree his dynamics were very good. I just meant that perhaps one could play even a little stronger at the high points. Anyway, it's always different to hear it online than in person, since the reproduction is not totally accurate. Anyway, this young man plays from the heart, and I get the feeling that there is no way he could ever be unmusical. It comes from his special way of listening and feeling, deep inside.

[coffeetea]

Thanks! Don't worry, I appreciate criticism too, but my opinion of the video could differ. The overall low recording volume of the video's makes the dynamics less appreciable, but he in fact played out several dynamic levels with clear and suitable dynamic changes, voiced both hands very nicely, kept the melody smooth, moving, and interesting. There were some minor places not smooth or accurate enough but overall I'm very happy with it.

[cdvorpiano]

It's quite amazing that a boy Charlie's age can bring such sensitivity to this mature piece, which could easily be monotonous in less talented hands. The key is to keep it moving forward, perhaps with even more dramatic crescendos in the high points. To me, Charlie's soulful expression is his true gift -- it is so unusual to find that depth in such a young musician. But try someting just for fun -- why not play it once with more of a dynamic? I think it could bring out the drama of the piece.

[coffeetea]

Thanks for your comment & input! I was actually rather happy with his dynamics though.

[blueyoyi]

I have so much problems with the way the audio finally end up in YT. A good amount of the "presence" is lost !

[OldRabit]

Wow, this is such an enchanting and beautiful song. You immediately drew me into it, Charlie.

[theotse]

Excellent performance!

[anmoose]

Magnificent! Charlie, you do nothing but keep getting better. The expressiveness in this interpretation reflects that.

Moosie

[piano6861]

Beautiful!

[Lalitamusic]

An elegant and terrific performance Charlie. Well done.

In tune

Lalita

[warren0088]

great!!!

[aawpiano2007]

I think it's fair to name it improved version -- it's a lot better, Charlie! Bravo!

[italco312]

Lovely, Charlie. Great maturity and subtle emotion.

[klingsor93]

My Dear and sweet Charlie, you play this work with the inspiration of a professinnal. All of Tchaïkowsky's romantic meditation is present in your interpretation.

[pianogirl98]

Soooo beautifully played!!!

[pianogirl4ever]

Great job, Charlie! (*^^*)

[tangledwind]

Such a beautiful playing. The touch is very good. All the way charlie~ But why does the cam keep moving..

[coffeetea]

Uh, that's because I was alive and breathing. :) (the camera was zoomed in). Thanks for your comment!

[MusicDoLove]

What a great way to end autumn and begin winter. Charlie, you play it so well that the piano cries for the end of the season. Very beautifully played and perfectly done. Thanks for treating us again to one of your favorites.

[coffeetea]

Thank you so much! Have a great holiday season!