Just wanted to give my *opinion* that I love both versions (Gimp excluded), but prefer the Catch 22 recordings, except in areas where the mixing and recording is so bad it's intolerable. I heard the C22 version first, so for a lot of the Streetlight versions where they changed the pitch of the horns and stuff it's always going to sound a little bit "off" to me, albiet still awesome.
Ok I've got very mixed opinions on the whole Catch 22 VS Streetlight Manifesto argument. I like them both, this song specifically I like the Catch 22 version more, but other songs, like Keasbey Nights and Dear Sergio, I like the Streetlight Manifesto versions more.
@LambOfJesus360 Just this album. Seeing as Kalnoky wrote all of them, I'd hardly consider them "covers". More just reiterations. Everything else they've done completely blows Catch 22's stuff out of the water.
@LambOfJesus360 none the same guy who wrote the songs for catch 22 formed this band so there are his songs. so its note really a cover. its more like a remastering.
@LambOfJesus360 They covered an entire Catch 22 album, but that's it as far as I know. They covered two Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution songs I think, though. All three of these bands had the same singer/songwriter, a genius only rivaled by Mike Patton and Maynard James Keenan, Tomas Kalnoky.
@LambOfJesus360 This explanation has been posted many many times throughout tons of streetlight videos , and since you can't just go to wikipedia. . . They covered the album Kaesbey knights, so all of the songs on the kaesbey knights. I don't like to think of them as covers, though, because Tomas Kalnoky wrote all of the songs and sang and did them in Catch 22. I like to think of it as a guy just rerecording songs with some different people.
@jebril I'm a Streetlight fan. Yes, you're super. No, your not nothing. Yes, your in Streetlight Manifesto. No, your not selling out. Yes, you are popular. You got half your shit wrong.
@jebril thats because theyve only done one album release since. and that album was a cover album, save for their one original "the provide the paint for the picture perfect masterpiece", which is a cover of Kalnoky's song from his other band, which, in my opinion, was the best song on the album. its not that theyve been sucking, its just that their original work is much better
oh my god who the hell cares...im sick of clicking on every streetlight song and seeing all of the comments talking about catch 22, everyone stfu and listen the song please
The lead singer of Streetlight Manifesto is the EX-Singer in Catch-22, he wrote all songs on Keasby Nights, and recorded it with BOTH bands, people argue over which is better.
Wrap your mind around this....Supernothing was written by Tomas Kalnoky and performed by his first band Gimp. Then he "covered" it for his next band Catch-22. Then "covered" it again for his next band Streetlight Manifesto. Cover of a cover of a cover....3 bands, 1 songwriter.
i firste heard these songs (Keasby Nights album) by Catch 22. then my friend played me the same songs by Streetlight. he then told me how Tomas Kalnoky was in Catch 22 but then started Streelight Manifesto. i love them both. :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
yea i dont really understand this catch 22 shit, like i know they are a band, but how could they have done the same album, and is streetlight a bunch of posers the? o.O
Catch 22 used to have Tomas Kalnoky, who wrote all of the songs on Keasbey Nights, but then he took off and in a few years started the band Streetlight Manifesto. Then Streetlight Manifesto re-did Keasbey Nights so it would sound better. "Allegedly." The original Keasbey Nights had bad quality in some people's opinions.
@Robocrat In the interview at the end of 1234 1234 I think he said that the label they where going to publish Streetlight's first original CD with wanted to re-release the CD untouched, so he redid them to increase the sound and so that people wouldn't be paying for something the already own.
@Robocrat ACTUALLY they kicked him out. Streetlight Manifesto and current Catch 22 hate each other. But Catch still sang all of Tom's music after they kicked him out. Hence the line in A Moment Of Silence "If you hate me so much then stop singing my songs"
@kampfspaniel streetlight had 3 former members from catch 22 when they started off. there was a point when catch22 and streetlight were rivals. streetlight had to release keasbey knights before catch 22 rerealeased the better sounding quality of keasbey. It was alnost liked streetlight was almost forced to remake it, its kinda hard to explain but easy to understand :)
@kampfspaniel the singer of streetlight was the singer of catch 22 for this album.catch 22 had a couple of other members of streetlight i think.then catch 22 got a new frontman when tomas kalnoky started streetlight
@MazterSpaz Yea I wasnt sure before but yea. That's why he said "if you hate me so much then stop singing my songs" in A Moment of Silence, because after they still used all of his stuff.
why would they make a cd of downgraded songs. this versions got no soul. weak, very weak, i guess its just to officially give them the right to play these songs in concert. pos
@kingblackhart
I love the gimp version too and I'm wondering what I meant by that.
Kavurcen 2 weeks ago
Guys! Calmitdownforgodsakewe'regoingnowherefastwiththesearguments.
Just wanted to give my *opinion* that I love both versions (Gimp excluded), but prefer the Catch 22 recordings, except in areas where the mixing and recording is so bad it's intolerable. I heard the C22 version first, so for a lot of the Streetlight versions where they changed the pitch of the horns and stuff it's always going to sound a little bit "off" to me, albiet still awesome.
Kavurcen 2 months ago
@Kavurcen this song was beautiful when he first recorded it with Gimp
kingblackhart 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I kinda like Gimp's version better. The cut out a really good part... It's still really awesome though.
Conchobear 4 months ago
Comment removed
Conchobear 4 months ago
imasuperimanothingimanoonegoingnowherefast
prestonADHD 6 months ago 3
"Catch22?" Skafail
ANBUblackops666 6 months ago
Ok I've got very mixed opinions on the whole Catch 22 VS Streetlight Manifesto argument. I like them both, this song specifically I like the Catch 22 version more, but other songs, like Keasbey Nights and Dear Sergio, I like the Streetlight Manifesto versions more.
ThatOtherSTD 6 months ago
Let's just just shut up about 2 bands and listen to what we came for. I HAVE SPOKEN.
PatchworkParamedic 6 months ago
how many of their songs are Catch 22 covers?
LambOfJesus360 8 months ago
@LambOfJesus360 Just this album. Seeing as Kalnoky wrote all of them, I'd hardly consider them "covers". More just reiterations. Everything else they've done completely blows Catch 22's stuff out of the water.
Valkodu 6 months ago
@LambOfJesus360 none the same guy who wrote the songs for catch 22 formed this band so there are his songs. so its note really a cover. its more like a remastering.
thepersona1 6 months ago
@LambOfJesus360 They covered an entire Catch 22 album, but that's it as far as I know. They covered two Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution songs I think, though. All three of these bands had the same singer/songwriter, a genius only rivaled by Mike Patton and Maynard James Keenan, Tomas Kalnoky.
uiruu 6 months ago
@LambOfJesus360 This explanation has been posted many many times throughout tons of streetlight videos , and since you can't just go to wikipedia. . . They covered the album Kaesbey knights, so all of the songs on the kaesbey knights. I don't like to think of them as covers, though, because Tomas Kalnoky wrote all of the songs and sang and did them in Catch 22. I like to think of it as a guy just rerecording songs with some different people.
KidPlayingPiano 6 months ago
@KidPlayingPiano I wrote this comment 2 months ago, suck a dick, I get it now.
LambOfJesus360 6 months ago
@KidPlayingPiano *Keasbey Nights
prestonADHD 5 months ago 3
@prestonADHD You're a petty prick. Did the confusion of the A and the E make what he said incomprehensible for you?
noxymoron19 5 months ago
@noxymoron19 Dont fuck with my friend preston ook u are just probably a troll on utube i mean he probably has a problem of needing to fix things
privat3p3anut 4 months ago in playlist privat3p3anut's Favorited Videos
I don't like the title Everything goes numb, it should have been called "Keasbey Nights part 2: We're Grownups Now"
Historyfan1776 8 months ago
lol Catch 22 sucks, but the original from Gimp is wayyyyyyy better
lForsakenGloryl 10 months ago
I'm Tom Kalnoky, I'm super, I'm nothing, I'm in Streelight Manifesto selling out is what I do cuz I'm popular now.
jebril 10 months ago
@jebril I'm a Streetlight fan. Yes, you're super. No, your not nothing. Yes, your in Streetlight Manifesto. No, your not selling out. Yes, you are popular. You got half your shit wrong.
SCARYFREAKINGPERSON 10 months ago
@jebril How exactly has Streetlight sold out in any way, shape or form?
SMfan199 9 months ago
@SMfan199 They've been sucking ever since Everything Went Numb.
jebril 9 months ago
@jebril thats because theyve only done one album release since. and that album was a cover album, save for their one original "the provide the paint for the picture perfect masterpiece", which is a cover of Kalnoky's song from his other band, which, in my opinion, was the best song on the album. its not that theyve been sucking, its just that their original work is much better
jewjewbinks69 9 months ago
@jebril Streetlight's popular? I had no idea
GoodgriefMaltese 8 months ago
Man this song came a long way. It was originally from Kalnoky's first band, Gimp.
MyNameIsNotRon 10 months ago
oh my god who the hell cares...im sick of clicking on every streetlight song and seeing all of the comments talking about catch 22, everyone stfu and listen the song please
moviemaker7007 10 months ago
Tom didnt get kicked out he left to go to college or art school
skimmer538 10 months ago
2 people are nothing not supernothing just NOTHING
zocphra 11 months ago
2 people are from Catch 22.
SpinnerZYo 11 months ago 6
2 people need to die
emomooc 1 year ago
Gimp.
Zarren364 1 year ago
Gimp.
Zarren364 1 year ago
whatever thomas kalnoky does sounds good in my opinion, if you disagree fucka you :P
GirardsCousin00 1 year ago
1 person has no life
SamJoeBillyBob 1 year ago
@SamJoeBillyBob 1 person has an opinion.
Allcommentsappreciat 1 year ago
@Allcommentsappreciat Explain then
SamJoeBillyBob 1 year ago
@SamJoeBillyBob 1 person dosn't like this band.
Allcommentsappreciat 1 year ago
@Allcommentsappreciat 1 person sucks
SamJoeBillyBob 1 year ago
One person sucks[:
winshu22 1 year ago
supernothings represent
backoffpunk95 1 year ago
catch or street light i don't care the album keasby night is good period
Sveners50 1 year ago
This could work for my Road Trip playlist.
SithArmyKnife 1 year ago
I've been seeing comments about Catch-22 in other SM videos. Is that like there rival band?
felx34 1 year ago
@felx34 Its been said a million times.
The lead singer of Streetlight Manifesto is the EX-Singer in Catch-22, he wrote all songs on Keasby Nights, and recorded it with BOTH bands, people argue over which is better.
deviant3232 1 year ago
Orrrrrr...We could just not worry and listen to the song ^_^
Progressionification 1 year ago 3
epic win!!
SimplyShadow 1 year ago
the new catch 22 sucks so bad now.
Ravioli74020 1 year ago
@Ravioli74020 tomas makes the band
shaneshaneshane94 1 year ago
Wrap your mind around this....Supernothing was written by Tomas Kalnoky and performed by his first band Gimp. Then he "covered" it for his next band Catch-22. Then "covered" it again for his next band Streetlight Manifesto. Cover of a cover of a cover....3 bands, 1 songwriter.
HarlequinNightmare 1 year ago
Doesn't matter what band, what recording, what time, what place. Anything Kalnoky is good. End of story.
DisAwpProductions 1 year ago
Sweeeet. :3
SKAtarina420 1 year ago
no dislikes :D
ICantDoShit 1 year ago 2
Chris Hansen sent me here.
Animeoverlord00 1 year ago
my math teacher is in streetlight manifesto
3min3mplaza 1 year ago
For music with balls and badass brass, see the above band. :]
alesslikelyhero 1 year ago 2
Violins make it better? Uh, no.
cfr5555 1 year ago
i firste heard these songs (Keasby Nights album) by Catch 22. then my friend played me the same songs by Streetlight. he then told me how Tomas Kalnoky was in Catch 22 but then started Streelight Manifesto. i love them both. :)
100blueeyedboy 1 year ago
the drums ruleee kinda dnb-ish
avemnevoiesideiarba 2 years ago 3
Violin makes it better. But horns make it good too.
BassClar4evr 2 years ago
SO HARD TO PICK A FAV some times i dig one of there song for a long time then i like another one these happens ON&ON&ON LOL
rvpfan 2 years ago 10
I liked Gimp's version better
cavanation 2 years ago 2
Same, so much more feeling with the violin.
ellimem 2 years ago
No One Cares.
BrainDeadScreamer 2 years ago 30
NO ONE.
EvanCo93 1 year ago
@BrainDeadScreamer about?
AlexYo234 8 months ago
This version is quite good, but the intensity of Tomas with the violin back in the Gimp days wins it for me.
SuperAsianEmo 2 years ago 3
are you kidding? the gimp version is great, but catch 22's remake was 100 times better. this is basically that version with better audio quality
987657654321 2 years ago 2
The lyrics aren't the same in the Gimp and Catch/Streetlight ska version.
SuperAsianEmo 2 years ago
This song totally talks about my current situation in life.
Nilahas0 2 years ago
Your's too?
Maybe we should be bestfriends
baseballking2468 2 years ago
lol maybe, I dnt like where Im at. but i am lookin 4ward to where Im going.
Nilahas0 2 years ago
Well, I don't know where I'm going sooo haha
baseballking2468 2 years ago
Dnt be like tht. lol Just gtta have an open mind to things.
Nilahas0 2 years ago
Also described as "QQ"
blackfang500 2 years ago 2
QQ?
Nilahas0 2 years ago 2
streetlight and catch both lose in this situation gimp did those song best botar should totally cover it for 99 songs including gimps original ending
whiteknuckledwill 2 years ago
FUCK CENSORING
iNeeko 2 years ago 4
when ever i want to listen to the keasby nights album i pop in catch's
he's voice sounds weird in this recording.
cuz when they play live it sounds more like catches version.
alwaysblinkin182 2 years ago
naw they're both alright and its true they're pretty much the same thing
isleppardbbjoker 2 years ago
is there a catch 22/streetlight vid out there were people don't argue about which one is better when they are pretty much the same
skaminy54601 2 years ago 5
davvero unici. grandi streetlight manifesto!!!
frassinagos 2 years ago 2
i like streetlights better mainly because they had more experience and a better recording studio and shit so they sound alot better
jaydog988 2 years ago 2
I like the Gimp version better, to be honest. =D
AnotherLollacaust 3 years ago 2
i love streetlights version sounds so much better in my opinion :D
killallneds 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yea i dont really understand this catch 22 shit, like i know they are a band, but how could they have done the same album, and is streetlight a bunch of posers the? o.O
mylifeisaboutmusic 3 years ago
Catch 22 used to have Tomas Kalnoky, who wrote all of the songs on Keasbey Nights, but then he took off and in a few years started the band Streetlight Manifesto. Then Streetlight Manifesto re-did Keasbey Nights so it would sound better. "Allegedly." The original Keasbey Nights had bad quality in some people's opinions.
Lol, I don't think they're posers.:P
Robocrat 3 years ago 22
thanks and i love streetlight in my opinion they both own ( streetlights better) in my opinion
mylifeisaboutmusic 3 years ago 3
Yeah that's your opinion, just like mine is that catch's poorer quality had a less commercialized feel to it, thus making it better.
streetgangtm 3 years ago
i said in my opinion like 15 times lmao
mylifeisaboutmusic 3 years ago
lol, i no. catch 22 is okay, but streetlight... well theres no competition, streetlight wins hands down, lol
ska4ever762 2 years ago 4
Haha yes i agree hands down, ohh and mylifeisaboutmusic is my other account =\
Lunitik415 2 years ago 2
@Robocrat my math teacher is in streetlight manifesto
3min3mplaza 1 year ago
@Robocrat In the interview at the end of 1234 1234 I think he said that the label they where going to publish Streetlight's first original CD with wanted to re-release the CD untouched, so he redid them to increase the sound and so that people wouldn't be paying for something the already own.
PoisonSpittingClowns 1 year ago
@Robocrat
bad quility = awesomness and proving the authenticity of the album ^_^
ihavecloudenvy 1 year ago
@Robocrat
Catch 22 and Victory Records were also trying to re-release "Keasby" with "Flashy new packaging" and nothing more.
Tom thought it'd be better just to redo the album, especially because he thought the sound quality was "pure garbage".
godisasock71 1 year ago
@Robocrat ACTUALLY they kicked him out. Streetlight Manifesto and current Catch 22 hate each other. But Catch still sang all of Tom's music after they kicked him out. Hence the line in A Moment Of Silence "If you hate me so much then stop singing my songs"
thunderectum 11 months ago
@Robocrat catch 22 is way better in my opinion
TheMorbidfoxx 10 months ago
@Robocrat he didnt just jam out, he left to go to school, and the rest of the members from catch 22 got butt hurt and felt back stabbed...
johnnyrocket566 8 months ago
is catch 22 the same band?
kampfspaniel 3 years ago
No, but they did the same album, Keasbey Nights.
Robocrat 3 years ago
@kampfspaniel streetlight had 3 former members from catch 22 when they started off. there was a point when catch22 and streetlight were rivals. streetlight had to release keasbey knights before catch 22 rerealeased the better sounding quality of keasbey. It was alnost liked streetlight was almost forced to remake it, its kinda hard to explain but easy to understand :)
goodtimesontoob 1 year ago
@kampfspaniel the singer of streetlight was the singer of catch 22 for this album.catch 22 had a couple of other members of streetlight i think.then catch 22 got a new frontman when tomas kalnoky started streetlight
30740088 1 year ago
@kampfspaniel Tomas was in both bands
shmittytimes2 1 year ago
@kampfspaniel Tom got kicked out of catch 22. Then he made Streetlight with a bunch of other great musicians.
thunderectum 11 months ago
@thunderectum i knew tom was from Catch but y did he get kicked out? i always thought he left
MazterSpaz 11 months ago
@MazterSpaz Yea I wasnt sure before but yea. That's why he said "if you hate me so much then stop singing my songs" in A Moment of Silence, because after they still used all of his stuff.
thunderectum 11 months ago
@kampfspaniel
Streetlight is like Catch 22 version 2.0...and much better.
ReptileNexus 9 months ago
why would they make a cd of downgraded songs. this versions got no soul. weak, very weak, i guess its just to officially give them the right to play these songs in concert. pos
CdnSpecOps 3 years ago
sooooo true
streetgangtm 3 years ago
i used to listen to this on ma mp3 all th time like 3 years ago ... love itttttttttt
dan1991woopwoop 3 years ago
great song!!! :D
JoeWebsterBass 3 years ago
great!!
noterapia 3 years ago
*******************************out of 5
saxxytenor01 3 years ago
no comments? why?!?!? nobody listens to this amazing song? 5/5 *****
FinisEnInfinito 3 years ago 3
Thank you, kind sir.
Robocrat 3 years ago