The Official "My Heart Is Broken" music video was released in Spain, etc. on January 22. The link to it is already posted at sites like evanescencewebsite
This song is growing on me. I really like the mood of the song. The music is uplifting, yet filled with strong emotions, such as grief. It's a bittersweet sort of feeling. However, the lyrics don't quite do it for me. They seem generic and lack any sort of depth. The structure of the lyrics are a big turn off for me, but not so much that I won't listen to the song again.
@darkangelik25 personally after 6 days of listening to the album non stop, track three would be my fav. "The Change" and 2nd best would be track 7 "Lost In Paradise" and then this.
Amazing how no matter how many years pass between albums, Evanescence can come out with songs that I can relate to. Every flipping song on each of their albums is captivating, and this one is no different.
There is deffinately a different sound than the other two albums, personally. I LOVE this song, and i think its the more "evanescence" out of all the others we've heard. I could see this fitting in The Open Door no problem but.....I'm glad it wasnt on there, I wouldnt love it so much. :)
@meserlian I wonder when people on this Earth are going to respect that we have different tastes in music :/. And another person's taste isn't bad either. I hate hip hop and all of that but I don't go around calling people who like it retards, or otherwise say they have bad taste in music.
@7792thereaper You are most probably right, but I do not see the need to respect anyone I personally do not know, I do not expect the same from the person sitting on the other side of the table as well.
Wouldn't it be cool if Youtube asked a reason every time you clicked dislike/like
@meserlian Respecting someone's musical talent is different, then liking their music. If you can appreciate the time they spent and the effort they did in making their songs, then you respect them. If you like or dislike their music is a different topic however.
@meserlian ur an idiot and stop paying attention to small things that dont matter...How about just watching the video and leaving your own opinion without looking at others
@7792thereaper thereaper, I don't think it's a matter of having personal taste, it's more a matter of people attempting to represent themselves in something unrelated to them. Likes/ Dislikes make sense when the person performing the such like/dislike is affected (For Example, a Rule, protocol, or regulation change within a sport, game, or competition) However they don't make sense when the person performing the negative critique has no affiliation or meaningful use.
@7792thereaper I will take the old cliche Justin Bieber for example. Can I respect him as an Artist? Yes I can. Do I think there is a fan base for him? I think his numbers answer that question quite clear. Am I a fan of his music? No I'm not. Am I going to go through every single one of his videos and click Dislike? Nope because I can appreciate his work, and it would be a waste of time to offer a dislike when I'm not a fan of his work.
@7792thereaper Lastly to some it up, when does it make sense for a dislike in the entertainment industry? Listen to "Hybrid Theory", "Reanimation", and "Meteora ". When you're finished with those, listen to "Minutes to Midnight", and "A Thousand Suns". Their style changed and as a result a lot of Die-Hard Fanatics who felt affected did not like this. I can respect that as a meaningful dislike, that had more then just a troll factor.
@OoShinkooO Yeah, I agree with you, I don't go and click on dislike when I don't like a song or whatever, I just leave. The only thing though I was pointing out was that we shouldn't disrespect people who click the like button. They did it simply because they didn't like the song, not because they're retards or whatever as some people like saying, which is really immature.
This is amazing. Vocal strengths are at their ultimate high with the break she took! Love you, and thanks for everything Mrs. Amy Lynn (Lee) Hartzler!
The way I look at it, if this was a different band, I would love them, but since this is evanescence its gonna take some getting used to the generic sound. But after I listened to it a couple times, I fell in love with them all over again, in a different way. Oct 22nd come sooner! <3
@drums22gdrkelly i got to see them on their first performance back in nashville back in august. i thought it would make my life complete, but now i just wanna see them as many times as i can before i die lol
I can't believe how different they sound. If the rest of the album is like this, I'm definitely getitng it. (This is coming from someone who usually isn't a fan.)
one of the few singersi can say who are true to themselves and devoted to their music! love amy lee, her voice, her style, and every song she has put out I've listened to...love you evanescence! you guys rock!
Good job :D
TheChimayo 5 days ago
4 haters
bellaxbreakdownxoxo 6 days ago
4 people missed the "like" button
xilovesasorix 1 week ago
She has the voice of an angel.
MsHart24 3 weeks ago
Awesome song nice job!!
oseleus 1 month ago
i just want to watch the fucking offical music video is that to much to ask for?
tsmurfman123 1 month ago
I wish this song had come out before Feb 6 2010. Would have been a good one for my daughters funeral.
RavenKnighthawk 1 month ago
my fave song of the albumis Lost in Paradise but i love this one too!!
AmuletHeart48 1 month ago
I love this song b/c my heart is broken cause my bf broke up with me today 4 days after i came home from seeing him been there for 3 weeks :(
Inuyashasluver83 1 month ago
shes beautiful in every way
theusedbert24 1 month ago
my new favorite on the new album
ibqueenbee44 1 month ago
YouTube User hermanasmacana6 uploaded The Official video too 10 hours ago.
Emomusicfan777 1 month ago
The Official "My Heart Is Broken" music video was released in Spain, etc. on January 22. The link to it is already posted at sites like evanescencewebsite
Emomusicfan777 1 month ago
Cant wait for the video tomorrow!!!
Kindanotreally2012 1 month ago
i love this song it reminds me of the pain im going thru
acullen105 1 month ago
4 people dont know what Evanesence is all about
MoNsT3RdRuMm3r 1 month ago 2
How is this official douch bag!
Wykydsynr1 1 month ago
@Wykydsynr1 There's no video yet, dumbass. It means that this is the studio version
MissHockeyChick98 1 month ago
@Wykydsynr1
this isnt the official video. its just the official song off the album...Douche Bag
TimmayZ24 1 month ago
songs pretty cool
i like it
moderndevbot96 1 month ago
This song is growing on me. I really like the mood of the song. The music is uplifting, yet filled with strong emotions, such as grief. It's a bittersweet sort of feeling. However, the lyrics don't quite do it for me. They seem generic and lack any sort of depth. The structure of the lyrics are a big turn off for me, but not so much that I won't listen to the song again.
TwoFlightsDown 1 month ago
This is my favorite song on the album, I have a cd player that wakes me up to this song every morning =]
skateboarder501 1 month ago
This is alright, but isn't anywhere close to as good as Fallen or The Open Door.
4lifeKidrock 1 month ago
looooooooooooooooove it cnt stop listenin to it
lemonade2able 1 month ago
amy lee its just great,,,
XIXJAGUARXIX 2 months ago
3 people are dicks and donnot know what good music is
ElliePatton1993 2 months ago
I personally think this iz best song of this album :)
RaeRae9439 2 months ago
Yea i asked out a chick and she said no she was chasing someone else who i know it wont work....
l00kint0myeyes 2 months ago
I wasn't a major Ev fan until my GF forced me to listen. Wow. This album is a modern classic. End to end quality. Listen while high. Mind blowing!!
MiddleagedGeek 2 months ago
Was not feeling this album until I came to this track. Love it.
CyckOne 2 months ago
i love it!!!!!
TheEmolioness 2 months ago
My heart is actually broken :( My crush asked out a girl that hates me. I never win, when I heard this song I related to it instantly.
MusicalGirl24 2 months ago
I love the piano in this one! Good to hear some new stuff from them, its about time! :)
TheHurtDoctor 2 months ago 2
i love her voice, its so pure... lolz i remember a time where i pretended to have her amazing voice:)
RaeRae9439 2 months ago in playlist sam
I'm a guy, and I still have to sing along with Evanescence... they're too awesome not to.
anacrophobic 2 months ago
i love this song. i listen to this alot.
therocker96111 3 months ago
I freaking love this song!!
rockout2kutless 3 months ago
INCREDIBLE
TomColontonio 3 months ago
amy lee has made my number one favorite singer!! for havin such a beautiful voice,etc.
erikaazzanni 3 months ago
Love this song. Second best Evanescence song of all time. My Last Breath is my all time favorite.
bdub1009 3 months ago
I love Evanescence, I love this song.... and I think I love Amy too
tddchdstr 3 months ago
She makes living to hear her music an ART! :D <3
IzzyV15 3 months ago
awesome u go amy u have a awesome voice u make me like 2 sing lol
keisha34100 3 months ago
My favorite song from their new album is a tie.. between this and The Change
MediaWire 3 months ago
i ♥ their songs and i ♥ her voice! xD
MorganaLethe 3 months ago
Comment removed
MorganaLethe 3 months ago
Comment removed
MorganaLethe 3 months ago
This song is so captivating ........ just cannot stop listening to it. The new CD is awesome!
tangledfan 3 months ago
i want her headphones!
Crazi4Budgies 3 months ago
I love this song! Great album!
superjuicy951 4 months ago
I do love the composition of this song...so beautiful! Lee is such a wonderful composer, pianist, and singer.
treble225 4 months ago
cant wait to see the vid they are going to make for this song
18baileychick 4 months ago
love her. her voice and love this song
18baileychick 4 months ago
2 idiots dont like it?!!!!!!
michellelpn9 4 months ago in playlist evanescence
CHILLS!!!!! So glad Will Hunt and Troy Mclohren from Dark New Day are in the band now. Evanecence just went to a whole new level! Beautiful!
ParadigmShiftVisual 4 months ago
OMFG!!!! AMY LEE I LOVE YOU!!! BE MY MOM!
IzzyV15 4 months ago 2
This is my favourite song off the new album. I can't stop listening to it!!!
darkangelik25 4 months ago 33
@darkangelik25 mine, too!
treble225 4 months ago
@darkangelik25 personally after 6 days of listening to the album non stop, track three would be my fav. "The Change" and 2nd best would be track 7 "Lost In Paradise" and then this.
but the whole album is grand.
meserlian 4 months ago 9
@meserlian I like Lost in Paradise & Secret Door, but I've always been drawn to her ballads more.
EpicAmyLee 1 month ago
Amazing how no matter how many years pass between albums, Evanescence can come out with songs that I can relate to. Every flipping song on each of their albums is captivating, and this one is no different.
Glad to have you back with us, Amy!
SilverFlashTenTails 4 months ago 3
This is definitely one of my favorite Evanescence songs, hands down.
7792thereaper 4 months ago
God I love them, such a great band! Best female vocalist out there imo
wecosvinosec 4 months ago
AMAZING!!!
Mariahfan4eva 4 months ago
I hope they make a music video for this! :) Thank you Evanescence!
jessicaann14 4 months ago
this is simply amazing just amazing wow.. Amy Lee went above and beyond my expectations
jctcmc59 4 months ago
Wow! This is really beautiful. Amy Lee out does herself each time. I say "Bravo".
EuSanMarina7469 4 months ago
Evanescence is the best
alltimelow33ful 4 months ago
beats are crazy!!!!
musicrockszak98 4 months ago
this song sounds wicked!
AkiraSpectrum 4 months ago
i absolutely looove her harmonies!
efgraham0921 4 months ago
Amy Lee has the lilting voice of a dark-haired angel.
rainethesage 4 months ago
i plan to buy this, both on itunes and in the stores :) i love this song!
sangotaisho 4 months ago
There is deffinately a different sound than the other two albums, personally. I LOVE this song, and i think its the more "evanescence" out of all the others we've heard. I could see this fitting in The Open Door no problem but.....I'm glad it wasnt on there, I wouldnt love it so much. :)
Ravenlightwood 4 months ago
I wonder which retard clicked dislike :/
meserlian 4 months ago 27
@meserlian
no names
just different tastes
stuckinsidemyself 4 months ago
@meserlian 2 retards now.
Kirarey 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Evanescence
@meserlian I wonder when people on this Earth are going to respect that we have different tastes in music :/. And another person's taste isn't bad either. I hate hip hop and all of that but I don't go around calling people who like it retards, or otherwise say they have bad taste in music.
7792thereaper 4 months ago 22
@7792thereaper You are most probably right, but I do not see the need to respect anyone I personally do not know, I do not expect the same from the person sitting on the other side of the table as well.
Wouldn't it be cool if Youtube asked a reason every time you clicked dislike/like
meserlian 4 months ago 3
@meserlian Okay, but you don't have to insult them either. Yeah, that would be interesting if YouTube asked that.
7792thereaper 4 months ago
@meserlian I have the same out-look.
Eliannacardwell 2 months ago
@meserlian Respecting someone's musical talent is different, then liking their music. If you can appreciate the time they spent and the effort they did in making their songs, then you respect them. If you like or dislike their music is a different topic however.
OoShinkooO 1 month ago in playlist Evanescance
@7792thereaper if you dont like the song the dont listen to it is easy as that
jenoli11 3 months ago
@jenoli11 At what point did I say that I didn't like the song? This is one of my favorites from Evanescence.
7792thereaper 3 months ago
@7792thereaper
@meserlian ur an idiot and stop paying attention to small things that dont matter...How about just watching the video and leaving your own opinion without looking at others
bananaman2002 3 months ago
@7792thereaper thereaper, I don't think it's a matter of having personal taste, it's more a matter of people attempting to represent themselves in something unrelated to them. Likes/ Dislikes make sense when the person performing the such like/dislike is affected (For Example, a Rule, protocol, or regulation change within a sport, game, or competition) However they don't make sense when the person performing the negative critique has no affiliation or meaningful use.
OoShinkooO 1 month ago in playlist Evanescance
@7792thereaper I will take the old cliche Justin Bieber for example. Can I respect him as an Artist? Yes I can. Do I think there is a fan base for him? I think his numbers answer that question quite clear. Am I a fan of his music? No I'm not. Am I going to go through every single one of his videos and click Dislike? Nope because I can appreciate his work, and it would be a waste of time to offer a dislike when I'm not a fan of his work.
OoShinkooO 1 month ago in playlist Evanescance
@7792thereaper Lastly to some it up, when does it make sense for a dislike in the entertainment industry? Listen to "Hybrid Theory", "Reanimation", and "Meteora ". When you're finished with those, listen to "Minutes to Midnight", and "A Thousand Suns". Their style changed and as a result a lot of Die-Hard Fanatics who felt affected did not like this. I can respect that as a meaningful dislike, that had more then just a troll factor.
OoShinkooO 1 month ago in playlist Evanescance
@OoShinkooO Yeah, I agree with you, I don't go and click on dislike when I don't like a song or whatever, I just leave. The only thing though I was pointing out was that we shouldn't disrespect people who click the like button. They did it simply because they didn't like the song, not because they're retards or whatever as some people like saying, which is really immature.
7792thereaper 1 month ago 2
@7792thereaper well said, i hope so too.
unknownwr 1 month ago
@unknownwr Thank you
7792thereaper 1 month ago
@meserlian He probably missed the like button by accident cause he was so excited to click it
smbrynien 4 months ago
@meserlian cat hit the keyboard / mouse
ahoover72 4 months ago
I think I may cry...
Wonder if this is her sister's song for the album? It's so beautiful D':
Thank you for posting this, the website has The Other Side playing where they said this was. lol, they lied to us. xD
YumiRulz 4 months ago
This is amazing. Vocal strengths are at their ultimate high with the break she took! Love you, and thanks for everything Mrs. Amy Lynn (Lee) Hartzler!
telamon1267 4 months ago
I really love this song!
Why can't the album come out sooner?!?!
12345liz12345 4 months ago
This is way better than The Open Door...maybe even better than Fallen! ^^ This and The Other Side are my favorites so far !
assassin6637 4 months ago
The way I look at it, if this was a different band, I would love them, but since this is evanescence its gonna take some getting used to the generic sound. But after I listened to it a couple times, I fell in love with them all over again, in a different way. Oct 22nd come sooner! <3
drums22gdrkelly 4 months ago
@drums22gdrkelly You mean October 11, no?
tutankhamun90 4 months ago
@tutankhamun90 No actually, I'm seeing them live at the congress theater October 22nd :D
drums22gdrkelly 4 months ago
@drums22gdrkelly Oh, I thought you meant getting the album. I am so envious of you, I hope you have a great time at the show! :D
tutankhamun90 4 months ago
@tutankhamun90 thanks!
drums22gdrkelly 4 months ago
@drums22gdrkelly i got to see them on their first performance back in nashville back in august. i thought it would make my life complete, but now i just wanna see them as many times as i can before i die lol
they were AMAZIIINNGG!! have fun at the show!
efgraham0921 4 months ago
@efgraham0921 I'm Jealous! And thanks!
drums22gdrkelly 4 months ago
I can't believe how different they sound. If the rest of the album is like this, I'm definitely getitng it. (This is coming from someone who usually isn't a fan.)
ivalice1980 4 months ago
11 days... then i shall have my drug of choice :)
stuckinsidemyself 4 months ago
damm this song is to amazing my mouth droped when i heard this !!!!! shes an amazing artist and finally shes back and dam she came hard
69eazyjosh 4 months ago
This song is incredible. One of their best ever!
wavy2525 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thank you Amy Lee for writing such beautiful lyrics.
MrFIERO74 4 months ago
Thank you Amy Lee for writing such beautiful lyrics.
MrFIERO74 4 months ago
Jeez...the way she sings the word "Broken" gives me chills...the only thing as beautiful as her voice is herself :D
ilaxim 4 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
One Cool Song A Day twitter list song choice for Sep 29, 2011
OneCoolSongADay 4 months ago
one of the few singersi can say who are true to themselves and devoted to their music! love amy lee, her voice, her style, and every song she has put out I've listened to...love you evanescence! you guys rock!
Mthib23 4 months ago 4
Oh my god I so cannot wait for the release!!!!! She is amazing!
atta57 4 months ago
This song is absolutely amazing. Her amazing voice, and her beauty is wonderful. I WANT THE ALBUM! NOW!!!!
telamon1267 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Troy is so much better as drummer than Rocky. This beat and the piano are awesome!!
Evanescencerockshard 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Troy is so much better as drummer than Rocky. This beat and the piano are awesome!!
Evanescencerockshard 4 months ago
Troy is so much better as drummer than Rocky. This beat and the piano are awesome!!
Evanescencerockshard 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Troy is so much better as drummer than Rocky. This beat and the piano are awesome!!
Evanescencerockshard 4 months ago
Troy is so much better as drummer than Rocky. This beat and the piano are awesome!!
Evanescencerockshard 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God she is amazing!!! so beautiful and man what a voice!
acox1805 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God she is amazing!!! so beautiful and man what a voice!
acox1805 4 months ago
god she is amazing!!! so beautiful and man what a voice!
acox1805 4 months ago
god she is amazing!!! so beautiful and man what a voice!
acox1805 4 months ago
Her voice ..... orgasmic!
meserlian 4 months ago 28
God I love this song. Their CD can't come out soon enough. The piano is really amazing.
TimelessHero233 4 months ago 26
@TimelessHero233 Are you planning on buying the CD? Cause I downloaded it the other day. But I couldn't find the deluxe version :(
MeLiE89 4 months ago
@MeLiE89 Yeah I purchased the deluxe edition on iTunes. An absolutely great CD and totally worth the extra money for the additional songs.
TimelessHero233 4 months ago