with the movement in Egypt towards democracy and possibly Jordan, why don’t they have the Arab world accept some responsibility and carve up a state for the "Palestinians" from their land and let the Jews have their small strip of biblical land and let them live in peace. How greedy can the Arabs be?
the world have seen masicares again & again, who ever think Isreal is a country or state is totally wrong, It is a death machine and its policies are based on military war machines. Some times they over size their war scope and some times they come down on the heads of poor people like those. Shame on you, this is a crime of humanity and the free world is watching this crime seen evolving over and over again. shame on you.
pG. 4 I seen a man holding a baby that must had been 1 month old dead, a woman her and her husband was trying to have a baby for 5 yrs. they had a son dead at 2 mos. old, I seen women was killed very close to their delivery date for their baby killed and the baby cut out of their bodies that's what Israel mean about 1 shot 2 kill and Israeli wear the shirt proudly. Not the act of my God or the act of someone that believe in God. Just look for yourself ppl it's all on YouTude. Very sad.
Pg. 3 Some Jews protested and said "they are glad they kill Jesus" look it up it's all on YouTube. Trust me I was shock to hear that coming from a Jew and he was not ashame to say so it was at his own will. When I seen the videos and seen kids are without families I wanted to go there and love all those kids and protect them. The families are innocent, all they want is to live thrie lives like you and I. After all that these ppl still gets on their and pray like they do every day. AMAZING
Pg. 2 I hope your kids safe, have food to eat, clean water to drink. The world seen the dead bodies in Gaza it's all in YouTube and I try to see the ones that lost their life on Israel side and seen no report. More ppl died in Gaza, lost thrie homes and in Israel the Palestinians are force to move by Israelis. Ive seen an Palestinian man lived in him home that he was born in for to move at gun point. Not the acr of my GO, Israel can never say "In Jesus name"
It's funny you should say that because all I seen on CNN is dead unborn babie, toddlers, kids and innocent Palestine ppl. and their blood and brains laying in the ground fron their heads. I have not seen dead Israelis yet and I watch everyday. Oh! the hate those ppl have, this not the act of God this is the devils work. Ppl has lost families, kids without a mother and father, stone walls fall on kids killing them, kids with bullet going throw their bodies from enemy fire.
To those who condemn Israel within your comments here... Had the subject of this video been about multiple Israeli dead following a Palestinian attack I suspect you would be condemning the Palestinians and saying "long live Israel".
" Long Live Israel" would be terribly out of context, that's why most people wouldn't say it. When Israelis die, its no less important, in my opinion, but the difference, my friend is that PALESTINE IS UNDER ISRAELI OCCUPATION AND ITS EXISTENCE IS ACTUALLY UNDER THREAT. ISRAEL IS THE OCCUPIER.
So yes,some Israelis have been killed but its all very EXPLICABLE (not less sad). when a family gets shelled on the beach while having an afternoon in the sun, there is no justification for that... .
lets not forget that those poor arabs was voting for Hamas at the elections! Hamas never will recognize the right of israel to -exist- befor and after this war!
so those people knew what are they doing! and now its the time to take responsability for thair actions! every country have the right to defend it self!!
"if the palastinians will cease fire will be peace, if israel will it will not be israel" hars to heard but its the true.
the land does not belong to israel, it is palestinian land that they are occupying, so it is the palestinians who are defending themselves and the zionists are the attackers
Palestine. The Israeli propaganda machine is HUGE! It has even Evangelical Christians under false beliefs. The only way to counter is with money invested in PACs, media outlets, and diplomacy. Please invest in these and not more rudimentary bombs.
Jewish are doing halacaust. May God curse them every day with every breath.May this life and next be hell for them.Gaza, Gaza don't you fear Muslimin are here... we are coming inshallah Allahu akbar
A logical argument first has to be valid before it can either be proved or disproved. Since your slow let me say this way: if it is not valid than it's not logical, and only logical can either be proved true of false.
Sorry for the word omission that was, "only logical arguments can ether be...."
Tell me, though, can you even name the conditions that would make an argument valid, or even the distinction between what kind of arguments are considered valid as opposed to the kind that are considered good, since the later would at least establish you do understand something about the nature of logical, i.e. rational, arguments?
It's a shame that here in the US we're numb to everything going on around the world b/c we're dumbed down w/ stupid news stories about celebrities. If only Americans were aware of how much their aid continues to propogate the violence that leaves these children homeless.
Thanks for this video. I wish that more people would see it and have a deeper interest in the conflict. All my sympathies goes with Raed Atharmneh and his family.
Sadly, I do not see an end in this conflict; I read in the newspaper today that the US will raise their military support to Israel. From 2008 the yearly support will be over 3 billion US dollars.
Wrong way to go. Violence feeds violence!
Anyone remembering Gandhi? "An eye for an eye, and soon the whole world is blind"
what i would like to see is a group of progressive and bold palestenian and israeli youth stepping up and leading a constructive debate on ways to end the domination of relegious extremists and religious ideology from both sides on this conflict! if everybody beleives that they have "the divine right" or "the divine obligation", this conflict will never be resolved.
I agree...religious dominance should end. It should not be part of the law of a country. But how do we get rid of it, when people still hate based on the killing of Jesus, regardless of who they blame.
Pretty clever... Though I was making a point about how someones comment makes no logical sense, while you are making a point about a question mark. I apologize if my lack of a question mark brought any discomfort to you.
You keep bringing up logic yet you've consistently failed to employ any yourself. You've yet to offer one impressive line of reasoning, while most of your argument is comprised of ad hominems.
I didnt say "all Americans who voted for Bush" are stupid. I said, Bush "got elected twice by the stupid Americans". Unless you really did vote for Bush and considered yourself as stupid, then nothing much I can say. So be it. You are stupid.
All Americans who voted for Bush are stupid. How much more stupid can one be than to intentionally re-elect an incompetent criminal administration who had perhaps done more damage to this country during their first term, than any other administration in U.S. history.
I would be hard pressed to define that behavior as anything other than stupid.
Idiots think of it logically. Israel has no use in targeting civilans because of the terrible PR campaigns each incident brings on. Not to mention the distortions of each event. Unless you think Israel is full of a bunch on nitwits it would not serve their interests at all to target civilians.
Some people just dont use logic and what the hell do they care about you when they think they are "superior". Its the same as your president who think himself as smart ass where the whole world think he is just a moron from Texas who got elected twice by the stupid Americans.
idiot think be rational and think logically. First, however you should become informed about the issue. Israel has a tremendous media lobby in this country. The U.S. corporate news is biased. This isn't an opinion it is a well documented fact. Then ignorant asses like you with few critical reasoning skills spew that bias in forms like this. Israel works hard to make Palestinians non entities in the media exactly so they don't have to deal with repercussion of violence against the Palestinians.
the men who fired rockets at Israel did that for those people's back yards and take off right after the launch. when the Israeli artillery fired back the ones who got hit were the sicilians in that area.
instead of blaming Israel for firing back, blame the terrorists who use Gaza's civilians as shilds.
I didnt hear any saying of terrorist at those people backyard. All I heard from the report is 18 people from that particular fixer's family dead because of Israelis artillery. And if you read what Tieflin wrote below it does make sense. With all the advance artillery technology that the Israelis got, why do they always make mistakes?
the 18 dead civilians were not terrorists. the terrorists were the Hamas men who launched rockets from those civilians' back yard.
Israel's artillery isnt very advanced. at least not as some of its other corps. the howitzer is the old M109 and the shells are the same HE, both from from the 70's.
no weapon in the would can determine in the object it hits is armed or not and when those terrorists launched their rockets they knew Israel will fire back.
Terrible. How can they expect to make peace with israel when they kill innocent palestinians? Even thought iam against hamas using suicide tacticts, honestly they dont have any other choice.Killing of innocent , whether jews or muslims, infact any race or religion, is wrong, period.
The saddest part about this video is that this incident will just breed more violence. Palestinians will keep attacking Israel, and Israel will in turn retaliate.
War sucks... While Israel does not target civilians, civilian casualties will occur in times of war. It is a very sad thing and I wish there was someway to turn back time. My condolences to the family.
Oh yeah, so ISRAELI tanks surround Beit Hannoun, they close off the city, then IDF starts bombing it from the air and massacre 18 members of one family and your conclusion is that Hamas and Fatah should be blamed? You nuts? Did you not hear that even Israelis admited it was them?
It's a popular terrorist tactic to hide in a civil populace, hoping that it will cause civilian deaths and bring sympathy to their cause. It amazes me that these people still give shelter and support to organizations like Hamas, when all it does is legitimize their being targeted.
openheimdavid, when you mothers ass is shot then you should come and mention it! israel's time is coming soon, their package is prepared by IRAN. HEIL HITLER
seems like an objective video.... nothing unusual at all that they fail to mention why Beit Hanoun is under attack. Why aren't other Palestinian villages under attack? Could it have anything to do with Kassam rockets not mentioned at all in this video?
interesting video
12TabulaRasa12 1 month ago
Firsthand information!
thetricon69 2 months ago
these people are magnets for propaganda
rockynanach 11 months ago
stupid fat cow maybe if you stop shoting rockets into israel you wont have your house blown up
rockynanach 11 months ago
Jordan is Palestine
watch?v=yIy0JLUmarg
with the movement in Egypt towards democracy and possibly Jordan, why don’t they have the Arab world accept some responsibility and carve up a state for the "Palestinians" from their land and let the Jews have their small strip of biblical land and let them live in peace. How greedy can the Arabs be?
rockynanach 11 months ago
What hurts me the most is not what the israelis are doing..It is the fact that we watch thousands of videos like this , and we just go back to sleep.
But there will always be the soldiers of allah everywthere :)
KINGZ44four 1 year ago
Being American, I thank Al Jazeera for showing the other side of the story, which is impossible here in the U.S.
passionplus07 1 year ago
the world have seen masicares again & again, who ever think Isreal is a country or state is totally wrong, It is a death machine and its policies are based on military war machines. Some times they over size their war scope and some times they come down on the heads of poor people like those. Shame on you, this is a crime of humanity and the free world is watching this crime seen evolving over and over again. shame on you.
1naturalforce 2 years ago 6
hope ur mother was there u motherfucker////
AMOKHAN786 2 years ago
fuckin palestine ugly cunt women, wonder why she wasnt killed
intelrox 2 years ago
hope ur mother was there, mr intelrox
AMOKHAN786 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wait taliban and alqaeda come israel wait and watch and inshallah we win
potty2341 2 years ago
pG. 4 I seen a man holding a baby that must had been 1 month old dead, a woman her and her husband was trying to have a baby for 5 yrs. they had a son dead at 2 mos. old, I seen women was killed very close to their delivery date for their baby killed and the baby cut out of their bodies that's what Israel mean about 1 shot 2 kill and Israeli wear the shirt proudly. Not the act of my God or the act of someone that believe in God. Just look for yourself ppl it's all on YouTude. Very sad.
MsCuriousCat 2 years ago
Pg. 3 Some Jews protested and said "they are glad they kill Jesus" look it up it's all on YouTube. Trust me I was shock to hear that coming from a Jew and he was not ashame to say so it was at his own will. When I seen the videos and seen kids are without families I wanted to go there and love all those kids and protect them. The families are innocent, all they want is to live thrie lives like you and I. After all that these ppl still gets on their and pray like they do every day. AMAZING
MsCuriousCat 2 years ago
Pg. 2 I hope your kids safe, have food to eat, clean water to drink. The world seen the dead bodies in Gaza it's all in YouTube and I try to see the ones that lost their life on Israel side and seen no report. More ppl died in Gaza, lost thrie homes and in Israel the Palestinians are force to move by Israelis. Ive seen an Palestinian man lived in him home that he was born in for to move at gun point. Not the acr of my GO, Israel can never say "In Jesus name"
MsCuriousCat 2 years ago
It's funny you should say that because all I seen on CNN is dead unborn babie, toddlers, kids and innocent Palestine ppl. and their blood and brains laying in the ground fron their heads. I have not seen dead Israelis yet and I watch everyday. Oh! the hate those ppl have, this not the act of God this is the devils work. Ppl has lost families, kids without a mother and father, stone walls fall on kids killing them, kids with bullet going throw their bodies from enemy fire.
MsCuriousCat 2 years ago
Comment removed
MsCuriousCat 2 years ago
this is genocide and it needs to stop
destroytheenemy1 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
8innocence8 3 years ago
Free Palestine!!! the have the right to defend itself too!!
Outpost007 3 years ago 2
To those who condemn Israel within your comments here... Had the subject of this video been about multiple Israeli dead following a Palestinian attack I suspect you would be condemning the Palestinians and saying "long live Israel".
Good luck taking your cake, and eating it too!
ytartapo 3 years ago
Comment removed
neguhjoe 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
" Long Live Israel" would be terribly out of context, that's why most people wouldn't say it. When Israelis die, its no less important, in my opinion, but the difference, my friend is that PALESTINE IS UNDER ISRAELI OCCUPATION AND ITS EXISTENCE IS ACTUALLY UNDER THREAT. ISRAEL IS THE OCCUPIER.
So yes,some Israelis have been killed but its all very EXPLICABLE (not less sad). when a family gets shelled on the beach while having an afternoon in the sun, there is no justification for that... .
neguhjoe 2 years ago
It's heart wrenching.May god bless the gaza people and his wrath be on Isreal.
zuezue2212 3 years ago
poor arabs !?
its defenetly hard to watch this pictures
lets not forget that those poor arabs was voting for Hamas at the elections! Hamas never will recognize the right of israel to -exist- befor and after this war!
so those people knew what are they doing! and now its the time to take responsability for thair actions! every country have the right to defend it self!!
"if the palastinians will cease fire will be peace, if israel will it will not be israel" hars to heard but its the true.
talrabovski 3 years ago
Free Palestine!!!
aikhooligan 3 years ago
I would like to thank Aljazeera for this presentation. Without this I, an American, would otherwise have no access to this footage.
stinkbuttdog 3 years ago
the land does not belong to israel, it is palestinian land that they are occupying, so it is the palestinians who are defending themselves and the zionists are the attackers
hzcassim 3 years ago 2
this is the reality of the brutality of the isrealits dont let anything tell you different may God bless Palestine
mrfxit2 3 years ago 2
Powerful.
Conspiracy2Riot 3 years ago
My God what a great documentary! Congratulations from Brazil!!! God may support the Palestinians against Israel.
stigmaweb 3 years ago 2
a aaaaaaaa
mannyfeseha 3 years ago
look at the morale of these brave ppl,even after this gruesome attack they are still smiling may allah bless them
zeedaanzeedaan 3 years ago 13
This is a good report!
jimed 3 years ago 8
Boycott Israeli apartheid.
robjirasama 3 years ago 3
Palestine. The Israeli propaganda machine is HUGE! It has even Evangelical Christians under false beliefs. The only way to counter is with money invested in PACs, media outlets, and diplomacy. Please invest in these and not more rudimentary bombs.
eyeDfy 3 years ago
Jewish are doing halacaust. May God curse them every day with every breath.May this life and next be hell for them.Gaza, Gaza don't you fear Muslimin are here... we are coming inshallah Allahu akbar
fumikoines 3 years ago
Jewish are doing halacaust.
forumchi 3 years ago
And you thought the Jews suffered the holocaust in WW-II while they are inflicting the same on innocent Arabs?
ThaiRaj 3 years ago
Wake up America and smell the coffee - stop supporting this Zionist terrorism.
WTU208 3 years ago 3
and the Israeli did that just because they had nothing better to do? Is it possible that a rocket or two or three was shot at Israel?
Oh no. That doesn't happen.
rezasantorini 3 years ago
watch the video properly...
at 8:10 a quote from Ehud Olmert saying that the artillery strike was a "technical failure"
..besides what excuse can you have for killing innocent civilians and women and children?
prazskykral 3 years ago
wonderful video. this is what the world needs to see!
AmjSadi 3 years ago
Again it is impossible to rationally argue with anyone who thinks that all Americans who voted for Bush are stupid. You proved my point.
guitargreg19 4 years ago
A logical argument first has to be valid before it can either be proved or disproved. Since your slow let me say this way: if it is not valid than it's not logical, and only logical can either be proved true of false.
TexasRounder 4 years ago
Sorry for the word omission that was, "only logical arguments can ether be...."
Tell me, though, can you even name the conditions that would make an argument valid, or even the distinction between what kind of arguments are considered valid as opposed to the kind that are considered good, since the later would at least establish you do understand something about the nature of logical, i.e. rational, arguments?
TexasRounder 4 years ago
don't generalize.there's a good bunch of Jewish peace-activists.
luxcretia2 4 years ago
keep it up aljazeera
danthg 4 years ago
It's a shame that here in the US we're numb to everything going on around the world b/c we're dumbed down w/ stupid news stories about celebrities. If only Americans were aware of how much their aid continues to propogate the violence that leaves these children homeless.
shusain0 4 years ago
There's no such thing as Palestine.
hotspur2514 4 years ago
theres no such this as ur mom
hassan691987 4 years ago
Thanks for this video. I wish that more people would see it and have a deeper interest in the conflict. All my sympathies goes with Raed Atharmneh and his family.
Sadly, I do not see an end in this conflict; I read in the newspaper today that the US will raise their military support to Israel. From 2008 the yearly support will be over 3 billion US dollars.
Wrong way to go. Violence feeds violence!
Anyone remembering Gandhi? "An eye for an eye, and soon the whole world is blind"
carlaberatio 4 years ago
what i would like to see is a group of progressive and bold palestenian and israeli youth stepping up and leading a constructive debate on ways to end the domination of relegious extremists and religious ideology from both sides on this conflict! if everybody beleives that they have "the divine right" or "the divine obligation", this conflict will never be resolved.
mushaqct 4 years ago
I agree...religious dominance should end. It should not be part of the law of a country. But how do we get rid of it, when people still hate based on the killing of Jesus, regardless of who they blame.
rezasantorini 3 years ago
Pretty clever... Though I was making a point about how someones comment makes no logical sense, while you are making a point about a question mark. I apologize if my lack of a question mark brought any discomfort to you.
guitargreg19 4 years ago
You keep bringing up logic yet you've consistently failed to employ any yourself. You've yet to offer one impressive line of reasoning, while most of your argument is comprised of ad hominems.
TexasRounder 4 years ago
Only by addressing both sides will there be anychance at ending the violence.
JusticeFish82 4 years ago
WHY???? IT's disgusting to see this...why don't people care...why don't we see this in the media!!!!
arsalanrozy 4 years ago
We are seeing it in the media, thanks to Al Jazeera.
TexasRounder 4 years ago
israel is a terrorist state
hassan691987 4 years ago
Its futile to argue with someone who thinks that all Americans who voted for Bush are stupid.
guitargreg19 4 years ago
I didnt say "all Americans who voted for Bush" are stupid. I said, Bush "got elected twice by the stupid Americans". Unless you really did vote for Bush and considered yourself as stupid, then nothing much I can say. So be it. You are stupid.
shinada 4 years ago
What a retarded reply. Did you flunk out of English class.
guitargreg19 4 years ago
Did you flunk in typing "?" after a question?
eliasbennis 4 years ago
All Americans who voted for Bush are stupid. How much more stupid can one be than to intentionally re-elect an incompetent criminal administration who had perhaps done more damage to this country during their first term, than any other administration in U.S. history.
I would be hard pressed to define that behavior as anything other than stupid.
TexasRounder 4 years ago
Idiots think of it logically. Israel has no use in targeting civilans because of the terrible PR campaigns each incident brings on. Not to mention the distortions of each event. Unless you think Israel is full of a bunch on nitwits it would not serve their interests at all to target civilians.
guitargreg19 4 years ago 2
Some people just dont use logic and what the hell do they care about you when they think they are "superior". Its the same as your president who think himself as smart ass where the whole world think he is just a moron from Texas who got elected twice by the stupid Americans.
shinada 4 years ago
idiot think be rational and think logically. First, however you should become informed about the issue. Israel has a tremendous media lobby in this country. The U.S. corporate news is biased. This isn't an opinion it is a well documented fact. Then ignorant asses like you with few critical reasoning skills spew that bias in forms like this. Israel works hard to make Palestinians non entities in the media exactly so they don't have to deal with repercussion of violence against the Palestinians.
TexasRounder 4 years ago 2
God? up untill 700 years ago, you guys didnt belive there was only one god.
speaking of civilization, what made you move to the US? living in the middle east wasnt good enugh for you?
NimDod 4 years ago
why should they killed the civilians though?
shinada 4 years ago
the men who fired rockets at Israel did that for those people's back yards and take off right after the launch. when the Israeli artillery fired back the ones who got hit were the sicilians in that area.
instead of blaming Israel for firing back, blame the terrorists who use Gaza's civilians as shilds.
NimDod 4 years ago
I didnt hear any saying of terrorist at those people backyard. All I heard from the report is 18 people from that particular fixer's family dead because of Israelis artillery. And if you read what Tieflin wrote below it does make sense. With all the advance artillery technology that the Israelis got, why do they always make mistakes?
hisbollah888 4 years ago
the 18 dead civilians were not terrorists. the terrorists were the Hamas men who launched rockets from those civilians' back yard.
Israel's artillery isnt very advanced. at least not as some of its other corps. the howitzer is the old M109 and the shells are the same HE, both from from the 70's.
no weapon in the would can determine in the object it hits is armed or not and when those terrorists launched their rockets they knew Israel will fire back.
NimDod 4 years ago
Except that in this case that didn't happen, according the Israeli government who admitted to making a mistake.
Zionism=Nazism
TexasRounder 4 years ago
what didnt happen?
did you even read my post?
go to school
NimDod 4 years ago
well, maybe they should have though about if before they staeted launching rockets at Israel from civilan areas?
they dont call them "human shilds" for nothing...
NimDod 4 years ago
Terrible. How can they expect to make peace with israel when they kill innocent palestinians? Even thought iam against hamas using suicide tacticts, honestly they dont have any other choice.Killing of innocent , whether jews or muslims, infact any race or religion, is wrong, period.
ultraperformance 4 years ago
The saddest part about this video is that this incident will just breed more violence. Palestinians will keep attacking Israel, and Israel will in turn retaliate.
chiefchumley 4 years ago
When does it end?
robot4001 4 years ago
War sucks... While Israel does not target civilians, civilian casualties will occur in times of war. It is a very sad thing and I wish there was someway to turn back time. My condolences to the family.
guitargreg19 4 years ago
i think they deliberately targeted the civilians. it wasn't the first time.
shinada 4 years ago
Rubbish. An occupation is not a war and Israel regularly targets civilians.
ivahewjas 4 years ago
this is a very biased one sided account of what is going on in Gaza. Why is Hamas and Fatah not being blamed for the killing?
lfbaker 4 years ago
Oh yeah, so ISRAELI tanks surround Beit Hannoun, they close off the city, then IDF starts bombing it from the air and massacre 18 members of one family and your conclusion is that Hamas and Fatah should be blamed? You nuts? Did you not hear that even Israelis admited it was them?
LUVDM 4 years ago
It's a popular terrorist tactic to hide in a civil populace, hoping that it will cause civilian deaths and bring sympathy to their cause. It amazes me that these people still give shelter and support to organizations like Hamas, when all it does is legitimize their being targeted.
hotspur2514 4 years ago
lol i see u been schooled pretty good in propaganda
hassan691987 4 years ago
I didn't see the funny side.
hotspur2514 4 years ago
this is genocide
Bm0h 4 years ago
Hey palesteniens wake up! fighting with each others , when you see this tape you realise who is you're real enemy
lamat78 4 years ago
openheimdavid, when you mothers ass is shot then you should come and mention it! israel's time is coming soon, their package is prepared by IRAN. HEIL HITLER
nabenda123 4 years ago
My understanding is that preceeding these events, rockets were fired form this location into Israel. Is this correct?
lapsiek 4 years ago
yeah, you're right. 4 rockets were fired that landed in an open desert in the western negev. no injuries or damage were reported.
gazawi10 4 years ago
Very Good
911mythbusters 4 years ago
israel kills its humanity before killing any palestinian
freemanlovesfreedom 4 years ago
i've got no sympathy for israel.
InfinityDose 4 years ago
this is stuff people really need to see.
Blickwinkel101 4 years ago
seems like an objective video.... nothing unusual at all that they fail to mention why Beit Hanoun is under attack. Why aren't other Palestinian villages under attack? Could it have anything to do with Kassam rockets not mentioned at all in this video?
oppenheimdavid 4 years ago
If you had watched the part one of "Witness" you would realize that they DO mention the Kassam rockets...
protoype13 4 years ago
excellent video
mrgrieves9876 4 years ago
viva WITNESS!
danthg 4 years ago