Added: 5 years ago
From: LeonaRulez
Views: 235,193
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,032)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Leonaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!­

  • I always thought Vonzell did Whitney the most proud until I heard Charice. Ever heard of Charice???

  • Can't touch Whitney !

  • And Whitney too.

  • Jennifer and Leona killed it!!!!

  • ummm leona was getting too much time ...and i notices vonzell never even get hit her high notes.... do over!

  • Listen the version of Sarah Riani.

  • Jennifer was the best...I don't Like Leona voice..It's boring...Jennifer was way close to Whitney's Perfomance

  • Leona

    Vonzell

    Whitney

    Jennifer

    Lakisha

    just because Whitney made the song doesn't mean that there aren't people out here that can sing the song better than her and Leona and Vonzell tore this song up

  • @LadyTucker4Life TOTALLY AGRREEE!!!

  • 1.whitney

    2.leona

    3.vonzell

    4.jennifer

    5.lakisha

  • there all so good.... i luv them all.... they all should have won on american idol..... n im glad leona won..... plus im glad that whitney made this song

  • 1. like whitney nobody!

    2. leona

    3. jennifer

    4. lakisha

    5. vonzell

  • nobody is better than the Whitney

    she is unique and perfect

  • 1. Leona

    2.Whitney

    3.Vonzell

    4.Jennifer

    5.Lakisha

  • they all did good i think jennifer hudson and lakisha made it seem effortless like whitney herself. leona did it her own and vonzell had the emotion in my opion.

  • every body sounds good but jenfer no lolz

  • charicè.. the chinese girl... sings this song the best.. you forget over here

  • 1. WHITNEY

    2.WHITNEY AND

    3.WHITNEY

    SHE WILL BE ALWAYS THE BEST!!! THE OTHER !JUST OTHERS!

  • whitney on 3th place..are you idiot or deaf??she was the greatest singer of all time and will stay this way for at least another century.

  • check out the i have nothing cover by Jessica Mauboy. Australian Idol

  • Lakisha was THE WORST!!! ill give her 4th place. Jennifer 3th sound to deep. Then vonzell amazing tone 2nd and leona the best.....

  • Vonzell has best the end

  • WOW Leona! Comes closer than anyone else to Whitney.

  • 1. Leona

    2. Vonzel

    3. Whitney

    4. and 5. - horrible

  • Vonzell and Leona - Bravo!!!

  • @Erwajs15 absolutely right!! lakisha too deep, jennifer WAAAYYYY ttoo deep and was out of time. i liked leona the best here

  • Jenifer, Lakisha - horrible

  • I think the only one to ever come close to Whitney was Leona...IMO.

  • whitney for ever

  • I remember when Leona sang this on the X-Factor. She was sooo good! As good as the others are, Leona sounds the closest to Whitney. She hits the high notes so effortlessly....probably even better than Whitney. But that all said.....I still think Whitney was one of the greatest pop singers the world has known! How can you better perfection?

  • Leona was good. Aside from Whitney being the best of course.

  • Leona is the closest to Whitney's voice, she is really good.

  • when they all say "if i dont have you" they all stick their hand out in the air lol

  • lakisha and jennifer were one note lower in singing this song. So mine are the following below:

    1. Whitney, of course

    2. Leona

    3. Vonzell

    4. Jennifer

    5. Lakisha

  • Even though it was just a falsetto note(a beautiful one, but one that many singers can do,) Leona was the only one who added SOMETHING to the performance to make it more memorable. Nobody who covers this song ever thinks outside of the box, which is why Whitney will probably always have the best version. Out of the other four, Leona is definitely the best, followed by Jen, Vonzell closely after, and then Lakisha.

  • my favourite is non of theese . It´s Maria Haukaas storeng from our neighbour-country. Norway :)

  • @n1cklass

    here she is

    /watch?v=fXqxDq-XBJ4

  • Vonzell and Lakisha sang it the best and of course Whitney!! :)

  • You missed out Katherine McPhee!

  • 1. whitney

    2.leona

    3.lakisha

    4.vonzell

    5.jennifer

  • Todas cantan precioso, pero me parece que faltó la interpretación de Charice Pempengco, que a pesar de su corta edad, tiene una voz de grande espectacular, y sinceramente supero algunas voces del video...

  • Leona is so overrated, I honestly think all the other singers in this vid blow her out of the water (other than maybe Lakisha)! But seriously (not counting Whitney, cuz she obvs would be #1 and it's not fair to compare the others to her):

    1. Vonzell (put more personality in it for me)

    2. Jennifer

    3. Leona

    4. Lakisha

  • Go Leona, Whitney!

    Leona!

  • whitney and leona...

  • what is this??????????????????????

    idiot!

  • Idol needs drop this song. Its getting really repetitive.

  • Lakisa doesn't get all the fancy echo chambers and crap that Simon has for Leona and the special movie effects like Whitney gets . She simply has her fantastic voice, which produces perfects songs always!

  • Lakisha can outsing all of them at any time! Best voice ever from American Idol!

  • Are you (TONE) deaf!! she sings it in a key lower - so does Jennifer

  • whitney all the way.......

  • Vonzell and Whitney...the others need some more training but they are not that bad either

  • whitney knocks them all into a corner....doesnt matter how good they are they cant compare!!! closest for me is leona lewis

  • WHITNEY>Leona> the others

  • Correct!!

  • 1) Witney

    2) Jennifer

    3) Leona

    4) Vonzelle

    4) Lakisha

  • umm. I would much rather prefer Vonzell

  • whitney's live performances are incomparable to the other singers' although they are good. so justice had been made with the (just) studio version showed. respect a diva. and remember who was doing it first' thank you very much.

  • Leonaaa && Whitneyy <3

  • i luv her

  • leona .....:)

  • Thia list is based off vocals of this video not popularity contest or career background.

    1.)leona lewis

    2.)whitney

    3.)vonzell

    4.)lakisha

    5.)jennifer

  • Die Diva ist wieder da Whitney housten sie ist die beste und schönste segerin sie kann es besser die anderen machen ihr nur nach  ich bin ihr größster fan der welt

  • Taking Whitney out of it,

    1) Vonzelle

    2)Jennifer

    3)Leona

    4) Lakisha

    In that order, based on Timbre, control, emotion and originality.

  • well whitney's version is a studio version so off the the list, not fair to the others (computers can do wonders babe).

    Now to the others,

    Leona is just amazing, the control she has over her voice and the pitches she chooses to sing, that girl is certainly one of the best of our generation. (for all you haters out there, don't blame your incompetence one someone just because you can't sing like that).

    Vonzell, wow girl, I've never heard of her until now and I loved it, my new fave one

    the rest

  • nice mix ;)

  • Here you can put to Rosa lopez, she sang this song in Ot. YOU CAN LISTEN HER IN YOUTUBE, YOU CAN PUT ROSA I HAVE NOTHING. I PREFER HER, SHE IS AMAZING!!!

  • 1.whitney need i explain

    2.vonzell she was amazing i love her voice if they would have done something with her then she would have gone bih

    3.leona it was just ok

    4.lakisha wrong song choice listen to her singing and i am telling you

    5.jennifer only because she put to much bass in her voice on this 1

  • Comment removed

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Vonzell

    3. Jennifer

    4. Leona

    5. Lakisha

  • yes

  • first of all i wont count whitneys part coz its her song and also a recording wheras every1 else is live .

    1. LEONA (she was amazing !!)

    2. the rest of em

  • Leona Lewis, and was not very trained to sing this song and this is still a reality show, I give you the first place with Whitney Houston.

  • leone is screaming alot sing gal you ve it all you can be whit and mariah you are leona

  • Whitney is too good. No comparison...

  • i think its...

    1) whitney

    2) all the rest.

    they all had certain parts that were amazing, whitneys just above all haha

  • leona has extremely irregular vibrato..

  • 1-Whitney

    2-Leona

    3-Vonzell

    4-Jennifer

    5-Lakisha

  • shoot I'd be happy if I could sing like any one of them! Fantastic vocals

  • i cannot believe i read someone say whitney couldnt sing good live..in her prime and when she did sing this live my god, on some performances she makes the cd sound rubbish whitney was not born to be in a studio she was born to be on stage with a mic in her hand blowing people off their seats, not one of these women will ever scale the heights ms.houston did

  • @chesneysimon and someone said Justin Beiber sang better than Whitney LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @chesneysimon i agree with u all the way some people just cant be touch she and michael jackson one of them

  • voice quality goes to leona lewis

    originality(other than whitney) vonzell and leona

  • They were all good but tbh Whtiney pwns all.

    So one lesson: Never ever copy the original

  • i love the black women's voice. they are very unique to me

  • Wow I forgot how good Vonzell was...she and Leona and OF COURSE Whitney sang it the best

  • and fabiola???

  • Whitney And VONZELL?!!!

  • Vonzell was DEFINITELY the BEST.

    But not enough Vonzell in this video! >:(

  • leona gave me chills at 2:19 - 2:27

  • leona and whitney all the way the others tried hard

  • and charice.

  • fuck off with charice, she cant compare with grown women

  • have to say vonzells was the best then leona and dont know why the hell lakisha is in this

  • she is good though!!

  • if you listen to this with out looking u can tell hu is the best and dats Whitney and Leona.. Yeah they bestest vocalists by far

  • whitney, leona and vonzell...maybe kath mcphee could be in this video..

  • LaKisha's the best!

  • Leona and Vonzell by a mile, That Lakisha is awful, why she on this video lol

  • 1. Whitney, but her live versions are better

    2. Jennifer

    don't really like the others.

  • how bout Katharine Mcphee? :s

  • 1. withney

    2. leona Vonzell &

    3. Lakisha

  • respect to all the women who sing these song knowing that they will be compared to the one and only whitney!

  • is this even a question, whitney !!!! hands down

    all the others are copying her style, you may think they are singing in their own style but they are trying to make their voices and performance closely resemble whitney.

  • well that's kind of the whole point of the talent shows...

  • Leona is the best!

  • do you mind putting charice pempengco's version too?

  • Obviously Whitney, then at a VERY CLOSE second, Leona... to be honest the high note that Leona hit MAY HAVE EVEN put HER over the top of Whitney. Other than those two, Vonzell gets a VERY distant third and as for Lakisha and Jennifer...well, Jennifer is in a category by herself, it just sucks that that particular category is BELOW Whitney where this performance is concerned,

  • I agree. I think the fact that Leona's version was so much more unique than the other imitations that it put her near the top.. and Lakisha and Vonzell song the mess outta this song but this was def. not Jennifer's best performance she sings so well tho..

  • THE BEST!!THE BEST!! THEY are the best!

  • leona's version is the best even if vonzell one's is also good

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Leona

    3. Vonzel

  • leonas the best

  • Only Leona Lewis and Vonzell Solomon retained the original key/note of Whitney Houston. It shows that they have the range to hit th notes. Lakisha Jones and Jennifer Hudson has the weakest performance here. However, Jennifer Hudson made a key change in her last chorus and hit the original note which Lakisha Jones did not.

  • leaona was very nice

  • leona and vonzell rocked!

  • 1-Whitney (original still reigns)

    2-Leona (mind-blowing signature, phenomenal)

    3-Vonzell (great tone, superb)

    4-Jennifer (big voice, slightly flats, lowers the original octave-dissapointing)

    5-Lakisha (pity performance, rockin' flats-thumbs up for these flats-sucks 'super')

  • Why won't you compare all of them singing this song live? Why everyone is always comparing Leona's live performances to Whitney's studio versions? As much as I like Whitney she ain't that good singing live, especially nowadays.

  • Leona,Whitney,Jennifer,Lakisha­,Vonzell...but they are all AMAZING

  • Loved it!!

    :-)

    Leona rocks btw

  • 1.whiteny

    2.leona.

    dont care about the rest

  • looooool

  • Leona is the best one for sure

  • 1. whitney

    2.leona/vonzell

  • 1.Vonzell

    2. Whitney.

  • WH is the rolls royce of this genre.Often imitated, but the quality is unparalled. It truly is an instrument of grace and beauty that commands your absolute commitment...no more is this evidenced than at

    3:06-3:48 [i.e all the singers ending the song] when its WH turn...WOW!

    speechless :-)

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Whitney

    3, Whitney

    4. Whitney

    5. Whitney

  • leona is the best singer ever!

  • Vonzell is much better than Leona, everybody says Leona's better only because more famous than Baby V...

  • Leona is the only one that even comes close to whitney, Whitney is untouchable.

  • thats true

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Leona

    3.Jennifer

    4. Vonzell

    5. Lakisha

  • Leona, Whitney, Jennifer <3

    ^^

  • Leona, Whitney and Jennifer <3

  • 1.leona

    2.jenifer.

    3.whitney. and the other2

  • Uhm YOU COULD NEVER..EVER,, Put leona on top of whitney.. OBVIOUSLY ITS WHITNEYS SONG AND TYHEY ARE ALL TRYING TO SING IT LIKE WHITNEY!! DUHH,

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Jennifer

    3. Vonzell

    4 Leona

    5. Lakisha

  • 1.Whitney

    2.Leona

    3.Jennifer

    4. Lakisha

    5.Vonzell

  • Withney Houston,

    la únicacon pasion y sentimiento desbordante.

    sin alegar a las virtudes de Leona o las demás, cada una busca apantallar, impresionar con la voz, porque estan concursando.

  • 1. Whitney

    2.Leona/Vonzell

    3. Jennifer

    4. Lakisha

  • 1.Whitney

    2.Jennifer/Vonzell

    3. Leona

    4. Lakisha

  • 1. whitney

    2. vonzell

    3. jennifer

    4. lakisha

    5. leona

  • i agree!!

  • Comment removed

  • 1. Whitney

    2. Jennifer

    3. Leona, Vonzeil

    4. Lakisha

  • Leona is the only girl who can sing this song (also "I will always love you") after Witney. By the way, Witney said about her "she is baby me", and it's absolute truth.

  • I don't believe that whitney likes her  WH is very particular, and wouldn't like a copy cat like leona . She was probably lying.