so genius, pink floyd is the only band that could write a song about time, something so great and big, and pull it off beautifully. my favorite band of all time, always will be.
Also I must say I kind of like the original first line in the chorus - "lying supine in the sunshine, let the grass grow on your brain" - better than what it was changed to ("tired of lying in the sunshine, staying home to watch the rain"). Maybe roger thought too many people would be puzzled by the word "supine"...not the most commonly used word
I love hearing this - it gives us insight into how the floyd songs came together - roger has the main idea down, it all starts with him, but then we see how much the song is improved with gilmour and wright's instrumental contributions (and them singing instead of roger of course, though I don't think roger's nearly as bad a singer as people say).
this is just a guess, but is this demo what waters would come up with himself while writing material and then present this to the band for their opinion and, critiquing, additions, etc. Like i doont believe he had intention of actually singing this himself, this is just his very rough draft to get it approved by the rest of the band.
i don't think it's all bad. it's just the sound of it. it is, after all, a demo from the early 70s. you can't seriously expect a well-produced recording.
I could just say that this is a crap version, but, in a way, it isn't. And what's more, (sorry for the Final Cut quote), I think it is absolutely fantastic to create possibly the greatest Pink Floyd song of all time - out of THIS! Absolutely astonishing. Not the demo, but the song and the development of it.
Most demo's of Roger are crap mate :), but then he had the ingenuity to come up with the lyrics and a basic tune for most of the songs and it is indeed a tribute to the band that they created several masterpieces from such simple compositions.
I have the money and comfortably numb demo as well, but they are already present in youtube ! but i will upload some more cool floyd songs in the future...keep watching...
so genius, pink floyd is the only band that could write a song about time, something so great and big, and pull it off beautifully. my favorite band of all time, always will be.
wantsumbacon 1 month ago
Wow...I hear a lot of Syd here. Guitar?
cadidliac 1 month ago
Fucking fascinating. The older I get, the more I love Roger
CtrlRm 5 months ago 2
@CtrlRm I agree, and the demos he recorded... The origin of all.
neagaritrance 3 months ago
it's a demo, meaning by definition that it's rough and incomplete, what we're you expecting?
redskin133 5 months ago
david gilmour + roger waters = perfection
Corleonetone 7 months ago
Thanks for sharing, THIS IS AWESOME! Let grass grow in your brain- I will.
ThePiperOfZazZuhZaz 7 months ago
Also I must say I kind of like the original first line in the chorus - "lying supine in the sunshine, let the grass grow on your brain" - better than what it was changed to ("tired of lying in the sunshine, staying home to watch the rain"). Maybe roger thought too many people would be puzzled by the word "supine"...not the most commonly used word
pancreaskid 8 months ago
@pancreaskid Actualy he was told by the band members to change those lines to come up with something better lol
mimzy1000 1 month ago
I love hearing this - it gives us insight into how the floyd songs came together - roger has the main idea down, it all starts with him, but then we see how much the song is improved with gilmour and wright's instrumental contributions (and them singing instead of roger of course, though I don't think roger's nearly as bad a singer as people say).
pancreaskid 8 months ago
OMG
charadeyouareha 8 months ago in playlist Pink Floyd Another Playlist
What a transformation it was to turn this into the classic song as we know it. Pure brilliance.
MiddyChannel 1 year ago
where did you find this demo .
geisterbahn1 1 year ago
ever heard of a tuner, roger? still love it though
bentertainment1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is just a guess, but is this demo what waters would come up with himself while writing material and then present this to the band for their opinion and, critiquing, additions, etc. Like i doont believe he had intention of actually singing this himself, this is just his very rough draft to get it approved by the rest of the band.
TheRockNRollFan 1 year ago
Roger waters wrote time when he was like 17 so of course it sounds like shit!
BailErik 1 year ago
@BailErik no he didnt lol
echoddity 1 year ago
Well, it may be crude but there it is. Roger's done the hardest part. Arranging it into a song is the easy bit. 'Gravy all the way' as they say.
benjamin308 1 year ago
i don't think it's all bad. it's just the sound of it. it is, after all, a demo from the early 70s. you can't seriously expect a well-produced recording.
bonejangles22 2 years ago
I could just say that this is a crap version, but, in a way, it isn't. And what's more, (sorry for the Final Cut quote), I think it is absolutely fantastic to create possibly the greatest Pink Floyd song of all time - out of THIS! Absolutely astonishing. Not the demo, but the song and the development of it.
Thanks for sharing! =)
Henkibojj 2 years ago 2
Most demo's of Roger are crap mate :), but then he had the ingenuity to come up with the lyrics and a basic tune for most of the songs and it is indeed a tribute to the band that they created several masterpieces from such simple compositions.
triptoechoes 2 years ago
@Henkibojj Why sorry?
JohannesMarslew95 1 year ago
@JohannesMarslew95 Haha, well, I guess it was kinda geeky. ;)
Henkibojj 1 year ago
@Henkibojj There's nothing wrong about being geeky, if it's Floyd
JohannesMarslew95 1 year ago
i need the chords used in this demo... please.... anyone??
sbarcena 2 years ago
wow!
LondonKumamoto 2 years ago 4
0:39 let the grass grow in your brain?
Chuck13 2 years ago 17
Yep, that's what he sung
66MadcapLaughs 2 years ago
awesome!! hey i heard the money version too. do they have any other demos?
hanswashere 2 years ago 2
I have the money and comfortably numb demo as well, but they are already present in youtube ! but i will upload some more cool floyd songs in the future...keep watching...
triptoechoes 2 years ago
do you have the full version of the Money demo?
PanekPL 1 year ago
@hanswashere there also was a demo for the wall too but It was taken down from YouTube but I don't know why. lol
austin27332 1 year ago
Wow, nice.
Malkin2004 2 years ago 2