to darix10 and jonjonmariah: i'm not wishing anything bad on mimi cause I love her...but God doesn't allowed one day she drops her mic or the pre-tapped recording goes crazy...she will be soooo embarrazed LOL and you all will understand that she SINGS ON TOP OF PRE RECORDERD versions...she starts singing live but then stops singing on the harderst notes. it's soooo obvious. her voice changes, her gestures change, she covers her mouth...lol
starting at 2:40 is all fake...she is not singing. she is letting the pre-tapped sing the harderst notes of the song. Now, go watch "we belong together" in Brazil. she did the same thing...same pre-tapped version. Still, i love her...she is a great song writer.
hahaha my sis went there and why is it that everone magically hates eachother and can talk all this shit n youtube hiding behind the computer but if it was face 2 face yall wont say shit so STFU damn fags..
No, sorry, it wasn't Canadian Idol. It was that BET show back at the beginning of 2008, when E=MC2 was more or less just about to come out. 'The Relativity of Mariah' or something like that.
Ok, I'm a huge fan of Mariah's, love her and adore her. And I love WBT and have watched almost every video of her singing. But I would have to agree, that the ending is sme old sme old since Canadian Idol. @hey0000you is right, they're the same. I'm not a fake fan, I'm not a hater, but even some ppl hve to admit that it sounds the same. Ok, maybe she was on fine form that night, but for the ending to sound exactly the same as other performanceS is a stretch. But she WAS singing live before then.
wth! that has nothing to do with anything, I can totally sing the same song twice and I would sound the same. the exact same pronunciation of words and the vocal runs and whatever. so if I can do that, then I am pretty sure as hell Mariah Carey can do it too.
I have simultaneously played the two videos to compare this video from her performance in Canadian Idol and I found out that the ending part of the two videos are totally the same...the enunciation of the words and the way it was sang...
Don't get me wrong, but the ending of this performance was lipped but I still loved her though.. PEACE! :)
I got all the performances of We belong together and in all of them you can notice when the live part stops and the lipped one starts, because the texture of her voice, the volume or whatever changes.
But that does not happen in MTV Movie Awards. She sounds the same during the entire performance.
So that's why I think is live. May not be, but I think so.
apart from the fact that i was at this concert and have a video of this myself u could CLEARLY tell that she was singing this live if you do listen to the two videos properly u will here a massive difference in the ends listen to the words she says and the way she says them are different for example when she says "rough" u can here that its longer on idol. Also when she does the high note it is sang higher on the idol version and THATS how u can tell its live.
@darix10 i know she is singing live because i sing and can tell when she lifts up her chest really big for the breath where she needs it. when people lip sink you can't actively think about every little thing to make it look real. you can so tell this is live!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you are the dumb bitch before comment listen to what i'm saying and you'll see , i like mariah but i know she often do playback and what ? at least i'm not a blind stupid fan who thinks she's singing live when she's not (prerecoreded) , you know what you know nothing about singing and music
Amo a Mariah Carey ! Concerteza , umas das melhores cantoras do planeta !
I love you !!
Edilaneeh 5 months ago
WTH? This is so so "live" and ppl are still saying it's lipped -_-
lovestoryhahaful 6 months ago
she's singing live, but her mic is turned off so the pre-recording can be heard.
Judgeyy 1 year ago
to darix10 and jonjonmariah: i'm not wishing anything bad on mimi cause I love her...but God doesn't allowed one day she drops her mic or the pre-tapped recording goes crazy...she will be soooo embarrazed LOL and you all will understand that she SINGS ON TOP OF PRE RECORDERD versions...she starts singing live but then stops singing on the harderst notes. it's soooo obvious. her voice changes, her gestures change, she covers her mouth...lol
andruz69 1 year ago
starting at 2:40 is all fake...she is not singing. she is letting the pre-tapped sing the harderst notes of the song. Now, go watch "we belong together" in Brazil. she did the same thing...same pre-tapped version. Still, i love her...she is a great song writer.
andruz69 1 year ago
i love how everyone is singing along.
i would totally be if i was there!
lol.
kayayebee 1 year ago
hahaha my sis went there and why is it that everone magically hates eachother and can talk all this shit n youtube hiding behind the computer but if it was face 2 face yall wont say shit so STFU damn fags..
MichaelMyers702 1 year ago
I don't think she's pregnant. She's been on the heavy side for more than nine months. Maybe it's medication with these side effects?
rdbarne 1 year ago
her weight changed drastically since then,she is a blimp now
yesAudis4 1 year ago
shes still got it!! :)
nguyen881 1 year ago
The REMIX version of Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel is featuring some AMAZING powerhouses in the industry.
Lil' Wayne, Beyonce, Mary J. Blige, Alicia Keys, R. Kelly to name some1
Comes out Feb. 23 and it's going to be amazing!!
SERTYG 2 years ago
No, sorry, it wasn't Canadian Idol. It was that BET show back at the beginning of 2008, when E=MC2 was more or less just about to come out. 'The Relativity of Mariah' or something like that.
MCisthebestbyfar 2 years ago
Ok, I'm a huge fan of Mariah's, love her and adore her. And I love WBT and have watched almost every video of her singing. But I would have to agree, that the ending is sme old sme old since Canadian Idol. @hey0000you is right, they're the same. I'm not a fake fan, I'm not a hater, but even some ppl hve to admit that it sounds the same. Ok, maybe she was on fine form that night, but for the ending to sound exactly the same as other performanceS is a stretch. But she WAS singing live before then.
MCisthebestbyfar 2 years ago
wth! that has nothing to do with anything, I can totally sing the same song twice and I would sound the same. the exact same pronunciation of words and the vocal runs and whatever. so if I can do that, then I am pretty sure as hell Mariah Carey can do it too.
SocialDemon09 2 years ago 2
I have simultaneously played the two videos to compare this video from her performance in Canadian Idol and I found out that the ending part of the two videos are totally the same...the enunciation of the words and the way it was sang...
Don't get me wrong, but the ending of this performance was lipped but I still loved her though.. PEACE! :)
acecampillo 2 years ago
All the first part was live, just the belting at the end is lipped. The only full live performance of this song was on BET Blueprint.
nicevidbro 2 years ago 2
I think that MTV Movie Awards was also live.
Just 2 complete We belong together performances.
It's a song that's really difficult to sing.
glamorous19 2 years ago
Actually no. On the MTV Movie Awards performance she lipped the whole ending. Just the BET Blueprint is competely live.
nicevidbro 2 years ago
I got all the performances of We belong together and in all of them you can notice when the live part stops and the lipped one starts, because the texture of her voice, the volume or whatever changes.
But that does not happen in MTV Movie Awards. She sounds the same during the entire performance.
So that's why I think is live. May not be, but I think so.
glamorous19 2 years ago
I got them all too, thats why I told you. ALso that performance is highly dubbed. Watch the undubbed amateur version and youll see.
nicevidbro 2 years ago
We Belong Together became SONG OF THE DECADE!
Um.............which is HUGE!
Nintendog140 2 years ago 6
i think this is the best performance of WBT ever!!
emma86100 2 years ago
and people say that she cant sing live.
bjp53pitt 2 years ago
We Belong Together is a song that Mariah can pull off 110% live. :D
Nintendog140 2 years ago 5
Shut up those haters, why u keep on hating her, because u cannot sing like her.
That's the most stupid thing ever.
My objective opinion is: she is the best diva, singer ever.....................................
hoangkieuco 2 years ago 3
apart from the fact that i was at this concert and have a video of this myself u could CLEARLY tell that she was singing this live if you do listen to the two videos properly u will here a massive difference in the ends listen to the words she says and the way she says them are different for example when she says "rough" u can here that its longer on idol. Also when she does the high note it is sang higher on the idol version and THATS how u can tell its live.
DJAK2803 2 years ago 4
yes she's singing live , i'm not saying she's not but the end is from canadian idol
hey0000you 2 years ago
its not a matter of "in my opinion" she is definatelly singing live...
richie5471 2 years ago
this is LIVE people!!!! are you deaf our something!!!!!!!
why must everybody crack mariah, she is the best preformer off al time, her voice is like magic. and nobody can compaire with this.
love you MIMI. your the best ever
xxxxxxxxxxxxx
loveyoumariah18 2 years ago 8
In my opinion she's singing live
darix10 2 years ago 18
@darix10 i know she is singing live because i sing and can tell when she lifts up her chest really big for the breath where she needs it. when people lip sink you can't actively think about every little thing to make it look real. you can so tell this is live!
rosannamalbran 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sings live until 2:38
hey0000you 2 years ago
you are deaf!!! this is live...
jonjonmariah 2 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
compare the end to canadian idol the same prerecorded version !!!
hey0000you 2 years ago
Why couldn't she sing like this in up out my face and hero?
HildaMcFumble 2 years ago
Hmm? She sounded great In UOMF she hit all of her notes and Hero was good as well....
OKzs 2 years ago 3
Amazing!! She can sing, she's back!
darix10 2 years ago 3
My all time fav...
Go MC...
Kehoe051 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the end is the same playback than when she sang in canadian idol
hey0000you 2 years ago
your comment is the same in every fucken video of mariah, shut the fuck up and leave mariah alone you dumb bitch!!
DanielAvilaAGT 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you are the dumb bitch before comment listen to what i'm saying and you'll see , i like mariah but i know she often do playback and what ? at least i'm not a blind stupid fan who thinks she's singing live when she's not (prerecoreded) , you know what you know nothing about singing and music
hey0000you 2 years ago
AMAZING!!! :)
jonashasauniqueside 2 years ago 2