On the second stanza the melisma at about the 3:09 mark is now the standard even though it is not indicated on this score or the one I have which simply repeat that of the first stanza. The convention in Hoffman's time and today remains in coloratura not to necessarily sing note for note a repeated phrase as written but to sometimes vary (often in the direction of greater virtuosity.)
Every operatic song can be taken with a little license unless its something like Wozzeck. And she has a very nice voice.
Still though, I agree with Msr. Grandier--a bit much on the ornamentation. Toning it down could have helped. Particularly in the cadenza where she's quite out of tune.
briliiant , but why add notes that are not written originally?, well i guess it has to do with a little narcisism from the performer , but anyway bravisimo impressive, bravo!!!!
actually almost no one sings the original piece.....they most often modify and add the notes.....it would be boring otherwise right? And yes, Parcells is a little narcisist.....really, she doesnt get to me, she is not hot but not cold....just indifferent
It is actually in the style to add notes, especially for repeated sections. In the old days if you did not add embellishments for a repeated phrase the audience would boo you off the stage.
It's part of this style for the performer to add their own creativity into the work. The composer actually expects it.
i prefer the high Eb a bit stronger in this, i dont think the soft pretty approach really fits this role. This is obviously the big bravura climax of the aria, but she is supposed to be a mechanical doll, which is why i dont think the soft, finess-laden sound works as well. She has great technique though
Beautiful rendition of the doll song. Seeing the music makes you realize how challenging this aria is. It is high tessitura throughout the whole aria.
Lovin' the pianissimi at :48. Her trills are a little harsh for me, but I was raised on Dessay's softer trills so that's just a personal thing. Her high notes were lovely, and her control is solid. What a great soprano. Those pianissimos keep getting to me. Last high note didn't sound like a shreik either! Brilliant performance.
I'm almost there!
LauraRose83 2 months ago
On the second stanza the melisma at about the 3:09 mark is now the standard even though it is not indicated on this score or the one I have which simply repeat that of the first stanza. The convention in Hoffman's time and today remains in coloratura not to necessarily sing note for note a repeated phrase as written but to sometimes vary (often in the direction of greater virtuosity.)
telephilia 10 months ago
where can i find thiiiiis???? i want it so badly but it's not on itunes :/
princesstootsweet2 1 year ago
it's "chanson gentile" the first time, you sang the second verse's "chanson mignon"
MisterSenseless 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP! That was amazing! High Fs and Gs! WOW!
jfluter 1 year ago
Does she forget the words to everything she sings?
Lisaveta1991 1 year ago
that is an amazing high Eb!!! how does she hold it out without cracking at all???? amazingg!!! brava :]
s2broadwaybabys2 2 years ago 5
A truly magnificent Olympia - and in a live performance. Incredible !!!
gestas60323 2 years ago 4
Every operatic song can be taken with a little license unless its something like Wozzeck. And she has a very nice voice.
Still though, I agree with Msr. Grandier--a bit much on the ornamentation. Toning it down could have helped. Particularly in the cadenza where she's quite out of tune.
Corflamum 2 years ago
briliiant , but why add notes that are not written originally?, well i guess it has to do with a little narcisism from the performer , but anyway bravisimo impressive, bravo!!!!
PGRANDIER 2 years ago
Ever heard of artistic license, this is a concert performance. So it doesn't have to be exact.
EmilyGreene1984 2 years ago
actually almost no one sings the original piece.....they most often modify and add the notes.....it would be boring otherwise right? And yes, Parcells is a little narcisist.....really, she doesnt get to me, she is not hot but not cold....just indifferent
killerbunny123123 2 years ago
the purity of her intonation is stunning.
PGRANDIER 2 years ago 3
It is actually in the style to add notes, especially for repeated sections. In the old days if you did not add embellishments for a repeated phrase the audience would boo you off the stage.
It's part of this style for the performer to add their own creativity into the work. The composer actually expects it.
Jaydoggy531 2 years ago 2
i was in this opera as a teenager and this song i thought was the most stunning, and 'm sure in this opera it probably always will be
Ringosfinger 2 years ago
i prefer the high Eb a bit stronger in this, i dont think the soft pretty approach really fits this role. This is obviously the big bravura climax of the aria, but she is supposed to be a mechanical doll, which is why i dont think the soft, finess-laden sound works as well. She has great technique though
skitzo429 3 years ago 2
So great,... BRAVA,....!!! :-)
fromheretoglory 3 years ago
amzing!
andrewoconnorblue 4 years ago
wow amazing control !
RAATCC36 4 years ago 2
wow! i hope i can sing this for my recital next semester!
nightbeauty02 4 years ago
Beautiful rendition of the doll song. Seeing the music makes you realize how challenging this aria is. It is high tessitura throughout the whole aria.
operaboy81 4 years ago
Bravissima!
jackinboy83 4 years ago
Wonderful voice!
Agathacarolina 4 years ago 2
BRAVA!!!!!!!!!!!
Mamasan41 4 years ago 2
Lovin' the pianissimi at :48. Her trills are a little harsh for me, but I was raised on Dessay's softer trills so that's just a personal thing. Her high notes were lovely, and her control is solid. What a great soprano. Those pianissimos keep getting to me. Last high note didn't sound like a shreik either! Brilliant performance.
Iareto 5 years ago