i think the only reason people value amy more is cause amy is a soprano dont get me wrong love amy but i love carly. and its not amys song. the song was composed by amy, ben, and david hodges so realistically it probably wasnt even her choice to do it. it was probably bens idea and she just went with it. come off your horses who r u to judge especially when you dont even know the circumstances
it is just a cover! damn! amy makes a lot of covers too. Amy can sings better, but I've seen her lose her breath and tune singing this song several times. Carly sings well. Amy sings better, but not means carly sings badly!
I know they have the right to cover Evanescence and what not... but it kind of annoys me that they don't even make it their own. It sounds like a cheap imitation of Evanescence :/
It´s soooo sad that people can´t find their personality themselves !!! So they try hardly to be someone else, like gorgeous AmyLee of Evanescence. NO ONE IN THIS WORLD is like Amy, doesn´t matter how hard you try to look or sound like her ! A Coverband is really ok, but trying to copy someones personality sucks ! And IF you are sooooooo like Amy, your Skirts must be longer ;)
Isso é ridículo d+ afêe, criem suas próprias musicas e não peguem as do Evanescence, não é só porque o Ben ajudou nesse primeiro álbum que pode sair distribuindo as musicas pra qualquer um cantar.
actually its not amy's song. its ben's song... amy only originally sang the song. if i heard this first instead of the original all those years ago.... maybe.. just maybe ill like this one better.
now i can imagine what evanescence will be without amy Lee Biggest Fail.... seriously WATF just needs to make their own style of music even though ben moody wrote half of the song or created the sound they need to be more established as themselves because evanescence still exists and by trying to recreate EV your just gonna have so much haters
ths is evanescence without amy and with carly. this is ben moody's song or perhaps, he owns partially, together with amy this song, and a lot actually in the "fallen" album of evanescence
Amy lee fas susseço sem vc ben o primeiro e The open doo o 2 e o novo e ai essa cagona ai q vc arranjou aff nunca vai bater Amy lee ja era man ou se vc pensa em volta pra banda e isso tever um lugar pra vc
@chinmaykai Those are Amy's, which was a bad choice on their part. It's fine if you cover the song but at least have the decency to record backing vocals from Carly instead of using Amy's.
She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! --- ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ONLY Amy can rock that song ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ---- She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eu sou fã do Evanescence mas não vou sair xingando a banda porque a vocalista canta bem e os meninos tbm mas não existe que nem o Evanescence e a própria Amy Lee cantar essa música.Pode milhões da bandas cantar alguma música do Evanescence mas não é comparado ao original.Tudo bem Carly vc fazer a sua banda cantar e tals mas eu acho que vc está exagerando em cantar Going Under e ainda mais com ex-membros do Evanescence mas eles estão tocando então não coloco só a culpa em vc.É tá puxado ;D,kkkkkk
Wow. Carly's got NOTHING on amy. this is pretty pathetic. I can't believe ben had them play this! Ben said in an open letter to amy and the fans "There was no way I would ever let someone walk on that stage and sing your lyrics". now look at this! ben, whats your problem?
@Steve1306 Because Ben also created it... That's the reason they're allowed to cover... You're right... it sucks! Amy didn't even sound like that when she had a cold... a very BAD cold... xD
Ben is a bas*ard. It's not Carly fault, but she is also b*tch because she could show respect and disagree with Ben Moody to re-make this song, which suck btw, too weak
i seen WE are the FALLen wif HIM ...not bad...but i really think this is very low for them to sing this...i know shet happen wif amy lee and the guys..but amy lee was the first..and only she can pull this off(: just sayin....CARLY isnt bad singer...just needs to stick wif her stuff make new music..ben moody should like have a little respect...i think amy lee and all the guys wrote the songs together...but still this is slap in amys face...! idk...miss evanescence..
this disgusts me beyond believe. that ugly amy lee wannabe needs to be ended. UGHHHHHH im listening to it as i write this. and i wanna kill people. ull never have what you had with evanescence, ben. stop trying. u look like a fool.
Please correct me if I am wrong but didn t Amy wrote the song herself? So why then is Ben copying it? Actually Carly as a good voice, though I don t like her personally but this is definately not her song!!!
@plove209 Tbh it is and was an Evanescence song, I for one prefer Lee's vocals to Smithson's, BUT because it was an Evanescence song at the time the then band had rights to it and given most of these other than the singer were in the band maybe they missed playing it live, you shouldn't be blasting this girl for having the balls for being a team player and letting them play it live again for their sake.
eu amo evanecence tanto quanto we are the fallen mas nessa eles deram mancada cole a do bem a amey lee adora ele mas agora ele vacilo feio e outra ela ta muito dessafinada nessa musica e na my imortal tbm nao gostei nao fico feiodexs
I really like WATF's album. I think it's very good. But I wish Moody would stop trying to have an agenda when he has Carly singing Amy's songs. I do like WATF'S stuff. I think they should think of their own stuff before they just play Evanescence's. That is all.
Am i tho only one who thinks these people need to stop freaking jerking around and spazzing and moving randomly on stage? I mean i understand doing that when ur at a huge concert and ur playing for thousands of cheering fans, but here? C'mon there's hardly 20 people i bet.
@AntiH3ro92 enough to do your best, each fan deserves the same respect even if there is just one person at your concert, and probably there were like 200 persons there
is it just me, or is Evanescence playing in the background? seriously, it counds like We Are The Fallen playing over an Evanescence track...bad bad bad
Carly and Amy are both talented in their own way. and their singing style is very close to one another's. but i'm sorry, Amy sings this song so much better. It's hers anyway.
Meu quem autorizou essa coisinha cantr uma música do Evanescence??? Isso é um ultraje ao Evanescence! Só por que alguns integrantes (que já foram muito bem substituidos diga-se de passagem) saíram e se juntaram com essa coisa, não dá direito nenhum de tocarem uma música, que é do Evanescence ! Nem copiando o visu da amy, as músicas, ela nunca vai chegar aos pés da Amy coitadinha, tá aí toda iludida pensando que um dia vai chegar ao ível da Amy! Hahaha, deixa ela sonhar... Evanescence4ever !!!
Now I need a doctor! The reason is simple - I just heard the song of Evanescence "GOING UNDER" performed by the group We Are The Fallen! Poor female vocalist to sing live does not know how! Amy Lee of Evanescence does it perfectly and beautifully! Amy Lynn Lee YOU ARE THE BEST IN THE WORLD!
I honestly don't see why everyone's getting so mad at them, just because they made a new band. So they covered an Evanescence song; BIG DEAL! It's not like they're selling it! They like the song, and they want to cover it! May as well get at every other band that plays covers!
Amy and Evanescence is still there! I personally like both bands.
I dont think its bad that they did an Evanescence song they like the band.. they covered them.. Ben is from Evanescence... but he'll never make another Evanescence for sure. They're hard to top but I dont think WATF are copying
I really like We Are The Fallen..... but they really need to stick to their own music.... And NEVER play another Evanescence song again!!!! No one will EVER be better than Amy
No doubt Carly's voice seems to be more... more... idk... strong? I mean, when Amy sings she does so many falsettos, no matter if it's a high or a low note but I guess that's what Amy chose to do and maybe just maybe it is the reason why the songs sang by her seem more souful/meaninful! No ofense to Carly, I think she's an amazing singer.
It's good now WATF is doing their own stuff. The should try and change their image too. Create something fresh, something "new". WATF is good enough 2 do that
Being a fan of both, i can honestly say this none too bias: Carly is much better live than Amy, but Amy has an over all better voice. When Amy just sits down and sings instead of jumping around, she's amazing. But she has some terrible performances under her belt. Carly, however, does not have quite as an amazing voice but can do very well live.
She sucks! Shit dude! Amy will always beat her no matter what and the new Ev album will be amazing!<3 Carly can burn in hell along with Ben for being suck dickheads!
We are The Fallen have some good tracks, sure, but they sound exactly like Evanescence. And Amy has a much more beautiful voice, in my opinion. Can't wait for their new album <3 :)
@TxxThunderTwight Also the songs from Fallen and before belong to David Hodges just as much as to Amy and Ben. He and Ben wrote most of the music, Ben and Amy wrote most of the Lyrics
@LeFemmeCrystal Do you have ANY idea about vocals at all? How can you possibly say she has a limited vocal range? She's well heralded as having one of the most impressive vocal ranges in the industry today.
I've never understood blindly hating someone to simply further the agenda of another... Amy Lee is still good irrespective of Carly's capabilities of a singer; so why do you feel the need to make an attack on Carly just to justify Amy's talent?
LMAO. Being adored by you doesn't means she is noted as having "one of the most impressive vocal ranges in the industry." The industry barely even know who she is.
I also am a big fan of Carly. She was the only reason I continued to watch AI past the beginning episodes. She has good vocals. On this song however, you don't see any of her talent. You only see her weaknesses.
This band kicks ass. Shut the fick up and ignore the fuckers if you don't like them. These other "haters" need to get a fucking life and stop bothering people for liking a band dude take your ghetto asses off of youtube
We are the Fallen ROCK!!!!!! Ben's songs have always been my favorite... i think they will make it just as big and I also think anyone who believes that Carly is not as vocaly great as Amy was are def! take some vocal lessons and you will see Csrly is better trained and has better control then Amy. Amy is a legend but Cary is just as good in her own right !!!!! people are horrible talking about this band as if they know what happened!
@PiaLovesEv actually it was his band...not her band, and it's not a copy 'cause the lyrics were written by him with Amy and David Hodges...it's for sure Ev is not Ev anymore as we used to knew it...and the single of the new album sounds like... CRAP! Ben rocks! we should be thankful with him for that amazing lyrics he left us...to all Ev fans...what would be really REALLY amazing is... that they could work together again :(
@dlinto42 what i see is, WATF did an album called TTWD and it is exactly a copy of FALLEN. No surprises no excitements at all and it sounds BORING after i've heard it for 2 times. But at least i hear new sound and great music as well from TOD - Ev and again new materials are coming out from their coming 3rd album. Men i can feel how Ev is moving on and having own new ideas, but for ben, i don't hate him but i can't hear any evolution from his music.
Same band with a different singer. Guitar player here is half responsible for the original band's creation. They have just as much right to play the old songs as Amy Lee does.
I actually like their own original songs and I really like John and Rocky and was very sad when they left Evanescence but THIS is simply stupid of them. First of all because it shows them mourning the past and second because Amy's vocal range is not easily met and in direct comparison Amy just HAS to win. Hands down. Too bad...
@TheMaidenBlackRoses YOU SHUT THE FUCK UP YOU IDIOT GOING UNDER WAS WRITTEN BY AMY LEE ABOUT BEN MOODY AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP BEN WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR MOST OF THE WRITING AND COMPOSING BUT AMY DID HER PART TOO. LMFAO THEY'RE NOT COMRADS DON'T MAKE ME LAUGH. THEY ARE FUCKING IDENTICAL SO STOP BEING SUCH A BIG RAGING BITCH FACE!!!!!!!!!!
@TheMaidenBlackRoses NO YOU'RE THE BIG FUCKING RAGING BITCH FACE YOU MUST BE ON YOUR PERIOD LMAAAAOOOO NOBODY IS SAYING ITS A WAR YOU IDIOT AHAHAHAHAHAHAH WHY DON'T YOU FUCKING GET A LIFE AND STOP BEING SUCH A STUPID BITCH LOSER. YOU FUCKING SLUT.
@TheMaidenBlackRoses GO AHEAD AND FUCKING REPORT ME FOR "HERASSING" YOU. I'M NOT EVEN DOING ANYTHING BAD AT ALL ITS NOT MY FAULT YOU"RE SO FUCKING SENSITIVE AND CAN'T TAKE OTHER PEOPLE'S OPINIONS.
could someone please kill her? or me? whatever gets me away from what sounds like a car that's hitting a bear killing a cat when the cats eating a squirrel with a mouse shoved up it's ass.
I have a feeling they recorded this song. 0:28 is Carly's voice in the background. I'd be willing to bet they recorded this song. I mean Ben has even said that they planned to sing more songs from Fallen too on the tour they were gonna do in the beginning.
This sounded exactly like Evanescence's stuff. Just, live stuff. Listen to the live version of Going Under and then listen to this. It is SCARY alike. I still like Amy better though. Amy Lee = goddess of singing. Amy = lack of Ben and the rest = AMAZING vocals... but lacking the true awesomeness.
no we have to be honest she have very good vocals and strong voice is just i honestly do not like to see her singin songs that honestly just are for amy i mean she can but all people now that is NOT the same!
WeAreBenMoody...!!!!for ever!!!
manospitsis 4 days ago
This group is Evanescence, only changed the soloist.
Ben the best!
LyiDeFines 1 week ago
Pura imitação da pobre Amy Lee q odioooo eu amo EVANESCENCE, a verdadeira banda
DaniAmoBichos 4 weeks ago
i think the only reason people value amy more is cause amy is a soprano dont get me wrong love amy but i love carly. and its not amys song. the song was composed by amy, ben, and david hodges so realistically it probably wasnt even her choice to do it. it was probably bens idea and she just went with it. come off your horses who r u to judge especially when you dont even know the circumstances
noctemaeternus13 1 month ago
olha.....a Amy pode ate ser melhor ,mais caramba e so um cover todo mundo faz covers.....e ate q n ficou ruim....
TheHjade 1 month ago
lixo
maivanelli 1 month ago
it is just a cover! damn! amy makes a lot of covers too. Amy can sings better, but I've seen her lose her breath and tune singing this song several times. Carly sings well. Amy sings better, but not means carly sings badly!
anajoyceescorcio 1 month ago
cara de pau,ainda uso a segunda voz da amy lee
bruna21914 1 month ago
Carly you are sooo pathethic in Amy's songs. Maybe their level is too high for you?
TheMonrose18 1 month ago
Comment removed
TheMonrose18 1 month ago
Comment removed
lehopardo 2 months ago
Carly seems to be struggling on this song. They should stick to WATF songs.
chloboshoka 2 months ago
I know they have the right to cover Evanescence and what not... but it kind of annoys me that they don't even make it their own. It sounds like a cheap imitation of Evanescence :/
Ohmieffinggosh711 2 months ago
C'est moche en comparaison a Amy ...
LINKINxSartan65 2 months ago
Amy Lee forever! =/
bonekaxsapeka 2 months ago
NEEEEVER
giuliamarangon 3 months ago
It´s soooo sad that people can´t find their personality themselves !!! So they try hardly to be someone else, like gorgeous AmyLee of Evanescence. NO ONE IN THIS WORLD is like Amy, doesn´t matter how hard you try to look or sound like her ! A Coverband is really ok, but trying to copy someones personality sucks ! And IF you are sooooooo like Amy, your Skirts must be longer ;)
MsRosyDawn 3 months ago
Isso é ridículo d+ afêe, criem suas próprias musicas e não peguem as do Evanescence, não é só porque o Ben ajudou nesse primeiro álbum que pode sair distribuindo as musicas pra qualquer um cantar.
Só a Amy Lee cantando fica boa essa musica vlw :D
DaniLindh 3 months ago
FUCKING TRIBUTE BANDS TODAY THEY JUST LOOK LIKE EM OH WAIT......AHAHAHAHA JUDGED !!!!!!
noobanate 4 months ago
Girl,close your mouth or a flying insect may enter in.
Kaelajin96 4 months ago
I appreciate more the voice of Amy Lee xD
we are the fail .l.
lance22x 4 months ago 2
This band have to stop being in the past with the obsession of being Evanescence again. They have to be focused on being themselves !
BTW Amy's doing this song much better than Carly ....
YaelHorwitz 4 months ago
don't you feel bad singing other people's songs? regardless of who wrote it, it was amy who sang it and recorded it!
kejotikyuri1986 4 months ago
actually its not amy's song. its ben's song... amy only originally sang the song. if i heard this first instead of the original all those years ago.... maybe.. just maybe ill like this one better.
katrinamuswagon 4 months ago
now i can imagine what evanescence will be without amy Lee Biggest Fail.... seriously WATF just needs to make their own style of music even though ben moody wrote half of the song or created the sound they need to be more established as themselves because evanescence still exists and by trying to recreate EV your just gonna have so much haters
kaarankin69 4 months ago
ths is evanescence without amy and with carly. this is ben moody's song or perhaps, he owns partially, together with amy this song, and a lot actually in the "fallen" album of evanescence
greenpokerchip 5 months ago
terrible.
lihua90 5 months ago
geez people give them a break...
Allianoranet 5 months ago
Ha! Wannabe Evanescence.
TheCataIyst 5 months ago
Amy lee fas susseço sem vc ben o primeiro e The open doo o 2 e o novo e ai essa cagona ai q vc arranjou aff nunca vai bater Amy lee ja era man ou se vc pensa em volta pra banda e isso tever um lugar pra vc
jefferafera 5 months ago
porra essa voz e boa mas pra quem ouviu a da Amy lee num tem comparação essa ai nuca vai chegar a voz de Amy lee
jefferafera 5 months ago
haha the background vocals are Amy lee's what the hell?
dennistaylork 5 months ago
Isn't it a bit strange that it only sounds good where it has backing vocals (probably from Amy Lee).
chinmaykai 5 months ago
@chinmaykai Those are Amy's, which was a bad choice on their part. It's fine if you cover the song but at least have the decency to record backing vocals from Carly instead of using Amy's.
Lummerie 4 months ago
okay guys i don't care who wrote the song or whatever
just simply leave a comment : this live sounds terrible.
YIN01992 5 months ago
Nossa, sambou na cara da Amy. Olha os agudos, Amy se mija toda pra fazer isso.
ImpossiblePrincebr 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! --- ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ONLY Amy can rock that song ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ---- She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!! She sucks and Is SOO OFF tune!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
velmacote 6 months ago
Comment removed
velmacote 6 months ago
Comment removed
velmacote 6 months ago
essa banda e uma merdaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
AnaPaula9814 6 months ago
a voz da amy da de 1000000000a 0 nessa garota a e fala serio ladra de musicas e esse ex integrantes do evanescence bando de traira
AnaPaula9814 6 months ago
sou mais a amy nao essa merdinha ae de banda we are the fallen
uma copia de evanescence
e pra qem fala q evanescence acabaou nao acabou
ta melhor q nunca pois novo cd saindo ja
AnaPaula9814 6 months ago
Saying that Ben is ripping off Evanescence is saying Ben is ripping himself off. He wrote the songs, too. It was as much his work as it was Amy's
LuthienofOssiriand 6 months ago
this voice is so much better than amy lee!!! thats wassup
goio87 6 months ago
@goio87 You either need to go hear her again, or if you have… you're just wrong…
zbothotmail 6 months ago
EPIC FAIL!
agaphbou 7 months ago
Well after watching this my love for Amy and my hate for Ben i'ts growing without control!!
gabsgabs13 7 months ago
I just realized how much I appreciate Amy's talent!!!
PoparaZou 7 months ago 15
po o ben so ta com dor de cutuvelu ainda + q ela fez o novo cd aff chora cagão
jefferafera 5 months ago
Eu sou fã do Evanescence mas não vou sair xingando a banda porque a vocalista canta bem e os meninos tbm mas não existe que nem o Evanescence e a própria Amy Lee cantar essa música.Pode milhões da bandas cantar alguma música do Evanescence mas não é comparado ao original.Tudo bem Carly vc fazer a sua banda cantar e tals mas eu acho que vc está exagerando em cantar Going Under e ainda mais com ex-membros do Evanescence mas eles estão tocando então não coloco só a culpa em vc.É tá puxado ;D,kkkkkk
ShadowyButterfly 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
they are pathetic
kaify12 8 months ago
people this was early 2009, we are in 2011, is been 2 years since they did this song and they never did it again, so just shut up already
Jordangreys 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Jordangreys this doesn't change the fact that they did it :D
stasyty 7 months ago
Wow. Carly's got NOTHING on amy. this is pretty pathetic. I can't believe ben had them play this! Ben said in an open letter to amy and the fans "There was no way I would ever let someone walk on that stage and sing your lyrics". now look at this! ben, whats your problem?
DarknessOfTheStorm 8 months ago 4
Can someone please explain me why they are even ALLOWED to copy one of Evanescence's best songs? Btw: it's terrible.
Steve1306 8 months ago
@Steve1306 Because Ben also created it... That's the reason they're allowed to cover... You're right... it sucks! Amy didn't even sound like that when she had a cold... a very BAD cold... xD
SanxCatxNaru4ewa 7 months ago
This is really bad, they SHOULDNT steal from Evanescence. Its just low
PearlandBuddy 8 months ago
Ben is a bas*ard. It's not Carly fault, but she is also b*tch because she could show respect and disagree with Ben Moody to re-make this song, which suck btw, too weak
DimaKats2 8 months ago
we are the fallen tem músicas legais, mas a voz dessa garota é meio irritante kkkk
DeeFialho13 8 months ago
i seen WE are the FALLen wif HIM ...not bad...but i really think this is very low for them to sing this...i know shet happen wif amy lee and the guys..but amy lee was the first..and only she can pull this off(: just sayin....CARLY isnt bad singer...just needs to stick wif her stuff make new music..ben moody should like have a little respect...i think amy lee and all the guys wrote the songs together...but still this is slap in amys face...! idk...miss evanescence..
ca1411foREVer 9 months ago
This was just...terrible...O_o
WhySoAnon 9 months ago
Wow. Look at all of the Amy Leebots getting butthurt.
AddictiveDisease 9 months ago
WTF???
RockGirlDia1 9 months ago
my dog sings better than fucking steals songs carly
carly is cheap capia amy lee ( =
TheEvanecencia 9 months ago
Gosto de ouvir We Are The Fallen! Exceto quando eles fazem cover da Amy... Fala sério! Alguém consegue imaginar Amy cantando Bury me Alive?
thiago3019 9 months ago
this disgusts me beyond believe. that ugly amy lee wannabe needs to be ended. UGHHHHHH im listening to it as i write this. and i wanna kill people. ull never have what you had with evanescence, ben. stop trying. u look like a fool.
AnasgayforNina 10 months ago
Please correct me if I am wrong but didn t Amy wrote the song herself? So why then is Ben copying it? Actually Carly as a good voice, though I don t like her personally but this is definately not her song!!!
MsJune6969 10 months ago
NEVER IN THE LIFE WILL SHE SING HER SONG!!!!!!! Although I'm impressed....;))
Zerofuze100 10 months ago
I LOVE HER!!!! <3
dogiemole 11 months ago
SHE SUCKS TRYING TO SING A AMY LEE SONG.......
plove209 11 months ago 9
@plove209 Tbh it is and was an Evanescence song, I for one prefer Lee's vocals to Smithson's, BUT because it was an Evanescence song at the time the then band had rights to it and given most of these other than the singer were in the band maybe they missed playing it live, you shouldn't be blasting this girl for having the balls for being a team player and letting them play it live again for their sake.
muzikscud23 5 months ago
eu amo evanecence tanto quanto we are the fallen mas nessa eles deram mancada cole a do bem a amey lee adora ele mas agora ele vacilo feio e outra ela ta muito dessafinada nessa musica e na my imortal tbm nao gostei nao fico feiodexs
riomaxwelldr 11 months ago
Perhaps they should call themselves We Are The Evanescence and spare us from all the drama on their music identity!
Ms1001frenzy 11 months ago 4
Comment removed
Ms1001frenzy 11 months ago
Right..cause Ben didn't help write this song...lmfao
JJTINO1231 11 months ago
I really like WATF's album. I think it's very good. But I wish Moody would stop trying to have an agenda when he has Carly singing Amy's songs. I do like WATF'S stuff. I think they should think of their own stuff before they just play Evanescence's. That is all.
Peace and love!
coolarcher92 11 months ago
This is awesome maybe even better than amy
Odovocar 1 year ago 3
@Odovocar ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm no
dadsbestchild 1 year ago
@Odovocar HAHA NO.
TheCataIyst 5 months ago
Its nothing with out amys voice and passion on stage. Carly will never come close, but at least Ben looks happy <3
bigheartp3 1 year ago
AMY LEE ROCKS ! \m/ ...
This is amy`s song , uu assholes
VeronikEVfan 1 year ago
@VeronikEVfan this song was compossed by Ben
plateroyextremo 1 year ago 4
@plateroyextremo well said bro, well said.thumbs up
1roystance 11 months ago
Am i tho only one who thinks these people need to stop freaking jerking around and spazzing and moving randomly on stage? I mean i understand doing that when ur at a huge concert and ur playing for thousands of cheering fans, but here? C'mon there's hardly 20 people i bet.
AntiH3ro92 1 year ago 4
@AntiH3ro92 enough to do your best, each fan deserves the same respect even if there is just one person at your concert, and probably there were like 200 persons there
plateroyextremo 1 year ago
is it just me, or is Evanescence playing in the background? seriously, it counds like We Are The Fallen playing over an Evanescence track...bad bad bad
fredsbassett 1 year ago
Carly and Amy are both talented in their own way. and their singing style is very close to one another's. but i'm sorry, Amy sings this song so much better. It's hers anyway.
rani121792 1 year ago
Meu quem autorizou essa coisinha cantr uma música do Evanescence??? Isso é um ultraje ao Evanescence! Só por que alguns integrantes (que já foram muito bem substituidos diga-se de passagem) saíram e se juntaram com essa coisa, não dá direito nenhum de tocarem uma música, que é do Evanescence ! Nem copiando o visu da amy, as músicas, ela nunca vai chegar aos pés da Amy coitadinha, tá aí toda iludida pensando que um dia vai chegar ao ível da Amy! Hahaha, deixa ela sonhar... Evanescence4ever !!!
rafaelaevanescence 1 year ago
Sounds like bad Karaoke :(
brinacc 1 year ago
KILL IT WITH FIRE.
GetMeASamich 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
KILL IT WITH F I R E.
GetMeASamich 1 year ago
wow this Evanescence vs We Are The Fallen shit is still going on damn give it a break they're both good
MrBda27 1 year ago 3
Eu gostei mas prefiro na voz da Amy Lee
adeleal 1 year ago
I hate Carly
Ilove13Ev 1 year ago
in my opinion amy is much better and it looks like carly tries to copy amy in some ways...like she moves on stage and so on ...
AsukaKonataIII 1 year ago
Carly is so much better than amy. Does Amy still make music? Or is there at least some talented song writer writing music for her?
YasminSystem 1 year ago
@YasminSystem
Nope. Amy pretty much writes her own stuff like she did on the fallen and the open door.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago
Now I need a doctor! The reason is simple - I just heard the song of Evanescence "GOING UNDER" performed by the group We Are The Fallen! Poor female vocalist to sing live does not know how! Amy Lee of Evanescence does it perfectly and beautifully! Amy Lynn Lee YOU ARE THE BEST IN THE WORLD!
losercontroler198888 1 year ago
wow shes a ok singer but sadly shes not good enough for this song, shes a BIT ugly
06vicalm 1 year ago
I honestly don't see why everyone's getting so mad at them, just because they made a new band. So they covered an Evanescence song; BIG DEAL! It's not like they're selling it! They like the song, and they want to cover it! May as well get at every other band that plays covers!
Amy and Evanescence is still there! I personally like both bands.
CrAzYbassist1013 1 year ago 2
I like WATF but don't do anymore EV songs
MrBda27 1 year ago
I dont think its bad that they did an Evanescence song they like the band.. they covered them.. Ben is from Evanescence... but he'll never make another Evanescence for sure. They're hard to top but I dont think WATF are copying
Thehighschool8888 1 year ago
I really like We Are The Fallen..... but they really need to stick to their own music.... And NEVER play another Evanescence song again!!!! No one will EVER be better than Amy
xoxmyimmortalxox 1 year ago
@VaniiaAlexandra te da envidia de que carly pueda cantar Going Under sin que a los tres pasos se quede como perro jadeando como le pasa a Amy?
Sele2punto0 1 year ago
thats suck,evanescence can do better
nandadimensi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
evanescence-era.weebly.com if u want to see amy lee's opinion about ben and we are the fallen
amy still be the best
v4mp1regirl 1 year ago
Awh! my ears got Sick.. plz any1 tell amy to fix them, LOL!
there's seriously no comparin'.. Ev. WIN
Shockprods 1 year ago
en verdad NOOOOOOOOO solo mi AMY LEE <3
buuu BEN¡¡¡¡ esa cancion es de EVANESCENCE y ya D:
ladygothMetlee 1 year ago
No doubt Carly's voice seems to be more... more... idk... strong? I mean, when Amy sings she does so many falsettos, no matter if it's a high or a low note but I guess that's what Amy chose to do and maybe just maybe it is the reason why the songs sang by her seem more souful/meaninful! No ofense to Carly, I think she's an amazing singer.
It's good now WATF is doing their own stuff. The should try and change their image too. Create something fresh, something "new". WATF is good enough 2 do that
AngelWithoutWingsWB 1 year ago
She sucks! Amy Lee Forever s2~
Pedro01161 1 year ago
Being a fan of both, i can honestly say this none too bias: Carly is much better live than Amy, but Amy has an over all better voice. When Amy just sits down and sings instead of jumping around, she's amazing. But she has some terrible performances under her belt. Carly, however, does not have quite as an amazing voice but can do very well live.
SliverOFsilver000 1 year ago
She sucks! Shit dude! Amy will always beat her no matter what and the new Ev album will be amazing!<3 Carly can burn in hell along with Ben for being suck dickheads!
RainbowzItUp 1 year ago
We are The Fallen have some good tracks, sure, but they sound exactly like Evanescence. And Amy has a much more beautiful voice, in my opinion. Can't wait for their new album <3 :)
MizzAutonomy 1 year ago
nice! and this and many many songs belong to Ben. (Like 'My immortal') wake up people, Amy is not an angel.
foreverjoyfull 1 year ago
@foreverjoyfull
The songs belong to Evanescence actually.
Evanescence means Amy Lee and Ben Moody because they are the original members, so the songs do not belong to Amy or Ben, they belong to both of them.
TxxThunderTwight 1 year ago
@TxxThunderTwight Also the songs from Fallen and before belong to David Hodges just as much as to Amy and Ben. He and Ben wrote most of the music, Ben and Amy wrote most of the Lyrics
Timothay2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is a bitch and the are all shit
sacrificemusic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey Everyone on October 8th, everyone on youtube is going to view
and thumb up the video Evanescence Bring Me to Life the vevo one.
Spread this comment around to other videos and don't forget to
participate. Let's blow shitty acts like Beiber out of the water!!!
jess76310 1 year ago
Common sense and a set of ears show that Carly does not have the skill to sing EV songs. Her range is relatively small compared to Amy.
Now I like WATF's album, because it suit what Carly can sing even though her range is very small, she sings what she can well.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago
@LeFemmeCrystal Do you have ANY idea about vocals at all? How can you possibly say she has a limited vocal range? She's well heralded as having one of the most impressive vocal ranges in the industry today.
I've never understood blindly hating someone to simply further the agenda of another... Amy Lee is still good irrespective of Carly's capabilities of a singer; so why do you feel the need to make an attack on Carly just to justify Amy's talent?
Absurd.
This is a great vocal.
Oiraeket 1 year ago
@Oiraeket
LMAO. Being adored by you doesn't means she is noted as having "one of the most impressive vocal ranges in the industry." The industry barely even know who she is.
I also am a big fan of Carly. She was the only reason I continued to watch AI past the beginning episodes. She has good vocals. On this song however, you don't see any of her talent. You only see her weaknesses.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck you bitch :)))))
deaathbutterfly 1 year ago
ben plays his songs again
Eltron1991 1 year ago
well.. lets leave the who's better who's not aside !
EV = amy + ben !
so now there is no evanescence there is just AMY!! and we are listening to amy's Music so stop comparing!
there is One question .. BEN always loved to show off why now he is almost the rhythm player only??
spookymayyom 1 year ago
This band kicks ass. Shut the fick up and ignore the fuckers if you don't like them. These other "haters" need to get a fucking life and stop bothering people for liking a band dude take your ghetto asses off of youtube
Thehighschool8888 1 year ago
We are the Fallen ROCK!!!!!! Ben's songs have always been my favorite... i think they will make it just as big and I also think anyone who believes that Carly is not as vocaly great as Amy was are def! take some vocal lessons and you will see Csrly is better trained and has better control then Amy. Amy is a legend but Cary is just as good in her own right !!!!! people are horrible talking about this band as if they know what happened!
KakeC13 1 year ago
ES MUY FEA ESTA MUJER GORDA.....Y CANTA MAL.....ES UNA MORSA VESTIDA
ductop 1 year ago
Wow she is really out of tune. Oh do you know watf only sold 50,000 copies of their cd so far, after almost 4 months.
jess76310 1 year ago 12
@jess76310 Sorry I made a mistake. It's 34,000 total.
jess76310 1 year ago
BITCH.
hoderjostias 1 year ago
Fail!!
First Ben leaves Ev to show Amy she can't make music without him and now he tries to copy her band. And he completely sucks.
Amy will kick his fuckin' ass with the new Ev album!!!
PiaLovesEv 1 year ago 28
@PiaLovesEv actually it was his band...not her band, and it's not a copy 'cause the lyrics were written by him with Amy and David Hodges...it's for sure Ev is not Ev anymore as we used to knew it...and the single of the new album sounds like... CRAP! Ben rocks! we should be thankful with him for that amazing lyrics he left us...to all Ev fans...what would be really REALLY amazing is... that they could work together again :(
dlinto42 6 months ago
@dlinto42 what i see is, WATF did an album called TTWD and it is exactly a copy of FALLEN. No surprises no excitements at all and it sounds BORING after i've heard it for 2 times. But at least i hear new sound and great music as well from TOD - Ev and again new materials are coming out from their coming 3rd album. Men i can feel how Ev is moving on and having own new ideas, but for ben, i don't hate him but i can't hear any evolution from his music.
YIN01992 5 months ago
para ben xora cagão > Amy Lee e a que levanta a banda e vc so so toca cagão
jefferafera 5 months ago
2:53-3:03
boooooooooooooo
AsyaThawho 1 year ago
No one sings this better than Amy. Carly, you need to just give up now.
EternalSailorNova 1 year ago
One can only wonder what Amy thinks about this
shootemup9339 1 year ago
Same band with a different singer. Guitar player here is half responsible for the original band's creation. They have just as much right to play the old songs as Amy Lee does.
itchyisvegeta 1 year ago
WTF !!!!!!!! hey !!!!! r u CRAZY !! first i think she should be a pop signer and second STOP SIGING EVANESCENCE SONG CUS U SUCK DOING THEM !!!!!
i 'm not saying that ur like amy but don't try to be like her cus u'll never be !!!
and do ur thing please !
nadiapipichokposs 1 year ago
It is not so interesting it is a copier as Lee is given a Copy is a short fraera And Lee does not compare at all A band of Loser!!!
prozoroschia 1 year ago
ahhhhh my ears xD
3:20... puuuuuuuh^^
ilAy88 1 year ago
HAHA! Bleeding, deceiving and bleeding for you xD
you should learn the lyrics again... ts tst ts
her voice is cool... but not for this kind of music... more kelly clarkson style or i dont know^^
ilAy88 1 year ago
We Are The Fallen can sing whatever song they like
So who cares
Its just a song
Why don't we all just enjoy and song in life :)
TheMaidenBlackRoses 1 year ago
I actually like their own original songs and I really like John and Rocky and was very sad when they left Evanescence but THIS is simply stupid of them. First of all because it shows them mourning the past and second because Amy's vocal range is not easily met and in direct comparison Amy just HAS to win. Hands down. Too bad...
crystalsmile 1 year ago
terrible this group like a fake.... amy lee=evanescence.... we are "the fallen" it is stupid name:)
kfl39 1 year ago
You emo fags a so funny: quabbling about this singer, that singer, this band, that band, her song, his song. Shut ---- the ---- fuck --- up !!
DreadedEd 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DreadedEd IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE COMMENTS THEN SHUT THE FUCK UP TOO AND GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE YOU STUPID MOTHERTRUCKER COCK SUCKING WHORE!
pete2k10 1 year ago
Comment removed
pete2k10 1 year ago
this is evanescence's song she has no right to sing it!!! and she sucks at singin it for that matter!!!! AMY LEE IS THE BEST!!!!
backwordcoma 1 year ago
She's not a bitch like Amy Lee
DreCP 1 year ago
@DreCP she's been rude to an interviewer before. I'd say she kinda is. (No, wait...TWO interviewers now that i remember)
evanescence9314 1 year ago
@DreCP YES SHE IS
pete2k10 1 year ago
although i love we are the fallen,this is evanescence's song.they should sing this song and my immortal.
thelovely1500 1 year ago
f**cking bitch xD
lotusdream344 1 year ago
ppl just shut the fuck up about this
originally ben thought up evanescence he made the songs
this aint a fucking war between evanescence and we are the fallen
they're comrads
plus she's moving around too much and she really puts forth in this song
so get a grip ppl, EVANESCENCE AND WE ARE THE FALLEN ARE NOT THE SAME, THIS AINT NO FUCKING WAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheMaidenBlackRoses 1 year ago
@TheMaidenBlackRoses YOU SHUT THE FUCK UP YOU IDIOT GOING UNDER WAS WRITTEN BY AMY LEE ABOUT BEN MOODY AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP BEN WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR MOST OF THE WRITING AND COMPOSING BUT AMY DID HER PART TOO. LMFAO THEY'RE NOT COMRADS DON'T MAKE ME LAUGH. THEY ARE FUCKING IDENTICAL SO STOP BEING SUCH A BIG RAGING BITCH FACE!!!!!!!!!!
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10
YOUR THE FUCKING RAGING BITCH FACE!!!!!
THIS AIN'T NO FUCKING WAR
SO WHY DON'T YOU JUST FUCK OFF AND GO CUT YOURSELF
YOU STUPID CUNT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheMaidenBlackRoses 1 year ago
@TheMaidenBlackRoses NO YOU'RE THE BIG FUCKING RAGING BITCH FACE YOU MUST BE ON YOUR PERIOD LMAAAAOOOO NOBODY IS SAYING ITS A WAR YOU IDIOT AHAHAHAHAHAHAH WHY DON'T YOU FUCKING GET A LIFE AND STOP BEING SUCH A STUPID BITCH LOSER. YOU FUCKING SLUT.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10
I'll fucking report you for herassing me
And no I'm not I'm period.......yet
all i'm saying its just a music and people should just shut up about it
TheMaidenBlackRoses 1 year ago
@TheMaidenBlackRoses GO AHEAD AND FUCKING REPORT ME FOR "HERASSING" YOU. I'M NOT EVEN DOING ANYTHING BAD AT ALL ITS NOT MY FAULT YOU"RE SO FUCKING SENSITIVE AND CAN'T TAKE OTHER PEOPLE'S OPINIONS.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10
Comparatively speaking, Amy did more on the Fallen album than ben did. She wrote and composed more.
LeFemmeCrystal 1 year ago 2
@TheMaidenBlackRoses
TheMaidenBlackRoses 1 year ago
não é tão ruim assim
já ouvi a amy cantando essa musica ao vivo e não foi tão bem quanto a carly
+ eu ainda gosto + do evans
lisainthezone 1 year ago
even if they're just doing a cover..this is a big motherfucking SLAP on Amy's face!!...shes a good singer but shes pisses me off at the same time!!
ahmshereiam16 1 year ago
could someone please kill her? or me? whatever gets me away from what sounds like a car that's hitting a bear killing a cat when the cats eating a squirrel with a mouse shoved up it's ass.
xXemozrusXx 1 year ago 4
FAIL!
bulletbabe3114 1 year ago
-_- She can't even hit those low notes. Why is she singing this?
bsilverdelis 1 year ago
I have a feeling they recorded this song. 0:28 is Carly's voice in the background. I'd be willing to bet they recorded this song. I mean Ben has even said that they planned to sing more songs from Fallen too on the tour they were gonna do in the beginning.
eggEgg23 1 year ago
This sounded exactly like Evanescence's stuff. Just, live stuff. Listen to the live version of Going Under and then listen to this. It is SCARY alike. I still like Amy better though. Amy Lee = goddess of singing. Amy = lack of Ben and the rest = AMAZING vocals... but lacking the true awesomeness.
rickyraccoon3 1 year ago
no we have to be honest she have very good vocals and strong voice is just i honestly do not like to see her singin songs that honestly just are for amy i mean she can but all people now that is NOT the same!
lolitalolipo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lin Yu-Chun performs Bring me to Life. watch?v=7T0AiKkHvmI
Tzu9003 1 year ago