Added: 3 years ago
From: rovingeye2
Views: 316,127
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (454)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow!!!! this white boy here really likes this, why I did,nt hear him back in the seventies? This guy was underated&not given more attention&respect as other black artist.

  • this song makes me miss brotha Gil sooo much!

  • so much truth... revolution

  • One of the finest tracks from one of the finest artists to come out of the 70s. No doubt.

  • 7 people with no soul or humanity.

  • and then we get kayne... fuck! we're fucked!!!!!!!!

  • @jceja87  Kanye... the 'self-proclaimed' "Genius"

  • @jceja87

    less than that a mongrel in the white house ....married to an alien ferrangi beast

  • Stalley -Summer In America

  • @forho2 I was gone mention that....Rashad did magic on producing the beat for that....And Stalley killed !

  • @kenitrad6932 Stalley is an amazing artist and one of few who appreciates the brilliance in older music and soul.

  • @forho2 Truth!...Dude will go down as a legend, no questions asked...Already considered one in my book

  • i'm only 14 but this music rocks!

  • I'm thankful I was raised up on this kind of music, and the music of many other great Black artist. It's so timeless and amazing.

  • Look at all these long comments, no bullshit, no four letter words. Only the god ones - like us - love Gil Scott-Heron :-)

  • @dibadirekt

    So true...Brother Gil's message will never be silenced. We are all the better for his message. & unconditional love thru his music..

  • I remember this like it was last week. None of today's black music can touch this. I'm 55 and white, a classic rocker, but this along with many, many other black artist's of the 60's/70's lives on in my memory. Scott-Heron, Wonder, Mayfield, SlyStone, IsaacHayes, etc., all had that urban vibe goin' on. I hope they play this stuff in heaven, because I'd hate like hell to leave it all behind. To my brother's: Listen to some EARLY "Chicago", jazzy, bluesy, soulful classic rock with the same message

  • @H1wyStr excellent taste in music...there is room in all of our ipods ofr multiple genres and you are evidence that diversity in music brings us all closer...thanks!

  • mygod where is he we are surrounded by gyrating self absorbed idiots but hey I still remember sitting on those hills in Berkeley and listening to his concerts we stood up we demonstrated and all over the world today others are making a stand

  • The Hollywood Jews can never be forgivin for releasing the virus of Jew-created Rap and hip-Hop in order to destroy black music, culture, family and future and turn black music into an international commodity of crime and depravity to be used as a weapon by the new world order to destroy societies around the world.

  • @statewithinastateuk are you kiding?

  • As a 77 year old disabled veteran I still find Gil and his songs so relevant today. Gil is simply the best there is. I have listened to him all my life.

  • Still...R.I.P. Uncle...*

  • im only 2 years old and love this muzic !!!!

  • OH MY WORD,the man is singing the heck out of this song, go baby, wish I could have met this legend, maybe in the new world, his music just touches you in a way no other music can, sing that song.

  • OH MY WORD,the man is singing the heck out of this song, go baby, wish I could have met this legend, maybe in the new world

  • 40 years later...its still the same..

  • Gil was a man of vision and a revolutionary! I can't believe some of these post? This music he set out to make we as Black people want to change our lives for the better to move forward. He did fall to the ways of wickedness in America, but that does not take away his mind and conscious effort to bring truth to us all! He impacted millions and that should never be forgotten. In term of this type of message in the music now, it is being blocked and we the people have to demand it for our youth!

  • @roburrage I disagree, no music in america is being blocled and it would be difficult to do so. With so many social media, blogs, free music offerings and other ways to make a message public, the Internet ensures NOTHING is being blocked.

    I do agree that Gil Scott was a visionary and a pioneer. If he were in his productive years today he would be a superstar!

    And the detractors here do so out of ignorance...nothing else - and so deserve our pity - not our scorn.

  • @11918239 I'm sorry but being in the industry there is a lot of music and artist that have been (more so then now) and are still being blocked. If you don't believe that I am sorry, but I know it first hand. I am not looking to get into long debates or arguments going now where, but whom ever you are I don't believe you are in the industry. Yes there are several means net, web, but they too are monitored and if you are current it is clear evidence as it soon may not be open or free.

  • Wait! Wait! Wait! Stop!! Doesn't he mean 2011??? History repeats as the profane take advantage and allow the prophets to prosper. To acquit yourself by accusing a man of being a lazy paranoid revolutionary...anger is the one true incorruptible emotion. It separates us from those animals and it's power should never be underestimated. History says so.

  • Where this type of music today..???

  • What a great song..I did love it in 1973...then I grew up

  • Brother Gil Had vision and insight and Truth of Heart but not piece of mind Listen to the drummers military cadence in this song that of a 2nd line funeral march and it was purposly done that way to show the slow desinacration of our society and our removal of our spirit

  • @funkman0811 your right drummers military cadence and flute are the joint

    Ain't nobody fighting cause nobody know what to save SAVE YOUR SOUL

    SAVE YOUR SOUL SAVE YOUR SOUL

  • HAPPY MUTHA F*CKING COLUMBUS DAY !!!!

  • R.I.P Gill SCOTT Heron. RIP Troy Davis. NOBODY KNOWS WHAT TO SAY!!!

  • this all i jam!!! R-I-P GIL SCOTT HERON! AGAIN, U A BAD BROTHA!!!

  • everybody recieves enlightement when they die and what a beautifull enightenment gil already had

  • This is simply amazing. I was on a plane from Rome yesterday and heard this on the jazz channel. It knocked me out. This nation can't stand much more; the Constitution - a noble piece of paper. OMG, as they say. Ain't nobody fighting 'cuz nobody knows what to say...

  • I didn't know he passed! Last I knew he was in some upstate jail for posession -- the Rockefeller drug laws victimized him, at least that was the pretense the authorities used to attack this revolutionary. The live version is incredible, too. The Nixon years were even worse than the Bush years.

  • Rest in heavenly peace brother...you were the voice of the voiceless, deploring and not glorifying the daily horror of life in the ghetto, unlike the punks who came after you glorifying and trivializing the violence, drugs, alcohol and brutality of life with the excuse of just trying to "get paid." You never received Grammy Awards or million dollar contracts, but you earned your rightful place in the hearts of those whose sanity was preserved by listening to your words.

  • @gldngoddess63 well put. It's the corporations. They have polluted everything.

  • RIP Troy Davis. 

  • @DeLeeJay12 First song I came too after hearing the news. RIP

  • A great poet!! See you on the other side!!

    

  • R.I.P. homie

  • This is one of music's greatest masterpieces! Thanks Gil Scott Heron for coming into my life. I have recently got a couple of your classic Lp's so even this sh!thole neighbourhood will hear what real music is about!

    Cain Classics

    Naples, Italy

  • BEING OLD OR JUST OLD /SAD TO SAY GIL SCOTT WAS LEFT US WAY TO SOON. &THE SEASON R @2011 STILL WINTER IN AMERICA. THANX 2 ALL PEOPLE WHO MADE THE CHANGES

  • Same az it ever was......UniVersal Keymaker7....SOUL CLAP !!!

  • also take a hard listen to a powerful group called "the last poets",back when I thought "we" would evoke change but only found out that ,money,power & corruption has continually beaten all of us Raw & fearful....where are the true heroes? some say Jesus,but I think Jesus is saying,"you all need to get a clue before I even consider a return". PEACE.

  • i found out about Gil Scott Heron when NPR covered the breaking news of his unfortunate death. they played the revolution will not be televised live on the air, and since then i'm hooked. NPR KERA

  • just amazing!

  • I'm an old white lady that loved him!!

  • The greatest poet of our times. Saw him many times in the UK...hubbie dj-ed for him. Once he did this tune after I requested it in Leeds, UK. Missed but never forgotten xxx

  • miss you Uncle, always will, i am glad i knew You thank you for helping me so much & yes, you did save my life back in '79 which i am forever grateful; how many others did you help, you gave Voice to us...big LOVE & Heart...

  • damn he passed away 3 days before my 14th birthday .

  • I had the pleasure and honor of meeting Gil backstage along with his band during a concert in the 70's in San Francisco....I will never forget that and thank God I will always be able to listen to his music. RIP Gil

  • One if the unquestioned talents in my lifetime

  • Comment removed

  • It truly is "Winter In America" isnt it?

  • in my humble opinion it is still WINTER IN AMERICA!...i was a teen when this great man performed his greatest works for the people He stood for the underdog, the down trodden and the oppressed ...he was a positive force of the area of his time..he was a prophet like bob marley ..i was fortunate to have seen him LIVE at berkley school of music in boston along with my husband~ thrilled to be in his presence and experience greatness! a concert i shall never forget

  • @satori802 Please understand that (Gil Scott-Heron/Winter In America) Holds a place in my heart & due to the values placed on me by our so called government - I too will not ever just sit black !

  • WE R @ WAR 4 HUMAN RIGHTS N OTHER LANDS BUT R GOV.DOES NOT RESPECT OUR CONSTUTIONAL RIGHTS ? I AM GUILT 2 A FELONY W/ NO TRAILI HAVE A FELONY REORD W/ NO ARREST ; -NO ARREST REPORT-NO TRAIL-NO CRIME - NO APPEAL (GUILTY 30 YRS LATER) American can do attitude willingness to serve . Cling to values believe to be true. Family , God , Red , White , & Blue.SAD TO TO SAY GIL SCOTT HERON KNEW THIS MANY - MANY YRS. AGO. HOW EVER IN MY TIME NOW I WILL BE SERVING TIME IN PRISON .

  • you cant save anyone if they dont want to be saved. my problem with my generation is that we seem content with the way the world is now. not only that my generation was born during the crack epidemic, i'm talking about inner city youth. to be honest the part of the reason why shit is continiously hitting the fan is b/c we alot of us were born to mother w.o fathers. homes influtrated by crack cocaine. alot of my generation is a product of that poison. hope i made sense

  • A fav. RIP

  • 40 YEARS AGO American was going down hill (fast) ! People was reasponable & took action , which lead to the next genenration . Sad to say that the next genenration sold out .

  • @wolorp right...we've been here....the country was on the verge of collapse 40 to 50 years ago.....history repeats itself.

  • Tragic that Gil left us as he seemed to be back on track with his life and music and just as he was attracting a new generation of fans. All i can say is his music will always stay with me, God bless you Gil.

  • Marvin Gaye once sang that there were songs u can trust, well here's a solid example of courage, more GSH's are needed...

  • OMG, what is this? I am a brazilian man who didn´t know Gill Scott Heron. This song makes me cry. Mr Heron should be an idol in US, shouldn´t be. I´d wish world wide world listened to this masterpiece. It´s an epic.

    Stay cool brothers.

  • QUEEN LATIFAH DID "REVOLUTION" ON THE BET AWARDS LAST NIGHT TO TRIBUTE HIM. BEFORE THEN I DIDNT KNOW HE DIED.

  • Rest In Peace, great poet and singer.

    I am only 15 but I am in love with your music. So soft, so sensitive and true.... Heron was way ahead of his time :(

  • I was happy to see that BET paid homage to Gil during the BET Awards last night. Queen Latifah did a rendition of "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised."

  • this man died on my birthday. i feel dead inside.

  • @Dragmack im soo sorry he died on he month of may ,my birthday. i feel the same way too

  • I must have been under a rock. Just found out he passed last weekend. Have not stopped listening to his music since I learned of the news. I was introduced to his music in 74 and had the honor of seeing him perform at Morgan State's Homecoming Concert in 1975. What a remarkable talent!!!! Rest in Peace my Brother, Rest in Peace!!!!!

  • I must have been under a rock. Just found out he passed last weekend. I was introduced to his music in 74 and had the honor of seeing him perform at Morgan State's Homecoming Concert in 1975. What a remarkable talent!!!! Rest in Peace my Brother, Rest in Peace!!!!!

  • Word

  • I used to crave this man. I saw him at the Bijou Cafe in Philly. I didn't know he was HIV positive until about a year ago. I'm sorry to hear about that. He was a good looking man.

  • how is he considered a rapper? he's clearly singing

  • @lizwisler11 THANK YOU !!!!

  • @lizwisler11 i'm guessing you are very young & possibly very white. the point is, he was creating music of his era, funk & soul based sounds, combined with strong social based lyrics that were delivered in manner of of spoken word poet as much as a singer. that pointed the way toward rap or hip hop. but history is not simply linear, this guy was creating something new, that effected an audience, who then responded & one of those responses was extension of what he was doing, ie rap

  • @lizwisler11 listen to his other works.

  • One of the most provacative songs of our times, a classic because it will be current until the situation changes.

  • written then...but is a look into today.....Rest brother.....rest

  • And now it's Summer in Germany, and nobody knows..

  • NOT UNDER THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE ULTIMATE  LIAR BARRACK OSAMA I MEANT OBAMA .. WHO NOW EATS FRIED CHICKEN ,WATERMELON AND COLLARD GREENS,SINGING KUMBAYA WHILE SHOOTING HOOPS AFTERWARD WITH AL SHARPTON.... AS OF 4/11 READ IN THE PAPER I AM BLACK LIBERAL FEMALE SENIOR CITIZEN

  • Fuck white people

  • @GoDiglet Your stupidity. Innate or all learned behavior?

  • @GoDiglet I'm actually quite a nicer person

  • The first "rapper" of Hip-Hop...

    RIP

  • gil scott-heron could musically verbalize the emotions that we feel with his songs because he never, ever stopped being one of us even when he reached fame. I will always love this man.

  • "There ain't nobody fighting cause nobody know's what to say"

  • 6 people afraid of the truth

  • @mikie8865 7 people are afraid of the truth.

  • SMH I shouldn't be tearing up at the age of 24, especially when its been over a week since he passed.

  • Good Brother,

    Your song is part of my repertoire now. I am honored to have met You back on I Street in DC, and am honored to sing your song.

  • Symmone, you got it right. I think the artist would have agreed. From education comes change.

  • Speaks to everybody, still.

  • As a 54 yr old fan of Gil Scott-Heron, I have definately been influenced by this great poet. I pledged Kappa Alpha Psi at Lincoln University in 1976 (attended West Chester University about 15 miles away). He was then and is still a legend there.

    I have been layed off many times since I have been a working adult. Now, I truly understand the lyrics to "Pieces of A Man". RIP good brother.

  • ...and almost 40 years later, it´s still winter in America! Let Freedom Grow!!

  • REAL MUSIC BRIDGES GAPS BETWEEN YOUNG AND OLD. (as witnessed in the comments)

  • a gotdamn shame. but the man lives on through and in his music. we thank you.

  • I'm 48 & grew up listening to Gil Scott-Heron. I love reading comments from the younger folks who have come to know and love the music from back in the day. This is my favorute G S-H song. R.I.P. Gil.

  • farewell Gil cause I just can't say goodbye

  • Comment removed

  • A great American artist.

  • Luv u Gil-Scott 4 ever !!!!#1 SOUL BRUTHA !!!!

  • One of America's greatest ever poets.

  • I saw him in concert last year. A great man and a great loss. Gutted.

  • I remember wearing this lp out back in 74-75. And we thought it was winter in America then! Then came Reagan & more reagan & bush & all this endless war bullshit. Perpetual winter in america. If you want to honour this GIANT MANs memory, then start getting it on in the USA, taking it to the man just like the brave brave brothas & sistas are doing in Tunisia, Egypt, Palestine, Bahrain, Spain. Revolution today, USA. Long overdue. See you all on the barricades

  • @elps84 WE'RE LONG OVERDUE FOR REVOLUTION

  • @elps84 I feel you. discovering this Brother in the early 70s was an epiphany for me. His brilliance and ability to express himself musically is unsurpassed. Thanks, Gil Scott-Heron!!!!

  • @elps84 Amen brother..

  • Word @elps84!! I couldn't agree more with what you said... and I'm not a citizen of the US but "we got to save the children" as this prophet said... keep spreading that truly democratic posture! Congratulations and blessings.

  • @elps84 I'm sure this question has already been asked, but will it be televised?

  • One of Americas Greatest Voices.....Peace!!!

  • Wow! Maat Hotep Brother...

  • his voice and message is immortal it will never die

  • I'm just so glad that my Grandfather schooled me on Mr.Gil Scott-Heron because I have been listening to him him for atleast 9 years now and I'm 20.

    Many of you just don't know what you have been missing.He made deep music that caused one to reflect and music should also be made to teach or enlighten listeners.

  • the voice of a generation...

  • LOVE YOU 4 EVER GIL~!! The world has lost a GREAT, UNCOMPARABLE ARTIST and that will be felt within the world of music...

  • THANK YOU GIL. Your music, poetry and ideology escorted me from adolescence into manhood. Your rhythms provided a background for my early development. Thanks for leaving BIG footprints in this thing we call life. Thanks for helping to wake up black America and serving notice to white America. I only hope that your death re-awaken the social conscience of America and help to renew the absolute hunger for cultural knowledge that's desperately needed amongst our people....................THAN­KS GIL

  • @Iliketosee08 i listen to it now

  • Like so many others, I just found out about Mr. Scott and after hearing a few of his pieces, he was brilliant!! Just think, his work was done some 40yrs ago and yet it still rings true in 2011! Sad but true. Not only was he a poet, he was a prophet.

  • @OMG100ism Change is a slow process. We're slowly getting better, however.

  • @OMG100ism Same here. What a unique song, what a powerful voice

  • @OMG100ism may i say this to you OMG100, be glad that you have heard of him today, we only have the moment...be happy to hear this great man's work in the present day...yes i agree it is still 'winter in america'! i was a teen when gil scott-heron/brian jackson made this song..i saw him LIVE in boston years later and he rocked ...as the young folks say! (smile)

  • Respond to this video... rest in peace brother gil scott~heron... tears for in my eyes when i hear this song..it speaks to your soul whomever and wherever you may be at the time you hear this song...

  • Truly a great and under appreciated artist.

  • Com' on, young folk . . . show us Ol' Skool Students of Gil's untelevised revolution whatchu workin' wit! Spit sumptin' real . . . I'm listenin' ;o) (go check out his poetry, WINTER IN AMERICA). Each of his songs started as a poem. Get his book of poetry.

  • Com' on, young folk . . . show us Students of Gil's untelevised revolution whatchu workin' wit! Spit sumptin' real . . . I'm listenin' ;o)

  • OUR LAUREATE

    now, more than ever

    all the voices must speak together

    every poet everywhere

    feels the time is in the air

    common truth grows on common plains

    and the common eyes know it was not in vain

    'cause now, more than ever

    all the poets sing your praise

    -Sheloni-

  • the late great RIP brother gil scott, down the road with the prophets that have been wiped away before you and before your time, thank you for your work and for your memories, like an angel dust, flying away

  • RIP my brother.

  • Can we really say his messages went un heeded? Took me a while. I finally straightened up my act. Few more speed bumps to go. Thanks to brothers like Gil reminding us the 'Revolution' starts in your own mind.

  • Need. Album. Now.

  • SuperXavier- you did lose a close friend.We all did.. Gil was more then a poet- he was a Prophet and he came to warn us all, but like all of those who went before him, his warnings went unheeded. . I read a tweet that said " RIP GIl, I didn't know you, but it seems you knew us all"....

    ..hardest part is spring isn't coming......

  • No shit, Sherlock.

  • @marlowe52 have some mercy!! u got me crackin..

  • OMG I can get this beat out of my head. This song and this man is classic.

  • For some strange reason this is the song I keep coming back to!..Feels like I lost a close Friend!

    (Peace go with you Brother)!

  • they listenin now Gil x

  • Poetry

  •  Always the EMBODIMENT of "COOL ",Gil, you will live forever !

  • haunting piece , born as he was in such troubled times , no change without the pain , he gave us all a continuous heads up he seen everytin god bless u blud, n thanks for ALL u works respec

  • So fine, so classy, so talented, never will be forgotten! we love you gil!free at last!

  • this is the U.S.A.!!! tell it how it is....sad day for ALL of us.

  • R.I.P.

  • This is one of his most beautiful pieces. I remember listening to him as a very young person. To think he was only about 25 years old when he thought of these lyrics, what a genius!!

  • @theniecygirl he was the chosen one to let us know .god was speaking through him at a very young age how could he foresight and make predictions .he was gifted.

  • this is beautiful ....

  • Great Stuff. R.I.P. GHS. you WILL be missed & remembered!!

  • Gil Scott-Heron died yesterday?? Why the hell wasn't it on the news? THis guy is an ICON>> OF AMERICAN SOUL>>> OF THE AMERICAN SOUL/SPIRIT, .. May he be Blessed

  • My favorite song by him R.I.P Gil Scott Heron

  • R.I.P. TO A TRUE MUSIC LEGEND ! AND ALL AROUND UNIQUE PERSON !!!

    HIS WORDS AND MUSIC WILL CONTINUE TO INFLUENCE !!

  • Damn...like so many of his other songs, this one is sooooo deep. Will truely miss you.

  • I prefer shorter songs but anyway this one goes straight to favourites

  • I echo the other listeners and glad to see his influence on so many of us!!!

  • R.I.P. Gil youre a hero!

  • He will always be with us!............An aware conscientious spirt sending information to the unobservant.....God bless him and may he rest, knowing we will carry on his thoughtfulness!

  • R.I.P. GSH the only word I can say is like Joe Strummer, Curtis Mayfield, Nina Simone they were my teachers and I developed my sense of right and wrong and intellectual curiousty from these griots. TRAVEL WELL TO THE ANCESTORS GIL SCOTT HERON.

  • gil scott the greatest poet that ever lived. You will be surely missed. Peace original man. King master

  • dag, just found this song., and heard he died a day before. wow, great song. real 70's feel

  • thou I have only listened to his music now and never heard of him before today , it seems to me he had a vary difficult life in this percutory of ours, I hope he found a renewed life in a much more peaceful place.

    R.I.P.

  • R.I.P PEACE MAY YOU FIND THE PEACE IN DEATH THAT YOU DIDN'T FIND WHILE LIVING

  • R.I.P. THANKS FOR THE YEARS OF MUSIC.

  • Enjoy Paradise Sweetie ....

  • I also had the great fortune to have meet this man and we shared a drink. Legend in his own Life time! His legacy will live on...

    God Bless RIP

  • DAMN, HARD TO BELIEVE THIS PART OF MY MUSICAL LINEAGE IS GONE? IT TRULY IS WINTER!!!

  • you left to soon buddy Rip thank you for all,..

  • I had the great priviledge to see him perform twice at Cornell in Ithaca, NY, in the mid- 70's. He was a superb poet and performer. It is so sad that he never reached the heights that he should have. His drug addiction simply crushed him. I am so sad right now as I listen to "Winter in America". RIP

  • I saw Gil Scott Heron a the Jazz Cafe in Camden back in the 1990's. The dude was PURE GENIUS live. RIP. We really lost someone important here.

  • thanks Gil

  • see ya later...