@portstewartsam When I first heard it, I thought so, too. But the more I listen to this song, the more I realise how essential the coda is. This song is about hop, hence the title. Just when you think it's all over, the song is finished, there is nothing to hope for, first we hear a hopeful little motif emerge from the accompaniment (which we don't hear in this version) and then the song is reborn. It's a deceptively simple song working at several levels.
im not a lyricist so anything i came up with would most likely be detrimental to the song, but neil's a clever bloke so i'd leave it to him, if he so wished
@portstewartsam I sometimes think the song would be perfect just ending at "...beneath the ground". It might punch the heart a little more powerfully that way. I imagine Neil didn't want to end the album on such a dark note, but personally I feel the whole "sunrise" coda puts the song into soft focus, taking away its rawness, and leaving us thinking, "well, that's sorted then." There's still a kind of hope implied in the "who cares?" verse - it says, we're all human, so let's stop this now.
@portstewartsam When I first heard it, I thought so, too. But the more I listen to this song, the more I realise how essential the coda is. This song is about hop, hence the title. Just when you think it's all over, the song is finished, there is nothing to hope for, first we hear a hopeful little motif emerge from the accompaniment (which we don't hear in this version) and then the song is reborn. It's a deceptively simple song working at several levels.
OperaMan22 1 month ago
i love his voice!
trottel3001 10 months ago
During the last football season I often found myself singing this song between the time that the offence went on. Such a lovely song!
locojets 1 year ago
1:41 = Alleluja (jeff buckley)
liveforevergirl 1 year ago
Amazing.
bonniekilty 1 year ago
Fuckin' beautiful!
newpixeldude 1 year ago
It is a peace song
simonhalstead 1 year ago
:( its too low
azwel 1 year ago
One of the best songs ever !
xtcollectorsociety 1 year ago
I'm from Enniskillen :)
RSNSkillplayer 1 year ago
This song is fantastic, its message should never be forgotten. We should listen to this and affirm, 'we are not going back to The Troubles.'
MarkMystic 2 years ago 5
Whoever did the sound mixing was on valium or something :(
BillyBird 2 years ago
Awesome. Peace and love.
colinsmyth99 2 years ago 3
Neil est le meilleur tout simplement...
gilopetre 2 years ago
with a few lyrical changes it could certainly be a new anthem for Ulster. beautiful song
portstewartsam 3 years ago
What lyrical changes would you suggest? Just wondering...
padraic2001eire 2 years ago
im not a lyricist so anything i came up with would most likely be detrimental to the song, but neil's a clever bloke so i'd leave it to him, if he so wished
portstewartsam 2 years ago
@portstewartsam I sometimes think the song would be perfect just ending at "...beneath the ground". It might punch the heart a little more powerfully that way. I imagine Neil didn't want to end the album on such a dark note, but personally I feel the whole "sunrise" coda puts the song into soft focus, taking away its rawness, and leaving us thinking, "well, that's sorted then." There's still a kind of hope implied in the "who cares?" verse - it says, we're all human, so let's stop this now.
JamesHarkerMusic 5 months ago
Always puts the hairs on the back of my neck standing on end. Really good song. It's more than just a song though. It always inspires national pride.
johngavin2008 3 years ago 7
Far and away the best song ever written about Northern Ireland, and one of the best on Fin De Siecle...
Dipthefal 3 years ago 25
@Dipthefal not forgetting the police 'invisible sun' of course. have you seen the video?
jaddajn1 5 months ago
Lovely song.
WritherInSilence 3 years ago
Such a beautiful and poignant song and Neil always sings it with such passion.
guysbitch 3 years ago 5
This give me the collywobbles every time. :)
clairefaerie 3 years ago 16
this is my favourite Divine Comedy song
Videodrome92 3 years ago 2