Added: 4 years ago
From: imoimo19891010
Views: 310,425
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (272)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like this piece.

  • this is what love sounds like

  • Such a masterpiece!

  • Astor Piazzolla tuvo un maestro en Nueva York cuando niño ,llamado Bela Wilda, que había sido alumno de Rachmaninoff. Creo que fue su primer maestro formal. Me parece que es posible que se haya transmitido la enorme capacidad melódica del maestro ruso a las hermosas melodías de Piazzolla. Hace mucho que tengo una grabación de esta sinfonía por Previn y me emociona siempre que la escucho.Desde Buenos Aires, felicitaciones.

  • this!This is true romanticism!!!

  • Thank you mr rachmaninoff for such beautiful music, it made me cry. And thank you mr previn and the NHK symphony who played this as it derseved to be heard, mr rachmaninoff would have been proud.

  • Ineffably beautiful. Evokes feeling I thought dead in me.

  • I dont see how people could have crtiqued rachmaninovs music so harshly its simply beautiful

  • Every movement ... f***ing beautiful!

  • Goosebumps... ^-^

    I love Rachmoninoff's piano pieces, I am a pianist and have studied them, yet never heard any of his symphonies. So I came to listen and see how they were... well, I am getting chills and tears are in my eyes! Love you, Sergei!

  • Amo escuchar esta pieza...

  • Listening to this is one of the most beautiful moments of a lifetime.

  • I have just heard this live in Toronto played by the TSO-and then opened my computer to replayed on U tube-just simply breathtaking-the horns and clarinette are simply great-what a wonder that someone could compose such a piece of art.

  • Thank you Maestro Previn and the NHK Orchestra for this heartfelt rendition of one of the greatest compositions ever written.

    That one single human being can create such music leaves me dumbfounded.

    Thank you Sergei Rachmaninov - you have touched my life

  • Unbelievably beautiful piece of music,music that is beyond genius.

  • BTW, listen to the main theme of "Sleeping With the Enemy". I think listeners who like this Rachmoninov piece will hear the same licks.

  • Nobody should NOT "like" this movement. This type of writting in music creates the mental sedation needed to experience complete nostalgia that composers felt and experienced when writting. This is truly God-sent.

  • My freshman year we played this during our ballad during marching band, I love this piece!

  • This is terribly difficult. Bravo!

  • I've always had a hard time playing this solo at auditions or performances. because I always get choked up.

  • Beautiful artistry by these very fine Japanese musicians.... pouring their heart and soul into their art, with a passion and understanding that is universal. A moving gift... Thank you....

  • so smooth...

  • かっこええ。

    本物や。

    すげえ。

    

  • Sent this video to Lee .... this was her response:

    "Absolutely glorious. It speaks to the cells of your body and puts music to their ability to sync with each other to fulfill their purpose .... I will agree with you - thank God for Rachmaninoff!!!"

  • one of the most touching melodies ever written. great conductor too. thanks for posting

  • I happened to listen to Eric Carmen's Never Gonna Fall in Love Again just before catching this performance. At 3:18 the similarity is absolutely certain. Eric's piano is substituted with the first violins.

  • I don't see this piece of information in the first few pages of posts, so I'll remind readers that Eric Carmen's song "Never Gonna Fall in Love Again" is richly based on this Rachmaninvov symphony. Carmen is pure genius. He also has said "All By Myself" has parallels to Rach's 2nd pianto concerto.

  • @minnabean33 True, "All by myself" is based on the slow movement of the 2nd piano concerto. It is very clear if you try listening to it

  • thanks a lot,mr rachmaninof!!!

  • I love this movement!!!!

  • Beautiful

    Just beautiful

  • Sorry, but the clarinetist falters at 1:07 - ruins it for me

  • @watutman I'm sure you already know, but Previn's 1970s RCA recordings of both the short and the full versions of the symphony, with the London Symphony Orchestra featuring Jack Brymer on solo clarinet, are definitive and should be heard to be believed. This is mush and the NHK players don't seem to 'get it'.

  • I feel sorry for all those people in history who died before this piece was written. For their sake, I hope you're able to listen to future music in the afterlife.

  • I must say that even though Rach is one of my favourites, I never could quite bring myself to like the 2nd symphony. It really has gorgeous passages, and the Scherzo as a whole is excellent, but somehow all in all it's just too sprawling, schmaltzy and overlong by half an hour.

  • @Astron278 have you heard Svetlanov's recording? (available right here on youtube i believe). he probably has the greatest understanding of the piece i've ever heard, so listening to his reading might help you see some structure. pure russian soul.

  • Perfection

  • This is amazing and nowadays music is a joke compared to this

  • 6 deaf people, that's all

  • WHO GIVES A FUCK ABOUT JUSTIN BEIBER!

    ITS ALL ABOUT THE MUSIC

  • Previn brings out elements sloughed off by other conductors. He allows elements of

    of sections that are usually not audible. He adds texture and edge to all his interpertations. He is my favorite condutor of all time. He will take the time,

    not rushing through sectiions. Sometimes its like hearing a Rachmanivov movement for the first time. He is a nuanced poet of music and a genuis.

  • Howard Roark, Architect.

  • Mein Gott, ich fühle mich wie zu weinen. Es ist so schön!

  • the 6 dislikes were from justin bieber making 6 accounts and disliking this video 

  • I fucking like to this!!

  • It's sad that the accesible beauty of Rachmaninoff's music has made so many music snobs (yes snobs) treat him as a second rate composer. I like Webern, Schoenberg, Steve Reich but I agree with @vegatrev - Rachmaninoff's music "has enriched my life beyond imagination". I first heard this symphony 50 years ago and it still touches my heart. It is wonderful music on all levels.

  • @keybawd, I couldn't have said it better. Not only is he treated badly by the critics for writing beautiful music, but also for not being an ethnic German or Austrian. There's this vicious idea floating around in the classical music world that the Germanic peoples are infinitely better than the rest of us at all things music-related. This idea is the direct result of the nationalistic German and Austrian musicologists of the 19th century.

  • @keybawd, don't get me wrong: there's wonderful German and Austrian music. We have had the names of the great Germanic composers drilled into our skulls during our years at conservatory. But we must realize that musical genius does not belong to any one ethnic group. Music is universal, and musical genius is found in every ethnic group at every period of time.

  • @keybawd, what distinguishes the classical music world as the only sphere of human activity which still embraces the idea of Aryan Supremacy is that most of the conservatory professors I have spoken with not only think the Germanic composers, as a group, are infinitely superior to all others, but that this is because the Germanic people are inherently infinitely superior at all things music-related. It's a truly vicious ideology, and one that needs to be destroyed as soon as possible.

  • @keybawd, if you think I sound crazy, it's only because the professors and music snobs I have come into contact with are crazed with their supremacy theories and their bigotry. What is furthermore incredible is that such conservatory programs should consider themselves politically and socially liberal, tolerant and open-minded, and then condemn all non-Germanic composers to comparative irrelevance, as well as, of course, all non-Western music.

  • @keybawd

    Just check out Grove for yourself! You'll see how snobby the description on Rachmaninov is ;( It's sad.

  • @keybawd Who treats Rachmaninoff as a 2nd rate composer?

  • @keybawd I can't believe there are actually people like that. This music is near unparalleled in its sheer beauty.

  • Romantic. Sublime. Moving. Utterly beautiful.

  • Not being totally familiar with this genre of music, but a fan nonetheless!, it's somewhat odd that you hear familiar undertones from this piece that is used in Barbra Streisands "Evergreen". Could it be possible that the arranger for her music could be or have been a Rachmaninov fan?

  • 8.33-8.50 brings me to tears. Astonishing piece of music..

  • Is there a DVD for this anywhere? I'm absolutely obsessed with this recording.

  • How could this beautiful piece be NOT liked??? It absolutely sends the senses beyond.......

  • NHK Symphony Orchestra is super!

  • Just beautiful... all movement.

    Buiii... <3

    I must say that the clarinet isn't one of my favorite instruments, however, the clarinet solo at the beginning... woww, no words... is simply perfect.

  • @MusicWonderz @jayster8496 ERO ftw! <3

  • Really interesting music, Very nice :-)

  • To me, this is "the crown of his life's achievements," one of the most moving pieces of love music ever written, and, with Delius's "The Walk to the Paradise Garden" and a tiny handful of other works, representative of musical late- and post-Romanticism at its very finest.

  • @HerrProfessorDoktor Andre Previn has a unique way of bringing out the romantic tenderness in Rachmaninov Symphonies. I can recall the atmosphere of the sessions for RCA in Walthamstow back in the 70s. I also recall Sir Adrian Boult warning Andre that his deportment on the rostrum would lead to back problems in later life. Sad to say Boult was right. But Andre can still work his magic on bands in this music.

  • @MusicWonderz Oh cool, funny we both watching the same video!

  • @jayster8496 wow nice :) and beautiful performance..

  • I just played this yesterday on English horn. I absolutely love it! The solos are SO beautiful. A real joy to play!

  • @jayster8496 ERO?

  • Comment removed

  • @MusicWonderz Yeah, were you there? What did you play?

  • @jayster8496 Clarinet, sat right behind you

  • It makes me weep

  • Wow, that clarinet solo just makes me melt. Absolutely beautiful. If I can play my clarinet even half as beautifully, I'd be happy. Wow.

  • What an outstandingly beautiful piece of music

  • this is such a beautiful Symphony... I just watched on BBC the life of Sergei Rachmaninov and I'm so touched by it.I think his music is not totally classic, it's quite revolutionary that's why not alot of people do not accept it . Thanks to him, this one has been quite an inspiration to alot of modern composers, I think I heard this alot of times in Animes. Hahahaha!

  • Bravo, Mr. Previn - Hauntingly beautiful.

  • Fab-U-lous : fabulous artist/s; fabulous music; fabulous construction!

  • I love how nice people have become on youtube recently. Good music unites us all! Beautiful piece.

  • So romantic. So beautiful. The music tranports one to such a lovely place. 

  • Just because it is an Asian orchestra, it's does not mean substandard.MANY musicians in NHk symphony are European and American trained and are top musicians in their own right. Sure, Japan had late start in Western music, but it's incredible how much they caught up. If they were mediocre, people like Ashkenazy (who, by the way, was the commissioned conductor of NHK) or Previn or other great conductors would not bother conducting them.

  • @strad1772 Yes wasn't it just awful. :-ß (sarcasm)

  • @strad1772 ????????????? Some of todays greatest musicians are Asians!

  • @shlomzion Yes! Yourself said the truth: MUSICIANS...but not Artist !

  • ZOMG! CLARINET SOLO!!!

  • Rachmaninoff is the greatest composer who ever lived. In every bar of his music is direction, purpose, motion, and their final sum: emotion. He may never have identified it in words, but he discovered a new principle of music composition which unlocked an unlimited potential for beauty. He was not the end of Romanticism, but its true beginning.

  • @HotSo0P, I completely agree with you. He was certainly one of the very best...most definitely leagues ahead of Beethoven and Mozart, and on par with Bach, Hildegard von Bingen, Tchaikovsky, Rameau, Holst, Chopin, and the other truly great composers.

  • @HotSo0P, I especially think Rachmaninov's piano music and concertos are truly great. His 2nd, 3rd, and 4th piano concertos are some of the finest pieces ever written. They are equal to the greatest works of Bach and Chopin, really something that has not been equalled to my knowledge. And then his preludes and etudes-tableaux...yes, Rachmaninov is criminally underrated simply because he isn't German or Austrian. This pro-German bias has overtaken the classical music world, sadly.

  • @HotSo0P, I would argue that Rachmaninov, rather being the end or the beginning of Romanticism, is it's peak, it's ultimate expression. Rachmaninov was the pure embodiment of Romanticism just as Mozart was the pure embodiment of Classicism. Rachmaninov may have lived toward the end of the Romantic period, but his music shows that he was the essence of Romanticism, not its end, as you say.

  • 6:30 gives me the chills time and again.

  • Herbert von Karajan the best conducter Period.....

    Previn can't compare,.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • what a dream.

  • Glorious. Why does a German-American jazz pianist understand Rachmaninov so well? Is it an exile thing?

    TPOC

  • what about Previn???? An excellent conductor...a genius!!!!

  • I LOVE RACHMANINOV...he's a genius...i feel something in my very soul when i'm listening his compositions....it's so great filling

  • @tylerenglish100 i feel smooth too : ' )

  • Rachmaninov is a magician...love his compositions so so hard...i feel something very pleasent in my heart while listening his compositions...

  • What a great performance, puts me at flight level 380 on the 747-400ER over the South Pacific Ocean, going to Sydney from LAX and seeing the beauty of the cloud formations and the endless ocean below on a long haul flight. Thanks for sharing.

  • I love Clarinet! beautifulllllllllll.....

  • last year, my marching band show was based upon this entire symphony, the first time we played the hit of the ballad, i stopped playing, it was so beautiful, and so moving, it gave me chills everytime

  • I'm no musician, but this piece is "magic". I could listen to it over and over, very moving.

  • Adding words to this sublime music is akin to adding a moustache to the Mona Lisa. The emotional message is ineffable; it is NOT a song.

  • OMG, no matter how many times I hear it, I feel like my heart will break asunder!

  • @Thunderbolt1000T I mean anyone can write depressing lyrics, but it takes a genius like Rachmaninoff to write a piece like this.

  • Touchingly beautiful music conducted by one of the great musical geniuses of our time, a great conductor, classical pianist, composer, and jazz musician.

  • Compared to the recording Prévin (Priwin) did with the London Symphony, this feels so terribly pedestrian, sad to say!! It's such a pity - this piece is so, so MIRACULOUS!!! Most certainly it's one of my very favourite symphonic movements. [Was he perhaps criticised as being too 'sentimental' for what he did in that recording?? If so, it's an even worse pity given how it seems he took it to heart...]

  • Bravo.

  • Wow.. I've not been brought to tears for no reason by music in years.. this did it to me.

  • There's a DVD or CD of this fantastic execution?

  • In my opinion, this is the single most beautiful piece of music. It brings me additional joy to see all of your comments and to know that others share in the same experience when listening to this music.

  • @DaJugglingFool I feel the same way. Nobody in my real life understands what music like this means to me. They tease me good naturedly for my taste in music but it is so nice to read these comments and know that there are people who feel like I do out there somewhere.

  • I Previn's autobiography. He dismisses a fantastic gem of opening credit music for "Bad Day at Black Rock." He standards are very, very high. But it was also a great piece of standalone romantic/dissonant music. This is a great piece he is conducting. oooh! How did Andre get older? I haven't! :)

  • @Harlan346

    Indeed! :)

  • Rachmaninov, Tchaikovsky, and Chopin, my unforgettable favorite three :)

  • this music is so powerful it reduces a fiftyfive year old man to tears everytime i hear it.

  • bellissimo..

  • Rachmaninoff is incredible.

  • Unfortunately, there is very little on the life of the composer. But a few years ago I bought an old bio by Sergei Bertensson & Jay Leyda. It is worth reading. "Sergei Rachmaninoff: I Lifetime in Music."

    Many thanks to imoimo for the upload, and praise to to the superb NHK Symphony Orchestra.

    Certainly no one captured the spirit of the best of Russia than Sergei Rachmaninoff.

  • @Amfortaz Certainly no one captured the spirit of the best of Russia than Sergei Rachmaninoff.

    Hear hear !

  • eric carmen aaalways uses rachmaninov's melodies, like all by myself

  • I love this melody. Eric Carmen's Never Fall in Love Again has the same tune as this one.

  • O.M.G. I adore Andre Pevin && Rachmaninov .....

    times goes by & we all age .. bless his heart

    To me Rachmaninow ............IS Andre Previn!

    I am so glad i have his earlier recordings on disc....

  • very very very nice sound

  • This is probably the most beautiful movement in any symphony ever composed. Rachmaninoff had a unique gift of being able to write heart wrenchingly beautiful melodies and orchestrate them perfectly. ahh the romantic period at it's best.

  • It sways your body like the wind....

    I also like Eric Carmen's Never Gonna Fall In Love Again since he based his melody on the main theme of the Symphony No. 2 Movement III.

    Great!

  • ¡Todos los pelos de punta! Es increible las sensaciones que siento con esta pieza. Es de una belleza emocionante.

  • Almost everything Rachmaninov has composed has a quality beyond compare. The man was incredibly sensitive to variances in music ... we are fortunate that he was around to touch our lives.

  • Quelle merveilleuse interprétation!

    C'est très émouvant.

  • I have admired the work of Maestro Previn since the 1960s. He has never lost his touch. Here, he turns classical music into absolute Magic.

    What great music - what a performance!

  • Andre Previn has such a great interpretation of this movement

  • Its so romantic... ist the most romatic symphony piece ever written.

  • @Sedanstotina It makes your heart weep with quiet joy

  • Oh yes it does.

  • Its the most romantic song I ever heard.

  • I didn't know that Rachmaninoff inspired all bye my self. It's a beautiful song.

  • Previn hits the bullseye with this interpretation. Just the right tempo and lushness to make this about the most romantic music ever written---after Rach's 2nd piano Concerto, 2nd movement, that is.

  • The music of Rachmaninov has enriched my life beyond imagination.

  • @vegatrev amen. me too

  • @vegatrev I completely understand, this composer has written some of the most powerful, intense music, and when I feel the world is a crappy place and need refuge, I often listen to a lot of his music to lift up my spirits.

  • one of my favorite symphonic movements ever written... great performance

  • The first time i heard this sound, i realize that This song could be considered as the best compositition ever made

  • Klauskristiannugraha hits on something. This song could be considered the best composition. The best composition, so long as compositions are beheld by individuals with rich needs, individual needs that could, every now and then, grasp at Rach's 2nd and call it perfect for the occasion.

  • Is the best version of all.

    For me, of course!!!

  • Such a touching Performance and the clarinet solo

  • for those who want a cd try previn's 1972 recording with the lso. remastered, beautiful sound and the recording that is still considered the best

  • My favorite conductor playing my favavorite symphony by my favorite composer with some wonderful musicians. Bravo! Thanks for sharing.

  • I think Andre Previn is one of the best conductors of this work. Eugene Ormandy and the Phialdelphia Orchestra also played this superbly. When it is played by the BSO or any other orchestra in Massachusetts I always make a point to hear it as it is one of my favourite symphonies. I love the varying and interesting harmonies. It is like a vision of heaven or the promised land.

  • My heart aches! My God, Rachmaninov was the embodiment of Heaven on Earth! How a man could create such a soul stirring gem, not without Divine intervention. He left us with nothing less than greatness. Bless him!

  • Yes, tears in my eyes when I heard this movement. Remember my most beautiful time in my life.

  • This is truly beautiful and transcendental.

    Thank so much for sharing!!

  • Brilliant

  • Symphonic music like this often requires cinematic context It ,in fact, invokes memory and memory is cinematic. Thank God there are people still making this music for the memories of our own lives.

  • I was fortunate enough to play this piece at my All State Orchestra Festival in CT in 2008... i had never heard of this piece nor the composer... but when we started playing it together as a full symphonic orchestra for the first time, my heart melted... never in my life had I enjoyed playing my violin as i had during this movement of His 2nd symphony.. just the whole build up until the climax is enough to melt the hardest of hearts. ill never forget this movement

  • It was the case for me as well. I had pleasure to play it too. Although it was hard work (so many notes for violins in 2nd and 4th movement!) but very satisfying. I was always getting shivers and goose bums no matter how often we had to reherse it. At the end of the concert I was literary pouring tears out and I could not stop them at any point and I belive some people at the audience cried too :)

  • Is there a CD from this NHK symphony orchestra? It is so beautiful

  • Andre Previn ,s Hands are so eloquent and This music is so achingly beautiful,,,,

  • That song and "All by myself" by Eric Carmen (he recalled the melody when he studied violin with his aunt who played for the Cleveland Symphony Orchestra)

  • The famous adagio movement gave rise to a popular song several years that lifted the melody, although I cannot recall the name of the song (something about I'm never gonna love again). Mr. Previn has come a long way since he directed the MGM orchestra for the film, "Gigi" for which he won the Academy Award fifty years ago, following in his father's footsteps. He is the last of the Twentieth Century's great musical giants.

  • I believe it's "Never gonna fall in love again" by Eric Carmen~

  • Now this is what I call music.

  • Esto es como un pajaro azul...que nunca podré ver.

  • chills down my spine! words cannot describe the beauty of it!

  • appreciated.

  • i have been looking everywhere for this melody, i heard it once and i knew it was of rachmanninoff but i couldnt find it...

    the best piece of music ever written!! its so celestialand perfect.. romantic!!!!!!! gosh i love it

  • yea, a year ago, this piece wasnt on youtube and i was like WTF?! thank god people decided to put this on youtube.

  • Kudos to Maestro Previn and the NHK Symphony Orchestra for the superb performance of this romantic masterpiece. It also brings back sweet memories of Previn's conducting of this symphony at the Hollywood Bowl under the stars which I attended in the summer of 1965. Unfortunately, he was panned by the music critics on that occasion.

    My heartfelt thanks to imoimo.

  • THe version Andre Previn recorded with the London Symphony Orchestra back in the 1970s won award with the Gramophone magazine. It is still available. Despite his age, the passion of this work stays.

  • Love how the music seems to wander off on its own, which is the beauty of the piece