It's amazing how the story behind the song is a third person one, but the way she sings it is like she's actually experienced it..i would think it would be difficult to put so much feeling into something when the experience isn't your own.
man this song so makes me think "1996" it might sound ridiculous, but it makes me think of the hanging at the shops down the road from my place when i was just a kid
Bingo! Was wondering how long it would take for someone to nail it. I believe the "I nearly died" is a reference to The Beatles' "No Reply", another great song.
As far as improvising, I think it's a combination of different sources; she's used "Why don't you get out of here and bring me some money , too" which was from a song written in 1929 called "The Weed Smoker's Dream", but later changed to "Why Don't You Do Right"(Jessica Rabbit covered it in "Who Framed Roger Rabbit").
Another line was "I gave you a wristwatch and you wouldn't give me the time of day" -not sure about origin. Let's face it, no matter what she says, it always sounds sexy, but the line from "Why'd You Do It? just sizzles with that thick Scottish brogue.
Spacemutt,(possibly the coolest name, ever), I'm so glad to know where that sort of "silly" line was from (well, silly compared to "I see her cunt in my bed"! Everytime I heard it, I'd think to myself, "O.K., you gave him a fucking wristwatch, get over it...or steal it back or something...seems kind of petty."
But it has a poetic/ironic feel, which is more Patti Smith"s style...I think. I'll have to listen to "Revenge" again and hear her delivery.
Interesting ending! Hey, does Shirl ever break out the pink boa that I spot sitting on an amp? I equate it so much with that brilliant first album. I wish she'd been working it during one of the numbers. Just a great tour, gah.
I see I got thumbs down and usually dont care (I dont come back to see what other people thought of what I wrote lol); but I was answerinf to someone who was wondering why she was moving - as if it was weird on stage... ?! you know xD
Oh sorry for that .I didn't give u any thumb down I just answered to see if u were criticizing her.And there's no doubt...everyone loves shirley , her voice and her on stage stalking on stage !
jesus christ she is hot in this...
bettydaw1970 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
I LOVE the extra lyrics at the end. Never heard it before but like everything that Garbage does - I LOVE IT!!!
BRAHMBO18 4 months ago
D-I-V-A!
feuds90 1 year ago
LA AMO
yaninplacebo 1 year ago
fuck hot band
julieswahn 1 year ago
she also used the "every time I see your dick I see her cunt in my bed!" from Why d do it song by Marianne Faithful - highly recommend it!
blackcanary147 2 years ago 2
jajajajajajajaja que chingados le pasa a la locotrona es ano mames jajajajaja bien exagerada
MODELMAKER 2 years ago
WoW
materialgirl130 2 years ago
Q LOKO
k3ngarbage 2 years ago 2
One of their best lives... I love it!
hujanna 2 years ago 2
Good song
jgcuba22 2 years ago 2
So much better than the music video
dunkmannhowlett 2 years ago 4
love that red hair :)
Artemis458 3 years ago 3
This is the shirley I LOVE!
andrea111292 3 years ago 7
i can remember when the video came out, great song, great memories, awesome band!
bixby1982 3 years ago
Wow!!!!!!!!!
thescream74 3 years ago
It's amazing how the story behind the song is a third person one, but the way she sings it is like she's actually experienced it..i would think it would be difficult to put so much feeling into something when the experience isn't your own.
RocknCorruptrepublic 3 years ago 4
Amazing growl!
andrea111292 3 years ago 3
Lovely Angry Voice
silenzioradio 3 years ago 4
i love how she stalks the stage like some kind of animal...
hippietrucker67 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like the way she sings live here but I always question myself why she never wears a bra?
ZakusDM 3 years ago
she doesn't have to! She doesn't want to make her tits look bigger with a push up!She's natural.
andrea111292 3 years ago 6
her voice hre is interesting: out of tiredness its broken, raw, grungy
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago
shirley played the guitar
chuwaka500 3 years ago
i have this concert
chuwaka500 3 years ago
I know for a fact she can sing better than that.
Ryeband 3 years ago 3
she's a bit tired and she lost part of her voice because the show was at the end
andrea111292 3 years ago
And she did a show at Bizarre Festival 2 or 3 days before... she was better there. Much better.
dizzlor 3 years ago
Beautiful Garbage!!!!!!!!!!!!
QUEERIDO 3 years ago
"like Jesus Christ coming back from the dead"
Shirley just rules^^
xisco77sietes 4 years ago 5
my favorite line in the song =)
RocknCorruptrepublic 3 years ago
Her voice is shot in this vid, but she is great anyway, fuckin' hot as hell.
rafalweb 4 years ago 4
she is a GODESS...evrytime i see ur dick i see her cunt in my bed
christosvip 4 years ago 2
man this song so makes me think "1996" it might sound ridiculous, but it makes me think of the hanging at the shops down the road from my place when i was just a kid
Dohey 4 years ago
her "aaargh" is so sweet :)
meshugeah 4 years ago 10
the "everytime i see your dick" thing is a line from "why d'ya do it", by marianne faithfull.
daviddinnizz 4 years ago
Bingo! Was wondering how long it would take for someone to nail it. I believe the "I nearly died" is a reference to The Beatles' "No Reply", another great song.
As far as improvising, I think it's a combination of different sources; she's used "Why don't you get out of here and bring me some money , too" which was from a song written in 1929 called "The Weed Smoker's Dream", but later changed to "Why Don't You Do Right"(Jessica Rabbit covered it in "Who Framed Roger Rabbit").
cathoderoy 3 years ago
Another line was "I gave you a wristwatch and you wouldn't give me the time of day" -not sure about origin. Let's face it, no matter what she says, it always sounds sexy, but the line from "Why'd You Do It? just sizzles with that thick Scottish brogue.
cathoderoy 3 years ago
The wristwatch line is from Patti Smith's song "Revenge"
spacemutt 2 years ago
Comment removed
cathoderoy 2 years ago
Spacemutt,(possibly the coolest name, ever), I'm so glad to know where that sort of "silly" line was from (well, silly compared to "I see her cunt in my bed"! Everytime I heard it, I'd think to myself, "O.K., you gave him a fucking wristwatch, get over it...or steal it back or something...seems kind of petty."
But it has a poetic/ironic feel, which is more Patti Smith"s style...I think. I'll have to listen to "Revenge" again and hear her delivery.
Thanks for the info!
cathoderoy 2 years ago
@cathoderoy When did she use Why Don't You Do Right?
horrorhearter 3 months ago
she said " Everytime i see your dick i see her cunt in my bed!!
KingCronic2107 4 years ago 2
Great Doesn't even do Shirley the Justice she deserves!
jeffnoles43 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes so unclucky havent seen ma dick
gangsta77x 4 years ago
ahahaha the ending is amazing!
did she improvise?? lol
connorlalitte 4 years ago 4
very good performance =D
what does she say after "everytime i see your dick i see you come in my bed"?
TowaMisaki 4 years ago
she sounds like tarzan when she says "i nearly died"
dcastil5 4 years ago
TARZAN?!?!?! Oh my god Ahahahaha!!! Wtf....?! I don't know why but that literally made me laugh out loud.
butterandcheese92 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
AWESOME!!!
WATCH NEW ARTIST JILL SHINE's MUSIC VIDEOS SHE's HOT, FUNNY AND ROCKS!!!!
weatherwatching 4 years ago
Shirley is the heart and soul of this band!
jeffnoles43 4 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
does she say 'everytime i see your dick i see you cum in my pants???' lol great song!
Dohey 4 years ago
no she says "everytime i see your dick i see you come in my bed" lol
raven007tr 4 years ago
Shirley Manson FOREVER
jronson22 4 years ago 2
Interesting ending! Hey, does Shirl ever break out the pink boa that I spot sitting on an amp? I equate it so much with that brilliant first album. I wish she'd been working it during one of the numbers. Just a great tour, gah.
julieswahn 4 years ago
shirleys got nice shoes... good show
xGreenDayoAvrilx 4 years ago 2
Why is she walking in circles?
sexyback545 4 years ago
dont you know you have to move on stage if you dont wanna look like a frozen stick recitating songs?
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago
Did u know this was the last song in the concert, she was tired and she 's still full of energy???
andrea111292 3 years ago 5
No I wasnt axre of that, thx for precising.
I see I got thumbs down and usually dont care (I dont come back to see what other people thought of what I wrote lol); but I was answerinf to someone who was wondering why she was moving - as if it was weird on stage... ?! you know xD
I adore Shirley, no doubt about that
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago 3
Oh sorry for that .I didn't give u any thumb down I just answered to see if u were criticizing her.And there's no doubt...everyone loves shirley , her voice and her on stage stalking on stage !
andrea111292 3 years ago 3
One of the more powerful rock performances you will ever see! BRAVO!
ilcchef2 4 years ago 5
HA HA FUCKIN UNREAL!And i want her..
holyjodeeshit 4 years ago
Butch and Shirley are so hot
jdlaw001 5 years ago 3
I Think The Same The Both Are So Hot....
grbgrockme 4 years ago
wow vow
k3ngarbage 5 years ago
Yeah this performance rocks ! Shirley is awesome as always !! ;) What's name of the song !? Ty skywalker74 for uploading ! :) Danke schön !
marting1981 5 years ago
The name of the Song is "Vow".
skywalker74 5 years ago
I just love the guitarsound!
okiko76 5 years ago
esta conmadre!!!!
increible cancion!!!
pinche garbage es la mamada
si vuelven a Monterrey me meo jajajaja
ciao!!!
gabomty99 5 years ago
Awesome performance!!! :)
gmags06 5 years ago