Very nice my Friend! But hey, why do aspiring young PROFESSIONAL guitarrists have such strong opinions on the absolute way of making music...? Guess the world is becoming more and more competitive....
I like this one slow too. Maybe that means I dont kow how to "feel" music correctly. I guess I'll just have to ask a guitar performance major. But really though this was nice. I like your Gavotte by Ponce as well!
Thanks very much. Yes, there was much debate about the speed of this piece. I tend to like it on the slow side....most recordings I've heard of it are fairly slow. Glad you liked the gavotte as well.
This is one of my favorites songs... It reminds me of a great friend of mine, who once left the country for study, because I've played this in his "departure party".
Well, congratulations, it's a beautifull version of this piece! I think that slowly is more sentimental, melancolical and magnifescent; I prefer it instead of the "original" one.
i'm sorry if i sounded completley rude, which by the way, i did. This version you play sounds really akward to me! Sorry guy. The version i'm thinking of comes from Dr Elliot Frank live in october 2006 cd. Also the song is in Suite del Recordeo. But, i mean im majoring in classical guitar and i play soo much differently than you. O yeah a good tip to play with really good tone is to pluck the strings on the left side of your nails! You can hear the difference!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is actually supposed to be played faster. Not slower. It's in cut time even though its Tempo rubato. Dr. Elliot Frank plays this song faster and more fluently. This guy has the timing wrong on the notes in two measures behinf the last 1st ending. Its not a good performance. (no offense)
Thank you for your critique...I enjoy freedom of speech as well. There are a number of versions of this piece, the one I play is by Jason Vieaux who first recorded and performed this suite. He has a position of Director of Guitar at the Cleveland School of Music. It's played slowly, exactly as I've played it and I prefer this approach. Can you tell me your credentials to be making your comments? Also, if you've also recorded this piece, I'd love to hear how much better you play it.
I am an Argentinian, nuts about clasic guitard. I love what i herd, I think that you really love to play guitar too. But if you allow me, I suggest: play the same song but a a little fast, and I think that you can do that and more, and be more involved, let your body flow with the music or the misic to flow in your body, let it be...dream in the music that you play be yourself. Do not restrict your feeling from the music that you paly.
n00b. but ya still have good taste for music!
blauegitarre 7 months ago
great performance!
StudioOctavia 8 months ago
Very nice my Friend! But hey, why do aspiring young PROFESSIONAL guitarrists have such strong opinions on the absolute way of making music...? Guess the world is becoming more and more competitive....
Anyway...keep on posting!
=))
LaGuitarrayYo 1 year ago
Great!!!
WongsirChannel 2 years ago
I like this one slow too. Maybe that means I dont kow how to "feel" music correctly. I guess I'll just have to ask a guitar performance major. But really though this was nice. I like your Gavotte by Ponce as well!
CrabtreeGuitar 3 years ago
Thanks very much. Yes, there was much debate about the speed of this piece. I tend to like it on the slow side....most recordings I've heard of it are fairly slow. Glad you liked the gavotte as well.
gt1957 3 years ago
Beautiful. Your rendition is, indeed, haunting.
roodeeroo 3 years ago
This is one of my favorites songs... It reminds me of a great friend of mine, who once left the country for study, because I've played this in his "departure party".
Well, congratulations, it's a beautifull version of this piece! I think that slowly is more sentimental, melancolical and magnifescent; I prefer it instead of the "original" one.
kell1987 3 years ago
beznadzieja. Gościu wogóle nie stosuje łączeń. Jeśli on jest nauczycielem, to współczuje jego uczniom...... :/ Beznajdziejnie
dzwoncu 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
check out La Suite del Recuerdo performance by the man himself, or Elliot Frank. Those are the versions that I'm used to.
fleidude 4 years ago
elliot frank! are you like an ecu student?
mrmet5 3 years ago
Why yes I know what it is, I have the book.
fleidude 4 years ago
i think you played it really well. i also play the version you played, and i love it slow, i think it sounds so much better!
guitaroxMM 4 years ago
i'm sorry if i sounded completley rude, which by the way, i did. This version you play sounds really akward to me! Sorry guy. The version i'm thinking of comes from Dr Elliot Frank live in october 2006 cd. Also the song is in Suite del Recordeo. But, i mean im majoring in classical guitar and i play soo much differently than you. O yeah a good tip to play with really good tone is to pluck the strings on the left side of your nails! You can hear the difference!
fleidude 4 years ago
Its from Suite del Recuerdo by Merlin....you're majoring in classical guitar and don't know the name of this suite?
gt1957 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is actually supposed to be played faster. Not slower. It's in cut time even though its Tempo rubato. Dr. Elliot Frank plays this song faster and more fluently. This guy has the timing wrong on the notes in two measures behinf the last 1st ending. Its not a good performance. (no offense)
fleidude 4 years ago
Thank you for your critique...I enjoy freedom of speech as well. There are a number of versions of this piece, the one I play is by Jason Vieaux who first recorded and performed this suite. He has a position of Director of Guitar at the Cleveland School of Music. It's played slowly, exactly as I've played it and I prefer this approach. Can you tell me your credentials to be making your comments? Also, if you've also recorded this piece, I'd love to hear how much better you play it.
gt1957 4 years ago
hey, I am following in your foot steps. Between the sheet music and watching your hand positions, it's not so bad. THanks a lot.
lerner01 4 years ago
I am an Argentinian, nuts about clasic guitard. I love what i herd, I think that you really love to play guitar too. But if you allow me, I suggest: play the same song but a a little fast, and I think that you can do that and more, and be more involved, let your body flow with the music or the misic to flow in your body, let it be...dream in the music that you play be yourself. Do not restrict your feeling from the music that you paly.
Thank you for the good time.
Goyi13 4 years ago
Very nice, very nice guitar playing :D
-Your daughter
Nefertiti127 4 years ago
Very nice, very nice guitar playing :D
-Your daughter
Nefertiti127 4 years ago
That was very moving, Roger. Thanks a lot.
jnclassicalguitarist 5 years ago
I enjoyed it Love the Piece well done. Keep making more :-)
mrhelsel 5 years ago
i really love sad / haunting pieces...well played
soniameh 5 years ago
Thanks you very much. I also am attracted to the melody of this piece.
gt1957 5 years ago
really nice..
m3l4nch0ly0 5 years ago
Thank you very much for the comment. I'm glad you enjoyed this piece.
Roger
gt1957 5 years ago
;))
m3l4nch0ly0 5 years ago
that was beautiful
sujil 5 years ago
Thank you so much. Glad you enjoyed it.
gt1957 5 years ago
Thanks! I like your playing a lot. This is one of my favorites to. Keep 'em comin' :-)
Peo
AndanteLargo 5 years ago
I'm so glad you like my playing, thanks very much! I'm working on the rest of this suite, so more to come...
Roger
gt1957 5 years ago