The music is good and I like the fact that some of the lyrics are canon.
But there's one line that's not:
"And what would you say, my love,
If you knew that I wished he was dead?"
Barty Sr. kept Barty Jr. alive under the imperius, in his house for about 14 years. His son then escaped his control and cast the dark mark. That would have made him angry, but he still kept him alive. He wanted to teach his son obedience. If he had killed his son, that would mean that he would have failed.
@jessicalestrange There are 2 parts to this reply, because the whole thing doesn't fit in one comment window.
1. Mr Crouch didn't want his son dead, all those years before the QWC, because he thought by controlling him, he would become repent. Mrs Crouch believed that Barty could become repentant and so sacrificed herself for him. Although she probably didn't know that her husband would use the imperius. I doubt she would have liked that treatment for her son.
2. After the QWC, Mr Crouch knew that Barty was far from repentance and yes, then I suppose he did want to kill him. Because his wife's reason for sacrificing herself is now gone and it would endanger the Wizarding community to keep him alive. But Mr Crouch couldn't bring himself to kill his son, because that would mean that he had failed to make Barty repentant, like he and his wife wanted.
@CastellanKat Honestly, I do believe he did all that for his son because it was what his wife would have wanted. If he was given the option of his son being dead and unrepentant and his wife alive or his son alive and repentant and his wife dead, he would probably chose his wife to be living. He may have done all that for his son, but he did it on his wife's behalf. Barty Crouch could have easily wished his son dead but that would violate his beloved's last wishes.
@bbbblllllaaaahhhh If you type in "TBAY: Crouch - C.R.A.B.C.U.S.T.A.R.D. (1 of 9)" into google and read the whole Crouch in 9 parts posts or particularly part 5, 6 and 7 (if you have time), you'll understand what I'm saying. It'll blow your mind.
Only Canadians can frolic in the snow in a off the shoulder dress!!! sorry that I find this amusing! I love the video is beautiful as well as the song!
I love how you guys do songs about the stories people don't normally consider. Like Petunia, Voldemort's mom, and Barty Crouch. It's made me think a lot more. Personally, I'm still looking for a song purely about Tonks and Lupin.
I think it is AMAZING that you chose to do this story into a song... so many stories get looked over in the series and you really brought out the beauty and sadness of this one... AMAZING
I totally just got into listening to wrocks, but I have only heard two of them, being that Im not all that far in the series. I waiting to read all of them before I listen to more of your music. I also tried looking for this song on iTunes, being that I really wanted to download it. Could you put this song/video on iTunes? Along with 'One Last Goodbye' with James and Lily. If you could, please do. :]
great song! but what I really want to say is that I just saw your tweet and I was going to reply but I figure you never see it so I'll post it here; @jesslestrange jess go back to school don't be like bella
ur songs and videos are the best! And you have a beautiful voice! I can't wait for more! Wow...dancing barefoot in the snow...omg that would be sooo cold!
Love this song! It's so cool that you did a song about Crouch. I don't think I've ever heard another song about him. Really original! And the video is beautiful.
This is such a beautiful song! It is such a great Wizard Rock song, it is amazing, and it is amazing you came up with this amazing lyrics to such a small part of harry potter, it is amazing! great job!
Her voice is so hauntingly beautiful. I love how these songs are directed towards the less important stories. They make me appreciate the characters more.
The song is beautiful and touching, and the video is brilliant and amazing in every way, what a beautiful place, what a beautiful light, what a beautiful dress.. but i bet you where soooo cold xD
this is a beautiful video jess! :) great editing and i love it in black and white <3 ...oh and of course it's an amazing song. i truly love the stuff you and brittany write
This is fantastic.
merryme134 6 months ago
One of my favorite things about this Wrock band is how they can write from the perspective of minor characters and do it well.
geekyclaire 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That's a wonderful video :)
slytherinsheirx 7 months ago
What a beautiful song! Did you sing this? Whoever did is /really/ talented. She shouldn't let her gift go to waste! Keep singing! (:
FreezingFyre 8 months ago
creepy ^.^
pitbullprincess852 9 months ago
The Crouch's story is explained in detail here:
TBAY: Crouch - C.R.A.B.C.U.S.T.A.R.D. (1 of 9)
(I don't think I can put links into comments, so type those words into Google and you'll find it).
CastellanKat 9 months ago
The music is good and I like the fact that some of the lyrics are canon.
But there's one line that's not:
"And what would you say, my love,
If you knew that I wished he was dead?"
Barty Sr. kept Barty Jr. alive under the imperius, in his house for about 14 years. His son then escaped his control and cast the dark mark. That would have made him angry, but he still kept him alive. He wanted to teach his son obedience. If he had killed his son, that would mean that he would have failed.
CastellanKat 9 months ago 4
@CastellanKat It's was basically what a coward would do if they couldn't kill someone. I see Jr as more of a victim that sr in this subplot tbh.
emROARS 8 months ago
@CastellanKat I don't understand how that could mean he didn't want him dead?
jessicalestrange 7 months ago 11
@jessicalestrange There are 2 parts to this reply, because the whole thing doesn't fit in one comment window.
1. Mr Crouch didn't want his son dead, all those years before the QWC, because he thought by controlling him, he would become repent. Mrs Crouch believed that Barty could become repentant and so sacrificed herself for him. Although she probably didn't know that her husband would use the imperius. I doubt she would have liked that treatment for her son.
CastellanKat 7 months ago
@jessicalestrange
2. After the QWC, Mr Crouch knew that Barty was far from repentance and yes, then I suppose he did want to kill him. Because his wife's reason for sacrificing herself is now gone and it would endanger the Wizarding community to keep him alive. But Mr Crouch couldn't bring himself to kill his son, because that would mean that he had failed to make Barty repentant, like he and his wife wanted.
CastellanKat 7 months ago
@CastellanKat Honestly, I do believe he did all that for his son because it was what his wife would have wanted. If he was given the option of his son being dead and unrepentant and his wife alive or his son alive and repentant and his wife dead, he would probably chose his wife to be living. He may have done all that for his son, but he did it on his wife's behalf. Barty Crouch could have easily wished his son dead but that would violate his beloved's last wishes.
bbbblllllaaaahhhh 5 months ago
@bbbblllllaaaahhhh If you type in "TBAY: Crouch - C.R.A.B.C.U.S.T.A.R.D. (1 of 9)" into google and read the whole Crouch in 9 parts posts or particularly part 5, 6 and 7 (if you have time), you'll understand what I'm saying. It'll blow your mind.
CastellanKat 5 months ago
Only Canadians can frolic in the snow in a off the shoulder dress!!! sorry that I find this amusing! I love the video is beautiful as well as the song!
MyLifesLabyrinth 11 months ago
only Canadians can frolic through the snow in a off the shoulder dress! Love the video!
MyLifesLabyrinth 11 months ago
I love how you guys do songs about the stories people don't normally consider. Like Petunia, Voldemort's mom, and Barty Crouch. It's made me think a lot more. Personally, I'm still looking for a song purely about Tonks and Lupin.
wolvengrl 11 months ago
that you dancin??? niiiiiice moves!
TheReginaspektorfan 1 year ago
I think it is AMAZING that you chose to do this story into a song... so many stories get looked over in the series and you really brought out the beauty and sadness of this one... AMAZING
wiccan2509 1 year ago
I love this song but at the same time I really hate Barty Crouch Sr. It was his fault his son ended up like in the first place.
emROARS 1 year ago 3
@emROARS
I think you're right and wrong. His dad influenced his choices, but at the end it was his own actions and decisions that put him where he ended up.
milleniumf15 1 year ago
I agree with @muggle394 . Thanks so much for your wonderful vids :D
FeistFanInsideAndOut 1 year ago
Comment removed
insaneXyesterdayX 1 year ago
This is so beautiful and so sad
GinGuareschi 1 year ago
Hey what editing software do you use???
TaylerMykel 1 year ago
@TaylerMykel I used cubase to edit this :)
reflekshun 1 year ago
I love this.
I love you.
I love the blog
jfhasjkfhasfhaljsdh
yourtornpictures 1 year ago
@yourtornpictures what blog
tigerheartx3 11 months ago
I love love love you music soooo beautiful and meaningful and full of emotion and amazingness
soooo great I want more and more, I really hope your working on more songs :D
Giascreen 1 year ago
i cant stop listening to it! stunning :)
catherine1495 1 year ago 4
only deatheaters will dislike this -.-'
SuzanneBlinkie 1 year ago 9
Will this song go on iTunes? Please say yes
silverdoe65 1 year ago 2
If this doesn't touch your heart, you must be heartless altogether. A job well done, Jess:}
chezmo2much 1 year ago 5
Beautiful <3
silverdoe65 1 year ago
Barty Crough... Very Cool
xyzfergie 1 year ago
I think it would be awesome if someone would ASL this whole song.
Someone should do it as a responce video. :)
MissBlondeification 1 year ago 3
nice video. the song is beautiful.
bellana94 1 year ago
Wow, beautiful. :O
missburn 1 year ago
I totally just got into listening to wrocks, but I have only heard two of them, being that Im not all that far in the series. I waiting to read all of them before I listen to more of your music. I also tried looking for this song on iTunes, being that I really wanted to download it. Could you put this song/video on iTunes? Along with 'One Last Goodbye' with James and Lily. If you could, please do. :]
Thanks.
MewLilyMew16 1 year ago
@MewLilyMew16 Check their bandcamp, Lets Lumos isn't on itunes.
PokemonTrainerAndrew 1 year ago 3
I can't believe I've never watched this. It's beautiful, dear.
RenaissanceWednesday 1 year ago
This is real magic
milleniumf15 1 year ago
That was beautiful.
Lyssa1Hale 1 year ago
Nice cello.
matleyz 1 year ago
I never thought about this scenario, but good video. :)
AnimeStargrl15 1 year ago
I loved the end where she was running away. This is so beautiful.
ElephantsWiithWings 1 year ago
I absolutley love love this song. Beautiful singing, beautiful lyrics. Jessica you are a talented writer
morgan111213 1 year ago 2
great song! but what I really want to say is that I just saw your tweet and I was going to reply but I figure you never see it so I'll post it here; @jesslestrange jess go back to school don't be like bella
Pennymsl 1 year ago
Wow. This is absolutely beautiful. In my opinion, it has an Evanescence-like quality to it. And Evanescence is my favorite band.
I love this. :)
wordsthatrhyme 1 year ago 2
I Think Your Very talented.
Your Band Shall be
SLYTHERIN
erm..
fuck it your cool xD
PerezxBear 1 year ago
did u sing this or somthing?
imenglishurnot 1 year ago
great!!!!!
kateclaudia 1 year ago 2
thts so cool & funny @ da same time that u would make a tribute to crouch's wife. XP
StripedxxSocks 1 year ago
Where can I get this remix in mp3?
It's not on his myspace, or his website, and its not on your bandcamp :(
Can you send it to me?
veganviola 2 years ago
This is a lovely song.
hannalestrange 2 years ago
ur songs and videos are the best! And you have a beautiful voice! I can't wait for more! Wow...dancing barefoot in the snow...omg that would be sooo cold!
xScarletxRosex 2 years ago
@xScarletxRosex oh, it was so cold. i got mild frostbite.
dollbits 1 year ago
Love this song! It's so cool that you did a song about Crouch. I don't think I've ever heard another song about him. Really original! And the video is beautiful.
thedemonhedgehog 2 years ago 2
What? I didn't hear this in the news... "Azkaban" I don't think there's a country with that name, unless a recent name change happened.
This music and imagery are incredible. 5 stars for the "BAMF" dedication!
AfroSchmuck 2 years ago
:)) jesus... afroschmuck, haven't you heard about harry potter? at least you could use google before posting such idiocy.
ze0germans 2 years ago
They didn't know. No need to be so mean.
Turquoiserose13 2 years ago
@ze0germans Idiocy would be your jurisdiction, I'm just the admirer...
AfroSchmuck 1 year ago
@AfroSchmuck, it's about Harry Potter, actually.
Turquoiserose13 2 years ago
@AfroSchmuck
It's about Harry Potter. Azkaban is a prison for wizards.
ell123lly 1 year ago
@ell123lly That's why I have you to help me cutie. Look's like a full time job for you ahaha.
Why don't you just marry me and get it over with? You could call me Daddy, and I could be your lover.
AfroSchmuck 1 year ago
@AfroSchmuck It's about a character in Harry Potter. Azkaban is the wizard prison.
MissTimBurtonFan 8 months ago
This is really beautiful. An awesome WizardRock song.
MonkeyAquarius 2 years ago
This is such a beautiful song! It is such a great Wizard Rock song, it is amazing, and it is amazing you came up with this amazing lyrics to such a small part of harry potter, it is amazing! great job!
ThePinkPowerRanger77 2 years ago 2
this is beautiful! I lovee it!
SianMusic 2 years ago
This is actually purely awesome.
I love it so much, and I've already watched it twice.
-subscribe-
madmonkeymadness 2 years ago
Her voice is so hauntingly beautiful. I love how these songs are directed towards the less important stories. They make me appreciate the characters more.
Tessa1440 2 years ago 2
you guys are definitely the best. so good.
j0ames 2 years ago
i actualy got shivers
ihearttheplanet 2 years ago
insane good
xshmoe 2 years ago
this is really really good.
loooooove it.
Darsoid 2 years ago
this is really touching...i got goosebumbs love you girls!!!
MonicaDean 2 years ago
oh sheesh there's an album?
any eta on that?
healingv1sion 2 years ago
it's out. check the sidebar.
kingsofroadkill 2 years ago
Amazing! Can't wait for the cd!
Summer0234 2 years ago
absolutely gorgeous. i love the beat to it and the polyphonic layering. this makes me want to dance. i can't wait till the cd is out
Geekella 2 years ago 28
woahhhhhh
healingv1sion 2 years ago
That was beautiful. The song was beautiful, the video was beautiful, and that was a beautiful dress. Bravo, once again.
muggle394 2 years ago 64
This is just beautiful.
dearcentennial 2 years ago 3
i love it.
dissolving 2 years ago 2
This is absoultly beautiful! I love all your songs!! Go Lets Lumos!
lilyhp27 2 years ago 2
Your songs are the most gorgeous and powerful! I agree with CarleeLicksCheese and am really haunted now. Unbelievable.
*favorites*
swimmersgirl 2 years ago 3
This should win an award or something. It's SO amazing and beautiful and WOW. I love this so much. When will the album be out?!?!? I can't wait.
meli5353 2 years ago 3
Uh-Mazing!!! Both the song and the video are absolutely beautiful!
moondreamer8907 2 years ago
please please PLEASE say that you will have a CD available sooner then later!
confuzzedlove 2 years ago
it is available. look in the sidebar.
kingsofroadkill 2 years ago
Mad Props to britt's sister. But next time I most def wanna see Brittany dance ;) haha
ChaosConRad 2 years ago
no.
kingsofroadkill 2 years ago
I think if i listen to it I will cry...
HPNEEK 2 years ago
amazing.<3
X0xChalotteLouisex0X 2 years ago
This is so haunting. I love it.
CarleeLicksCheese 2 years ago 3
how did ashley not lose toes. seriously.
CandyDemise 2 years ago 2
The song is beautiful and touching, and the video is brilliant and amazing in every way, what a beautiful place, what a beautiful light, what a beautiful dress.. but i bet you where soooo cold xD
Great work ^^
susipunkrockprincess 2 years ago
This is sad. But as I always hated Barty Crouch, I somehow can't cry, as usual =)
LaZitrone 2 years ago
really nice video :)
and nice song anyway ;)
Schussprinzessin 2 years ago
Beautiful! I love how the dress makes it look too, because the bottom part really stands out in the snow. Favorited!
M0onStruck 2 years ago 3
The two of you are awesome!
Ashly you are really a bamf for walking around in the snow like that! *stands up and aplauds... *
kateribethrose 2 years ago 2
@kateribethrose thanks, bro
dollbits 1 year ago
I lovee this song and videdo !
But I think I like the version on your website a littleee more better than this version (:
Still , it's beautiful !
memoimy1 2 years ago
My god. I am in tears. This song is amazing.
RocketRach 2 years ago 2
This song is beautiful, like all your others. <3
SpeakSSllooww 2 years ago
THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL!
casiesilverman 2 years ago
<333 i loveee it <333
reginafalloutgirl 2 years ago
amazing. i love it. the video was gorgee (:
eelhsax 2 years ago
Beautiful.
egernhat 2 years ago
i love love loveee the section where she's doing leg lifts in the snow...beautiful <3
Negzn 2 years ago
holy crap brittany this is heartwrenching
drinkthistea 2 years ago
This is absolutley stunning. I cried a bit.
Barfrainbows 2 years ago
this is amazing!
mandereeze3 2 years ago
This is so beautiful!
It kinda has a Celtic Women feel to it. Absolutely breathtaking.
mione134 2 years ago
O.O
That was absolutely gorgeous!
The coloring and the clips fit so beautifully with the remix.
Awesome.
BeautyVintageRoses 2 years ago 2
love this song and this video. *favorites*
ditzystef 2 years ago 2
this is a beautiful video jess! :) great editing and i love it in black and white <3 ...oh and of course it's an amazing song. i truly love the stuff you and brittany write
MisfitMassacreMakeup 2 years ago 2
this is awesome!
SmokeAndDiamonds13 2 years ago 2
The video was absolutely stunning. I love it! The song was gorgeous as well. You never fail to impress me. :)
deadzonefan13 2 years ago 3
this is lovely. i love this sub plot and its under appriciated. ahhhmazing
Snapiekins 2 years ago 2
Stunning! Wouldn't expect anything less <3
mysticxcharm 2 years ago 2
I love how all your songs arent about main characters but more about the side characters and their equally tragic stories.
PokemonTrainerAndrew 2 years ago 76
jess please ad me
xIxLovexAvrilx 2 years ago