Melanie C and Louis Walsh on Cd:UK

[MusicMixologyIl]

Louis was rude as hell, the Spice Girls paved the way for so many girl pop groups that came afterwards including Girls Aloud and those chicks are history nobody remembers them.

[annodam]

He was right. She has a terrible voice and he solo career flopped.

[matthieus2]

Mel C is great and really has a brilliant voice. Her solo career may not be as established as some others but I think she's right; the Spice Girls were original and people remember them, whereas many more recent bands rely on reality TV and cover versions.

[mrinvincible2001]

this was AMAZING! celebs dont get into scraps enough

[hurtboy83]

MELANIE WAS RIGHT......GIRLS ALOUD WHO??????

[stephenc4225]

Bring back CD:UK !!!

[hydrangea37]

I LOVE MELC!!! it was so true what she said to louis, spice girls were unbelievably BRILL!! GO MEL C!! XX

[tarrynkennedy19]

love melanie c saying how it is. dose not give a f... about anything back then

sporty spice 26

[hermespice]

gotta love mel c!!! funny i remember watching this live on telly back then.

[ganja3ero]

the spice girls 75 millions with just 4 albums... thats a real phenomenon!

[inkyinkster]

She says recored sales dont matter then pulls out the '37 million recored sales worldwide' card lol

[lostindiekid]

I miss this :(

[iluvashsimpson1]

girls aloud did make it in the guinness book of world records as having more 10 ten singles then any other girlband and for being the most sucesfull reality band

[victornuestro88]

mr. walsh is very stupid to say that. Girls aloud didn't make it to Guinness Book of world records. The Spice Girls did it.

[iluvashsimpson1]

mel has played every arena and stadium with the spice girls

[lucyAjane]

that's why I love Mel C

[Ktbailey2]

I miss SMTV and CD:UK i used to watch them every saturday morning :)

Those were the good days of childrens saturday morning TV with Ant, Dec and Cat.

[lordskittlesthefirst]

so true, back then the shows were actually funny unlike the shit that's on these days.

[dancergurl1416]

i love that the host of this is cat deely! (host for so you think you can dance) america! lol although i'm not surprised...

[midnightsgem]

from 6:00 and 7:00 can someone tell me what they're saying I can't make out the words the part where they go whoa and so on?

[midnightsgem]

I've never heard of westlife before....

[therockcrystal]

Gah. Mr. Walsh is competely wrong. I don't give a damn about what he said. Especially the part about "voices". Mel C has an amazing voice, Whalsh is just the way too disrespectful.

[annodam]

LOL - Louis really put the talentless minger in her place

[slayer4xtina]

I love Mel C btw! <3 my fave Spice girl!

[slayer4xtina]

She praised Christina Aguilera! <3

[petrikakko666]

Westlife HA HA HA HA!!!

It would be so easy to be a DJ, When the night comes to an end and slow songs start, i could put on any Westlife record on skip one of two tracks and let the record play on and on....HA HA HA same bullshit comes out...let´s see what we have...Ballad...Ballad...Balla­d...Ballad and What a nightmare, S****y Ballads, with no hook on them. Westlife can s**k my C**k

[rslphoenix]

phenomenon vs. hits? spice vs. westlyf? let's talk recordsold--spice:$55million, west:$40million, let's talk concerts--spicereunion$70M...s oldout 17 UK concert dates in 38 (madonna can't even do that), west:fuck don't know... popularity--spice: no.50 forbes 100 top celebrities, west:contented in UK, haha...latin American people don't even heard about them. who cares about 14 UK no.1 when ur stucked in UK? can't even write their songs...westdumbs r losers!

[racjan]

spice girls rawk!

[rslphoenix]

perfect response! Spice is spice--Iconic, westlife---hitmakers...that's all

[spicejade]

the point of spice girls forever is that no matter what..as a group or solo..they rock and doing music together or not they'll be friends forever..my question is wat's the point of westlyf staying together wen they cant make their own songs? zero contribution to music industry..useless

[rslphoenix]

mel b was noisy but she speaks her heart sincerely, emmma used to be baby but she's a grown up popstar...globally recognized and championed feminism that rivals marilyn monroe, madonna...plus the beatles.

we haven't seen the last of the spice girls. where are you now Westlife and girls aloud in the global barometers of pop power? are u included in forbes 100 celebrities?

[rslphoenix]

geri is lame but she has the heart of a pop queen, mel c had doubts but she has passion, victoria was misunderstood but she's a fashion czar,

[rslphoenix]

I love the spice girls coz they've worked hard to for their music not to record poor lame, overused themes but recreate their own music. they dominated and they fell apart but they will never fade in pop history! they journey was chaotic but great.

[rslphoenix]

here's the challenge popsters: sell your concert dates fastert than 38 seconds and i will bow down to you.

[ElectricalWater]

Spice Girls will always be the best!

Westlife did nice songs and Girls Aloud too,but Spice Girls were so much better!

[rslphoenix]

i mean madonna can't even sell 17 concert dates faster than 38 seconds. so who's lame? westlife, and loiuse don't u get it...the spice girls still has some pull over their fans and if given the right timing, project and mind set they can still join the pop race. those fans are not dump to buy their concert tickets for nothing. and yeah, stop covering songs ur so lame lame copycat band. five is better that you... i must say

[rslphoenix]

whether the spice girls will reunite someday or not, nothing can erase the fact that they changed pop music and influence a brand new way to express feminism. eat ur heart out westlife, ull never gonna overcome the spice records. can i sold 17 concert dates faster than 38 seconds? madonna can even do that... anyway, loiuse and weslife + girlsaloud esp. cole...get stick in UK chart 4ever haha!

[truenoDx]

Louis Walsh is shet

[rslphoenix]

some people don't really get...Spice girls made world music history...take it or leave it. now, Mr. Walsh wake up from ur dream that ur girlsaloud & westlife pop acts are not meant to be legend in 4 corners of d globe. mel c was right...if they could sell millions of records come back and talk to me. greedy, insecure, jealous, low-life old man. westlife was constantly snub in US and girlsaloud are not a s loud as u thought!

who ur calling talentless now? the SGreunion tour is a blast!

[YourOasis97]

i know right! and claiming none had a solo career afterwards!? who is he kidding? mel c has sold over 3 million and geri 2.5 million! while emma bunton's free me has sold close to 2 million! how's that for a solo career? plus mel c and geri have had #1s and melanie c is 2nd to lennon/mccartney when it comes to songwriting making it number 1 for 11 times!

[XxHemzyxX]

WESTLIFE RULE!!! lol. spice girls are crap. they're just a bunch of pathetic little girls. yeh, maybe westlife were not successful in america but why shud they be, it's not like they are from america. anyway, abs is fit and gawjuss. luv him, he's just sat there relaxed while mel c and louis argue. lol.

[doyoudomusic]

WESTLIFE ARE CRAP.

WALSH IS A PUFF.

[XxHemzyxX]

err. ur crap, nd ur a puff!!

[YourOasis97]

please, i never liked westlife. my faves were nsync and backstreet boys now those are real boybands. plus spice girls have sold close to 60 million and were a massive success worldwide. not so much westlife. the spice girls reunion was even met with great applause and success. not many can do that a 2nd time.

[rema2k7]

well westlife don't need to do it a second time coz they havn't broke up yet. i think it's better if you hold it together forever instead of coming on then going off then coming back again. it's pointless.

[ErniePi]

i love how the crowd cheers, even when the songs are being completely slated

[imedi]

spice girls conquer the world of music good god when did that happen lol

[dkbif]

Mel C is just jealous of Westlife.

Just because she can't hold a band together for over a decade!

[jonbob1]

y wud she be jealous of westlfe the spice girls are one of the most successful groups ever worldwide, while westlife are nobodies!

[dkbif]

Only The Beatles and Elvis Presley had more no. 1´s than Westlife, who have had 14 no. 1's! They also hold the record for most no. 1's in a row, worlwide, which I don't recall Spice Girls doing!!!!

So Westlife are more succesfukll than the Spice Girls. At least, all members of Westlife can sing!!!

[coolmencool]

Westlife are number one only in UK, they have never sold albums in America. The Spice Girls are a GLOBAL phenomenon, the first album sold 23 million, and have sold 53 millions record worldwide with only the first two albums. Westlife in ten years they have released nine albums and could not have overcome the sales of the spice girls.

[coolmencool]

Westlife are number one only in UK, they have never sold albums in America. The Spice Girls are a GLOBAL phenomenon, the first album sold 23 million, and have sold 53 millions record worldwide with only the first two albums.

[dkbif]

Who cares about America! Aren't the Spice Girls from the UK? The last time I checked they were. Westlife are NOT from the UK, but still holds a number of records here that the Spice Girls don't. And by the way, only two of the members can actually sing good.

But let us just agree to disagree.

[coolmencool]

But the Spice sold millions in the whole world, not only in his country UK, Westlife will be a legend when they conquer the whole world, which the Spice Girls already did.

[theBESTelvis]

westlife are wankers, end of.

[dkbif]

OK. But at least they can sing

[theBESTelvis]

2 of them can, the others are just fill in pretty boys.

then again..FAGGOT walsh likes his pretty boys doesnt he  haha

[dkbif]

Please don't ude that word about Louis. That is very discriminating. And who cares if he is gay? And how many of the Spice Girls can sing? One, at the most!

[theBESTelvis]

lol...

true !!!

[YourOasis97]

actually 4/5 spice girls can sing.

[smck2009]

I hope the one who cant in your opinion is Victoria because she is a million times shitter than Geri and thats fact

[YourOasis97]

actually, if you've seen the documentary Raw Spice or read Geri's autobio you'd know she's the one who had to work the hardest in both singing and dancing. she had no voice at all and it could get very raspy very qucikly if she used it too much. and if you listened to some of Victoria's solo songs, and the 3rd spice girls album, you'd disagree. unless of course you have listened to it and prefer Geri's voice over Victoria's then thats a matter of taste. all who worked with them knew Geri = worst

[rema2k7]

who can't?? well none of them but, who do you mean??

[rema2k7]

so true. spice girls smell. lolz

[XxHemzyxX]

no they're not!!! if they were wankers then they wouldn't hav lyk 14 no. 1s. and they wouldn't still be around after 10 years. and all of them can sing, not just 2.

[jesselovemimi]

I'm quite agree with you and I love them because they can sing and the songs they have covered were a great achievement

[rema2k7]

just lyk u!!! end of.

[sjfriend]

go mel , u defend against cover boys westlife

[pohdai]

what westlife is d biggest boyband in d world what happen to backsreetboys and nsync. backsreetboys sold 75m copies world wide. nsync sold 70m world wide.westlife sold 40m copies world wide.nsyc sold 1.2m first weekof sale while westlife sold 350thousand in first week aloneand luis walsh said westlife better than spice girls i dont think son spice girls out sold westlife in record selling but westlife out sold spice girls in number one hit.

[sjfriend]

westlife only outsold spice cos they bin goin longer than spice did. spice are the more popular, no doubt. and more worldwide popular.

[muchoo9]

your right man

[pohdai]

who is girls aloud they always talking guiness all time they never enter in d us all british act wants to be famus in us and over d world here in my country we dont know them

[pohdai]

luis walsh sut fuck up

[jamchip]

I like girls aloud and loved the spice girls when they were around. But Louis Walsh don't have talk some shit especially when he says westlife are better than spice girls. No one outside the uk and ireland know who westlife but yet spice girls hold the record for being the biggest girl group in the world ever

[Antidote001]

I'm sorry but Girls aloud only selling concerts in one or two arenas in Uk, 10 years later...Spice Girls selling out Arena's and Stadiums in US and Uk...Madison Square Gardens...etc...Louis you ass!

[MdivaC]

I don't want to go like: girls aloud who?, but really they haven't released anything in Latinamerica, and I imagine that the same happends in the states, nobody knows who they are because their music don't exist over here. I guess they're big in the UK and probably in Europe, but over here they don't exist. Don't have any idea about places like Australia, Southafrica or in hole Asia, but in American continent they haven't released anything. True is that SG have had all their singles at nº1 here

[greysanatomyfan25]

lmaooo. when ur records hit 37 million world wide come back and talk to me.

hahaha i lovee herrr!!<3

obviously my idol

[bluemallows17]

Girls Aloud sucks! they got talent but they dont have charisma! Ü Spice Girls forever!

[bluemallows17]

Honestly Girls Aloud do rili have good voices but...and again but! They're NOT as popular and successful as the Spice Girls. I don't even know Girls Aloud members. The Spice Girls earned they're mark as the Most Successfull Girl Group in the history of music! Ü And Mel C has all the rights to brush off Louis Walsh blah blah opinions! Westlife is great but they're not famous in the whole continent of America!

[megabrav3]

louis walsh? wot a loada crap! spice girls were original, were good singers and were great personalitys. Like Mel C says come back when u have 37 million album sales Walshy. u know fuk all!

[beckahmarie2]

He is a douche!!

Go Melanie!!

<3

[lissalls]

Girls Aloud who? lol

Go MeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeL..

spice the best ever

[SaSamanthar]

hahahahahaha go mel

[eastglory]

spice girls are just lucky to be the first girl band to not go with the flow kind of girl band..they change something and that was noticed by music lovers. If spice girls came out when there are so many girl band fighting for the chart, don't think they would be able to get the fame that they had. Spice girl's come back single was a total flop, thinking that it was for a charity, the only charity single that did not well in the chart. That only proves that spicegirls magic has long gone!!!!

[kashspice]

Headlines wasnt a flop it was a number 3 on all channels  go melanie

[jbomb060]

SG were the most successful out of Girls aloud and westlife. Never even heard of girls aloud until 2008 and this clip is from 2003 lol.

[Gaz205]

well ur a loser then? the spice girls wouldn't stand a chance these days jst look at headlines- wot a joke!

[jbomb060]

SG were the most successful out of Girls aloud and westlife. Never even heard of girls aloud until 2008 and this clip is from 2003 lol.

[sclubunitedrocked]

THE SPICE GIRLS ROCK!!!!

louis walsh SUCKS!!!!

[redgirl055]

who are girls aloud and westlife anywayz? COME ON PEOPLE! SPICE GIRLS WERE TRULLY GLOBAL!!

[Alexx011x]

I like Mel's boots :]

tht guy is so mean, the Spice Girls were SOO original and they deff. had personality

[Antidote001]

Louis Walsh is a right bitchy queen, Mel should have decked him!!

[MCNutters]

Go on Melanie! 2003, and ooh in 2008 Melanie is laughing on album number four.

[salenasbffe]

laughing? huh?

sorry i'm slow 2 catch on...

[xXxJadeLaurenxXx]

SPIC3 GIRLS AND GIRLS ALOUD.x.x

LOV3 TH3M BOTH .x.x // <3

[Charliefisher1987]

so do i

[Osani65]

mel c told it like it is. you go! she was totally right.

[megabronagh]

girls aloud andwestlife r both really gud but so r da spice girls

[lollipop123]

i've never even heard of westlife or girlsaloud...so clearly they were not as successful as the spice girls lol. Goes to prove you are only AWESOME if you make it in America...hence the spice girls are awesome. lol

[mmgwen]

melanie ruled the whole interview!!

she rocksssss

[supermanclone]

i love both the spice girls and girls aloud. the two bands are special in their own ways. so i do not think comparing them both is necessary at all.

[hattemerhooligan]

westlife is crap, so is girl's aloud. you can't compare girl's aloud to the spice girls. you can compare girls aloud to s club 7,and solid harmonie..but the spice girls stood out and proved it. that guy in the middle should shut up..he's pretty disrespectful to Melanie C....

[airheadxtreme44]

oh you can also come back and talk to mel c. when one of your girl aloud girls cowrites 11 number one singles k thanks!

[chisholmXlopezXecker]

amen!

[busy19]

the group has to get to nine number one's globally first, and then go from there lol.

[airheadxtreme44]

i think the guy is an idiot

westlife

and girlsaloud

could not make it in the us

so shut the fuck up asshole

[CraftyCroft]

oh but the way abs' talks is so damn annoying and sooooo put on!!!

[CraftyCroft]

LMAO!!! i remember watching this live! it was sooooooo brilliant

[busy19]

I hope you mean it was brillant watching Melanie put Louis in his place lol

[letjim]

who's Girls Aloud?

[sabbieelmo]

spice girls had global appeal. they're huge worldwide. took the world by storm. compared to the beatles. girls aloud? who? only in UK. can't even begin to compare. they just seem very generic. there are too many girls and they don't stand out. the spices were all unique. there's no comparison.

[thisismyusername05]

i have never heard of girls aloud..ever! were they ever big in the US?

[leduchiep]

Girls Aloud IS IN the Guiness book as the most successful girlband on UK Chart history!!! and where is Spice Girls?

[Totchi85]

Chart positions aren't saying anything about the popularity of a band. The Spice Girls weren't there long enough to have that many top ten singles... but I'm sure they would've had a similar number of hits.

The Spice Girls changed music history. Only because they were there, Girls Aloud could exist. So actually, Girls Aloud owe the Spice Girls A LOT.

[busy19]

They definitely owe Geri Halliwell that's for sure! I heard Girls Aloud say one time that it would be cool 2 do a duet with Spice, and if that ever happens I think I might actually have 2 puke or disown the Spices. GA went on the Jonathan Ross show once and talked a bit about the Spices and then they started talking about their own Guiness World Records. Spice Girls don't play that game and they never have, they've mentioned their success, but they've never gloated like GA have done.

[tyranusidious]

Haha, I love this. Mel handled herself brilliantly!! I love her comment - "when you rack up 37 million records worldwide come back and talk to me!"

[Charliefisher1987]

I love the Spices and the Aloud

[cinsoweiv]

"Spice Girls were original", nice comment Melanie

[danixxreloaded]

girls alous and westlife....

only in England, but in the whole world... they're NOTHING!!!!

[thisismyusername05]

totally agree! i have never heard of Girls Aloud or Westlife!

[pjpj0908]

the spice girls are the bigget Girl band ever in the whole world..Girls Aloud? oh cmon only in UK..they are not global brand..hehehe

[keyakikid]

Ladies and gentlemen, start your egos!!

[girlsaloud2110]

MEL C IS NOT A CUNT

[Cis4Chisholm]

wahahahahahahaha louise you are such an arse

[Heidinha]

Spice Girls Is the Better!!

[MCNutters]

Go on, Melanie! :D

[xxgeorgibunnyxx]

wOOOOOhoooo!!!!!!!Go mel C! Louis is talking shit, sayin the Spice Girls didn't have personality! Um hello!!!!!! That is ALL they had lol. Girls Aloud r just "O hello, Nice to meet u etc", fake fake fake! And at lest the Spice Girls didn't do covers. All Louis said was "This is a no.1 record"...hes a robot!

[Salguero83]

I Love Melanie C and i Love Christina Aguilera! And Nobody knows the name Girls Aloud,Only in the Uk! Everybody in the world knows The Spice Girls!

[Lboogs83]

louis walsh is a TOOL. He needs a smack in the face. A really really really hard smack in the face.

[rockerspice7]

who are those "Girls Aloud" anyway?

[u263b]

girl power, lmao. all you are just walking vaginas. you ain't shit.

[Rach4ever13]

that is officialy girl power, she licks ass. I just wish all 5 girls would get hold of him,lol.

[deb2uk]

wots happened to Cats hair lol

[BadBump]

I've been a Spice Girls fan since the beginning and I know that Girls Aloud will NEVER match them in record sales or worldwide impact, but--voice for voice--Girls Aloud are far better vocalists than the other Girls ever were. Melanie C, Mel B, and Emma could all sing, but Victoria and Geri--well, lets not go there. The poorest vocalists in Girls Aloud are Cheryl and Kimberley and they can sing circles around the other two. Anyway, I love both bands and they're both fantastic.

[poshhotel]

Girls Aloud who? If you're a nobody in North America, then you're nothing. Spice Girls were a WORLD WIDE phenomenon with 50 million+ albums sold. There is no fucking comparison.

[Rach4ever13]

I agree girls aloud are good but they will never ever be as good as the spice girls and as for louis saying girls aloud can sing and have personality and the spice girls dont is beyond a joke. Come on girls aloud are always critised because they can't sing live.

[Totchi85]

I think the major problem of Girls Aloud is, that they aren't as individual as the Spice Girls were. And I have the feeling that they aren't really honest. They try to cover up their bad sides. The Spice Girls also didn't give a damn about it and were always honest.

Girls Aloud are good but they're nothing special. And I don't like it that they do photoshoots half naked although they don't want to Oo Um... ever heard of "saying no"?

[chisholmXlopezXecker]

yeah...through melanie c here, the spice girls' honesty is visible

heart the chisholm

[aloud4ever1]

melanie made a very good point. ahah i mean i love girls aloud dearly..but they have yet to make it big worldwide like the Spice girls. <33

[Sija2004]

I can't stand Melanie C but she was the bollocks in this interview. She gave Louis what he deserves, what a cockhead he is!

[barneyboy2k]

Oh Louis, Mel just made you look like a fool. Retire like you shouldve loooong ago.

[joceyjoe]

Poor abs never gor a say lol

[SandyC21]

love melanie so much - this is one of the reasons why! brill 4 stckin up 2 louis - who obviously dnt know wot hes talkin about as much as he thinks considerin hes been sacked from x factor haha. agree 100% with melanie - as does nearly everyone whos posted a comment wich is gr8 :)

[muso4]

Spice Girls shit all over westlife as far originality and record sales go... every song they released was an original. THere is NO comparison. Spice Girls are definitely one of the biggest british bands in music history, everyone knows that! And they have had major solo success aswell, including multiple number ones and top ten singles.

[gjones1986]

rack up 37 million albums worldwide n come back! go mel. its now more like 50

[fightming]

Mel C is an idiot

[EmmaCharmed]

no shes not, shes cool (imo)

[YourOasis97]

actually she's being honest and factual. your the idiot.

[gingeragape]

thank you melanie.

for your great words!

[trickin22bully]

what does mel c say right before louis says 'no that was the spice girls'?

[braulio1670]

They (Westlife) could release any old tripe and it'll sell.

And NO that wasn't the Spice Girls, thank you very much.

[JonatanOnly]

I Like ABs

[playboibunny86]

Forgot ABS :P

[Kevsie]

Totally agreed with everything Melanie C said! Shes wicked and sooo right!

[TheSundayRain]

Melanie C spoke for most people at the time. I remember this is was classic TV.

[lizzieloveslouis]

louis was totally right!

[DirrtyHoney]

yay they love christina to:D

[truestepper]

I looooooove Melanie C!

[MC2K]

Melanie ruled this interview. Muwahah @ Louis. Tithead.

[rljl20]

I love Christina!

[DefinitelySupersonic]

Westlife is like the ONLY boyband in the world.

[charmedreturnz]

I posted this great interview last time lol