Added: 2 years ago
From: MyMaddenPad
Views: 52,873
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (270)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • HOW DA FUCK IS FITZGERALD BETTER DEN ANDRE JOHNSON!! BULL SHIT!!!

  • Hakeem Nicks was so underrated /:

  • Madden 2002 Menu was awesome!

  • HERES MY LIST....Wes welker is quick and elusive but not that tuff. It shoulb be 1. TERRELL OWENS 2. ANDRE JOHNSON 3. BRANDON MARSHALL 4. CALVIN JOHNSON 5. VINCENT JACKSON 6. LARRY FITZGERALD 7. T.J. HOUSHMANZEDAH 8. MARQUES COLESTON 9. MILES AUSTIN 10. SIDNEY RICE these are all big tuff recievers that cant be taken down 1 on 1 and hard to take down. Their size and quickness makes them tuff!
  • Roddy white on top of Marshall and Calvin thats BS

  • roddy white ahead of B Marsh WTF

  • Reggie Wayne is better than 95, he's top 3 in my list

  • I think Randy moss should be in number 1 but that just might be cause i am a pats fan but randy is good and you cant say that he isnt\

  • Yo, madden sucks

  • Seriously i expected desean jackson to be on there.. hes atleast top 10, he carries the team..

  • D Will, Steve Smith!!!!! Hell Yeah!!!! and I agree with others, how is Larry in front of Andre?

  • Id choose Andre Johnson as the best WR

  • no ochocino and no owens wow

  • @pintwinyrs yeah who ever made this is fucking dumb. TO and Ocho are better..

  • it really pisses me off to see that Terrel Owens is not on the Top Ten list....he is better than reggie wayne, brandon marshall, wes welker.....the other thing....what is Larry doing in front of Aundre Johnson????

    he is the 2nd best, but aundre johnson is defenatly number 1

  • the lions sux but calvin is still beast but if he was with the colts vikings or saints or cowboys he will be the best reciever in the leage detroit is messing up his career

  • madden 10 sucks chris johnson is only an 81 and on 09 wes welker is a 94

  • i do but still

  • dont wana sound like an idiot but how u update rosters

  • have to have xbox live

  • you have to have x box live, and when you do a quick match, it automatically updates the roster if its out of date, but if you don't have xbox live you can look up the roster updates on google and then you go to nfl rosters in the main menu on madden and do player management and when you choose a player you do edit player and go to skills and you can change them

  • thx

  • Where's Donnie Avery?

  • @TheMITB he isnt good bro

  • what about greg jennings

  • oh yeah the guy with 792 receiving yards has 99 overall even though andre johnson is faster stronger and has better hands then fitzy. FITZGERALD=OVERRATED!!!!

  • is that madden 10 cause it dont look like the gameplay on xbox 360

  • Anyway, if you check a players ratings on the spreadsheet-like screen, look at their special catch and route running. then click the rigt stick to bring up their card. Their ratings are reversed on the card. The spreadsheet is correct, as i compared some ratings, but talk about putting out a very unpolished game. Also no playbook create option? come on EA.This may be it for me. If 2K ever puts out a football game, I'm getting it. they are better in every other sport.especially basketball.

  • i do think tat randy moss is over rated because if u look if brady was never there moss wouldnt be as good

  • yeah, Deangelo and Jonathan Stewart are BEAST!!!

  • Tj houshmenzadaz hes goooood

  • wes welker is not that good he only as good as the wr around him and tom brady believe me if he go to a team and be there number 1 wr he would stink

  • Andre #1

  • why is steven jackson always so underrated

  • mine would go like this man .1 larry fitgerald .2 steve smith .3 randy moss .4 reggie wayne .5 andre johnson .6 anquan boldin .7 calvin johnson brandon marshall .9 roddy white .10 wes welker

  • you sir are an idiot ANDRE JOHNSON LED THE NFL LAST YEAR!!!!!!

  • they suck at rating this year

  • I think in my opinion, they over rated fitzgerald..

  • its not what the fans want i same on sunday once where a guy was hit and was falling to the ground and then was hit again. i tried that in madden10 guess what? my guy bounces off him BULL SHIT

  • calvin is top 3 for sure with andre and larry

  • wheres marcus colston hes a BEAST!!!

  • marcus colston bitches saints fo life

  • Wes Welker should NOT be a 93, hes good but not that good

  • what the hell are you talking about??

    wes welker is OWNAGE.

  • fuck those fus they got this all wrong michelle crabtree hes the shit hes a fucken 100

  • his first game is goin to be in week 7

  • santana moss man

  • white rapes calvin benhgn1..know ur facts

  • Hahaha, Wes Welker is ranked HIGHER than Brandon Marshall. hahaha, are you serious? They aren't even the same species.

  • I know they aren't the same species ...one beats his wife ...the other gets 100 yards in a game

  • Calvin Johnson at 92 as the tenth best WR!?

    hes gotta at least be in the top 5!

  • @FieldingYost Brandon Marshall deserves a better rating than 92. I bet he is at least 97 in madden 11.

  • How is Calvin Johnson t-9th! He's at least better than white and welker!

  • I KNOW RIGHT dude Moss shouldn't be 4th i was thinking 2nd 3rd MAYBE.

  • wtf moss dropped from 99 to 96!

  • jonny lee higgins should be faster then 93 speed. And DRC is faster then 96, he should be 98.

  • they should make it so the ratings update throughtout the season and stuff

  • yeah if you listened he just talked about that for 5 minutes.

  • they do

  • i want 2k back fuck madden

  • maclin is not faster than d jac

  • In madden 07 tony romo was a 64 and in 08 he went up to like an 88

  • tj houshmanzadeh? i agree

  • where is T.O at??? these rating are trash madden has been going down since madden 05

  • yea wit the new nfl 2k11 coming out madden got competition frm backbreaker and nfl 2k11......

  • when wil it come out>?

  • idk yet yet they jus released that will continue the nfl 2k series and are working on it...but if you have the last nfl 2k game for ps2 you can play live 2009 roster updates on it

  • i thought it was 2k12

  • Madden 10 ratings on PS2 is a JOKE!!! Randy Moss speed is 89 but Brian Urlacher speed is 90! Calvin Johnson speed is 87, Hines Ward speed is 93, Marcus Trufant speed is freaking 88! How about the throw accuracy ratings? A lot of QBs have accuracy ratings in the 70s and 60s. How about all the defensive lineman and linebackers having break tackle ratings in the 70s and 80s. Everyone slowed down to fake speeds. I think the people who made these ratings were on crack or something.

  • Yea but for some reason the ps2 maddens have more features than the ps3 or 360

  • your right about that

  • yea i had madden 09 for ps2 and a whole bunch of features but then i got a ps3 and bought madden 10 and had less features

  • Where's T.J. Houshmandzadeh? He's still been puttin up pro bowl type numbers and he's not even a 92?

  • well it might be because he's not as fast as the other players but he has good hand

  • 1. moss should be about 98

    2. where in the blue hell is T.O

  • haha they say they pride themselves on being the most authentic football game. I'd hope so since ya know, they shafted all other developers out of the NFL license.

  • Where is my boy, Y. Figurs?!?!

    just kidding

  • welker is not top ten material. so many other guys are better. braylon edwards, greg jennings, TO, hines ward..................

  • Comment removed

  • i dissagree ct6cavs, sure he isn't quite as athletic as many other WRs but wes is one of the hardest guys to cover in the league and he never drops a ball

  • I agree with you with everyone u said, except braylon. Braylon's my favorite player but right now hes not doing anything, its very sad

  • Wes Welker better better then Calvin Johnson? What a joke.

  • @IcyVegeta kiss my black ass calvin s faster biggeer and a better route runner

  • when i play this vid it keeps stopping on wes welker in mid air but the time keeps going for the rest of the vid. is this happening to everyone?????

  • yeah

  • hapened to em 2

  • yeah. its happening to me.

  • yea even the madden videos r messed up

  • authentic? the dolphins didn't have Cameron Wake the star of the CFL, unless they updated recently, and Ronnie Brown isn't a top 10 RB r u serious?

  • well last year, ronnie brown was in the top 5 stat wise

  • welker isnt 93...bout 90

  • calvin john is immerging...

    but wes welker is sick are u serious...

    im sure wes welker has runs routes better, catches better in traffic and he has like one of the best hands in the league... and agility quickness awareness rating...

    just cuz u have 97 speed and 07 jumping doesnt put u as a top reciever...

    calvin johnsons routes arent perfect and his hands arent either

  • WTF our you kidding me calvin johnson is an elite reciver ..calvin catches every fucking thing..calvin is a Beast ..calvin was tied last year with the most TDs with Larry fitzgarled your a Dumbass...Bicth ... TOP recivers ( NOT in Order) Andre johnson Randy Moss Calvin johnson Steve smith Larry fitzgarled Brandon Marshall roddy white Anquan boldin greg jennings T.O Ochocinco
  • I agree completley with this comment

  • Mr36OBeasT - Great list!!!

    Imagine how sick Calivn Johnson would have been on a team like the Cardinals, Saints, or Broncos!!!

    If he played for a diffrent team than the Lions, I could see him posting 2,000 reception yards in a season. He's a sud with a horrible team, with a great Oline and QB he could be the BEST!!!

  • I totally agree CJ is a beast and he could be the best reciever with a good team or at least a decent one.

  • Wes Welker is not better then Calvin Johnson but the Patroits should have a cold passing team on madden

  • colston

  • Wow, who do i think is better Wes Welker or Calvin Johnson? no brainer CJ. How could he be lower than welker ratings arent that good.

  • dude welkers 93 hes 92 not a big difference if it was 96 and 90 then u can say tht but no it wouldnt make a difference

  • Comment removed

  • where is colston

  • Calvin Johnson is the third best reciever in the NFL and he only got a rating of 92 that's just retarded

  • You do not know the NFL at all that is quite clear CJ is the third best reciever and everyone knows that except you dumb ass the other two in front of him would be Larry Fitzgerald and Andre Johnson

  • wow he has a Devin Hester jersey on. watch out, i bet Hester is raw on the game

  • T.O isnt on top ten huh? i because of his drops? last season he wasnt even n da top five n drops. Espn always exaggerattes everything Wow. Ten shpould be overall 93 while b marshall 94 n Calvin j 95

  • wes welker above brandon marshall u guys make great games but dont know about real football. wes welker has a very limited game that consist of NEVER being doubled and never beating anyone for a deep pass. Brandon marshall has to face doubles every week.

  • arizona's passing attack...

  • anyone heard of marvin harrison hes awesome!

  • roddy white a 94? r u kidding me?......he's good, but he is not better than marshall and calvin johnson

  • Welker is only praised because

    1: He plays for Bill Belicheat

    2. He has a lot of receptions behind the line.

  • Wow they are a bunch of retards saying that oh but chad pennington can't throw a deep ball so we gave him a shitty rating oh come on!!! it's not all about throwing it deep retards!!! he's still a good QB being accurate and knowing where and when to get rid of the ball!!! Fucking retards a six year old could do a better job!

  • They just base the Stats on what his year is projected to look like, Or what it was last year. And also how his team is, Cause you need high overall players to match the right overall of any intended team.

  • my top ten 1. Larry Fitz-99 2. Andre Johnson-98 3. Steve Smth-96 4. Randy Moss-95 5. Anquan Boldin-95 6. Greg Jennings-94 7. reggie wayne-93 8. T.O.-92 9. Brandon Marshall-92 10. Calvin J.-92. Wtf is wes welker on this list? he is overrated and is only good cause moss is triple teamed...Roddy white? waht a joke..
  • wtf wes welker rated higher than greg jennings and T.O.? please madden u are really gettin crazy now...

  • hes had the most receptions out of any wr for 2 years

  • If you dont like it get a job at Ea so you can help make the next MADDEN.

  • shut up...

  • Ummm where is TO???

  • Isnt evry one forgetting about Bernard Berrian.

  • Fitz, is better then moss. and im a NE fan. Randy Moss is still a great reciever and i think he should be rated higher than steve smith and andre johnson, but Larry Fitz deserves to be # 1

  • i think they are about even now that randy moss has primed... but you must be young because if you saw randy moss's rookie season u would disagree

  • I wonder where greg jennings and donald driver are?....i know their stats arent the best but they're still pretty good.

  • They slowed down Madden 10, and I really like it better. O fcourse, Im baseing my comment on the demo, but hopefully other people online wont be able to do the same quick slant route anymore.

  • madden is a product of a bunch of nerds who've never played football and they try and make a game.. its extremely unrealistic no matter how many new apps they add to it. at the end of the day its a glorified arcade game

  • I ASSUME TO COMES AFTER CALVIN...

  • moss is definitely the best on that list. how can you put steve smith andre johnson and larry fitzgerald on there? andre johnson has a shot but larry fitzgerald had one good year and steve smith isn't that great anymore. what the he''s wrong with you EA??!?!

  • Just because you havn't seen Larry play doesn't make him bad. I'm assuming you live on the East Coast?

  • lol fitz has had a great career so far, he has had a all but 2 years over 1000 yds i believe. and always gets in the endzone. only difference now is that the cards started playin on prime time tv, playoffs and SB. so now more people know about him. he was always underrated. and hey, fitz came to play in post season, moss has yet to do that, fitz is also a more complete reciver, toughness, YAC, better routes and runs through the middle.

  • i like the look of the stat colmn thing

  • Larry Fitzgerald is da best damn wr in da league rite now Randy Moss isnt dat effective last yr so yup larry da best nd Chevy u a dumbass Wes Welker is suppose 2 b up their he betta den yo ass lol but yea Fizzy da best BIOTCH

  • madden demo is pretty tight no commentary though it seems its a little hard 2 throw but ill get use to it

  • swagbucks(dot)com/refer/KBank2­001

    Get ____________ and more for free with Swagbucks, a search engine that rewards you just for searching words & phrases as you normally would. Get paid for something you already do with Swagbucks.

  • steve smith is as good as andre johnson and aquan boldin is as good as reggie wayne! and hines ward should be in the top 10! (maybe 92 points or better)

  • Andre Johnson son!!!

  • Chad is old but T.J. should have been up there. And screw Roddy White. I bet half of the world doesn't know who he is.

  • play for falcons?

  • wes welker shouldnt b n da top 10 he had 1 good season.

  • he has had several good seasons and he deserves to be on da list!

  • wheres hines ward and santonio holmes??????

  • santonio holmes suck he made 1 lucky ass catch and u think hes the shit

  • id put him in like top 15/16

  • im not a steelers fan as i think u can tell by my name.... but no way in HELL was that a "lucky" catch. You cannot make that catch with luck...

  • that madden 09 because they dont have the towels and DeAngelo Williams wears blue gloves

  • whats hines wards rating?

  • oh he is a 0 rating

  • 1. randy moss 2 larry fitzgerald 3. a. johnson 4. steve smith 5.anquan boldin 6 reggie wayne 7.santana moss 8. terrel owens 9. wes welker 10.ted ginn 11.seshaun jackson 12.joey galloway 13 t. holt 14. tony gonzalez (te) 15. antonio gates (te)
  • maybe TJ Houshmanzadeh instead of DeSean Jackson?

  • lol started gatting lazy near the end

  • Larry Fitz is way better than Moss

  • untill he breaks the records Moss has broken! Moss is the best!!

  • moss is overrated. boldin, fitzgerald, and johnson are the truth..

  • MOSS IS OVERRATED??????????? he gets no where near the publicity or respect as other wide outs

  • no chad ocho cinco no tj houshmanzadeh

    wat da hell!

  • SeShaun Jackson huh?

  • santanio holmes made a big catch in the superbowl,, that doesnt make him the best receiver in the game,, hell u should praise hines ward if any steeler, he's the one who knocks out linebackers

  • Lol, and he's always smiling.

  • no hines ward cheap shots defensive backs

  • steve smith puts tha sick in sickness,, even though i hate to omit it,, fitzgerald is probably the receiver on the game,, i just imagine if smith was 6'1

  • what rating is Tom Brady going to have

  • its 98

  • WHAT where is greg jennings he is a beast. and is the most underated reciver in the NFL

  • 1. Larry Fitzgerald

    2.Randy Moss

    3.Andre Johnson

    4.Steve Smith

    5.Reggie Wayne or Anquan Boldin

  • no santonio holmes? wtf!

  • listen 2 me SANTONIO HOLMES SUCK!!!!

  • COLTS ROCKS ¡¡¡¡¡

  • no T.O. is ridiculous

    Wes Welker is a lil punk and 85 at best

    Greg Jennings is probably a 90 or something so i have no problem with it

    Vincent Jackson??? Are you kidding me??? thats just dumb

    Larry Fitzgerald should be the best player in the entire game

    he's a 99 and EVERYBODY else is 98 or lower

    including Brady and Manning, Peterson and Westbrook, Reed and Polomalu

    Larry Fitz is the best we've ever seen, ONLY longevity and slow start will keep him outta record books

  • shutup santonio is the best

  • wow dude your dumb

  • they messed up the players speed ratings on dis years game big time

  • no T.O??? WTF at least a 95 for T.O he made a lot of badass catches!!

  • yeah, he made badass catches when one actually stayed in his hands.

  • jennings should have a 96...

  • no terrrel owens wtf

  • wheres vincent Jackson?

  • wes welker should be at the bottom of the list the only reason why he has such good seasons is because he's constantly single covered because of randy moss, and if you rate on flexibility at the WR spot wes welker cant go up and get the ball like calvin johnson can and defintly not brandon marshall

  • that might be true but welker is friggin strong! I mean ive seen him drag guys with him for ten yards or even more. most little wide receivers like him just get hit and go down.

  • no greg jennings??? wtf

  • chad johnson is up there as one of the best recievers just had a bad year......cant wait to get this shit

  • I don't make excuses. If you lined my mama up out there, I'd have to catch it over her, too. -Steve Smith "That guy Steve Smith, he's a nightmare, man," Gruden said. "He's like Freddy Krueger to me. He scares the hell out of me.