Added: 1 year ago
From: RockkkV2
Views: 614,139
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,444)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hopefully we are moving into a new world community of HUMANITY!

  • =D

  • Love love this one.

  • AMAZING GUITAR IN THIS SONG

  • Maybe Neil did write this about getting beaten up in a bar. A little bit of it might of been about the generations of terrible racism and racial oppression that occured in the South, that whole KKK/ slavery thing too. Idk.

  • @joverboss in the kkk's heyday(the 1920's) most of there members came from the Midwest (Indiana having the most members) not the south. You can say what ever you want about slavery in the south but racism was nation wide.

  • @Kyussfan96 Are you trying to say they had slaves in the northern states too? Now thats food for thought! It was a worldwide accepted practice at the time.

  • i think i just found another musical hero!

  • Comment removed

  • I think it's great that Neil Young actually stood up and said how horrible racism is. because it is horrible. his vocals in this song is so dramatic that is sounds creepy and eary when he shouts "I saw cotton and black, tall white mansions and little shacks" and although Lynyrd Skynyrd said they like Neil Young's music a lot, I think it's very disrespectful that they mocked him and this song in "Sweet Home Alabama"

  • @OddManSam it was mainly the fact that he grouped racism as a "southern man". When racism is everywhere and there were many southern men that weren't racist, it was embarrassing to intelligent open minded people from the south

    Skynyrd and Young were both LEGENDS

  • WOW!

  • song totally rules

  • Neil Young > Lynyrd Skynyrd

  • The SOUTH SUCKS ASS!! Heh. Just kidding. See how easy it is to get stupid people all riled up?

  • 73 people lost their slaves

  • War was over a while back...ya'll come out of the hills and chill...lol!

  • @PhazzerPhire i really like this guys music, but this is kind of like punching someone in the stomach whose stomach is cast iron. Alabama. Probably the last state with clean water and smogless air.

  • @PhazzerPhire A lot of wars were over awhile back,,,sadly, we start others to take their place.

  • Neil Young is from Canada

    think about it...

  • Although Neil Young may have good musical talent, I think we can all agree that this was a total douche move on his part

  • Southern Man, everything is your fault. I came to a bar with my hip, new age thoughts and got beaten up. It wasn't at all cool with me. I truly, truly hate the south and you should as well. Thanks for listening. Neil Young, a true contemperary.

  • @somethinillremember9 lol new age thoughts are anything but "hip". and why would you go to a bar and spout out random new age crap?

  • @SPOREthomas

    That's my point, Neil Young went to a bar in the 70's in the deep south, started talking about Young's "liberal agenda" (what rednecks heard: "I'm a queer, you should be one too, you're ignorant if you don't accept the transcendent Neil Young" says Neil Young.), then (naturally) got his ass beat. So what does he do? He writes a song about how ignorant everyone in the south is.

  • @somethinillremember9 That is the most small-minded and stupid thing i have ever heard. This is what makes me think u are an ignorant redneck. You are saying that it wasnt because all of the horrible lynching and racism that was in the south. it was because he was being "queer" Ik this is hard for u to understand, but sometimes people have different ideas from you. And the "liberal ideas" he was preaching are not hate people because of the color of the color of their skin, and be nice to people.

  • we are all American, now everyone shut the fuck up and listen to the music.

  • FUCK Skynard!!

  • @DustinTheWind2121 You're a complete moron. Good luck with that.

  • Neil's guitar! Genius!

  • just wonderful! 

  • Neil Young has no idea of most of the south... Who is he to judge?

  • @imcoleyo Oh i dont know maby listen to the lyrics they are true... I saw cotton and I saw black Tall white mansions and little shacks. Southern man when will you pay them back? I heard screamin' and bullwhips cracking How long? How long? So true. and you have to remember the time that this was written.
  • @imcoleyo Southern man don't need you anyhow!

  • I think the KKK started to be commandeered by people that wanted to co-opt the hatred and eventually vanquish it (hint - a fellow by the name of Green)

    The cross burning is a certain symbol that no one gets crucified.

  • @kroovyandcal Samuel Green was his name. He deferred the hero award to some actor playing Superman on TV

  • @kroovyandcal Almost embarrassed to say this but i have lived and my mom's whole family live in Pulaski, Tn. (home of the klan) the town really is against them now, but stories from grandparents and such say that they burned crosses in mainly alcoholics and wifebeaters yards back in the 30's and so.. more white's than blacks actually.. they started as like a vigilanty group.. Of course as time went on they became the disgusting group they are today

  • Civil War actually had very little to do with with slavery, It was more taxes and the Union was not letting the South have much say in anything. The Union destroyed, looted, and burned many Southern Towns to ruins.. I was born and lived a great portion of my life in Toledo Ohio so it's not like I am some biased southernor, it's just the Union made text books and stories like they were heroes much like claiming the wars today arent about oil :/.. Regardless, Neil Young and Skynyrd are LEGENDS

  • Long live Dixie

  • Wow, I just enjoy the song..

  • TOO many of u know nothing of what ur talking about...HERE IS TRUTH: from the info cover of the Second Helping Lynyrd Skynrd album) who by the way, Even their name for the band started as a mock tribute to their tyrannical High School gym Coach, Leonard Skinner.. "Sweet Home Alabama" started as a joke..Gary was tuning up & started strumming 3 chords, as King listened He came up with a counter to Gary's Riff ..to which he said it "just hit him like a ton of bricks" Ed came up w/ little loops

  • @cb61998a that completed the basic idea & Allen put something else on that then Ronnie started singing & w/in 30 minutes "Sweet Home Alabama" was born.. That which started as a tribute to their days recording in Muscle Shoals,(AL) turned into a mock political statement of populist regional pride,,they laughed, said,.ain't that funny? Never the less, Van Zant sounded like he was trying 2 pick a fight w/ ALL of North America, defending Wallace & boldly answering Canadian-born Rocker Neil Young..

  • @cb61998a and his (Neil's) double barreled blast at the Old racist South in his song, "Southern Man"& "Alabama","I thought Neil was shooting all the ducks to kill 1 or 2", Van Zant would later admit..Van Zant later chuckled of "Alabama", "it hit the top 10 & we've been paying for ever since".Van Zant even wore a Neil Young T-Shir on the Cover of Street Survivors album, it was all in fun, the mocking Neil Young & Young even said once, he was PROUD to be the subject of Skynyrd's Southern anthem.

  • Southern Man was a criticism of a particular group of Southerners (KKK types) and was never meant as a condemnation of Southerners in general. Still, it's a great song musically and lyrically has an important message.

  • That smell sounds like a burning plane crash. That was Gods doing

  • I grew up with this music and I still think it's better than anything new. Amazing! His guitar playing is unreal.

    

  • @jlanza227559 I am huge fan but on the guitar thing its all kewl. 

  • fu*k obama

  • more than certainly my favourite musician ever.

  • iste edo meta to tragudi tu rapsodu?

  • This band knew what was going on and let the whole world know about it !

  • Ok, the point is that prejudice is terrible, satanic and evil. NOW SHUT UP AND LISTEN TO THE F****N MUSIC!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @XTVking333

    FUCKING EH! Thank God someone said it!

  • I thinks when Neil says he's gonna cut him down Skynyrd say we don't need him around anyhow. And ol Neil put her down because he paints in Alabama a picture that decries how the locals: Skynyrd feel about their state.... Nonetheless Neils lyrics were first and Skynyrd seem to have made a lyrical slight or mention at/of Neil about these lyrics. Both Alabama and Southern Man are songs from the 1970s and Skynyrd's Sweet Home came out that same decade. Both Artists (Young,Van Zant) wrote good music.

  • I'm a Southern Man, but I had the good sense to escape. I moved to the West Coast, where normal people are the majority.

  • @lancetop you're a fuckin traitor and don't deserve your heritage

  • @shofneb1 my Southern "heritage" happens to be slavery, Jim Crow, extreme homophobia, religious fanaticism, and now anti Latin sentiments....

    You think that's something to be proud of? I wish I would have left the South when I graduated from high school in N.C. in 1973.

  • @lancetop Thank you for your honesty.It's the only way things change

  • @lancetop I am from the South & still LIVE in the South..Alabama to be exact..I am proud of WHERE I AM FROM..I am proud of my "heritage"..I am proud of my family LINE that I came from..HOWEVER, that does not mean..I agree with things that happened in the past! I DON'T keep a frigging stash of crosses on hand in the "barn"..in my "out buildings" OR in my car/any other place! The only PLACE I HAVE A CROSS IS AROUND MY NECK ON A NECKLACE! Stupidity, there STILL IS NO CURE FOR IT..YET!!

  • @cb61998a

    I'm originally from California mountains and have been in Texas for 7 years . I have talked to people and visited many areas in our country . The people from the South are among the best . My wife left her purse at a gas station in Alabama and 3 days later someone mailed it to our house . I constantly hear douche bags bashing the South . They probably know very little about it .

  • @jasavak wow, finally someone that has a logical mind on youtube =P

  • @jasavak I don't know if it helps that when yankees have it in their head that southern men and women are racist, occasionally there will be a dick head that proves their point in all the wrong ways, I grew up in southern Maryland and get called "racist" for just having a southern accent at times because of that one dick head that makes us all look bad, but I understand your point the south has some very nice generous people in it just like the north does it all depends where you are.

  • @HOAX900  Southern Maryland? Are you serious? lol

  • @jethrodassam it's not far from virginia, that's telling you something, to top it off anything below the mason dixon is geographically the american south.

  • @HOAX900 No shit Sherlock. lol Virginia is Obviously in the south. Not far from it means nothing. You're a northerner. Deal with it. lol

  • @jethrodassam a northerner would be pennsylvania, there were tons of confederate supporters in southern MD, what's that telling you?

  • @HOAX900 Maryland is a northern state. I'm sorry, but you can't change that. You're so stubborn that you won't even accept facts.

  • @jethrodassam look up what the true definition of a southern state is, and while you are at it search up what the mason-dixon line is, anything below the mason dixon is the south.

  • @HOAX900 Wow! You don't know where the mason-dixon line is.

  • @jethrodassam Even if you consider MD a 'northern state' (whatever that means anyway), I know exactly what he is talking about. Southern MD (St. Marys/Calvert Co.) Is different than any other area in the region. Most locals speak in heavy southern dialects and the area is surrounded by farmland and countryside. Hardcore rednecks. You should visit, might learn a thing or two.

  • @JLE102191 I should visit hickland? I'm a world traveler. What a ridiculous waste of time that would be. lol

  • @jethrodassam

    So you do understand this was written at a time when southerners hated hippies and neil young had pranced into a southern bar going "I'm the symbol of new-age thought and an end to you rednecks reigning over people." Then, he got beaten up. So HE WROTE A SONG ABOUT IT.

  • @somethinillremember9 lol southerners hated hippes, ever heard of the grateful dead? MTB?

  • @quertyb0y5

    HERPIDEE DERPIDEE DERP I WAS BORN AND RAISED IN ALABAMA, EVER HEARD OF WHAT ALL MY PARENTS AND THEIR FRIENDS SAY ABOUT HIPPIES. WE AREN'T IGNORANT REDNECKS LIKE YOU SO CALLED SOPHISTICATES SAY AND I'M GOING TO LAUGH WHEN YOU PEOPLE (YANKEES AREN'T REALLY PEOPLE THOUGH, A BUNCH OF LOUSY ENGLISH OPPRESSING THE SCOTCH-IRISH RACE LIKE BACK IN THE OLD COUNTRY) AND YOUR GLOBALIST AGENDA FAILS AND THE SOUTH (WHICH MAKES UP MORE THAN 70% OF THE U.S. ARMY) SAYS FUCK YOU AND BACKS OUT OF

  • @somethinillremember9

    YOUR FALSE ZIONIST OPPRESSION OF ISRAEL AND THE ARAB NATIONS AND HOW YOU STIR UP WAR BETWEEN THEM. THEN YOU CRY "WE FUCKED UP" AND IT'S TOO LATE. INTERNET TOUGH GUY UP IN THIS BITCH.

  • @somethinillremember9 generally zionists, or a form of judiasm, doesnt hate isreal, smart stuff. internet common sense in this bitch.

  • @somethinillremember9 uhh where i live in NY im surrounded by trees there isnt a skyscraper for 150 miles my father is in the military i fish and hunt and there isnt much difference between u and me unless u count geography and food

  • @somethinillremember9 Death to the Confederacy. Death to Traitors that fly the Traitor Flag. God Bless John Brown.

  • @jnlabrk6 Flying the Confederate Flag doesn't mean you do not love America or that your a traitor. People of Mexican descent still fly the tri-colored flag, it's just being proud of where you come from, God Bless Dixie God Bless America and God Bless Neil Young

  • @jnlabrk6 power to the rebel flag weeeoooooo!!!!!!!!

  • @jnlabrk6 you are ignorant along with everyone else that agrees with you...history lesson needed very much

  • @jnlabrk6 You want death. Your an idiot!!!

  • @quertyb0y5

    CCR Was founded by gents from California, thank you very much. Would you call a Californian Southern?

  • @somethinillremember9 no, because by southern he means stupid and small minded, which califoria (for the most part) isnt, where as alabama and missisippie are.

  • @lletinsk you would look more intelligent if you could spell a state right, Mississippi wow... And no matter where you go in the world there will be smart people and small minded people, at the time he was writing this the south needed to get their act together.. But by southern he definitely didnt mean stupid and small minded

  • @thinkformyself100 sure, criticise my ninja spelling. and i didnt say that by southern he meaned small minded and stupid, i was talking about the idiot somethinillremember9

  • @jethrodassam yeah didn't think so

  • @JLE102191 I've driven through Maryland several times. What's the point of this?

  • @jethrodassam thankfully maryland is not the south

  • @HOAX900 technicality YANKEE!!

  • @HOAX900 i agree, but this was written at a time when the civil rights movement was ending, and there was so much violence, so i think he was critising that. it is not really talking about now.

  • @jasavak this song is not meant for this time. he is talking about the violence in the south at the time of the civil rights movement.

  • @shofneb1 Yes, recognizing that there might be something wrong with the common perception of an area and removing yourself from that makes you a traitor. I suppose you would say the same to North Korean emigrants, no?

  • @shofneb1 stfu...ur the southern man this song refers to

  • a southern man dont need a canadian around any how

  • Why are there so many boobs in the recomended videos?... not complaining

  • I think musicians can have differences of opinions about politics and still respect each others art.

  • Lynyrd Skynyrd are a bunch of conservative rednecks from Jacksonville, Florida. Neil Young is a liberal hippie from Canada. They are as different as the KKK and the NAACP.

  • @sahkrov You are absolutely wrong.

  • @Slatrelle If I’m so wrong then why was Lynyrd Skynyrd performimg at a Republicans party in 2000 and 2004 during the Republicans Convention and why did Neil Young release a cd called “Living With War?” On his cd he had a song called “Lets Impeach the President” referring to George Bush. Can you explain that?

  • @sahkrov Maybe skynard are conservative hippies and young is a liberal redneck. As far as I know, they both wrote songs for each other. Also, sometimes you have to advertise your shit. 2004 was a perfect time to gain attention on either side of the war. There not that different. They are both successful musicians from the same time period and I bet they both appreciate each others shit.

  • @Slatrelle I'm african american and I relate more with Neil Young than Lynyrd Skynyrd. I've been through Alabama and ain't nothin "Sweet Home" about it. It's Sweet Hell Alabama for me! Neil Young was siding with African Americans when he wrote "Southern Man." Lynyrd Skynyrd salutes the Confederate Flag at their concerts and Neil Young doesn't. Johnny Van Zant once said "Fuck Neil Young!" at a concert while singing "Sweet Home Alabama." Why would he say that?

  • @sahkrov VAN ZANT actually spoke it best when he said..."we're not into politics, we don't have no education,& Wallace don't know nothing about rock 'n' roll." As quoted by Ron O'Brien, in 1997 (on their Second Helping release album info cover)..this was in regards to "Sweet Home Alabama" being nominated as the Official State (AL) song, which Wallace struck down the idea after learning..following the line.."In Birmingham they love the Governor, Skynyrd sang the words, "Boo, boo, boo."

  • @cb61998a What LS says and what they do are two different things. They say Boo, boo, boo to Wallace, then they turn around and salute and wave a Confederate (White Supremist)flag at their concerts. Unlike LS I give a damn about politics and education. As an African American I'm offended by and hate everything about the Confederate flag and what it stands for. I respect the Star Spangled Banner (the real American flag).

  • @sahkrov wow, retarted to the max. the reason that the south left the union was because of the very heavy and unfair taxes and tariffs the north was making. and another thing, african americans freedom was a by-product of the civil war, and was not a direct goal of the war. and idk why u take such offence to the confederate flag. i live in NY, and have a beachtowl with the flag on it, i also have black and mexican friends, and they dont give a fuck and see it as a joke.

  • @quertyb0y5 dumbshit the south also left the union because Abraham Lincoln was not going to let slavery expand to states it was not already in and eventually he issued the Emancipation Proclamation which banned slavery every. Think before you type

  • @sahkrov There are actually African Americans in my neighborhood bearing the Confederate flag, it all depends on how it's being used. Nothing is wrong with being proud of where you came from. Many African Americans have items that have had the African continent on it and I do not view this as racist

  • @sahkrov Todays LS had nothing to do with SWEET HOME ALABAMA, it was the Great Ronnie Van Zant and original LYNYRD SKYNRD of the 70s that wrote the song. And as we all know that band died with Ronnie on Oct 20th 1977 when plane crashed. I know he wasnt at 2000 convention this skynyrd band of today might have been but not original.

  • @sahkrov Haha you know so little :D

  • If I had a radio station I think this might be the first song I'd play

  • Still just as damn good:)

  • Feeling Southern today

  • NOTICE in 1971, the lack of rude people snapping snaps with their ultra cool cellphones and otherwise disturbing a great live show! Sad that in today's world, one cannot go to a concert, even a small initmate show in a coffee house, without half the audience snapping photos from their cellphones all through the song, with the light from the screens disturbing the show and turning it into a techno circus. Sigh. 2012 is all wrong. 1971 had it all right, yes or no?

  • 70+ people have Arthritis so bad from picking the six string they couldn't quiet manage to click "Like"...

  • Lynyrd Skynyrd can suck it. this has so much soul to it

  • @mrneontrafficlights why all the hate they are both very good singers and neither deserves to "suck it"

  • @mrneontrafficlights We stopped burning crosses a long time ago, that's why we have Obama

  • @mrneontrafficlights skynyrd were racist that the bottom line

  • @06cc14701 the ballad of Curtis Lowe is praising a black man. Black people were featured on their album cover before

  • Skynyrd are from Florida, what the fuck is that about..

  • @shittyfagg florida is the south

  • @knowtwodrugs i just meant, they're not from alabama. But oh well. No biggie.

  • @shittyfagg Florida was and still is one of the most conservative southern states in the US. Much of the "old south: mentality is still there

  • @bruce1chubb

    unless you are anywhere near the coast. in which case, there is zero "southern culture".

  • @shittyfagg obviously you haven't been to jacksonville. lol

  • :)

  • Neil Young. Better than anything, anybodys, got to say on youtube.

  • Reading these commends i heard screaming and bullwhips cracking Oo

  • southern man and sweet home alabama are both incredible songs. neiil young was a lynyrd skynyrd fan and skynyrd were fans of his. they both did covers of each others aforementioned songs in concert on more than one occasion. there is no feud and there never was a feud.

  • @The72koenig How do you know there was or wasn't, a feud?

  • @trampredboy6544 Because it was well documented in Neil Young's autobiography. Read about it. Lots of people from the south don't like NY because they think he was making "fun" of the southern man which was not the case at all. They were fans of each other.

  • @The72koenig There was a feud, but it was short-lived.

  • @The72koenig I wasnt a fued Neil was just saying in the song "We don't need no southern man" and lynyrd Skynyrd heard it and put it in their song " Sweet home alabama" saying " Neil young will think bout us a southern man do need you either" .. they could have been fans ive never seen a REALLY Neil Young version of Sweet home Alabama and no song by neil covered by Lynyrd.

  • @TriH4rdGaming i love southern/northern/eastern/west­ern man/woman/child and i love you too.

  • Comment removed

  • @The72koenig not a feued but there were some instances where you know skynard said "a southern man dont need him around anyhow" which is not really fighting words by any means but i cant help feeling it would be an awekward thanksgiving. Nothing too major though ur right. Neil is too peaceful for that anyways

  • @The72koenig thx for clearin that up for everyone who didnt know this.

  • @Man0nTheM00n44 no worries, cheers.

  • i dont give a shit what anybody thinks, this song is so far superior to sweet home Alabama as to completely negate anything skynyrd has to say

  • neil young is from canada

  • BTW... Sweet Home Alabama, folks!!

  • Long live the south!!!

  • As Ronnie Van zant would say a southern man dont need you around any how

  • @jeremywells1977 - Steve Van Zant(RIP) was not as musically talented as Neil. I'll take Crosby, stills, Nash, and Young over Lynard Skynard any day. Or Neil on his lonesome.

  • @TicinoParadise never said he did not have talent but skynard is one of the best bands ever

  • @TicinoParadise First of all you are probably referring to Ronnie Van Zant(RIP) since Steve Van Zant does not exist.Second of all Neil is Canadian and do not have his facts straight.And third and most important of all,I've listen to them for 30 years and there is no Neil's song that can match Freebird!!!

  • Neil Young was writing HIS perception of the TIME people. That time has passed...Let the past be the past... We are all One human race and until people lposting on here, let go of the past,, we can't get to a racial balance and that's so sad.......

  • @Fratalian274 Hitler was a Socialist. He also put everything under government control, much like today's Liberals. You should try to look at the political model of right wing and left wing like this: To the Left is a sliding scale leading to total Government control, to the Right is an opposing sliding scale leading to no Government control at all. To the left of center you'll find Democrats, Liberals, Socialists (of every stripe), Fascists all the way up to total Communism.

  • @IamDayoldHate1 Slavery would have died out anyway because of the Cotton Gin. Not many people in the North wanted a war over slaves, anyway. There was a very great deal of resistence in the North when Lincoln published the Emancipation Proclamation which, if you actually read it, didn't free anybody!

  • Only 6% of the south were slaveowners Neil! Many people in the north had slaves, even Lincoln had slaves, and the capital building was built by a slave labor.

  • @PaintballMasterAlec Not to mention the fact that there were Blacks fighting for the South in the Confederate Army before there were any fighting in the Union Army. U.S. Grant was also a slave owner while R.E. Lee was not. Lee thought slavery was 'wicked' to use his own words.

  • can we all just agree that the midwest sucks?

  • @gamer4life1723 fuck you

  • Mind your own business Neil...what is going on in Canada?

  • @crustymcfaden Amen Crusty....I assume the Native Americans in Canada are really happy right now (from North Carolina).

  • @crustymcfaden what

  • both sides north and south were praying to win the war, whose side did GOD pick? the union

  • @mickeyadams527 Vietnam did't pray as much, but the Union lost.. at least morally

  • doesn't their 'good book' (the bible) find slavery acceptable? However I'm sure slavery in the south was way worse than any slavery in Biblical times...