grass roots of punk and new wave....newer generations will neglect...... their loss. top 5 joy division means top 100 all time..pay attention a.d.d. myspace twitter mtv retards...this is the real joint right here
ITS crazy how its not even pst-punk that they made its more like a dance punk because if you notice the bassist peter hook would snap on some catchy dance beat but well my opinion is that joy division was the best band and the second best is misfits but joy division fan til i die!!!!!!!!!
The changed their name because there was already a pretty well established punk band named Warsaw Pact, they changed it to avoid confusion on the bill. A bunch of angry working class oi punks coming and seeing joy division by accident might not have ended well...though in the Warsaw days, they were a bit more heavy and experimental, especially live. Might have gone over well.
@KazakageoftheSand, there was a band called Warsaw Pakt, Joy Division changed there name from Warsaw to prevent confusion with them, i'm not sure it was because of copyright though, seriously look up the name Warsaw Pakt and you will see what were talking about.
@KazakageoftheSand, @ChanterLaChanson is refering to the the band Warsaw Pakt (1977-78), not the actual Warsaw Pact (notice the k), Joy Division changed there name from Warsaw in 1977 to prevent being confused with Warsaw Pakt.
@KazakageoftheSand doesn't matter what decade a band was made in, for example if someone started calling themselves the beatles it still counts as copyright
I like this song - here is where they turn the corner, from being the sex pistol's poor northern cousins to something much more distinctive and profound.
I like this - here you can see them turn the corner from a mediocre northern sex pistols copycat band into something distinctive and much more profound. I think I got that off one of those video documentaries, but it makes a lot of sense when applied to this song in particular.
Joy Division rules. Always. There are no other artists out there like them. I love how Ian had different singing voices. For instance, "Love Will Tear Us Apart," apparently Ian was trying to be more like Frank Sinatra. ;)
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
not that it matters - no one knows them as Warsaw so maybe it's all the same that everything ends up listed as Joy Division - still, maybe there should be some respect for what they chose to call themselves at the time
not trying to start a huge debate, and in a way we're both right - but i was a teenager at the time, and heavily into the scene - all tracks on An Ideal For Living were recorded when the band was still called Warsaw - the original version was recorded as a single in early '77, this version was recorded in Dec 1977, An Ideal For Living was released January 1978, they decided on the name-change just a few days prior to release - so it was recorded by Warsaw, released by Joy Division
@makky123 lol this is first version, that version was released on ideal for living. The older one from 1978 was recorded in 'poor quality of sound' arrow studio. Lenghts of this version is about 4:54
@MultiNickDanger also their changing name to joy division was regarded as an act to reflect the bands work previous and future, so i'm sure none of joy division would object to all their songs being labelled joy division.
The Warsaw Pact was an agreement signed by the Eastern European Communist Bloc in the 50's. It isn't something worthy of disdain or protest, just a meaningless piece of paper.
I believe that by naming the band Warsaw they were standing against the overrun of Poland by the nazi's to kick off WWII.
The Warsaw Pact was an agreement signed by the Eastern European Communist Bloc in the 50's. It isn't something worthy of disdain or protest, just a meaningless piece of paper.
I believe in naming the band Warsaw they were standing against the overrun of Poland by the nazi's to kick off WWII.
To clarify, makky123 is kinda correct. However, this version was recorded while they were still called Warsaw, and released after they'd changed the name to Joy Division. Basically it's only a matter of a month or two, it's just semantics. Still, they had a reason for calling the band Warsaw, and I choose to acknowledge the vision of artists over politicians, or even the business decisions of the very artists themselves.
This was recorded in December 1977, right as Warsaw transformed into Joy Division. The May 1978 RCA Studios Joy Division version was recorded later, and it sounds much different than this one. The RCA version was eventually released on album entitled "Warsaw", but it's still Joy Division.
If anything, this is the Warsaw version and the other version is the Joy Division version. :P
i didn't know this song and i'm really pleased ! please stay arounf joy division, don't fight, it's ridiculus, reading your comments, enjoy the music !....
Spoken extract from the book 'House of Dolls' (2nd verse):
Through the wire screen, the eyes of those standing outside looked in at her as into the cage of some rare creature in a zoo. In the hand of one of the assistants she saw the same instrument which they had that morning inserted deep into her body. She shuddered instinctively. No life at all in the house of dolls. No love lost. No love lost.
who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
@Johnnyo743 Exactly mate, People don't seem to realise that any recognition of him weather it's negative or not- means he wins,it's all exposure. If people just ignore his existence he'll soon disapear.I'm so sick of comments saying "654 people are justin bieber fans" or whatever, and it's always the highest rated comment,people are so fucking boring.
@makky123 I know but a new great age is coming i know its the nature of the universe we have to remeber that after the dark ages there is always a Renaissance
@XHeath86 who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
@Johnnyo743 Who asked for your opinion. Did i ask for your opinion? if you actually even bothered to read my comment correctly dickhead. I was just concurring with another dudes opinion. And for your information, i don't mind todays music scene, theres alot of talent about. And theres only one person bitching here and thats you.
@makky123 ha, the funniest 2 things in this whole arguement are:
1) 2\3 of the planet (or is it 3\4?) don't even know who he is
2) he'll disappear soon enough, just like each and every other pop-star-made-yesy, take sugababes (or how's that written?), they've had fans and everything, and who remembers them now? nobody!
@vrieskip of corse i do, i'm not a brainwashed pop-fan...i'm sure that most rockers remember most "last season" pop stars when pop-fans in fact don't ;D
@makky123: true, but what if those people are opinionated, but not talented?
I would agree that people whinging about 'music these days' is old though. You look at the great records of the last decade and the same people mithering about 'no good music these days' are the least likely to get out and listen to anything new.
@makky123 i completely agree. also, there ARE really great bands out there today, obviously, that are genius and they're super popular. they may not be as famous as justin bieber or any other of these pop culture stars, but they are here and they deserve attention.
@Johnnyo743 i actually find the bitching hillarious, thats four videos in a row i've seen somone telling people to shut the fuck up about justin beiber XDD
@makky123 who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
i like the part of the video with the girls face, for some reason it fits so perfectly at that moment when ian starts the little spoken word part! excellente!
@thoughtcrimer I'm the idiot? You bully people over YouTube...that kinda suggest idiocy to me. Nobody is putting up a decent fight against my comment anyway. Wow.
@cliklab I am not a musical n00b, which judging by your comment you seem to think I was. And I love Joy Divison with an unrelenting passion. To compare them to someone else is to not put them down. PS. Apologies, I meant 'The Gift' by Velvet Underground.
@cliklab Ahem. I never once said Joy Division are a derivative of Velvet Underground. I was comparing this song to the work of Velvet Underground. 'Lady Godiva's Operation', for example, is particularly reminiscent of this track, with the spoken word recital and all. Additionally the punchy vocals reminded me of Lou Reed. I think it's fair to say JD took a tip or two from VU when making their music. As they did The Doors, whatever. To say any artist sounds like nothing before is false.
@jessieintheskywith. That is an unfair misinformed assessment of this track. Without getting too academic, can you qualify your statement that No Love Lost is a "Velvet Underground rip off"? I can honestly say, no song written, performed or covered by Joy Division has sounded like anything I'd ever heard before. Their cover of Sister Ray is the most sincere recording/performance of a Velvet Underground. With that said, to imply Joy Division is derivative of Velvet Underground is out-of-line.
dont give a toss which version this is, its a great fuckin tune
jonnywotten 3 weeks ago
you've been seeing things, in darkness not in learning
hoping that the truth will pass
slangshotstudios 4 weeks ago
"so long sitting here"
...watchin this video!
Great job mate!!!
BillKaps65 1 month ago in playlist Joy Division
@BillKaps65 Thanks.
makky123 1 month ago
R.I.P Ian
nicoflamel1 1 month ago
If you like the intro, check out Neu!'s "Negativland" on youtube
MisterSpinalzo 1 month ago
this is such a mighty track. What balls to have a two minute long intro to a four minute song. try to imagine it live. Sick sick sick...
superultramegasorta 1 month ago
now this is awesome thanks for the share
ogdjjohnnyflashback 2 months ago
J forget,great video...cheers dude...
aleksandargaronja 2 months ago
Opasno dobra stvar,narocito intro,bas upecatljivo...
aleksandargaronja 2 months ago
minimalist , powerful, simple , great song ,great riff !!
omiroe 2 months ago
the best introduction ever
DonVanVliet83 2 months ago
this song drives me fucking crazy just jumping and dancing shit...
sasvite 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
grass roots of punk and new wave....newer generations will neglect...... their loss. top 5 joy division means top 100 all time..pay attention a.d.d. myspace twitter mtv retards...this is the real joint right here
agentdave408 2 months ago
Comment removed
agentdave408 2 months ago
yea my brothers. Get it on. Joy Division.
evilnerf1 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Joy Division
Ever heard Advert by Blur, the riff is similar. Great song.
BringItBackITV 3 months ago
r.i.p. ian, best dancer ever to walk the earth. :)
evilthesaurus 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Joy Division
Great song...check out the Horrors version as well......
hugs1705 4 months ago
drum solo!!!!!
CTCJakinator 4 months ago
that bass is amazing! i love this song so much...and then the guitar comes in...brilliant...
JoyDivisiongirl 5 months ago
@JoyDivisiongirl if u love the bass bow down to hookey
TheShakiebreaks 4 months ago
well, not the Nazi camp, that was evil, I meant the band. (For all you Joy Division NOOBS!!!!)
BassPr0digy 5 months ago
I LOVE JOY DIVISION!!!! :D
BassPr0digy 5 months ago
amazing and awesome
djmusicjac 5 months ago
silesian pictures und sound
TheStrammer 5 months ago
who is singing??
crassadict211 6 months ago
@crassadict211 who do you think..it is Ian Curtis...does not sound like his older stuff but this is the earlier music...amazing!
JoyDivisiongirl 5 months ago
Joy Division's music was truly wierd. But I love it.
clarkewi 6 months ago 3
Great, great job on this video. Perfectly evokes the feeling of the music. Kudos, makky.
maxjhogan 7 months ago 2
@maxjhogan Cheers bud.
makky123 7 months ago
YES!!! MY THOUGHTS, ENTIRELY. BETTER THAN JOY DIVISION
emilyoshiro 4 months ago
Who gives a fuck. Oh did I SAY that?
Lrpesme48 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Joy Division, Mr. I Think I know Everything. The Warsaw version is much different. Go fuck yourself, pretentious asshat
borden1118 8 months ago
the perfect union of mind l instruments
albertomius 8 months ago 4
Just stfu and listen.
Lrpesme48 9 months ago 8
ITS crazy how its not even pst-punk that they made its more like a dance punk because if you notice the bassist peter hook would snap on some catchy dance beat but well my opinion is that joy division was the best band and the second best is misfits but joy division fan til i die!!!!!!!!!
josegrey01 9 months ago
The changed their name because there was already a pretty well established punk band named Warsaw Pact, they changed it to avoid confusion on the bill. A bunch of angry working class oi punks coming and seeing joy division by accident might not have ended well...though in the Warsaw days, they were a bit more heavy and experimental, especially live. Might have gone over well.
Kraftysot 9 months ago 2
@KazakageoftheSand, there was a band called Warsaw Pakt, Joy Division changed there name from Warsaw to prevent confusion with them, i'm not sure it was because of copyright though, seriously look up the name Warsaw Pakt and you will see what were talking about.
TripleBuggerOff 10 months ago 2
@TripleBuggerOff i thought people we talking about the warsaw pact as in the treaty.... lol. what you're saying makes sense
KazakageoftheSand 9 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson, I know, i'm defending your position
TripleBuggerOff 10 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand, @ChanterLaChanson is refering to the the band Warsaw Pakt (1977-78), not the actual Warsaw Pact (notice the k), Joy Division changed there name from Warsaw in 1977 to prevent being confused with Warsaw Pakt.
TripleBuggerOff 10 months ago
@TripleBuggerOff thanks for clearing that up, but they did change their name because of warsaw pakt thats what im saying
ChanterLaChanson 10 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson no they didn't.
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand They did if Warsaw Pakt wasnt formed before Joy Division, they wouldnt have changed their name
ChanterLaChanson 9 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson that's so ignorant
KazakageoftheSand 9 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand If you say so mate
ChanterLaChanson 4 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson way to bring up something that happened months ago
KazakageoftheSand 4 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand soz man I just discovered it in my inbox, and well I didn't want to be rude
ChanterLaChanson 4 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson oh well in that case i appreciate it
KazakageoftheSand 4 months ago
well done
SCHNKHOUSE 10 months ago
well done
SCHNKHOUSE 10 months ago
@SCHNKHOUSE well done in deed
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
watch?v=l5zFsy9VIdM
This song propably inspired No Love Lost..check bass line especially at the end song
krysotof 10 months ago
@krysotof bloody doubtful. that song came out in 1977.....
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand watch?v=EDtFTysmExg&feature=related really ? 1975
krysotof 10 months ago
They changed their name from Warsaw to Joy Division because of Warsaw Pakt :)
ChanterLaChanson 10 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson no way. the warsaw pact was made in the 50's >.>. how would that have affected the name of the band?
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
@KazakageoftheSand doesn't matter what decade a band was made in, for example if someone started calling themselves the beatles it still counts as copyright
ChanterLaChanson 10 months ago
@ChanterLaChanson the warsaw pact is a treaty not a band O_O you can't have copyright infringement on a political treaty O_O
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
Is that Ian Curtis singing?
yetimichael 10 months ago
@yetimichael yeah, this was before ian sang in his signature baritone voice.
ri394 10 months ago
Comment removed
MultiNickDanger 11 months ago
one of my favourite tracks but i swear this is when they were warsaw
TheShakiebreaks 11 months ago
I like this song - here is where they turn the corner, from being the sex pistol's poor northern cousins to something much more distinctive and profound.
fleeciewool 1 year ago
I like this - here you can see them turn the corner from a mediocre northern sex pistols copycat band into something distinctive and much more profound. I think I got that off one of those video documentaries, but it makes a lot of sense when applied to this song in particular.
fleeciewool 1 year ago
Cool video man.
sydbarrett5 1 year ago
when you guys argue it makes me sad
yrmexmetanoia 1 year ago 30
I just heard a cover of this song on House. Surprising but welcome.
LifeInBrunswick 1 year ago
Joy Division rules. Always. There are no other artists out there like them. I love how Ian had different singing voices. For instance, "Love Will Tear Us Apart," apparently Ian was trying to be more like Frank Sinatra. ;)
menomineefalls 1 year ago
In addition to the above... you guys SUCK; lol. Nice song btw.
empeax 1 year ago
WARSZAWA!
oktobox 1 year ago
makky123. Great visuals and great tunes. Any chance of making it available on mobile? I think you have to turn on syndication.... Thanks!
gabrielsroka 1 year ago
This song is The Velvet Underground evolved.
synthstatic 1 year ago
i like your channl it was hard to find in the dark but im blind no just kiding
dopeurwhatuuse 1 year ago
whos that singing :O
yetimichael 1 year ago
- 21 !
gilamonster001 1 year ago
JOY DIVISION aleluyaa !!!
pablo007700 1 year ago
HOUSE OF DOLLS read it
vinnyflee 1 year ago
HOUSE OF DOLLS read it.
vinnyflee 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HOUSE OF DOLLS read it
vinnyflee 1 year ago
HOUSE OF DOLLS read it
vinnyflee 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
maverickMAQUIAVILE 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M
everybody waiting the last album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
maverickMAQUIAVILE 1 year ago
Is this the song, when Ian goes to work with 'HATE' on a back of his coat? (In CONTROL movie)
Jochimo 1 year ago
@Jochimo It is mate, yeah!
robertokeano 1 year ago
@Jochimo i think it was interzone actually go listen to it and see if it sounds right to you i think its right but i'm not possitive
cgalla0307 1 year ago
not a bad band eh??-don't matter which name you use-can even throw in The Stiff Kittens for all i care.....
joydivisionboy1 1 year ago
stupenda!!!
lostinthemeadow 1 year ago
A study has recently come out suggesting that it may in fact be hazardous to your health to not listen to this song at maximum volume.
herecomesmrbillsdog 1 year ago 4
just perfect , Warsaw or Joy division no matter ...
thetioseb 1 year ago
Favorite Joy Division song ever!
Brambleiah 1 year ago
This song is absolutly amazing.
misfitkitten138 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
twenty people are a disgrace to the human race.
christhecreep 1 year ago
Did Ian sing this? His voice always sounds lower than on this song..
charliegrs 1 year ago
@charliegrs yes he did.
lagowski 1 year ago
@charliegrs
it was recorded before he learned how to sing in his signature baritone voice
ihave2 1 year ago
I need it.
moofiebooble 1 year ago 3
Un-fucking-believably amazing.
robertokeano 1 year ago
@robertokeano spot on mate
XHeath86 1 year ago
orgasmic.
joesmomisdead 1 year ago
I second the comparisons to early CAN. Both phenomenal bands.
mesoocoool 1 year ago
Rest easy, Ian
quicklern818 1 year ago
Love this song! R.I.P Ian Curtis....
nirvanafrik999 1 year ago
this was Warsaw not Joy Division - both versions
not that it matters - no one knows them as Warsaw so maybe it's all the same that everything ends up listed as Joy Division - still, maybe there should be some respect for what they chose to call themselves at the time
MultiNickDanger 1 year ago 10
@MultiNickDanger The Warsaw version is earlier than this one, they recorded this version on an ideal for living just after they became Joy division.
makky123 1 year ago 40
@makky123
not trying to start a huge debate, and in a way we're both right - but i was a teenager at the time, and heavily into the scene - all tracks on An Ideal For Living were recorded when the band was still called Warsaw - the original version was recorded as a single in early '77, this version was recorded in Dec 1977, An Ideal For Living was released January 1978, they decided on the name-change just a few days prior to release - so it was recorded by Warsaw, released by Joy Division
MultiNickDanger 1 year ago
@makky123 Yeah makky123 is right. there are extra verses on the warsaw version.
SuperiFox 1 year ago
@makky123 lol this is first version, that version was released on ideal for living. The older one from 1978 was recorded in 'poor quality of sound' arrow studio. Lenghts of this version is about 4:54
S4M3L 1 year ago
@makky123
Warsaw's version sucks compared to this one. Where did you find this version? Which CD?
NintendoSegaSonyGuy 11 months ago
@NintendoSegaSonyGuy- 'Ideal for living', It's also on 'Substance'.
makky123 11 months ago 3
@makky123 yeah i learned this off substance
KazakageoftheSand 10 months ago
@MultiNickDanger also their changing name to joy division was regarded as an act to reflect the bands work previous and future, so i'm sure none of joy division would object to all their songs being labelled joy division.
Bobsrathercool 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheRATTLEHEAD75 1 year ago
@MultiNickDange A question.. were they not called warsaw pact?
comacful 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@comacful
Naw, just Warsaw.
The Warsaw Pact was an agreement signed by the Eastern European Communist Bloc in the 50's. It isn't something worthy of disdain or protest, just a meaningless piece of paper.
I believe that by naming the band Warsaw they were standing against the overrun of Poland by the nazi's to kick off WWII.
MultiNickDanger 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@comacful
Naw, just Warsaw.
The Warsaw Pact was an agreement signed by the Eastern European Communist Bloc in the 50's. It isn't something worthy of disdain or protest, just a meaningless piece of paper.
I believe in naming the band Warsaw they were standing against the overrun of Poland by the nazi's to kick off WWII.
MultiNickDanger 11 months ago
@comacful Nah, Warsaw Pakt were a different band.
fakeis751 10 months ago
@MultiNickDanger
To clarify, makky123 is kinda correct. However, this version was recorded while they were still called Warsaw, and released after they'd changed the name to Joy Division. Basically it's only a matter of a month or two, it's just semantics. Still, they had a reason for calling the band Warsaw, and I choose to acknowledge the vision of artists over politicians, or even the business decisions of the very artists themselves.
MultiNickDanger 11 months ago
Comment removed
MultiNickDanger 11 months ago
@MultiNickDanger It's Joy Division, Mr. I Think I know Everything. The Warsaw version is much different. Go fuck yourself, pretentious asshat.
thoughtcrimer 8 months ago 25
@thoughtcrimer Well said.
SpanishAtHeart2010 7 months ago
@thoughtcrimer keep it cool and flowing i know its hard to do thanx for saing it
marchel26666 1 month ago in playlist Joy division
@thoughtcrimer
This was recorded in December 1977, right as Warsaw transformed into Joy Division. The May 1978 RCA Studios Joy Division version was recorded later, and it sounds much different than this one. The RCA version was eventually released on album entitled "Warsaw", but it's still Joy Division.
If anything, this is the Warsaw version and the other version is the Joy Division version. :P
NintendoSegaSonyGuy 5 days ago
Eventhough "Closer" is the ultimate. "Substance" had so much energy that the later Joy Division did not have.
Israe5l 1 year ago
Great band, great voice, great lyrics, great music.
wisprworld 1 year ago
best ever tune in the world............
LeonNexus6 1 year ago
Who cares about how many likes and dislikes there are??? This is Joy Division we're talking about here. Joy Division is BEAST, nuff said.
rldaniels95 1 year ago
The guitar tone in this song will never be bested.
meisross 1 year ago
i didn't know this song and i'm really pleased ! please stay arounf joy division, don't fight, it's ridiculus, reading your comments, enjoy the music !....
farine5 1 year ago
i <3 joy division
ElDiabloBerrios 1 year ago
Spoken extract from the book 'House of Dolls' (2nd verse):
Through the wire screen, the eyes of those standing outside looked in at her as into the cage of some rare creature in a zoo. In the hand of one of the assistants she saw the same instrument which they had that morning inserted deep into her body. She shuddered instinctively. No life at all in the house of dolls. No love lost. No love lost.
ichbinderhammer 1 year ago 5
passaionant?
marcaholic 1 year ago
@marcaholic asshole?
Johnnyo743 1 year ago
who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
Johnnyo743 1 year ago 55
@Johnnyo743 Exactly mate, People don't seem to realise that any recognition of him weather it's negative or not- means he wins,it's all exposure. If people just ignore his existence he'll soon disapear.I'm so sick of comments saying "654 people are justin bieber fans" or whatever, and it's always the highest rated comment,people are so fucking boring.
makky123 1 year ago 51
@makky123 I know but a new great age is coming i know its the nature of the universe we have to remeber that after the dark ages there is always a Renaissance
Johnnyo743 1 year ago
@makky123 Agreed on the Justin Bieber bollocks...ffs just listen to the mighty Curtis. peace
XHeath86 1 year ago
@XHeath86 who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
Johnnyo743 1 year ago
@Johnnyo743 Who asked for your opinion. Did i ask for your opinion? if you actually even bothered to read my comment correctly dickhead. I was just concurring with another dudes opinion. And for your information, i don't mind todays music scene, theres alot of talent about. And theres only one person bitching here and thats you.
XHeath86 1 year ago 2
@makky123 ha, the funniest 2 things in this whole arguement are:
1) 2\3 of the planet (or is it 3\4?) don't even know who he is
2) he'll disappear soon enough, just like each and every other pop-star-made-yesy, take sugababes (or how's that written?), they've had fans and everything, and who remembers them now? nobody!
theRavenTrue 1 year ago
@theRavenTrue You remember the sugababes :P !
vrieskip 1 year ago
@vrieskip of corse i do, i'm not a brainwashed pop-fan...i'm sure that most rockers remember most "last season" pop stars when pop-fans in fact don't ;D
theRavenTrue 1 year ago
@makky123 SPEAK!
fanatsy15 1 year ago
@makky123: true, but what if those people are opinionated, but not talented?
I would agree that people whinging about 'music these days' is old though. You look at the great records of the last decade and the same people mithering about 'no good music these days' are the least likely to get out and listen to anything new.
RHutton2710 1 year ago
@makky123 i completely agree. also, there ARE really great bands out there today, obviously, that are genius and they're super popular. they may not be as famous as justin bieber or any other of these pop culture stars, but they are here and they deserve attention.
wonderwoman1148 10 months ago
@Johnnyo743 i actually find the bitching hillarious, thats four videos in a row i've seen somone telling people to shut the fuck up about justin beiber XDD
BloodyPitOfHorror 1 year ago
@Johnnyo743 I love this comment, it made my day. thanks sir.
thewotsit 1 year ago
@Johnnyo743 I conccur says jackthedog38. let us all sound off like we all have a pair O nuts.!
SPT111 1 year ago
Oh YAH !
BoyT0oY 1 year ago
Iv'e always thought it sounds more like early CAN than anything else...I really don't hear any similarities between this and Lady godiva's operation.
makky123 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
@makky123 who gives a fuck about justin bieber shut the fuck up im tired of everyone bitching about how shitty poplar music is. the people that arent being pleased by todays music need to go out and form a band it dosent matter if you cant play an instrumnt as long as you are passaionant about the music you are preforming people will be impressed and there will be a new great age of music we just have to go out and make things happen instead of bitching about how things suck.
Johnnyo743 1 year ago
@makky123 Hey, Joy Division earns all their praise, but in regards to your (video) contribution: brilliant fucking job
cacam01 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is totally referrencing Lady Godiva's Operation with some mean Link Wray riffage driving it. That's what I hear.
kingbingus 1 year ago
This is totally referrencing Lady Godiva's Operation with some mean Link Wray riffage driving it. That's what I hear.
kingbingus 1 year ago
what velvet underground song is this a rip off of? this doesnt sound anything like lady godivas operation...
xxcherryypieexx 1 year ago
i like the part of the video with the girls face, for some reason it fits so perfectly at that moment when ian starts the little spoken word part! excellente!
Turtlesquad989 1 year ago
@thoughtcrimer I'm the idiot? You bully people over YouTube...that kinda suggest idiocy to me. Nobody is putting up a decent fight against my comment anyway. Wow.
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
Comment removed
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cliklab I am not a musical n00b, which judging by your comment you seem to think I was. And I love Joy Divison with an unrelenting passion. To compare them to someone else is to not put them down. PS. Apologies, I meant 'The Gift' by Velvet Underground.
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
Comment removed
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
@cliklab Ahem. I never once said Joy Division are a derivative of Velvet Underground. I was comparing this song to the work of Velvet Underground. 'Lady Godiva's Operation', for example, is particularly reminiscent of this track, with the spoken word recital and all. Additionally the punchy vocals reminded me of Lou Reed. I think it's fair to say JD took a tip or two from VU when making their music. As they did The Doors, whatever. To say any artist sounds like nothing before is false.
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
@jessieintheskywith jessieintheskywithairbetweenherears
legoland3 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@legoland3 Really? Explain to me why this is.
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
Such a Velvet Underground rip off. BUT I LOVE IT. <3 Division of Joy
jessieintheskywith 1 year ago
@jessieintheskywith. That is an unfair misinformed assessment of this track. Without getting too academic, can you qualify your statement that No Love Lost is a "Velvet Underground rip off"? I can honestly say, no song written, performed or covered by Joy Division has sounded like anything I'd ever heard before. Their cover of Sister Ray is the most sincere recording/performance of a Velvet Underground. With that said, to imply Joy Division is derivative of Velvet Underground is out-of-line.
cliklab 1 year ago
Godlike Geniuses
kritonas7 1 year ago
I love the band and this song is a fav.Good vid too ;)
mike666nz 1 year ago
Through the wire screen, the eyes of those standing outside looked in
at her as into the cage of some rare creature in a zoo.
In the hand of one of the assistants she saw the same instrument
which they had that morning inserted deep into her body. She shuddered
instinctively. No life at all in the house of dolls.
No love lost. No love lost.
littlewhip88 1 year ago
by far my favorite joy division song. post-punk at it's best.
BagpipeHustler 1 year ago
best tune ever
LeonNexus6 1 year ago